Can't reach IRS? Claimyr connects you to a live IRS agent in minutes.
Claimyr is a pay-as-you-go service. We do not charge a recurring subscription.
Using Claimyr will:
- Connect you to a human agent at the IRS
- Skip the long phone menu
- Call the correct department
- Redial until on hold
- Forward a call to your phone with reduced hold time
- Give you free callbacks if the IRS drops your call
If I could give 10 stars I would
If I could give 10 stars I would If I could give 10 stars I would Such an amazing service so needed during the times when EDD almost never picks up Claimyr gets me on the phone with EDD every time without fail faster. A much needed service without Claimyr I would have never received the payment I needed to support me during my postpartum recovery. Thank you so much Claimyr!
Really made a difference
Really made a difference, save me time and energy from going to a local office for making the call.
Worth not wasting your time calling for hours.
Was a bit nervous or untrusting at first, but my calls went thru. First time the wait was a bit long but their customer chat line on their page was helpful and put me at ease that I would receive my call. Today my call dropped because of EDD and Claimyr heard my concern on the same chat and another call was made within the hour.
An incredibly helpful service
An incredibly helpful service! Got me connected to a CA EDD agent without major hassle (outside of EDD's agents dropping calls – which Claimyr has free protection for). If you need to file a new claim and can't do it online, pay the $ to Claimyr to get the process started. Absolutely worth it!
Consistent,frustration free, quality Service.
Used this service a couple times now. Before I'd call 200 times in less than a weak frustrated as can be. But using claimyr with a couple hours of waiting i was on the line with an representative or on hold. Dropped a couple times but each reconnected not long after and was mission accomplished, thanks to Claimyr.
IT WORKS!! Not a scam!
I tried for weeks to get thru to EDD PFL program with no luck. I gave this a try thinking it may be a scam. OMG! It worked and They got thru within an hour and my claim is going to finally get paid!! I upgraded to the $60 call. Best $60 spent!
Ask the community...
- DO post questions about your issues.
- DO answer questions and support each other.
- DO post tips & tricks to help folks.
- DO NOT post call problems here - there is a support tab at the top for that :)
Join the conversation
Join the conversation
This thread has been incredibly helpful! I'm dealing with a similar situation but with vintage art prints that I've been collecting for about 8 years. Reading through everyone's experiences has clarified so much about the 28% cap rule and the importance of documentation. One thing I'm curious about that I haven't seen addressed - does anyone know how the collectibles tax rules apply to items that might straddle the line between collectible and regular investment? I have some limited edition prints by contemporary artists that were sold through galleries as "investment grade" art, but I'm not sure if they'd be classified the same way as more traditional collectibles like coins or baseball cards. Also, @Sean Doyle your point about timing sales during lower income years is something I really want to explore. I'm a freelancer so my income varies quite a bit year to year. It sounds like there could be real tax savings by being strategic about when I sell pieces, especially since some of my prints have appreciated significantly. The record keeping advice from everyone has convinced me I need to get much more organized. I have most of my purchase receipts, but I've been pretty casual about tracking things like framing costs and insurance - sounds like I should be more systematic about documenting everything that could potentially be added to my basis. Thanks to everyone for sharing their real experiences with collectibles taxes. This is exactly the kind of practical information that's impossible to find in the generic tax articles online!
@Jace Caspullo Your question about contemporary art prints is a great one! The IRS classification generally doesn t'depend on whether something was marketed as investment "grade -" what matters is the nature of the item itself. Art prints, even contemporary limited editions, would typically fall under the collectibles category and be subject to the 28% cap rule, just like traditional art, coins, or trading cards. The key distinction the IRS makes is whether the item is held for personal enjoyment/investment versus business use. Since you re'collecting these prints presumably for appreciation and personal interest, they d'almost certainly be treated as collectibles regardless of how they were originally marketed by the galleries. As a fellow freelancer, I can definitely relate to the variable income situation! Strategic timing of sales can make a huge difference with the 28% cap structure. In years when your freelance income is lower and you re'in the 12% or 22% bracket, your collectible gains would be taxed at those lower rates instead of hitting the full 28% cap. It s'definitely worth planning around if you have flexibility in timing your sales. For framing and insurance costs - framing that s'done to preserve or present the artwork can often be added to your basis, but insurance is typically considered an ongoing expense rather than a basis addition. Keep those framing receipts though, especially for museum-quality framing that adds long-term value to the pieces!
