
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
This is my first time handling a clergy member's taxes and I'm completely stumped with the housing allowance situation. I'm working with a pastor (let's call him Pastor Mike) who gave me his W-2 showing $33k in boxes 1, 3, and 5. Boxes 4 and 6 have the normal Social Security and Medicare withholding amounts. But then there's box 14 that shows "Housing Allowance $15,000" and I'm not sure how to handle this on his return. I know clergy taxation is unique, but I'm confused about whether this housing allowance is taxable for income tax purposes vs. self-employment tax purposes. Do I need to add it back somewhere? Is it excluded from income completely? I've read something about Schedule SE but not sure how that interacts with the W-2 values. Any help from someone who's dealt with clergy taxes before would be really appreciated! I don't want to mess this up for my client.
I recently picked up a part-time teaching position at my local community college as extra income. I'm only teaching 5-6 credits per semester at this point. Based on their pay scale, my bi-weekly checks are around $434.90 after Medicare and Social Security deductions, but I noticed they're not withholding ANY federal income tax. I ran into this same issue last year with another side gig. Apparently, if you make less than $600 bi-weekly, they don't automatically withhold federal taxes because the amount is considered too low. For that job, I just requested they withhold $15 per check (and those checks were only like $150-$200 every two weeks). My situation is that I have a full-time job, my wife also works full-time, and we file Married Filing Jointly. What I need to know is how much should I request this community college to withhold for federal taxes from these biweekly paychecks? I don't want to get hit with a big tax bill come filing time.
I adjunct at a community college too! For my $500ish biweekly checks, I have them withhold $100 for federal taxes. My spouse and I are in the 22% bracket with our combined incomes, and this has worked out almost perfectly for the past two years. You could try a similar percentage. Just remember that teaching income stacks on top of your other income for tax bracket purposes, so it's getting taxed at your highest marginal rate. Don't make the mistake I made the first year where I only had 10% withheld because I thought that's what the bracket would be if it was my only job!
I'm dealing with a similar situation with my part-time consulting work! One thing that really helped me was using the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator on their website. You can input all your income sources - your full-time job, your spouse's income, and your teaching income - and it will give you a pretty accurate recommendation for additional withholding. Since you're married filing jointly with two full-time incomes plus the teaching gig, you're likely in the 22% or 24% bracket. For your ~$435 biweekly checks, I'd probably start with requesting around $85-95 in federal withholding. You can always adjust it later if needed by submitting a new W-4. The key thing to remember is that this side income is being taxed at your marginal rate since it's "on top of" all your other income. Better to err on the side of slightly overwithholding than getting hit with underpayment penalties!
I submitted my tax return using FreeTaxUSA on March 12th and it was accepted on March 13th. I opted for the expedited processing option which supposedly gets your refund 5 days earlier (would put my deposit around April 1st according to the estimated DDD from IRS). It's now been over two weeks and the Where's My Refund tool still just shows "processing" and my transcripts haven't updated at all. Haven't received any emails or updates. This is my first time using FreeTaxUSA after years with another service, so I'm not sure if this is normal. Anyone else experiencing delays like this or know what to expect?
Something similar happened to me and I was going CRAZY trying to figure out what was wrong with my return. Spent hours researching transcript codes and still couldn't understand why it was delayed. I used taxr.ai and it translated all the IRS gibberish instantly! Showed me exactly why my refund was delayed (had a random review code) and when to expect it. Saved me so much stress - definitely recommend checking it out at https://taxr.ai if you're stuck in limbo like I was.
I'm in a really similar situation! Filed with TurboTax on March 10th, accepted March 11th, and still showing "being processed" on WMR. My transcripts are also showing N/A for 2023. This is so frustrating because I really need that refund for some upcoming bills. It's reassuring to see I'm not the only one dealing with this - the IRS processing times seem all over the place this year. Thanks for posting about this, it helps to know others are in the same boat!
I'm at my wit's end here! I mailed my tax return back in February (with plenty of time before the deadline) and now the IRS is telling me they never received anything from me! I've been trying to call them for weeks but either get disconnected or sit on hold forever before giving up. I had a refund coming of about $4,300 that I was counting on. I kept the certified mail receipt but that only shows it was delivered to the IRS facility, not that they actually processed it. I even tried checking "Where's My Refund" but it says there's no information on my return. Has anyone dealt with this before? What am I supposed to do when they can't find my return but won't answer their phones? Should I just file again electronically? I'm worried about being penalized for filing twice or having my return flagged as suspicious. I'm seriously stressed about this!
Has anyone tried faxing the IRS? I was in a similar situation last year and ended up faxing a copy of my return with a cover letter explaining that it was previously mailed. I got confirmation they received it within about 2 weeks, and my refund started processing after that. Just make sure to write "DUPLICATE - ORIGINAL MAILED ON [DATE]" on every page.
