Back to California Unemployment

Keisha Williams

What happens if I lose appeal hearing when employer appeals unemployment benefits in California EDD?

My former employer is appealing my unemployment benefits and I have no idea what I'm expecting at this hearing. Got laid off from my warehouse job about two months ago and EDD approved me, but then my old boss filed an appeal claiming it was misconduct. Now I have a hearing scheduled with a judge and I honestly don't know what losing even means. Do they take back the money I already got? Do they stop future payments right away? I've been certifying every two weeks and still getting paid for now but I'm terrified the rug gets pulled out from under me. Has anyone been through this from the claimant side when the employer was the one who appealed? What actually happens if the judge sides with them?

Employer claimed misconduct on my claim too, same situation about six months back. Filed at Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live EDD agent on the phone because the UI Online messages weren't getting answered — the video at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 shows how reaching a live person at EDD works. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my approved weeks were showing certified and processed, and that the employer's appeal wouldn't affect payments already issued unless the judge ordered an overpayment after the hearing. She also said to keep certifying every two weeks through the whole appeal process so EDD could pay any weeks the judge later upholds. That was the most useful thing I found out — stopping certifications would mean EDD couldn't pay those weeks even if I won.

0 coins

30 days before the hearing date — does that timeline change anything about certifying? I've got three weeks certified already since the employer filed.

0 coins

keeping certifications going during an appeal is something nobody tells you upfront and it really should be

0 coins

The agent being able to see your specific weeks like that is what I needed to hear. Mine's been pending for two weeks and I keep wondering what's actually in there.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact scenario last year when my old retail job appealed after EDD said I was eligible. Here's what actually happened to me and what I learned: the administrative law judge holds a real hearing, testimony is under oath, and you get to tell your side just like the employer tells theirs. If the judge sides with the employer and finds misconduct, EDD sends a Notice of Determination reversing your eligibility. That's when the overpayment question comes in — anything paid to you during the period they rule you weren't eligible can be classified as an overpayment you have to pay back. It's not automatic that they demand it immediately but it does show up as a debt. The key thing is you have 30 days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal again, this time to the CUIAB, the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. The appeal form DE 1000M comes with the notice. Keep every scrap of paper from your original layoff — anything that shows the reason you were let go, any emails, any performance records, whatever you have.

0 coins

If the judge finds misconduct and sends that Notice of Determination, is there any way to argue the overpayment separately from the main ruling? Like appeal the ruling but also contest having to pay back what I already got?

0 coins

The 30 days from the mailing date thing caught me off guard once because I was counting from when I actually got the letter, not the date printed on it. Those can be different by several days.

0 coins

This is the clearest breakdown I've seen of what actually happens after a loss. The overpayment piece is what scares everyone and nobody explains it plainly like this.

0 coins

Had my hearing date land right before rent was due and the anxiety was something else. One thing I want to flag about the hearing itself — an administrative law judge runs it, not some EDD employee. The Notice of Hearing comes by mail at least 10 days before and that notice matters because it also tells you what questions will likely come up. Read it carefully. You can represent yourself or bring a union rep or an attorney. Nobody is going to hold your hand through the process so going in prepared makes a real difference. Write down the specific facts of your layoff before the hearing and stick to those facts when you testify. The employer has to prove there was misconduct, so your job is basically to tell your accurate story and let them try to prove something that isn't true.

0 coins

Mine said something about likely questions on the DE 4800 — is that the same as the Notice of Hearing or a different form?

0 coins

DE 4800 is the interview scheduling notice, not the hearing notice. Two different things. The phone interview is EDD gathering info before they decide. The hearing is after EDD already decided and someone is appealing that decision.

0 coins

Oh wait so I already had the DE 4800 phone interview before EDD approved me. The hearing is a whole separate thing with the judge. I think I mixed those up completely.

0 coins

Lots of people mix those up, the naming isn't intuitive at all. EDD phone interview to gather facts, then EDD decision, then if someone appeals, CUIAB hearing with the judge. Three separate steps.

