Back to California Franchise Tax Board

Jake Sinclair

Franchise tax workaround — am I going to owe a penalty on top of what I already can't pay?

Okay so I filed my 2025 California return back in April but I genuinely could not pay the full balance at that point. I figured paying something was better than paying nothing, so I sent in about a third of what I owed through Web Pay and hoped that would at least show good faith. Fast forward to now and I got a notice in the mail from FTB that includes a balance that is way higher than I expected — I'm looking at what seems like penalty and interest stacked on top of the original tax owed. My question is basically: is there any franchise tax workaround where I don't have to just absorb all of these penalties? I've heard people mention something called a one-time abatement but I honestly have no clue if that applies to my situation or how to even start asking for it. I'm also trying to figure out if setting up a payment plan would stop the penalties from growing or if they just keep piling on regardless. Would really appreciate any insight from people who've dealt with FTB in a similar spot.

April of this year was the first time a late payment penalty showed up on my account, and I genuinely didn't know which penalty it was or which tax year it was tied to because MyFTB was showing two separate balances from two different years. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through the hold on FTB's customer service line, and the representative pulled up my account and told me exactly which penalty was posted and that it was for the 2024 tax year, not 2025 like I'd assumed. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the Franchise Tax Board: https://youtu.be/XbqD8mexcoQ. Knowing which penalty it was actually mattered because the late payment penalty and the delinquent filing penalty are calculated differently — the late payment one builds at half a percent per month on what's unpaid, while the delinquent filing one is five percent of the amount due for each month you didn't file by the extended deadline. If you're in the same boat, the question to put to FTB is: which specific penalty code is on my account and for which tax year? That tells you whether abatement is even on the table.

0 coins

The two-penalty thing confused me for a long time too. I assumed any penalty for not paying enough was the same thing. So for the person who posted above — when you say delinquent filing, that's for people who also didn't file by October, not just people who didn't pay by April, right?

0 coins

Exactly. If you filed on time by April 15 or by the October extension but just didn't pay the full balance, you're looking at the late payment penalty, not the delinquent filing one. The delinquent filing penalty kicks in when the return itself wasn't filed by the extended due date. Those are two different things and they carry different rates, so it's worth getting FTB to confirm which one is actually on your account before you assume anything.

0 coins

MyFTB shows the balance detail broken out by tax year if you log in. I could see the penalty line item but it didn't label what kind of penalty it was — just a dollar amount. Phoning to ask which penalty code it is makes sense if the description online isn't clear.

0 coins

The one-time penalty abatement you mentioned is a real thing. The question I'd ask FTB first is: does my account qualify, meaning have I filed all required California returns for the past five years and have I never used abatement before? Those are the two gates. It only covers the late filing and late payment penalties, and it only applies to tax years starting January 1, 2022 or later, so your 2025 year should be eligible on that front. You request it on form FTB 2918, or by phone at 800-689-4776, or through MyFTB. But it's not automatic — FTB decides, and they don't guarantee it.

0 coins

So that 800-689-4776 number is the collections line, not the main customer service line? I keep seeing two different numbers and I'm not sure which one handles penalty questions.

0 coins

Collections at 800-689-4776 is actually where penalty abatement requests go too, not just garnishments and levies. Main customer service is 800-852-5711. Both are weekdays 8 to 5. For abatement specifically FTB's penalty help page points you to that collections number, so that's the right one to dial.

0 coins

Agreed — I called the main line by mistake about a penalty question and they transferred me to collections anyway. Would've saved time going to 800-689-4776 directly.

0 coins

Payment plans don't stop the interest from adding up — I want to be clear about that because I had the same misconception. You set up an installment agreement and you're still accruing interest on the unpaid balance until it's fully paid off. What it does do is keep FTB from escalating to a wage garnishment or bank levy as long as you stay current on the plan. The setup itself adds a 34-dollar fee to your balance when approved, and you have to have all your returns from the last five years filed before they'll approve you.

0 coins

Wait so interest keeps running even while I'm on a payment plan? I figured once it was set up it kind of froze everything. That's pretty discouraging but good to know before I assume a plan solves everything.

0 coins

Yeah, it doesn't freeze. The plan just spreads the payments out. The balance you're paying down still has interest running on whatever remains unpaid. If you can pay it off faster than 60 months you'll pay less overall, but FTB lets you take up to 60 months if needed as long as the amount is under 25,000.

0 coins

I didn't know about the five years of returns being filed as a requirement. I had a year from a while back where I never filed because I thought I didn't owe anything. Turns out FTB still wanted a return and that unfiled year almost blocked my payment plan.

0 coins

Has anyone here tried the MyFTB chat to ask about penalties? I'm wondering if the chat agent can actually see your account or if they just give you generic answers. I'd rather not sit on hold for 45 minutes if chat can answer this.

0 coins

Account-specific chat is inside MyFTB once you're logged in. The public chat without logging in can only handle general questions — they literally say they can't help with your account. So if you want them to look at your actual penalty and balance, you have to be in MyFTB chat.

0 coins

MyFTB account is what I've been putting off setting up. I'll do it this week. The registration page on their site — does it mail you a PIN or can you get in right away?

0 coins

It depends. When I signed up it gave me the option to answer questions from a credit agency for instant access, or if that doesn't work for some reason it mails a PIN letter that takes 5 to 7 business days. I got instant access but my spouse had to wait for the PIN because the credit questions didn't match.

0 coins

Reasonable cause is a separate path from the one-time abatement and I don't think people talk about it enough. If something genuinely unusual happened — a medical situation, a family emergency, something that made it impossible for you to pay on time — you can send FTB a written explanation with supporting documents and ask them to waive the penalty. The form is FTB 2917. The catch is you have to pay the penalty in full first and then request the refund of it, which is rough when you're already short on funds.

0 coins

That's the part that always kills me — pay it first then ask for it back. I don't have the funds to pay it in full right now, which is why I'm here. So the abatement route where I don't have to pay first sounds more workable for me.

0 coins

Abatement through FTB 2918 doesn't have that pay-first requirement the same way, so yes that's probably your more practical route for now. The 2917 reasonable cause path is better if the one-time abatement window has already been used or doesn't apply.

0 coins

Does the 2917 require specific documentation or is a written letter with your explanation enough? I had a job loss situation earlier this year and I'm wondering if that's the kind of thing they'd consider.

0 coins

FTB's penalty help page says a written statement with documentation — so the letter alone probably isn't enough, they want something to back it up. What counts as sufficient documentation for a job loss I genuinely don't know, that's the kind of thing worth asking FTB about your specific situation rather than guessing.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question? The notice FTB sent — is there typically a phone number printed on it that goes somewhere specific, or do you just call the general customer service line? I always assumed you'd call whichever number is on the letter.

0 coins

The number on your notice is usually the right starting point. Different notices route to different FTB departments. If the notice is about a balance due or a penalty, it'll often point you to collections rather than general customer service.

0 coins

The letter I got doesn't have a number on it, just an address for mailing payments. I guess I call the main line at 800-852-5711 then.

0 coins

If the notice has FTB 4963 printed on it somewhere, that's the Notice of State Income Tax Due. Those usually either have the collections number or you'd use 800-689-4776. If it's a different notice number, the type of notice changes which team handles it.

0 coins

THESE PENALTIES ARE INSANE. I went through almost this exact thing two years ago and I swear the penalty and interest together added up to more than 20% of what I originally owed. I'm not exaggerating. And every time I tried to call I either got a busy signal or sat on hold until the line disconnected. Absolutely brutal system. FTB doesn't make it easy to fix something they're partly responsible for making confusing.

0 coins

The late payment penalty alone can get to 25% of unpaid tax over 40 months if it's fully unpaid the whole time — 5% upfront plus half a percent each month after that. That's not an exaggeration, the math does get there.

0 coins

EXACTLY. And nobody explains that to you until you're already deep in it. I found out what my penalty breakdown was only after I finally got someone on the phone, which took forever.

0 coins

The penalty structure is legitimately confusing. I had to read FTB's penalties page three times before I understood that the delinquent filing penalty and the late payment penalty are separate things that can both apply at once.

0 coins

I want to flag something about the payment plan process because I made the same mistake as a lot of people — I applied online and it got rejected immediately because I had a wage garnishment already in effect. Turns out if there's a garnishment or any active collection order on the account, you can't apply for the installment agreement online at all. You have to call 800-689-4776 to do it by phone instead.

0 coins

No garnishment on my account yet, thankfully. So the online application should work for me if I qualify? I haven't missed enough payments for them to escalate to that point.

0 coins

If there's no active garnishment or levy, the online application is available as long as the balance is under 25,000 and your returns are all filed. Keep making whatever payments you can in the meantime — FTB's page says not to stop paying while the request is processing.

0 coins

I didn't know the 25,000 cap was for the total balance including penalties and interest, not just the original tax. My total crept above that and I had to phone rather than apply online.

0 coins

That's a really important detail. If penalties and interest push the total above 25,000 you lose the online option regardless of what the original tax amount was.

0 coins

A notice came to my address last spring dated a full month before I even opened the envelope — I'd been traveling for work — and I had no idea what change FTB had made to my return. The penalty they assessed made no sense to me based on my own records. I had Claimyr hold with FTB while I was in between meetings, and the representative told me exactly which change had triggered the notice: a withholding amount that didn't match what FTB had on file from my employer. The notice was an FTB 5818, the Notice of Tax Return Change, and each paragraph has a code that maps to the specific adjustment. Once I knew which code applied to my situation I could actually look it up on FTB's notices page and decide whether to dispute it.

0 coins

The code thing on the Notice of Tax Return Change is something I wish I'd known earlier. I got one of those and just stared at the paragraph thinking the whole thing was an error. Didn't realize each section had a code with an explanation.

0 coins

FTB's page for that notice lists every code and what it means. Once I had the right code from the representative, the page made sense immediately. Before that call I was guessing at what the adjustment was for.

0 coins

Withholding mismatches are one of the most common reasons for a Notice of Tax Return Change based on what I see in this forum. If your employer's W-2 shows a different amount than what FTB received from them directly, that's usually what causes the discrepancy.

0 coins

How do you even find out what FTB has on file for your withholding without calling? Is that visible in MyFTB?

0 coins

MyFTB shows California wage and withholding info under the account details. I could see the number FTB was using but I couldn't tell from that screen alone whether it matched my W-2 — that's what the call clarified.

0 coins

Has anyone actually gotten the one-time penalty abatement approved? I keep reading that it exists but I never see people say what happened after they applied.

0 coins

My abatement request took about two months from when I submitted FTB 2918 before anything showed in MyFTB. I don't want to say it was approved because I genuinely don't remember the outcome now — I think I ended up calling to follow up. No one here can promise you it'll work, only FTB decides.

0 coins

Two months is a long time to wait especially if you have interest running. I guess you just keep making payments in the meantime and hope the abatement comes through.

0 coins

I called 800-689-4776 to request abatement by phone instead of mailing the form. The representative noted it on the account but told me a letter would come with the decision. That's about as much as FTB would say over the phone about it.

0 coins

Genuine question about Web Pay — if I want to pay more than my minimum installment some months when I have extra cash, can I just go in and make a one-time extra payment on top of my plan payment without messing anything up?

0 coins

Web Pay lets you make payments outside of your installment agreement — you schedule a separate payment for the same tax year and it applies to that balance. It shouldn't disrupt the plan itself, but I'd confirm with FTB that the payment is going to the right tax year after you make it.

0 coins

That's exactly what I needed to know. I'll make sure to double check which tax year it's being applied to afterward. I've heard of people having a payment land on the wrong year.

0 coins

If a payment does go to the wrong year, the question to ask FTB is which year it was applied to and can it be corrected. They can see the payment on their end and tell you where it landed.

0 coins

There was a scheduled Web Pay payment sitting on my account from two months ago that I completely forgot I'd set up — the amount was more than I could actually cover at that point. I had Claimyr handle the hold for me and ended up talking to an FTB representative who confirmed the exact scheduled date that was on file. Turned out I was still inside the two-business-day window to cancel it, so I cancelled through MyFTB right after the call. If you're trying to cancel a Web Pay payment, the cutoff is two business days before the scheduled date — after that it's going through no matter what.

0 coins

Two business days is not a lot of runway. So if I scheduled something by mistake today, I'd need to cancel it by end of day the day before the last business day before the payment date?

0 coins

Roughly yes. The safest read is that if the payment is scheduled for a Thursday, you need to cancel by end of business Tuesday at the latest. I'd call FTB at 800-852-5711 to confirm timing if you're right on the edge of that window.

0 coins

I had no idea you could cancel a Web Pay payment at all. I thought once you scheduled it, it was locked. Good to know.

0 coins

You can cancel through MyFTB if you have an account there — it shows your scheduled payments. If the cancellation window has closed, there's no way to pull it back.

0 coins

I want to make sure I understand the extension situation correctly because I see a lot of people mix this up. The October extension was only to file the return, right? The money was still due in April. So if someone filed in October but hadn't paid anything by April, the late payment penalty started running from April, not from October?

0 coins

You've got it exactly right. California gives you until October 15 to file without a penalty for late filing, but that extension has nothing to do with when you have to pay. Payment was due April 15 for a 2025 return. The late payment penalty starts from April 15 on any unpaid amount.

0 coins

So the franchise tax workaround of just taking the extension and paying later doesn't actually save you from the late payment penalty. People think they're buying time on both the return and the payment when it's really only the return.

0 coins

THIS is the thing that trips everyone up. I genuinely thought filing in October meant my payment wasn't due until October. Learned that the hard way when I saw interest and penalty charges that started from April.

0 coins

Even tax software doesn't always make that clear. It says 'extension granted until October' and it feels like you're covered on everything. The fine print about payment still being due in April is easy to miss.

0 coins

The delay option in MyFTB is something I haven't seen mentioned yet. You can request a 30-day delay to pay a bill in full through MyFTB — it's under Services. That doesn't stop interest from building but it at least keeps FTB from starting collection action while you get your finances together. It's a one-time thing though.

0 coins

I actually didn't know that existed. Can anyone use it or is there some balance limit or qualification you have to meet first?

0 coins

FTB's page on it just says you can request it through MyFTB under Services and then 'Delay my bill payment' — it doesn't spell out specific qualifications beyond having the bill in front of you. I'd log in and see if the option appears on your account.

0 coins

I tried to find this in MyFTB and couldn't locate it at first. It's under Services in the left menu if anyone else is looking for it.

0 coins

What happens if you just ignore a Notice of State Income Tax Due? I know that's not the smart move but I'm curious what FTB's actual escalation looks like.

0 coins

FTB typically sends several notices before they move to any collection action. Eventually they can issue a wage garnishment — an earnings withholding order — or a bank levy through what's called an order to withhold. After enough time with an unpaid debt they can also record a tax lien, which is public record and can affect your credit.

0 coins

The lien being public record is what I didn't realize. I thought it was just between me and FTB.

0 coins

A lien can get filed with the county recorder or the Secretary of State. It stays in effect for at least 10 years and FTB releases it after the full debt is paid. They don't report it to credit bureaus themselves but it's findable by anyone doing a public records search.

0 coins

Knowing the lien timeline is 10 years makes me much more motivated to get a plan in place sooner rather than later.

0 coins

Paycheck that came in two months ago was short by exactly the same amount every time, which is how I finally connected it to FTB. My employer gave me a copy of a withholding order and I didn't understand how much was actually left on the balance or how long the garnishment would run. Claimyr handled the hold with FTB for me and I was on the phone with a representative who confirmed the exact balance remaining on the earnings withholding order. That balance was lower than what I'd calculated because a payment I'd made separately had been applied to it. The only way to change how much comes out of each paycheck is to contact FTB directly — only they can issue a new order to the employer.

0 coins

The employer just follows whatever order FTB sent them and can't change it on their own?

0 coins

Correct. The employer follows the EWOT — earnings withholding order for taxes — and only FTB can modify or release it. If you have a financial hardship you contact FTB and they decide whether to issue a revised order to the employer.

0 coins

Up to 25% of wages per paycheck is what they can take under a garnishment. That's brutal when you already can't cover rent.

0 coins

And the garnishment keeps running until either the balance is paid in full or FTB releases the order. Once it's paid, you have to contact FTB to actually close the account and release it — it doesn't automatically stop the moment your balance hits zero.

0 coins

I have a question about MyFTB registration that might be holding me up. I moved earlier this year and my current address is different from what was on my last California return. If FTB mails a PIN letter for MyFTB registration, does it go to my old address on file or my new one?

0 coins

PIN letters go to the address FTB has on file, which may be from your most recent return if you haven't updated it yet. If your old address is still on file, the letter could go there. You can update your address by phoning 800-852-5711 or by mailing form FTB 3533 before you try to register, so the PIN lands at your current place.

0 coins

So I should update the address before I try to register rather than after? That makes sense but adds a step I hadn't planned for.

0 coins

Updating first is the safer move. If the PIN goes to the wrong address you'd have to request a new one and wait another 5 to 7 business days. Updating by phone with 800-852-5711 is probably the fastest way.

0 coins

Does anyone know if Taxpayer Advocate Services can help with penalty abatement or is it only for things like levy situations? I'm wondering if that's another route if the normal process drags on.

0 coins

Taxpayer Advocate Services is for situations that the normal FTB channels didn't resolve — things like a financial hardship from a wage garnishment, a levy or a lien, or a delay that goes beyond FTB's own timeframes. It doesn't take cases just because you're waiting on a penalty abatement decision. If the normal process drags on without a hardship escalation, you'd keep following up through the main channels first.

0 coins

So if I'm just waiting on the abatement and nothing has escalated to a levy or garnishment, Taxpayer Advocate Services probably isn't the right door yet.

0 coins

Exactly. Their line is 800-883-5910 weekdays 8 to 5 if you do get to a point where it qualifies. But a pending abatement on its own isn't typically what they handle.

0 coins

Their request form is the FTB 914 if you do end up needing to go that route. At least knowing it exists is useful.

0 coins

I've been following this thread and my franchise tax workaround question is slightly different — I already have a lien on my account from two years ago that I think should have been released because I paid the balance. How do I actually confirm it's been released?

0 coins

Lien status is visible in MyFTB — it shows FTB-issued liens on the account. If the balance that was liened is paid in full, the release process starts once the payment posts. I'd log into MyFTB first and check what the lien status shows before calling.

0 coins

MyFTB is where I should start then. I've been hesitant to log in because I was afraid to see what else might be on there, but I need to actually check.

0 coins

Logging in and knowing what's there is better than guessing. The balance detail, the lien status, any active orders — it's all in one place and you can at least see where things stand.

0 coins

Someone earlier mentioned the delinquent filing penalty and I want to make sure I understand it correctly. If a person filed in October using the extension but didn't pay by April, does the delinquent filing penalty also apply on top of the late payment penalty?

0 coins

Filing by the extension date — October 15 — means the delinquent filing penalty doesn't apply. The extension is specifically to avoid that penalty. You'd only face the late payment penalty from April, not both. The delinquent filing penalty kicks in when you miss both the April deadline and the October extension deadline.

0 coins

So as long as the return was actually filed by October, only one penalty applies, not both stacked on top of each other?

0 coins

Right. One penalty for not paying on time from April, but no delinquent filing penalty if the return was in by October. The two can stack if someone misses both deadlines entirely.

0 coins

That's a relief to understand clearly. I'd been worried for someone I know who filed in September and owed a balance — sounds like they're only dealing with the late payment side of things.

0 coins

Coming back to update: I called 800-689-4776 this morning and waited about 20 minutes before a representative picked up. I confirmed which penalty was on my account and that I hadn't used the one-time abatement before. The rep said a letter would come with the decision after I request it through FTB 2918. I'm going to submit the form through MyFTB today. Still keeping my payment plan application in the queue too in case the abatement doesn't come through — at least now I know exactly what I'm dealing with.

0 coins

Submitting FTB 2918 through MyFTB is the fastest way to have a record of the request on the account. Sending the payment plan application at the same time makes sense — keep paying in the meantime while both are in process.

0 coins

Knowing which specific penalty is on the account is half the battle. At least now you can make a real decision about which path to take instead of guessing at the numbers.

0 coins

Glad you got through. 20 minutes of hold time is actually not too bad for that line.

0 coins

California Franchise Tax Board AI

Expert Assistant
Secure