Back to California Unemployment

Lilly Curtis

What to expect at unemployment appeal phone hearing for identity verification disqualification

Got my Notice of Determination in the mail last Friday saying I'm disqualified because of identity verification. I had already uploaded everything through ID.me weeks before this notice even showed up - driver's license, selfie, the whole deal - and EDD still issued a disqualification. Filed my appeal using the DE 1000M right away because the 30-day clock starts from the mailing date on the notice. Now I have my CUIAB hearing date. The Notice of Hearing came in the mail and I'm trying to figure out what actually happens during the appeal phone hearing itself. Like what does the administrative law judge actually ask? Do I just explain what I did with ID.me and when? Should I have screenshots or confirmation emails ready to reference? I've been certifying every two weeks this whole time because I read somewhere you have to keep certifying during an appeal or EDD can't pay the back weeks. Is that right? Also my Claim History in UI Online shows all those weeks as Pending still. Does that change once the judge rules in my favor? I'm about 9 weeks into this now and the financial pressure is real. Any help from people who've been through one of these hearings would be huge.

My identity situation got flagged even though I completed ID.me before EDD ever sent me anything about it. The DE 1326C came after I'd already verified, which made no sense. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to a live EDD agent - the site holds your place in the phone queue so you end up talking to someone without sitting on hold yourself. There's a video they put together on reaching a live person at EDD: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed ID.me had received the verification but it hadn't synced to my claim yet - she told me to expect a letter within 10 business days. That cleared it before it ever got to a hearing for me, so I'd say if you haven't had an agent actually look at your account recently, that's worth doing even now.

0 coins

The ID.me sync issue is real and seems to happen a lot. Did the agent say anything about whether the pending weeks would automatically release once the sync caught up, or did something else have to happen on EDD's end first?

0 coins

From what the agent said, once the identity flag cleared on my claim the pending weeks moved to paid on their own - nothing extra I had to do except keep certifying. Took a few days after that call.

0 coins

So if the OP is already at the appeal stage does it even make sense to try reaching EDD by phone, or does everything go through the CUIAB now? I'm not sure how those two tracks work together.

0 coins

Appealing doesn't stop you from contacting EDD - the two tracks run at the same time. EDD could fix the underlying identity issue even while the appeal is pending, and if they do, they'd withdraw the disqualification. Worth trying both.

0 coins

Went through a CUIAB appeal hearing last spring over a different issue but the format is the same regardless of what the disqualification was about. The judge introduces everyone on the call, swears you in, then walks through the facts. For an identity verification case you'd basically explain your timeline - when you completed ID.me, what confirmation you got, when the disqualification notice was mailed. The judge is not trying to trick you, they're just building a record. Keep your answers direct and factual.

0 coins

How formal does it feel? I'm picturing something like a courtroom phone call and I keep second-guessing how I should talk - should I be super formal or just explain my situation normally?

0 coins

More conversational than courtroom. The judge runs it methodically but it's not adversarial. Plain, clear language is better than trying to sound legal. Just stick to what you did and when.

0 coins

Agreed on the plain language point. I fumbled mine by using terms I wasn't sure about and had to walk back a couple of things. If you're not certain of something just say so rather than guessing.

0 coins

DE 1000M was the right move filing it quickly. One thing that matters for the hearing - have your ID.me completion date written down somewhere you can reference fast, because the judge will likely ask for a specific date and you don't want to be fumbling around trying to remember mid-call.

0 coins

ID.me does send a confirmation email with a timestamp, so I have that saved. Would it help to actually read the timestamp out loud during the hearing or just give the date?

0 coins

The date is usually enough unless the judge asks for more specificity. Having the email open and ready is smart, though - better to have it and not need it.

0 coins

Screenshots from UI Online showing when the pending weeks started would also help paint the timeline. I had a folder with everything organized by date for my hearing and it made the judge's questions much easier to answer.

0 coins

Keeping up with certifications during the appeal is absolutely the right call. The way it works is EDD can only release payment for weeks that were actually certified - if you stop certifying and win the appeal, those uncertified weeks are just gone. So keep going even when it feels pointless.

0 coins

Every certification has gone through fine, it's just that the status stays on Pending in Claim History. So the certifications are registering, they're just not paying out - that's how it's supposed to look while the appeal is active, right?

0 coins

Exactly. Pending during an active appeal is normal. When EDD processes the resolution, those weeks move to paid. You'll see the update in UI Online first, usually within a day or two.

0 coins

My weeks sat at Pending for almost four months during my appeal. The moment the judge's decision came down in my favor, EDD released them all at once. Payment posted to my Money Network card within 48 hours.

0 coins

Four months - okay that's sobering but at least it resolved. Did you have to do anything after the judge's decision or did EDD process it automatically?

0 coins

Automatic on my end. The CUIAB sends its decision to EDD and EDD acts on it. I didn't have to call anyone or submit anything extra.

0 coins

My appeal hearing got scheduled about six weeks after I sent in the DE 1000M. The Notice of Hearing listed the judge's name, the dial-in number and the time, and it said to have any documents ready because the judge might ask you to describe what they show. For an ID.me disqualification specifically, the confirmation email from ID.me and your application date from UI Online are your two most important pieces.

0 coins

The Notice of Hearing I got says the same kind of thing about documents. Does the judge actually ask you to email anything over or just describe it verbally?

0 coins

In my experience it was verbal. The judge creates a written record from the testimony. If you wanted to formally submit documents ahead of time you'd do it in writing before the hearing date, but for an identity case your testimony about the timeline is usually the main thing.

0 coins

You can also send documents to the CUIAB office in advance, mailed to the address on the Notice of Hearing. I sent copies of everything I had and the judge referenced them during the hearing, which felt reassuring.

0 coins

After being stuck on pending for about seven weeks on my claim, the EDD phone line was hopeless - kept getting cut off after long hold times. Ended up using Claimyr to actually get through to an agent. Asked specifically whether my identity verification had been received and the agent confirmed the ID.me data was sitting in a queue and hadn't been processed to my claim. She flagged it for review and I got a letter about two weeks later saying the disqualification was lifted. Never even had to do the CUIAB hearing.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything specific when the agent flagged it, like submit a form or just wait for EDD to work through the queue?

0 coins

Just waited. The agent said she added a note to the account and that I'd receive mail once it was reviewed. No form on my end.

0 coins

Mine didn't resolve that way - EDD sent the disqualification notice before anything got flagged or fixed, so I'm already past that point. The appeal is the path I have at this point.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up at my hearing: the judge asked me to confirm my identity at the start - name, Social Security number, claim start date. Have those right in front of you. It sounds basic but when you're nervous it helps to not have to think about it.

0 coins

Good call, I would absolutely blank on my claim start date under pressure. Is that the date I actually filed or the Sunday of the week I filed?

0 coins

The claim starts on the Sunday of the week you apply - so if you filed on a Thursday, the official start date is the Sunday before. EDD lists it on the DE 429Z, so check that document.

0 coins

The DE 429Z also shows your weekly benefit amount in case the judge's questions go anywhere near that. Good document to have in front of you for any part of the hearing.

0 coins

Whoever said you need to have won a previous appeal to file another one has it wrong - you get one shot to appeal the Notice of Determination, and if the judge denies it you can do a second-level appeal to the CUIAB board itself. Different process but the door isn't closed after the first hearing.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying to reach EDD by phone before my own identity issue got sorted - finally got through to an agent through Claimyr. The agent explained that my DE 1326C response had been received but wasn't yet linked to my UI account. She said to watch for a letter within 15 days. Ended up not needing the full appeals process because the agent manually escalated the flag on my file.

0 coins

That escalation step is apparently something only an agent can do from their end - there's no way to trigger it through Ask EDD or the message system in UI Online as far as I know.

0 coins

The message system can get a response but it's slow. Talking to an actual agent is the only way to get something flagged same-day.