Coming at this from a different angle - I'm a CPA who specializes in collectibles taxation and wanted to add some professional perspective to what's been an excellent discussion thread. Everything shared here about the 28% cap rate is correct, but I want to emphasize a few nuances that could save people significant money. First, the timing strategy several people mentioned is crucial - if you can control when you realize gains, selling in years when your ordinary income is lower can result in substantial tax savings since you'll pay your marginal rate (up to the 28% cap) rather than the full 28%. Second, on the business vs. investment distinction that @Layla Sanders and others raised - the IRS looks at the "facts and circumstances" but frequency is a huge red flag. I generally advise clients to limit sales to no more than 10-15% of their collection per year to stay clearly in investment territory. Document your collecting intent and keep items for at least 12-18 months when possible. Finally, for anyone dealing with substantial collectible gains (over $50k), consider consulting with a tax professional who understands collectibles. The rules around like-kind exchanges (1031 exchanges) were eliminated for collectibles in 2018, but there are still some advanced strategies for deferring or minimizing tax on large gains that most general practitioners aren't familiar with. The record-keeping advice everyone's shared is spot-on - I see too many clients scrambling to reconstruct basis information during tax season. Start organizing now!
@Daniela Rossi Thank you so much for adding the professional perspective! This is incredibly valuable coming from someone who actually specializes in collectibles taxation. Your point about limiting sales to 10-15% of collection per year to stay in investment territory is really helpful - that gives me a concrete guideline to follow rather than just guessing where the line might be. I m'particularly interested in your comment about advanced strategies for deferring tax on large gains. I have a vintage watch collection that s'appreciated significantly, and while I m'not quite at the $50k gain level yet, I could see getting there in the next few years as some of my pieces continue to appreciate. Are there specific strategies you d'recommend researching, or is this really something that requires individual consultation given the complexity? The elimination of 1031 exchanges for collectibles in 2018 is something I wasn t'aware of - that seems like it would have been a useful tool for collectors looking to upgrade their collections without immediate tax consequences. Are there any other recent tax law changes that collectibles owners should be aware of? Also, your advice about keeping items for 12-18 months minimum is noted - I ll'definitely be more mindful about that holding period going forward. Better to be conservative and clearly qualify for long-term capital gains treatment than risk the much higher short-term rates.
Join the conversation
This has been such an enlightening discussion! As someone who's been hesitant to invest in hedge funds partly due to the tax complexity, reading through everyone's experiences really helps demystify the process. A few key takeaways I'm noting for anyone else following along: 1. The Section 754 election seems to be a critical factor that can significantly impact your tax treatment - definitely worth asking about upfront when investing, not just when redeeming. 2. The "hot assets" issue under Section 751 could turn what you expect to be capital gains into ordinary income - this seems like something that could really catch people off guard if they're not prepared for it. 3. The timing of redemptions can make a meaningful difference - both the calendar timing and coordination with the fund's typical trading patterns. One question I haven't seen addressed: for those who have gone through this process, how far in advance did you start planning your redemption from a tax perspective? It sounds like there's quite a bit of information gathering and analysis involved, so I'm wondering if this is something you need to start thinking about months ahead of when you actually want to redeem. Also, has anyone dealt with redemptions during volatile market periods? I'm curious if market volatility affects any of these tax calculations or creates additional timing considerations beyond the normal tax planning aspects. Thanks to everyone who's shared their experiences - this is exactly the kind of real-world insight that's hard to find elsewhere!
Great summary of the key points! You're absolutely right that these factors can really catch investors off guard if they're not prepared. Regarding timing, I'd recommend starting the tax planning process at least 3-6 months before you want to redeem, especially for larger positions. This gives you time to request and review all the documentation, potentially get professional advice, and coordinate with any other tax planning you're doing for the year. Some funds also have specific redemption notice periods (often 30-90 days), so you need to factor that into your timeline as well. For volatile market periods, you raise an excellent point. Market volatility can definitely affect the calculations, particularly around unrealized gains/losses. I've seen situations where investors planned a redemption during a market downturn thinking they'd have minimal gain recognition, only to have the fund realize significant gains right before their redemption date due to portfolio rebalancing or defensive trading. One strategy some investors use during volatile periods is to request updated pro forma redemption estimates periodically leading up to their intended redemption date. This helps avoid surprises, though of course the final numbers won't be known until the actual redemption occurs. The complexity really does underscore the importance of understanding these tax implications upfront when investing, not just at the exit. It's one of those areas where a little advance planning can save significant headaches and potentially money down the road.
This thread has been incredibly valuable for understanding hedge fund redemption taxation! I'm a CPA who specializes in partnership taxation, and I wanted to add a few additional considerations that haven't been fully addressed yet. One critical point regarding the Section 754 election: even if your fund has made this election, it only applies to transfers that occur AFTER the election was made. So if you invested before the fund made the election, you might not get the full benefit of the stepped-up basis adjustment. This is something worth clarifying with your fund's tax team. Also, regarding the unrealized gains treatment - there's an important distinction between "regular" unrealized gains and gains that might be subject to the "mixing bowl" rules under Sections 704(c) and 737. If your fund holds appreciated property that was contributed by partners rather than purchased by the partnership, different rules may apply to your redemption. For those dealing with international hedge funds or funds that invest significantly in foreign securities, be aware of potential PFIC (Passive Foreign Investment Company) implications. These can create additional ordinary income treatment and interest charges that aren't immediately obvious from the standard partnership tax analysis. Finally, don't overlook the potential for "phantom income" in your final year. Even though you're redeeming, you'll still receive a K-1 for your portion of the year before redemption, and you could owe taxes on income that you never actually received in cash if the partnership made non-cash distributions or had debt-financed income. I'd strongly recommend getting professional advice for any significant redemption - the potential tax savings usually far exceed the advisory fees!
Thank you for adding these crucial technical details! As someone new to hedge fund investing, this is exactly the kind of nuanced information that would be impossible to figure out on your own. The point about the Section 754 election only applying to transfers after it was made is particularly eye-opening - that could completely change the tax impact depending on when you invested versus when the fund made the election. I definitely wouldn't have thought to ask about that timing. The "mixing bowl" rules and PFIC implications you mentioned sound incredibly complex. For someone like me who's considering their first hedge fund redemption, how would you even know if these issues apply to your situation? Are these things that would typically be disclosed in the fund documents, or do you need to specifically ask about them? Also, your point about "phantom income" is concerning - could you potentially owe significant taxes on your final K-1 even if you've already redeemed and no longer have the investment to generate cash to pay those taxes? That seems like it could create a really difficult cash flow situation. This is all reinforcing my sense that I should definitely get professional help rather than trying to figure this out myself. Do you have recommendations for finding CPAs who specialize in this area? It seems like regular tax preparers might not have the expertise to handle these partnership complexities properly.
Join the conversation
18 Has anyone tried bunching their donations? My tax guy suggested I donate 2 years worth in one year so I could itemize, then take the standard deduction the next year. Seems like a hassle but might be worth it if you're donating substantial amounts.
5 I've done this for the past 4 years and it works great! In even-numbered years I donate around $5000 and itemize, then in odd-numbered years I donate nothing and take the standard deduction. You need to plan which charities are okay with this pattern though. Some smaller organizations really depend on consistent annual support.
14 Another strategy worth considering is using a Donor Advised Fund (DAF) if you're planning to donate regularly over several years. You can contribute a larger lump sum in a year when you itemize (getting the full tax deduction), then distribute grants to your favorite charities over multiple years from the fund. For example, if you normally donate $1,300 annually, you could contribute $2,600-$3,900 to a DAF in one year, itemize that year, then make your charitable grants from the fund over the next 2-3 years while taking the standard deduction. Fidelity, Schwab, and Vanguard all offer DAFs with relatively low minimums ($5,000 or less). This gives you more flexibility than the bunching strategy since you're not locked into a rigid every-other-year pattern.
That's a really smart approach! I hadn't heard of Donor Advised Funds before. Do you know if there are any restrictions on which charities you can donate to from a DAF? Also, are there any fees associated with these funds that might eat into the donations? With only $1,300 annually, I want to make sure most of it actually goes to the charities rather than administrative costs.
Join the conversation
Just want to add something that might help with the quarterly payments question - your nephew should definitely set up estimated tax payments if he's not having taxes withheld. The IRS safe harbor rule means he won't face penalties if he pays 100% of last year's tax liability (or 110% if his AGI was over $150K) divided into four quarterly payments. Since he's just starting this job, his previous year's tax liability was probably much lower, so this could be a manageable amount while he figures out exactly what he'll owe with the cruise income. One more thing - if the cruise line has any US operations or offices, they might actually be required to withhold US taxes even for foreign-flagged vessels. It's worth having him ask HR about this directly. Some cruise lines do withhold for US citizens even when they're not legally required to, just to make things easier for their American employees. The international debit card situation is pretty standard in the cruise industry, but make sure he keeps detailed records of every deposit. Screenshot the deposit notifications, save monthly statements, whatever he can get. The IRS will want to see proof of income even without traditional tax forms.
This is really solid advice about the quarterly payments! I'm actually in a similar situation - just started working on a Celebrity cruise ship last month. One thing I learned from talking to other American crew members is that some cruise lines will actually help you set up the quarterly payments if you ask. They deal with this situation all the time with US employees. Also wanted to mention that keeping those deposit records is crucial - I use a simple spreadsheet to track every deposit with the date, amount, and any fees deducted. Makes it much easier when tax time comes around. The cruise line's payroll department should also be able to provide you with a letter stating total compensation paid, even if they don't issue a W-2 or 1099. @Ava Thompson - Do you know if there s'a specific threshold where the cruise line HAS to withhold taxes for US operations? I m'curious if the size of their US office matters for this requirement.
@Emma Wilson Great question about the withholding requirements! From what I understand, it s'not really about the size of the US office, but more about whether the cruise line is considered to have effectively "connected income with" a US trade or business. If they have substantial US operations like (ticket sales, marketing, or passenger services ,)they might be required to treat US citizen employees as if they re'working for a US employer for tax purposes. However, most cruise lines structure their operations specifically to avoid this requirement. They ll'often have the actual employment contracts handled by their foreign subsidiary, even if they have a large US office for other operations. It s'pretty common for the US office to be just a sales and marketing operation while the actual cruise operations and employment are handled by the foreign entity. Your best bet is to ask HR directly about their withholding policies for US citizens. Some do it voluntarily to help their American crew members, others don t.'Either way, you ll'want to plan for quarterly payments just in case. Better to be prepared than get hit with underpayment penalties! The spreadsheet tracking system you mentioned is exactly what I was going to suggest. Makes everything so much easier come tax time.
One more important consideration for your nephew - he should also look into whether he needs to file Form 8938 (Statement of Specified Foreign Financial Assets) in addition to the FBAR that others mentioned. If that international debit card account has a balance over $50,000 at any point during the year (or $75,000 at year-end), he'll need to report it on Form 8938 as well. Also, since he's working as an entertainer, make sure he keeps detailed records of any work-related expenses he pays out of pocket - costumes, equipment, training materials, etc. These could be deductible business expenses on Schedule C if he ends up filing as self-employed. The cruise industry can be tricky for tax purposes, but the good news is that many crew members have navigated this successfully. I'd recommend he connect with other American crew members on his ship - they've probably dealt with similar tax situations and might have practical tips specific to his cruise line's payroll setup. One last tip: if he's planning to work multiple contracts over several years, consider having him establish a relationship with a tax professional who specializes in international tax situations early on. It'll make future years much smoother, especially if his income increases and he needs to deal with more complex planning strategies.
@Kiara Greene This is really comprehensive advice! I hadn t'thought about the Form 8938 requirement - that s'a good catch. The $50,000 threshold might seem high, but if he s'working 10 months and saving money while living on the ship, it could definitely add up. The point about connecting with other American crew members is spot on. I ve'found that the cruise ship community is pretty tight-knit, and experienced crew members are usually willing to help newcomers figure out the tax situation. They might even know which tax preparers other crew members have used successfully. One thing I d'add - since he s'new to this, he should definitely keep a detailed log of his days in different locations throughout his contract. Not just for the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion calculation, but also because different ports might have their own tax implications if he s'earning income while docked there. Most of the time this won t'matter since he s'employed by the cruise line rather than working independently in each port, but it s'good documentation to have. Also worth noting that if this becomes a long-term career for him, he might want to consider establishing tax home somewhere other than the US eventually, but that s'getting into more complex territory that would definitely require professional guidance.
Mei Liu
This is such a comprehensive discussion! As someone who went through this exact situation a few years ago, I want to add one practical tip that really helped me: keep a simple spreadsheet tracking your year-to-date withholding from both jobs. I set up a basic Excel sheet with columns for pay date, gross pay, federal withholding, and cumulative totals for each job. Every payday, I'd spend 2 minutes updating it. This made it super easy to see if I was on track with my withholding goals throughout the year. The spreadsheet also helped me catch when my restaurant job (similar to Omar's situation) had a payroll error that under-withheld taxes for three weeks straight. I probably wouldn't have noticed until tax time otherwise! For Omar specifically - given that you're making $42K + $15K, you're looking at roughly $8,500-$9,000 in total federal taxes for the year (very rough estimate). Having that target in mind while tracking your actual withholding can give you peace of mind that you're staying on course. One more thing - if you do end up owing a little at tax time (under $1,000), don't stress too much. As long as you paid at least 90% of this year's tax liability or 100% of last year's tax liability through withholding, you won't face any underpayment penalties.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
•This spreadsheet tracking idea is brilliant! I wish I had thought of doing this when I started my second job. I've been kind of flying blind just hoping my withholding adjustments were working. Quick question about your rough tax estimate - when you say $8,500-$9,000 in federal taxes for Omar's income level, does that include just income tax or also the Social Security and Medicare taxes? I'm trying to figure out what my total "federal withholding" line on my paystubs should add up to by the end of the year. Also, that's a great point about the underpayment penalty thresholds. I didn't realize there was a safe harbor rule if you pay at least what you owed last year. That takes some of the pressure off getting the withholding calculation perfect, especially for those of us with variable hours at our second jobs. Thanks for sharing such practical advice! I'm definitely going to set up a tracking spreadsheet this weekend.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
This is such valuable information! I'm actually in a very similar situation to Omar - just started a second job about a month ago and have been putting off dealing with the W-4 situation because it seemed so overwhelming. Reading through everyone's experiences, I think the biggest takeaway for me is that doing nothing is probably the worst option. I was kind of hoping I could just ignore it and everything would work out, but it sounds like that's a recipe for a nasty surprise come tax time. The IRS Tax Withholding Estimator seems to be the unanimous recommendation here, and honestly, 10-15 minutes to potentially save myself from owing thousands in April seems like time well spent. I'm going to bite the bullet and run through it this weekend with my paystubs from both jobs. One thing I'm curious about - for those who have used the estimator multiple times throughout the year, do you find that small changes in income or hours make a big difference in the recommendations? I'm worried about constantly tweaking my W-4 if my part-time hours fluctuate week to week. Thanks to everyone for sharing such detailed, real-world advice. This thread has been way more helpful than any generic tax article I've found online!
0 coins