I went through this exact nightmare two years ago! Here's what finally worked for me: Don't panic about filing twice - the IRS has procedures for handling duplicate returns. What you need to do is file a Form 3911 (Taxpayer Statement Regarding Refund) along with a copy of your original return. This formally starts a trace on your missing return. Since you have the certified mail receipt, you're actually in a strong position. The IRS considers your return timely filed based on the postmark date, even if they can't locate it internally. Make sure to keep that receipt safe! I also recommend sending everything via certified mail again, but this time include a detailed cover letter explaining the situation, your certified mail tracking number from the original filing, and copies of any correspondence you've had with the IRS. One thing that helped me was creating an online account at irs.gov - sometimes the online transcripts show information that phone representatives can't see. It's worth checking your account transcript to see if there's any record of your return being received. The whole process took about 6 weeks for me, but I did get my full refund plus interest for the delay. Hang in there!
I recently sold a parcel of vacant land that I had originally purchased with plans to build a home on it. Life circumstances changed, and I ended up selling it instead, making about $20,000 profit on the sale. I'm trying to understand my tax obligations correctly. From what I've researched, I know I need to pay capital gains tax - federal (15%) and state (5.57%) on the profit I made from the sale. However, I'm getting conflicting advice from family members who are insisting I have to report the ENTIRE sale amount as income on my tax return, not just the capital gain portion. This would obviously result in a much higher tax bill. Can someone clarify what's actually required here? Do I only report and pay taxes on the $20,000 profit, or do I somehow need to report the full sale amount as income and pay additional taxes beyond just the capital gains? I'm really confused and don't want to make a mistake that could cause problems with the IRS later.
Dont forget to check if your state has different capital gains rates than federal! I got burned on this last year - my state treats all capital gains as ordinary income so I ended up paying a higher rate than I expected.
Great thread with lots of helpful info! Just wanted to add one more consideration that saved me some money when I sold land last year - don't forget about selling expenses when calculating your basis. You can add legitimate selling costs like real estate agent commissions, attorney fees, title insurance, transfer taxes, and even advertising costs to your basis. This reduces your taxable gain dollar-for-dollar. In my case, I had about $3,500 in selling expenses that I almost forgot to include. That reduced my capital gain by $3,500, saving me around $525 in taxes (15% federal rate). Make sure you keep all receipts related to the sale - they're deductible against your gain!
Keisha Taylor
Don't forget to check state tax rules for clergy housing allowances! Federal excludes it from income tax but includes it for SE tax. But states vary wildly - some follow federal exclusion, others tax it fully, and some have special clergy provisions. In my state of California, the housing allowance is excluded from income for state tax purposes if it qualifies for federal exclusion. But I have a clergy client who moved from Pennsylvania where they DO tax housing allowances. Make sure you know your state rules!
0 coins
StardustSeeker
Good point about state variations! Do you know if there's a good resource that lists how each state handles clergy housing allowances? I've looked around but haven't found a comprehensive guide.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
I don't know of a single comprehensive guide for all states. Your best bet is to check with your specific state's department of revenue or taxation. Most have publications or sections of their tax guides dedicated to clergy income. For the most complex states, denominational offices often provide state-specific guidance for their ministers. The Church Law & Tax organization also has some good state-by-state resources, though you might need a subscription to access the detailed information.
0 coins
Paolo Marino
One thing nobody mentioned - make sure your clergy client is aware of the Parsonage Allowance Lawsuit situation. Some court cases have challenged the constitutionality of the housing allowance exclusion as a violation of separation of church and state. The latest case (Gaylor v. Mnuchin) upheld the allowance, but it's been challenged multiple times. Just something to be aware of since this area of tax law could potentially change in future years.
0 coins
Amina Bah
Is there actually any real chance of this benefit going away? My pastor client is planning his finances around this exclusion for years to come. Should I be warning him that this might not be something he can count on long-term?
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
The housing allowance has survived multiple constitutional challenges over the decades, so I wouldn't panic about it disappearing overnight. The most recent decision in Gaylor v. Mnuchin actually strengthened the precedent by ruling it doesn't violate the Establishment Clause. That said, it's always wise to diversify tax planning strategies. I tell my clergy clients to take advantage of the exclusion while it exists, but also build other tax-advantaged savings like maximizing retirement contributions. The benefit has been around since 1954 and has strong support from religious organizations across all denominations, so any change would likely be gradual with plenty of advance notice. Your pastor should definitely use the exclusion for current planning, but having backup strategies isn't a bad idea for long-term financial planning.
0 coins