0 coins

At my hearing the judge specifically asked whether I had any witnesses. For an identity case you don't really need one, but it was good to know that was an option. The Notice of Hearing mentions you can have a representative too - union rep, attorney, anyone really. For something like an ID verification issue, most people represent themselves fine.

0 coins

Mine just says I can have a representative but doesn't explain how I'd get one lined up in time. Is there any kind of free help available for unemployment appeals?

0 coins

Some legal aid organizations in California take unemployment appeal cases at no cost. Searching for legal aid plus your county usually turns up options. For an ID verification case the facts are pretty simple, but having someone who knows the process is never a bad thing.

0 coins

California Rural Legal Assistance and Bay Area Legal Aid both do unemployment appeals depending on where you are. Worth a call to see if they can help before your hearing date.

0 coins

Got disqualified for ID verification myself about eight months ago. At the hearing the judge asked three main things: when did you complete ID.me, did you receive confirmation that it was done, and when did the disqualification notice arrive. That's pretty much the whole case - either your verification completed before the disqualification or EDD has documentation to the contrary. Mine completed two weeks before the notice mailed date, the judge saw that in the records, and the decision came back in my favor within two weeks.

0 coins

Two-week turnaround on the written decision - is that typical or were you just lucky with timing?

0 coins

Honestly not sure if it was typical or fast. I've heard of some decisions taking longer. The CUIAB doesn't publish timelines for how long it takes.

0 coins

Mine took closer to five weeks for the written decision to arrive after the hearing. The judge said at the end of the hearing that it would be mailed and to watch for it - no specific date given.

0 coins

Real procedural point about the hearing itself: the judge records everything, the testimony is under oath, and the recording becomes the official record. That's why staying factual and calm matters - not because judges are harsh, but because if you end up doing a second-level appeal, that recorded testimony is what the board reviews.

0 coins

Under oath made me nervous to even think about until I realized I'm literally just describing what I did - completed ID.me on this date, got this confirmation, received the disqualification notice on this date. There's nothing complicated about my story.

0 coins

That's exactly the right way to think about it. The oath just means you're confirming the truth of what you experienced. For a straightforward ID verification timeline it's not dramatic at all.

0 coins

The judge is also there to make a fair record, not to catch you in something. If they ask a clarifying question it's usually because they want to understand the sequence of events, not because they're skeptical of your account.

0 coins

Missed my own appeal deadline once because I counted 30 days from when I received the notice, not from the mailing date printed on it. Those are different dates. The mailing date is what the 30-day window runs from, not the date you actually opened the envelope. For anyone who just got a denial notice, check that date carefully.

0 coins

The mailing date vs. received date thing catches people off guard constantly. Got a Notice of Determination dated the 1st of the month but didn't get it in my mailbox until the 6th - but my 30 days ran from the 1st.

0 coins

Exactly. Five days is not a lot of cushion to lose right at the start. Mail it or file it as soon as possible, don't use the full 30 days unless you have to.

0 coins

Is there any way to file it electronically or does the DE 1000M have to go by mail? I want to know for my situation, I just got my denial.

0 coins

The appeal can be a letter or the DE 1000M form, mailed to the address on your Notice of Determination. That address is the appeals office that handles your case. Some people also fax it - check the notice for a fax number. EDD's online contact tools aren't set up to accept a formal appeal.

0 coins

For anyone confused about what a CUIAB hearing actually is vs. the EDD phone interview: they are completely different things. The phone interview is EDD's internal process before they make a decision - the CUIAB hearing is an independent appeal in front of a judge after EDD already made a decision. If EDD schedules a phone interview, that's not an appeal hearing. The DE 4800 is the interview notice, the Notice of Hearing from CUIAB is the appeal.

0 coins

So important to flag that. I was completely confused when I got my DE 4800 and thought I'd already won something. The interview is EDD gathering information, not EDD telling you the outcome.

0 coins

The decision only comes later as a Notice of Determination, and only if EDD decides you don't qualify. If they determine you qualify, there's no determination letter - payments just start processing for weeks you certified.

0 coins

Wait so if EDD decides in my favor after the phone interview there's literally no document that says so? I've been waiting for some kind of approval letter and apparently it doesn't exist?

0 coins

Correct - no approval letter exists. You'd just see your pending weeks move to paid in UI Online. The DE 429Z that came earlier is about your potential benefit amount, not about whether you've been approved for payments. The two are different things.

0 coins

Before my own CUIAB hearing I called EDD using Claimyr to double-check that all my certified weeks were showing properly in their system, because I wanted to make sure the judge's records matched what I was seeing in UI Online. The agent confirmed which weeks were certified and pending and which had any flags, so I went into the hearing knowing exactly what picture EDD had on their end. That made me feel a lot more prepared for whatever the judge might ask about my claim status.

0 coins

Knowing what EDD's own screen shows before you testify makes a lot of sense - otherwise you're describing your side without knowing if EDD's records even match.

0 coins

That was my thinking. I didn't want to say 'I certified every week' and have the judge see something different on EDD's end. The agent confirmed everything was there, so I could say it with confidence.

0 coins

DE 1326C is the identity verification request EDD sends when it can't verify you through ID.me automatically. If you got that letter and responded to it, that's key documentation to reference at the hearing - when you got it, when you responded, by what method. That shows EDD the full chain of steps you took.

0 coins

In my case I didn't get a DE 1326C - EDD went straight to disqualification without ever sending me a verification request. Can I still mention that at the hearing, that I completed ID.me without being asked to?

0 coins

Absolutely mention it. The timeline of your ID.me completion relative to EDD's decision date is the core of your case. The absence of a DE 1326C is actually relevant - it means EDD never gave you an opportunity to respond before disqualifying you.

0 coins

That sequence - ID.me completed, no DE 1326C sent, disqualification issued anyway - is worth presenting clearly because it goes to whether EDD followed its own process before issuing the denial.

0 coins

The administrative law judge doesn't work for EDD - they're part of the CUIAB, which is a separate state board. That matters because some people go into the hearing thinking the judge is EDD's representative and get defensive. The judge is neutral. EDD might not even have a representative on the call in some cases.

0 coins

EDD doesn't show up at the hearing? I assumed someone from EDD would be on the call arguing against me.

0 coins

Not always. For identity verification cases especially, it's often just you and the judge. The judge reviews EDD's documentation and your testimony. It's less adversarial than people expect.

0 coins

In my hearing EDD had no representative on the call at all. The judge had the case file, I explained my timeline, and that was it. Much less intimidating than I'd built it up to be.

0 coins

My hearing for a different issue lasted maybe 20 minutes. For an identity case it might be even shorter because the facts are pretty narrow - either you verified before the disqualification or you didn't, and your ID.me confirmation email settles that pretty quickly. Don't go in expecting something that drags on for an hour.

0 coins

Twenty minutes is so much shorter than I was imagining. I've been treating it like I need to prepare a whole argument when maybe I just need to answer questions clearly and have my dates ready.

0 coins

Exactly - it's not a trial. The judge asks, you answer, they close the record and issue a written decision later. Keep your documentation organized and answer directly and you'll be in good shape.

0 coins

Short hearing doesn't mean the decision is quick though - my 15-minute hearing still took three weeks to produce a written ruling. The hearing and the decision timeline are separate.

0 coins

After the judge issues the decision, if EDD still doesn't release your pending weeks within a reasonable time, you can contact EDD directly and reference the CUIAB decision date. Sometimes there's a lag between CUIAB sending the ruling to EDD and EDD actually processing the payment release. Doesn't happen to everyone but worth knowing it's a step you can take.

0 coins

How long is 'reasonable' to wait after the judge's decision before following up with EDD?

0 coins

I'd give it about two to three weeks from the written decision date before following up. The official position is that CUIAB transmits decisions to EDD but processing times vary.

0 coins

Mine posted without any follow-up needed. If you can see in UI Online that the weeks are still showing Pending after a few weeks post-decision, that's when it makes sense to reach out to EDD.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure