Converting SEP IRA to Roth IRA — what does the IRS actually want from me at tax time?
Spent the last two weeks trying to get a straight answer on this and I'm going in circles. My SEP IRA contributions over the past few years were pre-tax, so when I moved the balance to a Roth IRA this fall the custodian told me the whole converted amount counts as taxable income for 2026. Fine, I understood that part going in. What I didn't understand was how to make sure the IRS has what it needs. My custodian says a 1099-R gets issued and I report it on my return, but I also heard I need to file Form 8606 and that if I skip it there's a penalty. Then I read something about owing an estimated payment now instead of waiting until April. I've been self-employed for three years so my situation isn't the same as someone with a regular paycheck where tax gets withheld automatically. The converted amount is a pretty significant chunk of income for the year and I'm worried about underpayment penalties on top of everything else. Is the 1099-R enough on its own or do I really need Form 8606 too? And does the IRS have a way to verify what basis, if any, I had in the account before the conversion?
73 comments

Kiara Greene
Balance in my IRS Online Account from two tax years back had a discrepancy I couldn't explain from just looking at transcripts, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get on the line with an IRS agent rather than spend half a day redialing 800-829-1040. The agent pulled up the balance owed for that year and confirmed the exact figure, which turned out to match a payment I'd already made but that hadn't been applied yet — the account just hadn't updated. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. For the original question here about the SEP-to-Roth conversion, the 1099-R is what the IRS receives from the custodian, but Form 8606 is what you file to show your own basis calculation — both matter for documenting the transaction properly on your return.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorAppreciate the account balance context — that's a separate headache I might hit later. The Form 8606 clarification helps though. So the 1099-R comes from the custodian automatically and I still attach 8606 to my own return?
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Your read is right. The custodian handles the 1099-R; Form 8606 is yours to file with your 1040 to establish your basis. If you had any nondeductible contributions the form is especially important. Miss it and the IRS has no record of basis, which could mean paying tax on that money again later.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorNo nondeductible contributions in the SEP — everything went in pre-tax. So my basis is zero and the full converted amount is taxable income. That much I had right, at least.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
Form 8606 question comes up a lot with SEP and traditional IRA conversions. Worth knowing the form does two jobs: it reports the conversion itself and it tracks cumulative basis across all your traditional-type IRAs. Even if your basis is zero right now, filing it creates a paper trail the IRS can follow if you ever do have nondeductible contributions in a future year.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Didn't realize 8606 was cumulative across accounts. I thought each IRA was tracked separately.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
They're aggregated. The IRS looks at all your traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA balances together when calculating the taxable portion of any distribution or conversion — the pro-rata rule. A tax professional can walk through the math for your specific numbers if the mix is complicated.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Pro-rata rule is the part that always trips me up. Good to know it applies here even with a full conversion out of just one account.
0 coins
Raul Neal
My estimated payment situation this year looked a lot like yours — self-employed, big taxable event mid-year, nothing being withheld automatically. The way I understood it after reading the IRS's guidance: if you expect to owe a certain amount after subtracting withholding and credits, you're supposed to pay in quarterly. The IRS's Tax Withholding Estimator on their site helped me figure out roughly what I needed to send in by the Q3 deadline, though for a conversion this size I'd strongly suggest running the numbers with a tax professional before the final quarter deadline.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorQuarterly payments were on my radar but I wasn't sure if the conversion amount changed which quarter I should be adjusting. Sounds like it hits whichever quarter the conversion happened in.
0 coins
Raul Neal
Timing matters, yes. The Q3 estimated payment deadline already passed for 2026, so if the conversion happened this fall your Q4 payment is the one to focus on. Missing quarters can still result in an underpayment penalty even if you pay it all by April.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
Underpayment penalty is a real thing, not just a scare tactic. I skipped two quarters once and owed more than I expected even after paying the full balance when I filed. No way to know the exact penalty amount in advance — the IRS calculates it on your return.
0 coins
Christian Burns
Transcript question on the original post is worth addressing too. Your IRS Online Account at https://www.irs.gov/your-account shows wage and income data the IRS has received from third parties — including 1099-Rs once the custodian files them. If you want to verify the custodian reported the right amount, checking your wage and income transcript early next year should show it. The account transcript for 2026 will show what's posted after you file.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorHadn't thought to verify the custodian's end of it. Will check the wage and income transcript once it populates. How early does that usually show up after the custodian files?
0 coins
Christian Burns
Timing depends on when the custodian submits to the IRS, which is usually by late January or early February of the following year. The wage and income transcript won't show 2026 data until the custodian actually files, so give it until late February before expecting it to appear.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
Account transcript vs. wage and income transcript confused me for months. The account transcript shows what's on your return and any changes after filing; the wage and income one is just what employers and financial institutions reported. Two different documents with different info.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Self-employed income plus a large IRA conversion in the same year is a combination worth flagging to your tax preparer early if you use one. The conversion amount gets added on top of your business income, which can push you into a higher bracket for the year — not stating a specific rate, but the stacking effect is real and worth modeling before you file so the Q4 estimated payment isn't a shock.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorAlready bracing for a rough 2026 tax year because of this. The conversion was planned but I underestimated how big the quarterly payments needed to be. Live and learn.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Your note about stacking is the part people miss when they convert in a year with strong business income. A lot of people assume they can just convert and worry about it in April. The quarterly system doesn't really work that way for a self-employed person.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
Payment plan terms on my account were off by several months last spring, which sent me scrambling. Used Claimyr to reach an IRS agent who pulled up the payment plan's monthly amount and due date — the original agreement showed a date that the system had shifted when I modified a payment, and the agent confirmed what date my next payment was actually due so I didn't accidentally miss it. For the SEP-to-Roth question: if the 2026 tax bill ends up larger than you can pay at once, the IRS does have installment agreement options you can apply for online, but the first step is still filing your return on time.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorPayment plan is in the back of my mind as a contingency. Good to know the online application is an option if the balance after estimated payments is still larger than expected.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Filing on time regardless of what you owe is the key piece there. The late-filing penalty is separate from the late-payment penalty, so even if you can't pay the full amount, getting the return in by the April deadline limits the damage.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
Exactly right on the two separate penalties. I made the mistake of thinking an extension to file was also an extension to pay one year — it's not, they're different things. Learned that one the hard way.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Confused about something in the original post — does the IRS treat a SEP IRA differently from a traditional IRA for conversion purposes? I always thought they were the same at the point of conversion since both are pre-tax.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
For conversion purposes the tax treatment at the point of conversion is the same — the full pre-tax amount becomes taxable income in the year of the conversion. The main difference between account types shows up in contribution rules and limits, not at the moment you convert to a Roth. The 1099-R and Form 8606 process is the same either way.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Makes sense, the conversion mechanics are the same even if the account types differ going in. So my SIMPLE IRA rollover question is probably the same answer too.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
SIMPLE IRAs have an extra rule worth checking: there's a waiting period before you can roll one over without penalty if the account is relatively new. Worth verifying with a tax professional or on the IRS's site for your specific situation rather than assuming it matches a SEP exactly.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
The 8606 penalty for failing to file it is a fixed dollar amount on the IRS's books, but the more practical risk is not being able to prove your basis later. If your basis is zero the penalty is the smaller concern — the bigger one is that the IRS has no record showing you already paid tax on the conversion, which matters if you ever take distributions from the Roth and something looks off.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorSo even with zero basis I should file 8606 just to have the paper trail? That's what I'll do then.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Yes, file it regardless. Zero basis is still a basis figure the IRS should have documented. Future you will appreciate having it on record.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
Roth IRA qualified distributions question: someone told me the five-year clock for the converted funds starts from the year of conversion, not the year the original SEP was opened. Is that right for someone who already has an existing Roth IRA?
