


Ask the community...
This has been such an incredibly helpful thread! I'm in the exact same situation - just started a new job and my spouse runs their own business. I was totally confused about the W4 form until I found this discussion. The advice here is crystal clear: definitely don't check box 2c since that's only for when both spouses have traditional W-2 jobs with employers doing withholding. Since my spouse is self-employed and makes quarterly estimated payments, that box doesn't apply to our situation. What I'm planning to do based on everyone's advice: 1. Use the free IRS withholding estimator to calculate additional withholding for line 4(c) 2. Make sure I'm using my spouse's NET business income (after expenses) not gross revenue 3. Account for the higher tax rate on self-employment income (including SE tax) 4. Plan to review and adjust quarterly since business income can fluctuate I really appreciate everyone sharing their real numbers and experiences - it makes this so much less intimidating! The hybrid approach where you do some additional withholding plus coordinate with the spouse's quarterly payments seems like the smartest strategy for handling the variability in self-employment income. Going to tackle the IRS estimator this weekend and get my W4 updated. Thanks to everyone who contributed their knowledge here - this thread should definitely be bookmarked for anyone dealing with mixed employment situations!
This is such a great summary of all the key points discussed throughout this thread! As someone who was just as confused about this situation a few months ago, I can definitely confirm that the approach you've outlined is exactly what worked for me. One small tip I'd add - when you're working through the IRS withholding estimator this weekend, have your most recent pay stub handy along with a realistic estimate of your spouse's quarterly business income. The tool will ask for specific numbers like your current withholding amounts and pay frequency, so having that info ready will make the process much smoother. Also, don't be surprised if the additional withholding amount seems pretty substantial at first - remember that it's covering both the income tax AND the self-employment tax on your spouse's business income, which can add up quickly. The peace of mind of not owing a big chunk in April is definitely worth the smaller paychecks throughout the year! Best of luck getting your W4 sorted out - you're being really smart to tackle this proactively rather than just guessing and hoping for the best!
This has been such a comprehensive and helpful discussion! I'm also dealing with this exact situation - I have a W-2 job and my spouse just started their own marketing consulting business this year. Reading through all the advice here, I'm feeling much more confident about how to handle my W-4. The consensus is definitely clear: don't check box 2c since that's only meant for two traditional W-2 employees, not when one spouse is self-employed. I'm planning to follow the roadmap that's been laid out here: - Use the IRS withholding estimator with both my income and my spouse's projected net self-employment income - Add the calculated amount to line 4(c) for additional withholding - Remember that self-employment income gets hit with both income tax AND the 15.3% SE tax - Review quarterly since consulting income can be unpredictable What I found most valuable was seeing people's actual experiences and dollar amounts rather than just theoretical advice. The idea of doing a hybrid approach with some additional withholding from my job plus coordinated quarterly estimated payments makes a lot of sense for managing the variability in consulting income. Thanks to everyone who shared their real-world experiences - this thread has been incredibly educational and should definitely help others who find themselves in this same confusing situation!
As someone who's been through a similar situation with Chime and post-divorce financial transitions, I wanted to share my experience from this tax season. My DDD was 3/5 and the funds hit my Chime account on 3/3 at around 2:15pm EST - almost exactly 48 hours early. What really helped me was setting up push notifications on the Chime app so I knew immediately when it arrived, which was crucial since I was coordinating some time-sensitive financial arrangements. One thing I learned is that Chime's early deposit feature works so consistently with tax refunds that you can almost treat your DDD minus 1-2 days as your actual expected date. The peace of mind this provides during major life changes like divorce cannot be overstated. Best of luck with your deposit - based on everything shared here, you should see it by Monday 3/11 at the latest!
Thank you so much for sharing your experience! It's incredibly reassuring to hear from someone who's been through a similar situation. I just set up those push notifications you mentioned - that's such a practical tip that I hadn't thought of. The timing you described (48 hours early) aligns perfectly with what others have reported here, so it sounds like Monday 3/11 is a very realistic expectation for my deposit. Having that kind of predictability is honestly a huge relief when you're trying to coordinate finances during a major life transition. Sometimes it's the small certainties that help keep everything else manageable. Really appreciate you taking the time to share those details - it's exactly the kind of real-world insight that helps!
I wanted to add some perspective on the Chime early deposit timeline that might be helpful. I've been tracking this across multiple tax seasons, and there's actually a pretty predictable pattern with how the IRS releases funds versus when Chime makes them available. The IRS typically processes refund batches in waves - they'll approve a group of returns, assign DDDs, then release the ACH instructions to banks about 24-48 hours before the official date. Traditional banks like Chase or Bank of America receive these funds but are contractually obligated to hold them until the DDD. Chime's business model is built around early access, so they release funds immediately upon receipt. For your 3/12 DDD, I'd expect to see the deposit hit your account sometime between Saturday evening (3/9) and Monday afternoon (3/11). The exact timing often depends on which IRS processing center handled your return - some tend to release their batches earlier in the week than others. Given that you're navigating post-divorce finances, I'd recommend checking your account starting Friday evening just to be safe. The early arrival of these funds can make a significant difference when you're coordinating multiple financial obligations during a major life transition.
This is incredibly detailed and helpful! I really appreciate you breaking down the process step-by-step like this. It makes so much more sense now why there's such a consistent pattern with Chime deposits arriving early - I had no idea about the contractual obligations that traditional banks have to hold funds until the official date. Your timeline suggestion of checking starting Friday evening is great advice. I'd rather start looking early and have a pleasant surprise than miss it and worry something went wrong. The predictability you've described here is honestly such a relief when everything else feels uncertain right now. It's also reassuring to know that this pattern has held across multiple tax seasons - gives me a lot more confidence in planning around that Monday timeframe. Thank you for taking the time to share all these insights!
VA taxpayer here! I just went through this exact situation last month. After I completed my ID verification, it took 8 business days for my refund to hit my account. The key thing I learned is that VA's "Where's My Refund" portal is pretty unreliable - mine still showed "processing" even after I got paid! I'd recommend checking your actual bank account daily rather than obsessing over the portal. Also, if you have direct deposit set up, refunds typically hit on weekdays. From what I've seen talking to others, most people are getting theirs within 7-14 business days after verification, so you should be getting close! Stay patient, it's definitely coming.
Really appreciate you sharing your experience! 8 days sounds pretty reasonable. I'm about 6 days post-verification myself so hopefully I'm close. Good tip about checking the bank account directly - I've been relying too much on that portal which sounds like it's pretty useless for real-time updates. Did you get any email notifications from VA when it was processed or did it just show up in your account one day?
VA taxpayer here! Just wanted to share my recent experience since I see a lot of people going through the same thing. I completed my ID verification about 2 weeks ago and got my refund deposited yesterday (took 9 business days total). Like others mentioned, the Where's My Refund portal is pretty much useless - it was still showing "processing" when I woke up to find the money in my account! My advice: check your bank account directly each morning if you have direct deposit, and try not to stress too much about the portal status. VA seems to be processing verifications pretty consistently in that 7-14 day window. Hang in there, yours should be coming soon! š
This whole 199A deduction makes my head spin! I think the commenters above are right about software not being tangible property, but have you looked into whether you qualify for the deduction without worrying about the property test? If your taxable income is below $170,050 (single) or $340,100 (married filing jointly) for 2022, the qualified property limitation doesn't even apply to you and you can take the full 20% deduction regardless.
Those thresholds are outdated - they increase with inflation each year. For 2024 filing (2023 tax year), the thresholds are $182,100 (single) or $364,200 (married). For 2025 (2024 tax year), they'll be even higher.
I went through this exact same situation last year with my software consulting business. After consulting with my CPA and doing extensive research, I can confirm that custom software development costs do NOT qualify as tangible property for Section 199A purposes. The key distinction is that Section 199A requires "tangible property subject to depreciation under Section 167." While software can be depreciated, it fails the tangibility test. The IRS has been consistent on this - software is classified as an intangible asset unless it's inseparable from hardware (like firmware or pre-installed operating systems). For your $75,000 in development costs, focus instead on any computer equipment, servers, or other physical assets you purchased for the business. Those definitely count toward your qualified property basis. Also, don't forget about office furniture, testing equipment, or any other physical assets - they all add up and can help with the property limitation if your income is above the threshold. One thing that helped me was keeping better records of hardware vs. software purchases going forward, since the tax treatment is so different between the two.
This is really helpful, thanks for sharing your experience! I'm curious about one detail you mentioned - when you say "inseparable from hardware," does that include situations where I've developed custom software specifically for hardware devices I use in my business? For example, I created some diagnostic tools that only work with specific testing equipment I purchased. Would that change the classification at all, or is it still considered intangible because the software could theoretically be separated from the hardware?
StarGazer101
Has anyone successfully disputed one of these bills completely? I traded my motorcycle and then moved counties two weeks later. Now BOTH counties are trying to charge me property tax!
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
ā¢You definitely shouldn't pay twice! Most states have laws preventing double taxation. You'll need to provide both counties with documentation showing when you moved and when you traded the bike. The original county should only charge you for the time you lived there AND owned the bike. The new county shouldn't charge you at all if you didn't own the bike when you moved there.
0 coins
Serene Snow
This is a really common issue that catches people off guard! You're absolutely right to be confused - the property tax system doesn't automatically know about vehicle trades unless you tell them. Here's what typically happens: Property taxes are assessed based on who owned what vehicle on a specific date (usually January 1st in most places). Since you owned that first motorcycle during part of the tax year, you're responsible for paying property tax for the period you owned it. The good news is that most counties will prorate the tax based on your actual ownership period. You'll need to gather your documentation - the original purchase paperwork, the trade-in documents, and any transfer paperwork - and contact your county tax assessor's office. They can usually adjust the bill to reflect only the roughly 2 months you actually owned the bike. Don't just ignore the bill though - unpaid property taxes can lead to penalties, interest charges, and in extreme cases can even affect your ability to renew vehicle registrations. Most tax offices are pretty reasonable about these situations once you provide the proper documentation. Also, keep an eye out for a separate property tax bill for your new motorcycle - that'll be coming too since it's treated as a completely separate taxable item.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
ā¢This is really helpful advice! I'm actually dealing with something similar right now. Quick question - when you say "specific date" for assessment, is January 1st pretty standard across most states? I'm in Texas and wondering if I need to look up when exactly my county does their assessment date. Also, do you know if there's typically a deadline for when you can request these prorations? I don't want to miss some cutoff period.
0 coins