0 coins

NOBODY told me before my hearing that the employer often just doesn't show up and when they don't it usually goes in your favor by default. Mine filed the appeal and then didn't appear. Judge asked me a few questions, I answered them honestly, and that was basically it. Still got the written decision mailed to me later. Doesn't always happen that way but worth knowing employers sometimes file appeals as a scare tactic or to drag things out and then don't follow through.

0 coins

Has anyone seen the opposite where the claimant doesn't show and what happens then?

0 coins

Missing your own hearing is bad — the judge decides based on whatever information is available and that usually means what the employer said goes unchallenged. Phone EDD the same day if something prevents you from attending and explain the situation. They may reschedule but it's not guaranteed.

0 coins

I missed mine years ago because I had the wrong time written down. It was not a good outcome. Triple check the notice.

0 coins

The misconduct standard is worth understanding before you walk into that room. EDD's own language is that if you're fired, the employer has to prove there was misconduct. What employers sometimes try to do at hearings is reframe a plain layoff as performance issues or rule violations after the fact. If you have any documentation showing it was a genuine layoff — an email, a letter, a text, anything — bring copies. The judge takes testimony under oath from both sides. You're allowed to ask questions about what the employer says. Write your questions down beforehand so you don't blank in the moment.

0 coins

What they listed in their appeal as the reason is different from what they told me when I was let go. Can I bring that contradiction up at the hearing?

0 coins

Absolutely bring it up. That kind of inconsistency between what they told you then and what they're claiming now is exactly the kind of thing that matters to a judge. If you have anything in writing from when it happened, that's even better.

0 coins

My employer tried something similar at my hearing, claimed I violated a policy that wasn't even in the handbook they gave me. The judge asked about the written policy and they couldn't produce it. Went in my favor.

0 coins

Something I got wrong before my hearing that cost me some stress — I thought losing the employer's appeal automatically meant I had to repay everything EDD already paid out. That's not quite right. If the judge rules against you, EDD issues a Notice of Determination. If that creates an overpayment, you can apply for a waiver using the DE 1446UI if the overpayment wasn't your fault and wasn't fraud, and if paying it back would be an extraordinary hardship. No guarantees on the waiver but it's not like they just garnish your wages or take it all at once with no recourse. EDD collects from future benefits or tax refunds, things like that. Appeal first if you disagree with the ruling, and if the overpayment still stands after all that, look at the waiver application.

0 coins

The DE 1446UI is the waiver form — where do I even get that? Does EDD send it automatically or do I have to ask?

0 coins

EDD typically includes information about the waiver option when they send the overpayment notice. If it's not there, ask EDD directly through a UI Online message or the phone line.

0 coins

About a year ago I had an overpayment situation after a different appeal and the waiver process took forever but it was worth submitting. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent and confirmed the DE 1446UI had been received and was in review — the agent told me it was assigned and that I'd get a written notice of their determination on it. Knowing it was actually in the system instead of lost was the main thing I needed.

0 coins

So you can appeal the main ruling AND apply for the waiver at the same time? Or do you have to wait on one before doing the other?

0 coins

You can do both. Appeal the ruling within 30 days if you think the judge got it wrong. And if there's an overpayment notice, respond to that separately. They run on different tracks.

0 coins

Preparing for my employer's appeal hearing I found it really helped to write out a timeline. Like literally a written timeline of everything: when I was hired, what my job was, any changes, the last conversation I had with my boss, the day I was told I was done and what exactly was said. When you're testifying under oath and nervous, having that timeline in your head makes it easier to answer questions without getting tangled. The judge isn't your enemy but they do ask pointed questions and you want your answers consistent.

0 coins

Did you end up winning your hearing or did the employer succeed on their appeal?

0 coins

Judge found in my favor. Employer claimed I'd violated attendance policy but the records they submitted actually showed I'd called in each time per their own procedure. Their own documents helped my case.

0 coins

This timeline idea is genuinely good prep advice regardless of how the hearing goes.

0 coins

For the question about losing and what happens to future payments — if the judge rules for the employer, your benefits stop from the date covered by the ruling. EDD processes that through a new Notice of Determination. Any weeks you certified that fall under the ruling's scope become the overpayment, and any weeks after the ruling date where you're found ineligible won't be paid at all even if you certified them. The 30-day appeal window is on the written decision. If you want to fight it, that's the form DE 1000M you send to the address on the notice. The CUIAB handles the second-level appeal, which is a separate review.

