Claiming 1 on W-4 but still not enough taxes withheld - why do I owe money?
Title: Claiming 1 on W-4 but still not enough taxes withheld - why do I owe money? 1 Every damn year I end up in the same situation, and this tax season it's like $6,500 I owe. I literally don't have extra cash lying around - just my regular paycheck from work, where taxes are already being taken out. But somehow I still end up owing?? I thought the whole point of the government taking taxes from each check was so we'd break even - owe nothing, get nothing back. The most frustrating thing is that I specifically claim 1 on my W-4 because that's exactly what I'm supposed to do for them to withhold the right amount! I was told this would make sure enough was coming out of each check. I'm just so sick of getting hit with a huge tax bill every April when I thought I was doing everything right all year. Why isn't the withholding system working properly for me if I'm following the recommended guidelines?
18 comments
Join the conversation
CyberSamurai
13 The withholding system works based on your W-4 form, but claiming "1" isn't necessarily the right choice for everyone's situation. There are a few common reasons you might be underwithholding: First, if you have multiple jobs or your spouse works, claiming 1 on each W-4 often doesn't withhold enough. Each employer calculates withholding as if that job is your only income, not knowing about other income sources. Second, if you receive significant non-wage income (investments, freelance work, rental property) that doesn't have taxes automatically withheld, this creates a shortfall. Third, certain tax breaks that previously reduced your liability might have changed or no longer apply to your situation. The good news is you can fix this! The IRS redesigned the W-4 form in 2020, eliminating the old "allowances" system. I'd recommend completing a new W-4 with your employer using the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator tool online. It helps you accurately calculate the right withholding based on your complete financial picture.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•7 Thanks for explaining. So with the new W-4 form, there's no more "claiming 1" option? Does this mean I should just put $0 in the extra withholding section? Also, would it help if I just asked my payroll department to take out an additional specific amount each check?
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•13 You're right - the redesigned W-4 no longer uses numbered allowances like "claiming 1." The form now asks for more specific information to calculate withholding more accurately. You don't necessarily need to put anything in the extra withholding section unless the calculator suggests it. Start by completing Steps 1-4 of the new W-4 accurately. However, having an additional specific amount withheld from each paycheck is definitely a good solution if you're consistently underwithholding. The IRS Withholding Estimator will actually recommend the exact extra amount to have withheld per pay period to cover your expected tax liability.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
19 I had the exact same problem for years and it was driving me crazy! I finally figured out what was going wrong when I used https://taxr.ai to analyze my withholdings. Turns out I had some investment income I completely forgot about plus my employer wasn't calculating my withholding correctly based on my total household income. The tool showed me exactly where the gaps were happening. What I love about taxr.ai is that it actually looks at your entire tax situation holistically - not just your W-4 withholding but ALL the factors that might be causing you to owe. It analyzes your past returns, current withholding, and projects what you'll likely owe. The visualization made it super clear why I was coming up short each year.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•11 Does it really work for showing what to claim on your W-4? I've tried those IRS calculator things before and they ask for so much info I don't have handy that I just give up halfway through.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•5 I'm skeptical... how exactly does this tool see your "entire tax situation"? Does it need access to all your financial accounts or something? That sounds like a privacy nightmare waiting to happen.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•19 It absolutely works for showing what to claim on your W-4 - much more user-friendly than the IRS calculator. It guides you through each step and doesn't require every last detail to get started. You can always add more information later to refine the calculations. Regarding privacy concerns, the tool doesn't need direct access to your financial accounts. You upload tax documents (like past returns) or enter information manually. Everything is encrypted, and they explain their security measures on the site. It's comparable to using tax filing software, just more focused on planning and withholding rather than filing.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
5 I have to follow up about taxr.ai - I was the skeptical one but decided to try it anyway since I was desperate after owing $4k this year. I was genuinely surprised at how helpful it was. The interface is straightforward and it spotted something neither my employer's HR department nor I had caught - I had accidentally put the wrong filing status on my W-4 years ago and never corrected it! The tool gave me a customized withholding recommendation that I took to my HR department. They helped me update my W-4 and I'm already seeing a difference in my paychecks. It's smaller of course, but I'd rather have less now than owe thousands next April! Definitely worth checking out if you're consistently underwithholding like I was.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
22 If you've updated your W-4 but still have questions or need to deal with the amount you currently owe, you might want to try Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) to actually speak with the IRS. I was in a similar situation owing about $7k and needed to set up a payment plan. Spent DAYS trying to get through to the IRS with no luck - constant busy signals or disconnects after waiting for hours. Claimyr got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 15 minutes. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent helped me set up a reasonable payment plan with minimal penalties. They also explained some additional withholding strategies specific to my situation that have helped me avoid owing so much in subsequent years.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•17 Wait, I'm confused. How does this service get you through to the IRS faster? Doesn't everyone have to wait in the same phone queue? Sounds like they're claiming to have some special access or something.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•8 Yeah this sounds like BS. I've been trying to reach the IRS for 3 weeks. If there was some magical way to skip the line, everyone would be using it. I'll believe it when I see it.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•22 It's not about skipping the line - Claimyr uses an automated system that continually redials for you when the IRS line is busy. When it detects that a line is open, it calls you immediately and connects you to the IRS. You're still waiting in the same queue as everyone else once connected, but you don't have to spend hours manually redialing busy signals. The service basically handles the frustrating part of constantly getting busy signals and disconnects. I was skeptical too, but after trying for days on my own and getting nowhere, I was willing to try anything. It worked exactly as advertised - saved me hours of frustration and got me connected to resolve my payment issues.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
8 I have to eat my words. After seeing the responses here, I decided to try Claimyr because I was desperate to set up a payment plan before penalties increased. I thought it was complete BS, but I was connected to an IRS agent in about 20 minutes after weeks of trying on my own. The agent not only helped me set up a payment plan I could actually afford, but also explained that I qualified for first-time penalty abatement which saved me almost $800! I would have never known to ask about this. They also walked me through exactly how to adjust my withholding so I wouldn't be in this situation next year. Still can't believe I actually got through after all that time wasted on hold.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
3 Did you check if you're actually eligible to claim 1? A lot of people don't realize that your filing status, number of jobs, and other factors all affect what you should claim. My brother kept claiming 1 for years before realizing he should've been claiming 0 since he had a side gig that didn't withhold taxes.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•1 I thought I was eligible because I'm single with one job and no dependents. What other factors would make me need to claim 0 instead of 1? I don't have any side gigs, but I do have some investments that pay small dividends (maybe $2k per year).
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•3 Those investment dividends could definitely be part of your problem! Even $2k in dividend income doesn't have any tax withheld, so you need to account for that separately. With the new W-4 form, you'd add this as "other income" in Step 4(a). Also, if you receive any bonuses or commission that are taxed at a flat 22% supplemental rate, this might be less than your actual tax bracket if your income is high enough, creating a shortfall at tax time.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
10 Have you tried using tax software that lets you do tax planning? I use TurboTax and they have a feature where you can estimate next year's taxes and it tells you if you're withholding enough. Saved me from owing $3k this year because I caught the underwithholding in October and adjusted my W-4 for the last few months.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
•16 I second this! I use H&R Block and their tax planning tool caught that I was going to owe about $4,500. I immediately updated my W-4 to take out an extra $375 per month for the rest of the year. Still owed a little but WAY less than I would have otherwise.
0 coins