
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I've been putting money into a traditional IRA since 2020 and I'm trying to figure out the tax implications now that I've converted everything to a Roth in 2024. In 2020 and 2022, I was able to deduct my contributions because my income was lower, but in 2021 and 2023 I couldn't deduct them due to income limits. My question is about how to calculate the taxable amount for this Backdoor Roth conversion. I think the total gains on my investments (the value at conversion minus my original contributions) need to be allocated proportionally between my deducted and non-deducted contributions. Then, the taxable amount would be my previously deducted contributions plus the portion of gains allocated to those deducted contributions. For example, if I contributed $6,000 in each year (total $24,000), with $12,000 deducted and $12,000 non-deducted, and the total value grew to $30,000 (so $6,000 in gains), would half of those gains ($3,000) be allocated to my deducted portion? That would make my taxable amount $15,000 ($12,000 deducted contributions + $3,000 allocated gains). Am I thinking about this correctly? This backdoor Roth stuff is making my head spin!
Just checked my IRS transcript for the first time and noticed they only show part of my name and address at the top? ๐ Feels weird to see it cut off like that. I'm still new to the US tax system (moved here 2 years ago) so not sure if this is normal or something to worry about. Don't want to make any mistakes that could delay my refund - I'm counting on it to catch up on some bills! Is this how everyone's transcript looks or should I contact someone about it?
@e97069fb8802 Hey there! I totally understand your concern - when I first moved to the US and saw my transcript with partial information, I thought there was some kind of error too! ๐ But everyone here is absolutely right that this is completely normal and actually shows the IRS is taking good care of protecting your personal information. As someone who's been through the "new to US taxes" experience, here's what helped me feel more confident: I compared the important numbers on my transcript (like my total income and tax withheld) with my actual tax return, and everything matched perfectly even though the name and address were partially masked. That's really all that matters for your refund processing! Since you mentioned counting on your refund for bills, I'd definitely recommend using the "Where's My Refund" tool on IRS.gov - it updates every 24 hours and gives you a pretty clear timeline of where things stand. Most electronic returns with direct deposit process within 2-3 weeks, so hopefully you won't have to wait much longer! You're being smart by double-checking everything. That attention to detail will really help you as you get more comfortable with the US tax system. Don't stress too much - sounds like you've got everything handled correctly! ๐
@e97069fb8802 @d2bef0c1d010 Just wanted to add my voice to this incredibly helpful thread! I'm also fairly new to the US tax system (moved here about 18 months ago) and had the exact same initial panic when I saw my transcript for the first time last month. That partial information display really does look concerning when you're not expecting it! What really helped ease my mind was realizing that this masking is actually the IRS being proactive about protecting our data - especially important for those of us who might not be as familiar with all the potential scams out there. Liam's suggestion about comparing the key numbers to your actual return is perfect advice. @e97069fb8802 Since you're counting on your refund, one thing that gave me peace of mind was setting up text alerts through my bank for any deposits. That way I'd know immediately when the refund hit my account rather than constantly checking. The waiting is definitely stressful when you need those funds! It's so comforting to see how many of us newcomers went through this same initial confusion. Makes the whole system feel a lot less intimidating knowing we're all figuring it out together! Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences. ๐
@e97069fb8802 Don't worry at all - what you're seeing is completely normal! I had the exact same concern when I first checked my transcript after moving to the US. That partial information display is actually the IRS's way of protecting your identity while still letting you verify it's your account. I remember calling the IRS in a panic about this same issue, and they explained that they intentionally mask personal details on transcripts as a security measure. You'll see partial name, partial address, and only the last 4 digits of your SSN - but all your tax data (income, withholdings, credits) will be complete and unmasked. Since you're counting on your refund, focus on making sure those key tax numbers match what you filed rather than worrying about the header info. The partial masking won't affect your refund processing at all! If you filed electronically with direct deposit, most refunds come within 21 days. You're doing exactly the right thing by double-checking everything - that careful attention will serve you well as you get more familiar with the US tax system. The "Where's My Refund" tool on IRS.gov will give you the most current updates on your refund status. Good luck! ๐ค
Hey tax people, I'm losing my mind trying to figure out if our multi-member LLC can be treated as a disregarded entity for tax purposes. My business partner and I started a small marketing agency last year, and we originally filed as an LLC with two members (me and my cousin). Our accountant mentioned something about possibly being able to file as a disregarded entity to simplify our taxes, but everything I'm reading online suggests that only single-member LLCs qualify for disregarded entity status. Does anyone have experience with this? Is there any way a multi-member LLC can be treated as a disregarded entity for federal tax purposes? Or are we stuck filing partnership returns? Our revenue was about $87k last year but we're projecting around $125k this year, so I'm trying to figure out the most tax-efficient approach. Any guidance would be super appreciated!