0 coins

If I appeal the judge's decision to the CUIAB and I'm waiting on that outcome, should I still be certifying?

0 coins

Keep certifying every two weeks through any appeal. If a later decision comes back in your favor, EDD can only pay the weeks you actually certified. Weeks you didn't certify are gone even if you eventually win.

0 coins

This should be posted somewhere official because the number of people who stop certifying during appeals and then lose those weeks is genuinely sad.

0 coins

Went back and forth with EDD and my former employer for about four months total on mine. The hardest part wasn't the hearing itself, it was the waiting between the hearing and the written decision. Judge didn't say anything at the end of my hearing that told me which way it went — just said the written decision would be mailed. That wait was rough. Set up expectations accordingly.

0 coins

They really don't give you any indication at all at the end of the hearing?

0 coins

Nothing. At least in my case. The judge wrapped up, said thank you, and that was it. The written decision came in the mail and that was when I found out.

0 coins

Same experience here. The lack of any signal at the end of the hearing is a thing. Prepare yourself for the waiting period after.

0 coins

One thing I wish I'd known is that you can represent yourself but you don't have to. A union rep can come with you, an attorney can represent you, any person you choose can be your representative at the hearing. If your old job had a union and you're still a member, ask about representation specifically for the CUIAB hearing. Some legal aid offices in California also help with unemployment appeals at no cost. Worth a call before your hearing date.

0 coins

Does having a representative change the timeline or the format of the hearing at all?

0 coins

Format is the same either way. Having a rep just means someone who knows the process can ask questions and make arguments on your behalf. The administrative law judge runs the hearing the same way.

0 coins

Legal aid for unemployment appeals is genuinely underutilized. Most people don't know it exists and go in alone when they don't have to.

0 coins

My employer filed an appeal about three weeks after EDD approved me and the whole thing took about two and a half months from their appeal to the hearing. During all of that I never stopped certifying and kept getting paid. What finally clicked for me reading the Notice of Hearing was that the burden in a misconduct case is on the employer to prove it, not on me to prove I didn't do it. That shifted how I thought about the whole hearing — I wasn't there to defend myself from accusations so much as let them fail to prove theirs.

0 coins

Two and a half months is a long time to be in that uncertainty. Did the payments keep coming the entire time without any interruption?

0 coins

Every certified period paid out until the written decision came. After the decision in my favor, everything continued normally. No gap in payments at all.

0 coins

That's really reassuring to hear for anyone going through this right now.

0 coins

Something that tripped up a person I know in a similar situation — they thought the employer's appeal meant EDD had changed its mind. That's not how it works. EDD made a decision. The employer is challenging that decision to the CUIAB, not back to EDD. EDD isn't re-deciding anything. The administrative law judge is an independent reviewer. EDD's original decision in your favor stands until the judge says otherwise, which is why payments keep coming through the appeal period.

0 coins

So EDD itself isn't involved in the hearing process once it goes to appeal?

0 coins

EDD issued its decision and that decision is what's being appealed. The hearing is in front of the CUIAB's administrative law judge, not EDD staff. EDD might be referenced but it's not EDD conducting the hearing.

0 coins

This is a really important distinction that gets confused constantly. The appeals process is separate from EDD's day-to-day claim operations.

0 coins

My employer appealed after I was approved for benefits from a layoff they started calling a 'voluntary resignation' after the fact. At the hearing I had a text message from my supervisor telling me my position was being eliminated. That one piece of evidence was the whole ballgame. Bring whatever you have in writing, even if you think it's minor.

0 coins

How do you submit evidence like that — do you bring printed copies or is it submitted beforehand?

0 coins

Brought printed copies to the hearing. The judge accepted them, looked at them, and they went into the record. I'd bring multiple copies just in case — one for the judge, one for yourself, one in case the employer needs to see what you're referencing.

0 coins

Multiple copies is the right move. I've seen hearings where someone only had one copy and it slowed things down awkwardly.