0 coins
Paloma Clark
Five-year rules for Roths get complicated depending on what you're withdrawing and when, and whether it's contributions, converted amounts or earnings. That's really a question for a tax professional or the IRS's own publications — the answer varies by what's being distributed and your age at the time.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
Fair, that's a question for my preparer. Didn't want to assume the SEP conversion clock matched my regular Roth contributions.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
The IRS site has Publication 590-B which covers Roth distributions in detail if you want to read the rules before meeting with a preparer. The IRS's site has the full text under forms and publications.
0 coins
Laila Prince
My 1099-R from a rollover two years ago showed code G in box 7 and my preparer said that was for a direct rollover, not a conversion. If your custodian did the conversion as a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer to the Roth, make sure the box 7 code on your 1099-R reflects a conversion and not a rollover — the codes are different and the wrong one can cause the IRS to treat the transaction differently on your return.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorHadn't thought to check box 7. The custodian said it was a conversion so I assumed they'd code it correctly, but I'll verify when the form arrives.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Custodians usually get it right but it's worth confirming. If the code is wrong the fix is to contact the custodian and request a corrected 1099-R before you file. Don't file with an incorrect code and hope the IRS sorts it out.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Corrected 1099-R process can take weeks and delay your filing. Better to catch it early. My custodian issued a corrected form once and it arrived two days before the filing deadline — not a fun situation.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Wages and withholding reported for 2026 was something I needed to verify on my own account this fall — I had a side job that ended partway through the year and wanted to confirm the withholding matched what my final paystub showed. Used Claimyr to reach an IRS agent who pulled the wages and withholding reported for the year so far, which matched my records, so I knew the employer had filed correctly. For a self-employed person doing a conversion with no withholding, knowing the IRS already has the custodian's side of the transaction is actually reassuring — once that 1099-R posts to your wage and income transcript you'll see what they received.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorVerifying the custodian's reported figures against the transcript is a step I wouldn't have thought to take. Adding it to my checklist for February.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Transcript verification step is especially important when the income isn't from a regular employer. I had a 1099 from a client that the payer filed late one year and the wage and income transcript didn't match what I had until March.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
Estimated payments for 2026 — are they still possible to make at this point in the year? I thought the Q4 deadline was in January.
0 coins
Raul Neal
Q4 estimated payment for 2026 is due in January 2027. If we're still in the fourth quarter right now, there's still time. After that date anything unpaid stays on the return and the underpayment calculation runs from each quarter's deadline, not just the final date.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
Good, so there's still a window to make a Q4 payment and reduce what I owe when I file. That's a relief.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
You can also pay directly through the IRS's site or via the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System before the deadline. No need to mail a check if you're close to the due date.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
The pro-rata rule that came up earlier in this thread is the reason I decided not to do a Roth conversion from my SEP when I still had a traditional IRA open with a small balance. If I had done it that year I would have had to calculate the taxable portion across all three accounts combined, which made the math ugly. I ended up rolling the traditional IRA into my current employer's plan to zero out that account first, then converted the SEP the following year. Sharing because the sequencing matters and it's easy to overlook when you're just focused on the conversion itself.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorThat sequencing strategy is exactly the kind of thing I didn't hear from anyone before I did this. Too late for me this time around, but useful context.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Worth mentioning to your tax preparer when you file — they can at least confirm the pro-rata calculation for 2026 and flag whether a similar cleanup move makes sense in future years.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Rolling an old IRA into a current employer plan to clear the pro-rata issue is a move not enough people know about. Some employer plans won't accept IRA rollovers though, so it has to be verified with the plan administrator first.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
My first year self-employed I completely missed the estimated payment system and owed a penalty when I filed. Nobody had told me that without an employer withholding for you, quarterly payments are basically your version of paycheck withholding. The IRS's Tax Withholding Estimator is worth running every time something big changes in your income picture — a large conversion like this would absolutely count as a big change.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorRunning the estimator was on my list but I kept putting it off. Doing it this week before the Q4 deadline.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