Another option nobody's mentioned is that one member could sell their interest to the other, making it a single-member LLC that can be treated as a disregarded entity. Then the former member could become an employee or independent contractor of the business. This might work depending on your specific situation and relationship.
Interesting idea but wouldn't there be tax consequences from selling the ownership interest? Like capital gains or something? And what about if both members want to maintain ownership for liability reasons?
Yes, there could definitely be tax consequences from selling the ownership interest - potentially capital gains depending on the value of the business versus the original investment. It's not a solution for everyone. If maintaining shared ownership is important, you could explore creating a single-member LLC owned by one person, and that person could grant profit interests or other compensation arrangements to the other party. This gets complicated quickly though and would require consulting with both a tax professional and business attorney to structure properly.
I went through this exact situation with my consulting LLC last year. The short answer is no - multi-member LLCs cannot be treated as disregarded entities under any circumstances. The IRS is very clear that disregarded entity status is only available for single-member LLCs. Your default classification is partnership taxation (Form 1065), but you're absolutely right to explore other options. At your income level, an S-Corp election could save you significant money on self-employment taxes. Here's what I learned: 1. With partnership taxation, both members pay self-employment tax on their entire share of profits 2. With S-Corp election, you only pay employment taxes on reasonable salaries, not on distributions For a $125k business, if you each took $40k salaries and split the remaining $45k as distributions, you'd save about $3,400 in SE taxes annually (15.3% ร $45k). The tradeoff is quarterly payroll filings and more complex bookkeeping. I'd strongly recommend running the numbers with a CPA before deciding. The breakeven point where S-Corp election makes sense is usually around $60-80k in profits, so you're definitely in the range where it could be beneficial.
Well I'm in a total panic right now. After being a loyal customer for almost a decade, my CPA just fired me as a client literally 2 weeks before year-end closing! This morning I refused to pay a fee for some tax questions they never even answered (but still tried billing me for their "time"). The owner said it wasn't an issue, then tonight emails me saying they're terminating our relationship effective immediately! I've had professionals handle my taxes for the past 15 years, so jumping back into DIY mode feels overwhelming, but I think I can manage it (I've always been pretty good with finances). What should I prioritize between now and April? Should I waste precious time hunting for a new CPA during their busiest season when most aren't taking clients, or just buckle down and handle everything myself? Realistically, I probably don't have many options at this point in the year, so I'm preparing to DIY this whole mess. Where do I even begin? What tools and accounts do I need? Here's what I'm working with: S-Corp (pass-through entity), need to finalize Q4 2024 payroll, send several 1099-NEC forms. I also have one Schedule-C business and a partnership for a real estate investment. I use QuickBooks to track expenses across all these businesses. Any advice would be hugely appreciated! I'm seriously stressing out here.
Since you're already using QuickBooks, make sure you're leveraging its full potential for your year-end processes. For your 1099-NECs, you need to have vendors properly flagged as 1099 contractors with complete W-9 information entered. Run the 1099 verification report ASAP to see what's missing. For S-Corp reasonable compensation documentation, create a formal corporate minute documenting how you determined your salary amount. This is crucial if you ever get audited. Don't forget about state filings too! Many S-Corps have state filing requirements beyond just the federal return. QuickBooks reports filtered by state can help organize this information.
Thanks for the QuickBooks tips! One question - for the 1099 vendors, some of them were added years ago and I'm not sure we ever got proper W-9s. What's the best way to handle that this late in the year when I need to issue them in just a few weeks?
For those vendors without W-9s, send them the form immediately with a deadline of 7 days for return. Most vendors are used to this process and will respond quickly. You can email them the form with a clear subject line mentioning the urgent tax deadline. If any vendors don't respond, you'll still need to issue their 1099-NECs by the deadline, but you might have to do so with incomplete information. In that case, use whatever information you have on file, but be aware that you may need to issue corrected forms later. The IRS can penalize for missing or incorrect TINs, so document your good-faith efforts to obtain this information by keeping records of your requests.
Don't forget about the Qualified Business Income (QBI) deduction for your S-Corp and Schedule C! It's a potentially huge tax benefit (up to 20% of your business income) that many DIY filers miss. Also, remember that S-Corp reasonable compensation requirements mean you MUST pay yourself a market-rate salary before taking distributions. If your salary is too low compared to distributions, it's a huge audit flag.
How do you determine what a "reasonable" salary is though? I've heard different things from different accountants. Is there some kind of formula or percentage of profits?
There's no exact formula, but the IRS looks at what you would pay someone else to do your job. I use a combination of approaches: check salary.com or payscale.com for similar roles in your area, look at what comparable businesses pay their key employees, and consider your actual time spent on business activities versus passive ownership. A rough rule of thumb I've seen is around 60-70% of net business income as salary if you're actively involved full-time, but it really depends on your specific situation. The key is being able to document your reasoning - keep records of salary research you did and write a brief memo explaining how you arrived at your number. As long as you're in a reasonable range and can show you made a good faith effort to determine fair compensation, you should be fine.
I'm at my wits end trying to file my 1040 through the Free File Fillable Forms system. Every time I attempt to submit, the system keeps telling me there are errors, but it's super vague about what's actually wrong. I've gone over everything like five times and can't figure out what's missing. Has anyone else run into this problem? The deadline is coming up soon and I'm getting really anxious about getting this submitted on time. This is my third year using FFFF and never had issues before. Any suggestions on common errors that might be triggering this?
I had a similar issue and fixed it by signing out, clearing browser cache/cookies, and trying in a different browser (Chrome worked when Firefox didn't). Sometimes FFFF has browser compatibility issues that cause weird errors during submission. Worth trying before giving up!
This thread has been incredibly helpful! I've been dealing with the same FFFF submission errors for the past week. Based on all the suggestions here, I'm going to try the browser switching approach first (currently using Safari), then double-check my AGI from last year since I did file electronically. If those don't work, I might have to bite the bullet and try one of the services mentioned to identify what's actually wrong with my return. It's frustrating that the IRS system can't give more specific error messages - "there are errors" tells us nothing! Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences and solutions.
Everett Tutum
One thing nobody's mentioned yet: you need to be really careful with the timing of your backdoor Roth. Some people think there's a waiting period required between making non-deductible traditional contributions and converting to Roth, but that's actually a myth. The "step transaction doctrine" that people worry about has never been enforced by the IRS for backdoor Roths. When I did mine, I converted literally the day after making my non-deductible contribution, which minimized the gains I had to pay taxes on. If you wait too long between contribution and conversion, you'll have more gains to deal with in your pro-rata calculation.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
Is that really true? My financial advisor told me to wait at least 30 days between non-deductible contribution and conversion to avoid the step transaction doctrine. Are you saying that's unnecessary?
0 coins
Everett Tutum
The 30-day waiting period is one of those myths that gets repeated a lot but doesn't have any basis in actual IRS enforcement. The IRS has never challenged a backdoor Roth based on the step transaction doctrine, even when the contribution and conversion happen in quick succession. Congress has essentially blessed the backdoor Roth strategy through their inaction to close this "loophole" despite knowing about it for years. Many tax professionals now recommend doing the conversion as quickly as possible after the contribution to minimize taxable gains. But everyone has different risk tolerance, so some people still prefer to wait just to be extra cautious.
0 coins
Hugh Intensity
I messed this up last year and ended up paying way more in taxes than I needed to. I didn't realize that having money in a SEP IRA from a side business would affect my backdoor Roth conversion from my regular traditional IRA. The pro-rata rule looks at ALL your traditional IRA assets, not just the one you're converting from. So instead of just paying taxes on the deducted portion of the IRA I was converting, I had to pay taxes on a much larger percentage because of my SEP IRA balance.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
That's rough! Do you think it would have been better to roll your SEP IRA into a 401k first, then do the backdoor Roth? I've heard that can help avoid the pro-rata issue.
0 coins
Freya Larsen
Yes, rolling your SEP IRA into a 401(k) first would have completely avoided the pro-rata issue! Since 401(k)s aren't included in the pro-rata calculation, you could have then done a clean backdoor Roth conversion with just your non-deductible traditional IRA contributions. This is actually a common strategy called "reverse rollover" - moving your pre-tax IRA money into an employer plan to clear the way for future backdoor Roths. Not all 401(k) plans accept rollovers from IRAs though, so you'd need to check with your plan administrator first. For anyone reading this who has significant pre-tax IRA balances and wants to do backdoor Roths going forward, definitely look into this option before doing your conversions!
0 coins