0 coins

Appeal from a termination EDD called a layoff was filed on my claim about eight months ago. After a week of the UI Online messages going unanswered I went through Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line. The agent confirmed the employer's appeal had been received, that my current certified weeks were processed and paid, and told me the Notice of Hearing would come by mail at least 10 days before the scheduled date. I'd been panicking that the appeal had somehow frozen my claim and that call settled it — the agent showed me the payments were going through normally and the hearing was just scheduled separately.

0 coins

Eight months ago — has your hearing happened already? How did it go?

0 coins

Happened about six months ago. Judge ruled in my favor. Employer couldn't substantiate the misconduct claim with anything concrete.

0 coins

That detail about the Notice of Hearing coming at least 10 days before is in the actual regulations. Good to have an agent confirm it matches what's on your actual claim.

0 coins

Before my hearing I was confused about whether the employer appeal meant my weekly certification should change in any way. I checked through UI Online first but couldn't find any clear status update, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask directly. The agent walked me through my claim week by week and confirmed each certified period was paid and nothing was flagged as held pending the appeal outcome. Knowing the certifications were going through gave me one less thing to spiral about while waiting for the hearing date.

0 coins

Week by week confirmation sounds like exactly what I need right now. I keep second-guessing whether something I certified got held.

0 coins

That spiral of wondering what's actually in your claim status is real. Having someone actually walk you through each week is different from refreshing UI Online.

0 coins

Overpayment notice showed up about three weeks after my hearing loss on an employer appeal years back. Went through Claimyr for that — ended up talking to an agent who confirmed the notice amount, explained I had 30 days from the mailing date to appeal it, and told me the DE 1446UI waiver was an option to ask about given the circumstances. Filed the appeal on the main ruling and submitted the waiver application at the same time. Eventually got a reduced amount after the second-level review.

0 coins

Reduced amount through the second-level CUIAB review or through the waiver process?

0 coins

Through the second level — the CUIAB review changed the ruling on a few specific weeks, which reduced what counted as overpaid. The waiver was still pending when that happened and I withdrew it since the amount got smaller.

0 coins

The fact that you can get a partial ruling change at second level isn't something most people realize. It's not all or nothing necessarily.

0 coins

Just want to add for anyone reading this later — the written decision from the administrative law judge gets mailed. It is not in UI Online. I kept checking my claim status online thinking it would show up there and it doesn't. Watch your physical mailbox after your hearing.

0 coins

Good to know. I've been living in UI Online and would have definitely missed something sent by mail.

0 coins

EDD sends a lot by mail that never appears in UI Online. DE 429Z, Notice of Determination, the hearing decision — physical mail for all of it. Keep a good address on file.

0 coins

Address on file being current is so basic and yet I've seen people miss documents because they moved and forgot to update it.

0 coins

Went into my employer appeal hearing thinking it would be like a courtroom scene and it was nothing like that. It's more like a formal phone call or video call with the judge asking structured questions. Much less dramatic than I expected. Still stressful but knowing what to expect format-wise helped me stay focused on answering the questions rather than the whole performance of it.

0 coins

Mine is a phone hearing based on the notice — is that common or is in-person more typical?

0 coins

Phone hearings have been the norm for a lot of these for years. Some are video. In-person is less common. The process is the same regardless of format.

0 coins

Phone hearing for mine too. The judge was professional, the whole thing was recorded, and it was pretty structured even without being in a room together.

0 coins

Made the mistake of not bringing a witness to my employer appeal hearing even though I had a coworker who saw the whole situation that led to my termination. By the time I realized witnesses were allowed and would have helped, the hearing was already over. If you have anyone who can speak to what actually happened, ask them before your hearing date if they'd be willing to participate. The Notice of Hearing has information about what you're allowed to bring and present.

0 coins

How do you actually arrange for a witness — do they need to be listed somewhere in advance or can you just bring them?

0 coins

Check the Notice of Hearing for the specific instructions. Some hearings have specific requirements about giving notice of witnesses beforehand. Don't assume you can just show up with someone without checking first.

0 coins

This is a really important practical point. The hearing notice has procedural instructions and reading them fully before the day matters.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure