Why did deny my claim and also send a benefit amount letter? California EDD confusing me
okay so i'm completely lost and kind of freaking out right now. got laid off from my warehouse job about a month ago and filed my claim pretty much right away. two weeks later i got this letter in the mail showing my weekly benefit amount — $387 a week — so i figured everything was good and i just kept certifying. then out of NOWHERE i get a Notice of Determination saying i'm disqualified. no warning, nothing. i didn't quit, i didn't get fired for doing anything wrong, the whole facility shut down and they let everyone go. how does EDD send you a letter saying here's your weekly amount and then turn around and deny you? is the first letter not an approval? what does the disqualification even mean if they already told me what i'd be paid? i appealed but i have no idea what i'm doing and i still have pending weeks sitting there. anyone been through this?
76 comments

Toot-n-Mighty
DE 429Z came in the mail about ten days after i applied and showed $412 a week — i thought the same thing as you, figured that was the green light. then my Claim History in UI Online showed three weeks stuck on Pending and i couldn't get anyone on the phone. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to a live EDD agent. She pulled up my file and explained that the DE 429Z is basically a projection of what the claim COULD pay based on your wages, and EDD hasn't actually decided eligibility yet when they send it. She said my weeks were pending because they needed to verify something with my former employer. The video on reaching a live person at EDD by phone that Claimyr posts — https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 — that actually explains the process. The agent told me to watch for a Notice of Determination separately, which is the actual decision. That letter and the benefit amount letter are two completely different things that go out at different times.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorwait so the DE 429Z is NOT an approval? i genuinely thought that was EDD saying yes we're paying you. that makes so much more sense why they can send it and then deny me. does it say anywhere on the letter that it's not a final decision? i must have missed that
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
DE 429Z is titled Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award — the word award threw me off too, makes it sound like you won something. but it's really just the wage calculation. the actual decision on whether you can collect comes separate.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorugh 'award' really is misleading. i read that word and just assumed i was good to go
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
Facility-wide shutdown and they still issued a disqualification — that part is worth looking at closely. If the whole place closed, there shouldn't be a question about misconduct or a voluntary quit, so check your Notice of Determination to see exactly what reason EDD gave for the denial. The notice has a section that says why. Sometimes a former employer responds to EDD's inquiry in a way that doesn't match what actually happened, and EDD goes off that information until someone challenges it. Your appeal is the right move, and keep certifying every two weeks while it's going on — if the judge rules your way, EDD can only pay back the weeks you actually certified for. Missing certifications during an appeal means those weeks are gone.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorthe notice says something about 'voluntarily leaving work without good cause' which makes zero sense because nobody chose to leave, the company shut down. i'm guessing the employer filed something wrong?
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
employer responses to EDD are wild sometimes. they submit the wrong reason code or use a template that doesn't match what happened, and EDD just goes with it initially. the appeal is exactly where you fix that — bring anything you have showing it was a facility closure, like a layoff notice, a final paystub, anything from HR
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
Layoff documentation is key here. A company-wide closure letter or even an email from management saying the facility was shutting down goes a long way at the hearing. The administrative law judge looks at what both sides submitted.
0 coins
Sofía Rodríguez
the same confusing sequence happened to me last spring. the DE 429Z showed up, i certified, money came in for two weeks, and then everything stopped and a denial letter arrived. what i didn't realize is EDD can pay some weeks and then claw them back if adjudication goes against you — but in your case sounds like nothing paid at all, so you're in a cleaner spot for the appeal. what does your Claim History in UI Online show for the pending weeks? still showing Pending or did it flip to something else after the denial came?
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorstill showing Pending for three weeks. the determination letter is dated last thursday so maybe it hasn't updated yet
0 coins
Sofía Rodríguez
Pending usually stays until EDD processes the determination and either pays or formally denies those weeks. once the appeal is filed it can sit like that for a while. main thing is keep certifying
0 coins
Aiden O'Connor
yeah pending weeks during an open appeal is basically the normal state of things unfortunately. nothing moves until there's a decision
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
i want to clear something up because i see a lot of people assume that if you got a denial it means your work history wasn't enough to qualify. the DE 429Z actually proves your wages were fine — they calculated a valid weekly amount, which means you passed the earnings threshold. the disqualification is about eligibility, meaning why you stopped working, not whether your wages count. those are two separate questions EDD looks at. yours is clearly an eligibility question about the separation, not a wage issue.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorthat is actually really helpful to understand — so i'm not fighting the whole claim from scratch, just the question of why i left?
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
Exactly right. The base period wages were enough to open the claim. The only fight is over the separation, and a facility-wide closure is about as clear-cut a layoff as it gets. Document everything and lay it out at the hearing.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
this distinction tripped me up too when i got my first denial. i thought the whole claim was invalid but the agent explained it the same way — the DE 429Z proves the wage side is settled, the determination is only about the separation reason
0 coins
Fatima Al-Rashid
appeals with California EDD go through the CUIAB — that's the Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board — and an administrative law judge handles the actual hearing. you get a Notice of Hearing in the mail at least 10 days before it happens. at the hearing you testify under oath and can bring any documents you want. the judge is there to hear both sides and issue a written decision. a lot of people are intimidated by hearing and think it's like a formal court but it's more of an interview with documentation. your best evidence is anything that shows the closure was company-initiated, not a personal decision to walk away.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authoris there any way to know how long before the hearing notice comes? i filed the appeal form like two days ago
0 coins
Fatima Al-Rashid
Honestly the timeline varies and EDD's appeals guide doesn't give a specific number of weeks. The 10 days notice before the hearing is what's guaranteed. Some people wait a couple of months, some longer. Keep certifying the whole time regardless.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
my hearing notice came about six weeks after i filed the appeal form. the hearing itself was by phone, the judge was straightforward and let me explain everything. had my layoff paperwork ready and it went fine
0 coins
Aaliyah Jackson
quick question — when you certify during the appeal, do you answer the work search questions like normal? i'm in a similar situation with a pending appeal and i've been certifying but i always second-guess whether i should mark that i was available and looking for work even though the whole thing is in dispute
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
Certify honestly for each week — available and looking for work means you actually were during that week, which you should be. The appeal doesn't pause your obligation to meet the requirements for the weeks you're claiming. If you weren't available one week for some reason, don't check yes just to keep the claim moving.
0 coins
Aaliyah Jackson
Got it, that makes sense. I've been available and applying so I'll keep doing what I'm doing.
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
EDD's requirement is that you're able and available every week you certify. appeal or no appeal, that standard applies to each individual week you're claiming. it's not a blanket thing for the whole claim period
0 coins
KylieRose
the voluntary quit language on a denial freaks everyone out but it covers a lot of situations EDD initially codes wrong. i got one that said the same thing after a layoff and it turned out the former employer checked the wrong box when they responded to EDD's inquiry notice. at the appeal hearing i brought my layoff letter and the judge took about fifteen minutes to issue the decision in my favor. the written decision came about a week later and EDD processed my pending weeks after that.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorfifteen minutes! that's actually reassuring. i was imagining something way more intense and drawn out
0 coins
KylieRose
the hearing was low-key honestly. phone call, judge asked me to describe what happened, i explained the closure, he asked if i had documentation, i described the letter i had, and that was basically it. your situation sounds very similar
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
the burden is on the employer to show there was misconduct if they're claiming a firing, and on the claimant to show good cause if it's coded as a quit. for a closure situation where you can show the facility shut down, you're not really trying to prove anything — you're just showing the quit code doesn't apply at all
0 coins
Miguel Hernández
hold on i'm confused about something — the person above said the burden is on the claimant to show good cause for a quit. does that mean the OP has to prove good cause? because a facility shutdown isn't really a quit at all
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
right, that's the exact point — a facility closure is a layoff, not a quit. the employer wrongly coded it as a quit when they responded to EDD, so the OP's argument at the hearing is that the quit code simply doesn't reflect what happened. they're not trying to defend a quit with good cause, they're correcting a misclassification.
0 coins
Miguel Hernández
okay that makes way more sense. so the whole appeal is basically just showing that the employer's response to EDD was wrong
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
Exactly. EDD issued the determination based on what the employer reported. The appeal is the place to show the actual facts. That's what the administrative law judge is there for.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
EDD phones at the number on the DE 4800 at the exact scheduled time for the interview — i learned this the hard way when i missed mine because i was on a different call and figured i'd just answer EDD's number whenever it came through. i didn't realize the interview time was fixed and they'd call right at that moment. ended up calling EDD the same day and they rescheduled but it delayed everything by weeks. not related to the OP's specific situation but worth knowing if you have an interview scheduled
0 coins
Aaliyah Jackson
Keeping my phone free starting the morning of the interview and just waiting is my plan after reading stuff like this. that scheduled window seems really strict
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
Completely strict. the DE 4800 and the UI Online homepage both show the date and time and that's when the interviewer phones. treat it like a job interview and clear your schedule around it
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authormine already happened before the denial came out — that's probably partly how EDD got the wrong information, because if the employer gave bad info during their interview that's what shaped the determination
0 coins
Liam Murphy
Fourteen weeks into dealing with EDD on my own claim and finally got some clarity after using Claimyr to reach a live agent about my adjudication hold. The agent looked at my account and told me which specific week was flagged and why the hold was sitting there — she said a document EDD sent me hadn't been returned yet. I didn't even know they'd mailed something. If your pending weeks aren't moving after you file the appeal, it might be worth asking an agent whether there's anything sitting open on your side of the account, not just waiting on the appeal decision.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authora document i didn't know about — that is exactly the kind of thing i'd miss. i've been checking UI Online but i don't know if i'd catch that
0 coins
Liam Murphy
the agent told me EDD mails things and if the address is off or the mail gets lost, your side just shows pending with no explanation in UI Online. checking directly with an agent is the only way to find out if there's something specific holding it
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
i've had the same thing happen, something mailed to an old address. worth confirming your address is current in myEDD before anything else
0 coins
Amara Okafor
something nobody mentioned yet — once the appeal decision comes out in your favor, EDD doesn't automatically release the pending weeks the same day. there's usually some processing time before Payments in UI Online updates. i got impatient and thought the system hadn't gotten the decision, but it just takes a few days after the written decision to work through the system
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorgood to know, i'll be way less likely to panic if the weeks don't show up the second i hear something
0 coins
Amara Okafor
the written decision comes by mail and then processing takes a bit. EDD's payment line at 1-866-333-4606 updates daily so you can check there once you're expecting something to move
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
UI Online Payments section is what i watch, but yeah there's always a gap between when a decision is made and when the dollars actually show
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
i genuinely thought for about two weeks that my DE 429Z was my approval and i was set. kept waiting for my direct deposit and nothing came. it wasn't until i called and finally got someone that i understood what had actually happened. the system really does not make it obvious that eligibility determination is a separate step that happens after the benefit amount letter goes out. EDD should put that more clearly on the DE 429Z itself
0 coins
Sofía Rodríguez
Agreed, 'Award' in the name implies something was given. i think the confusion happens to nearly everyone on a first claim
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
and if you've never dealt with unemployment before you have no context for knowing there are two separate processes — calculating the benefit amount versus deciding if you're eligible. nothing in plain language explains that before you're in the middle of it
0 coins
Jamal Brown
my onboarding with EDD was basically just trying to figure out what each letter meant as it arrived. there's no guide that explains the sequence upfront
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
DE 1000M is the appeal form that comes with the Notice of Determination — it has a spot for your name, claim number, and the reason you're appealing. if you already sent it you're set, but make sure it was postmarked or submitted within 30 calendar days of the mailing date on the determination. the date on the notice is what matters, not when you received it, so if it sat in your mailbox for a week you might have less time than you think
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authori sent it within four days of getting the letter so i should be fine on timing. is there any confirmation that they received the appeal?
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
EDD doesn't send an immediate acknowledgment from what i experienced. the Notice of Hearing is usually the first thing you get back, and that can take a while. some people send it certified mail just to have proof it was delivered
0 coins
Fatima Al-Rashid
Certified mail is smart. Keep a copy of everything you send, including the appeal form, your layoff documentation, any supporting letters. If you submit anything for the hearing itself, do the same.
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
the 'voluntary quit without good cause' code is honestly one of the most common errors i see in these threads when a whole workplace or department shuts down. because EDD sends the employer a Notice of Unemployment Insurance Claim Filed and asks why the person stopped working, and sometimes whoever fills it out at the company just picks the nearest category instead of layoff/reduction-in-force. then EDD issues a denial based on that response before the interview even gives you a chance to explain
0 coins
Miguel Hernández
so EDD literally sends a denial without hearing from the claimant first?
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
EDD usually schedules a phone interview before issuing the determination when there's a question, but sometimes the determination comes out anyway. the OP mentioned a determination arrived — it's possible the interview happened and the information the employer gave was weighted more heavily, or the interview was about something else. either way the appeal corrects it
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
right, and the appeal is a fresh look by an administrative law judge who is separate from EDD, so the initial determination being wrong doesn't doom the case at all
0 coins
Jamal Brown
something that helped me when i was in appeal limbo was registering in CalJOBS and getting my resume up. i had seen a notice about it when my claim started — the DE 8405 — but kept putting it off. found out it had to be done within 21 days of that notice or it could affect payments. would hate for someone to win their appeal and then have a separate issue pop up because CalJOBS wasn't done
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authori didn't even know about this, going to check right now. i don't remember getting that specific notice
0 coins
Jamal Brown
check UI Online and also your physical mail from that first couple of weeks. if EDD determined you don't need to register they'll say so, but if the DE 8405 came and nothing was done within 21 days it's worth addressing
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
CalJOBS registration and resume posting is something worth getting sorted regardless. edd.ca.gov has the link to caljobs.ca.gov and it doesn't take long. better to have it done than to have a separate hold show up after you resolve the appeal.
0 coins
CaptainAwesome
reading this thread because i got the same two-letter combo last month and my first thought was EDD made a mistake and accidentally denied me. spent a full day convinced it was some system error. once i calmed down and read the actual determination it turned out they had a question about some part-time work i did during the base period — completely different situation from a closure but the same feeling of 'how are both of these letters real at the same time
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorexactly the feeling — like these two letters cannot both be right, one has to be wrong
0 coins
CaptainAwesome
they're not contradictory once you understand they're answering two different questions. benefit amount letter is about your wages. determination is about why you stopped working. EDD just never explains that clearly upfront
0 coins
Sofía Rodríguez
most people piece this together only after going through it themselves or reading threads like this one. it's genuinely not obvious from the letters themselves
0 coins
Aiden O'Connor
for anyone who gets to the hearing stage — you can represent yourself, have a union rep, or bring an attorney. the hearing is under oath but it's not a formal court and judges at CUIAB hearings generally walk claimants through what they need to explain. i brought a folder with my termination paperwork, printed emails from my manager, and my final paystub and the judge actually said that level of documentation made it easy to follow my account of what happened
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authori have a written notice from HR about the facility closure — is that enough or should i be gathering more?
0 coins
Aiden O'Connor
an official notice from HR about the closure is solid evidence. if you have anything else like emails or the actual date the facility stopped operating, bring it, but HR documentation is the core piece for a closure case
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
the judge is going to compare what you say happened versus what the employer reported to EDD. a written closure notice from HR directly contradicts a voluntary quit code from the employer, which is about as clean a case as you can have
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Adjudication hold on my claim stuck around for weeks longer than i expected after my separation had a question on it. The agent I talked to through Claimyr told me my hold was showing resolved on EDD's end but the payment processing hadn't run yet — she said to check UI Online the following morning and the pending weeks had cleared by then. Worth knowing that sometimes the hold is gone before UI Online catches up.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorthis is good to know — so if my appeal resolves i shouldn't just assume nothing happened if UI Online still shows pending?
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
right, give it at least a day before assuming the system hasn't gotten the update. the payment processing runs on a schedule separate from when EDD actually makes the decision
0 coins
Aaliyah Jackson
Checking the payment line at 1-866-333-4606 the morning after a decision is probably smarter than refreshing UI Online all night
0 coins
Esmeralda Gómez
the appeals process is slower than most people expect but the administrative law judge is genuinely independent from EDD — that matters. when i appealed a denial the judge basically said she was looking at the evidence fresh and what EDD initially decided didn't weigh on her at all. she reversed the decision. i was nervous going in thinking EDD's initial call was hard to overturn but that's not how it works
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Authorthat's actually the most reassuring thing i've read in this whole thread. i kept thinking the first decision was hard to fight
0 coins
Esmeralda Gómez
a lot of people assume the deck is stacked and don't even bother appealing. for a situation like yours where the basic facts support you, the appeal is worth going through
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
EDD's initial determination is based on limited information. the hearing gives you a real chance to lay out everything and have a judge evaluate it properly. not the same process at all
0 coins