Do it soon. The estimator asks for your expected total income for the year including conversion amounts, so having a rough total ready makes it faster.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Form 8606 also matters if you ever do a Backdoor Roth — which is contributing to a traditional IRA and then converting, usually when income is too high for a direct Roth contribution. Even if that's not your situation now, keeping clean 8606 records each year means the basis tracking stays consistent if your strategy changes later.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Backdoor Roth is something I've been reading about and I never understood why people stress the 8606 so much until this thread. Makes a lot more sense now.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
The form is the only documentation the IRS has of your basis. Without it, every distribution or conversion looks fully taxable on paper. It's a small form with an outsized importance.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
Deadline question from earlier in the thread about estimated payments: the IRS does accept them online and the January due date for Q4 is firm. If you're getting close, the IRS Online Account at https://www.irs.gov/ lets you schedule a payment directly and you get a confirmation number. That confirmation is the only receipt you'll have until it shows up on your account transcript.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
Confirmation number tip is useful — I'll save it somewhere safe until the payment shows on the transcript.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Account transcript won't show the payment immediately — usually takes a few days after the payment date. Worth checking again about a week later to confirm it posted.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
After going through a large conversion of my own last year I want to flag one more thing: state income tax. The taxable income from a SEP-to-Roth conversion is also typically reportable to your state, and some states have different rules about retirement account distributions. Your state's own tax agency is who handles that side — it doesn't go through the IRS — but you'll want to factor it into your estimated state payments too if your state has them.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorState side is handled through a completely separate agency, right? So my IRS payments and my state payments are two different things.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Completely separate. The IRS only deals with federal. Your state's tax agency runs the state side, with its own deadlines and payment methods. Worth confirming what your state requires for estimated payments on a large conversion amount.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
IRS Online Account is worth checking periodically throughout all this — not just for transcripts but also to confirm any payments you make are posting correctly and to the right tax year. I had a direct pay entry post to the wrong year once and it caused a notice I had to resolve by phoning in. Getting the tax year right on the payment screen is easy to overlook when you're in a hurry.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorTax year field on the payment screen — noted. That's the kind of small thing that causes a big headache.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Exactly. The IRS mails a notice when something doesn't match, and by the time it arrives you've forgotten what you clicked. Keeping a screenshot of the payment confirmation with the tax year visible saves a lot of backtracking.
0 coins
Christian Burns
Payment posting to the wrong year happened to me too. The fix wasn't terrible once I called in, but it took time to sort out. Verification at the payment screen is much easier than trying to correct it after.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Filing the return on time in April matters even more than the estimated payments, in a way — the return is what reconciles everything. If your estimates came up short, the return shows the balance and that's when you either pay the remaining amount or set up an installment agreement. The penalties diverge at that point: one for underpayment of estimated tax, another for not paying on time after filing. They're separate calculations.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorTwo separate penalty calculations — hadn't fully understood that distinction. So even a perfect Q4 payment doesn't wipe out earlier quarter shortfalls?
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Correct. The underpayment calculation looks at each quarter's shortfall individually. A large Q4 payment helps going forward but doesn't eliminate the per-quarter calculation for earlier ones. A tax professional can tell you if you qualify for any exceptions that reduce it.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
Exceptions to the underpayment penalty exist — the IRS has a safe harbor based on last year's tax liability that some people can use. Worth asking a preparer whether it applies here, since it's a calculation specific to each person's numbers.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
My custodian sent the conversion proceeds as a check made out to me once — not to the new Roth custodian — and I had to deposit it into the Roth within 60 days to avoid it being treated as a distribution instead of a conversion. If that's what happened here, the 60-day clock is strict and the IRS doesn't have much flexibility on it. Just want to make sure the original poster's custodian handled it as a direct transfer rather than an indirect one.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
AuthorMine was a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer, so the check never came to me. But I didn't know the 60-day rule existed for indirect conversions. Good information.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Direct transfer is the cleaner way. The 60-day indirect rollover rule catches a lot of people off guard, especially when a custodian offers to send the check to the account holder as a default.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Indirect rollover also has a mandatory withholding issue — the custodian may withhold a percentage for taxes on the distribution, and you'd have to make up that withheld amount out of pocket to convert the full balance. Direct transfer avoids all of that.
0 coins