Back to California Unemployment

Mateo Hernandez

What happens after withdrawing appeal before the hearing - California EDD question

Filed an appeal back in October after getting a denial notice (DE 1080CZ) for a claim that started when my warehouse job eliminated my position. The denial said something about 'voluntary leaving' which made no sense because I was laid off - they just worded the termination weird in their paperwork. Anyway I submitted the Appeal Form DE 1000M and got my Notice of Hearing scheduled for next month. Here's the thing though - my former employer actually reached out and said they're willing to write a letter clarifying it was an involuntary layoff, and EDD has since started processing some of my weeks as paid. So now I'm wondering if withdrawing the appeal before the hearing is even a smart move, or if doing so would mess up my remaining pending weeks. What actually happens after you withdraw an appeal? Does EDD automatically deny everything that wasn't already paid? Do I lose any rights to appeal again if something else comes up wrong later? I've been certifying every two weeks like I'm supposed to and I still have weeks showing as Pending in Claim History. Really need to understand the process before I make any decisions here.

DE 1000M was the form you used to appeal, and there's actually a separate written withdrawal process - you'd send a letter to the address on your Notice of Hearing stating you want to withdraw. The California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board (CUIAB) handles it from there. Withdrawing the appeal doesn't automatically resolve the underlying eligibility question EDD already decided on. Those pending weeks in your Claim History are a separate matter from the appeal itself - EDD could still be holding them for other reasons, or they could be tied to the same issue. The appeal covered the specific determination on the DE 1080CZ you got. If EDD has already started paying some weeks, that might mean they're reconsidering on their own, but I wouldn't assume the withdrawal fixes everything. You'd want to know why those specific weeks are still pending before you pull the appeal.

0 coins

That's what I was afraid of - the pending weeks being separate. So theoretically I could withdraw and still have pending weeks that never get resolved?

0 coins

Exactly the risk. The Notice of Determination you got covered a specific period or question. Withdrawing the appeal means the ALJ never rules on it, but EDD's original decision on that DE 1080CZ would stand unless EDD issues a new one. If the employer letter changes what EDD has on file, EDD might issue a new determination on its own - but that's EDD's call to make, not guaranteed by the withdrawal itself.

0 coins

This is the part that tripped me up too - I thought appealing meant everything was on hold. The appeal is just about fighting that one determination letter, not about all your pending stuff.

0 coins

Adjudication hold on my account lasted six weeks before I finally got someone on the phone about it. The status in Claim History just said Pending with no explanation of which weeks were affected or why, and the UI Online message I sent sat unanswered for two weeks. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD - there's a video they have on reaching a live person at EDD by phone at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my account and told me the hold was because my former employer had flagged the separation reason differently than what I reported. She said there was a phone interview scheduled that I hadn't received notice for yet, and she confirmed the date was coming up so I could be ready. That's the kind of thing you can only find out by actually talking to someone - for the pending weeks question here I'd really suggest getting a live agent to look at whether those weeks are tied to the appeal issue or something else entirely.

0 coins

Six weeks of Pending with no explanation sounds like exactly what I'm dealing with. Did the interview end up clearing the hold?

0 coins

The interview happened and within about a week two of my pending weeks showed as paid. The others took longer because there was a separate wages issue EDD had to look at. Point being the agent at least told me what I was waiting for, which made it less of a guessing game.

0 coins

That adjudication hold situation with the employer flagging the separation differently - ran into the exact same thing. Took forever to untangle.

0 coins

Thought withdrawing meant you were giving up forever, which stopped me from withdrawing my own appeal for months even though my situation had basically resolved. Turns out that's not how it works. Withdrawing one appeal doesn't take away your right to appeal a future determination. Each Notice of Determination you get has its own 30-day window to appeal. So if EDD sends you a new DE 1080CZ after your employer submits that letter, and you disagree with what it says, you'd have 30 days from the mailing date on that new notice to file another appeal. What you're giving up by withdrawing is only the chance to have an administrative law judge rule on the specific determination that's already in front of the CUIAB right now.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date on each new notice - okay that actually helps a lot. I was thinking one withdrawal meant I lost appeal rights permanently.

0 coins

30 days is the window and it goes by the mailing date on the notice itself, not when you actually receive it. That tripped me up - mine arrived a few days late and I almost missed the deadline thinking I had more time.

0 coins

Mailing date is the one that counts, yes. If you're ever cutting it close, send the written appeal by certified mail so you have proof of when it was sent.

0 coins

The voluntary leaving vs layoff distinction matters a lot here before you decide anything. EDD's standard is that if you quit, you have to show a good reason - but if your employer is now saying it was a layoff, that's a factual correction, not just your word against theirs. The employer letter could change what EDD has on record about why the separation happened. Some people in this situation let the appeal proceed precisely because the ALJ hearing is a chance to put that employer letter and testimony on the record under oath. Withdrawing before the hearing means that documentation never gets formally heard. EDD might act on new information anyway, but the appeal hearing is a structured opportunity to make sure it's considered.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about the hearing as a formal chance to put the letter on the record. That's a really different way to look at it.

0 coins

Administrative law judge hearings are less intimidating than they sound - testimony under oath but it's not like a courtroom drama. I represented myself and just walked through the timeline of what happened with my job.

0 coins

Exactly, the ALJ is there to hear both sides and you can represent yourself. If the employer is cooperating with a letter anyway, they might even participate in the hearing and that testimony plus the written letter is a stronger record than the letter alone.

0 coins

This is good to know. I always assumed appeals were these huge formal legal things you needed a lawyer for. Didn't realize you could just go in and explain your own situation.

0 coins

My appeal was scheduled and I withdrew it thinking EDD would automatically reconsider everything - big mistake. What actually happened was EDD's original denial just stood there, uncontested, and my pending weeks stayed pending because the determination hadn't changed. Had to then contact EDD separately to ask about the weeks, explain the new information from my employer, and basically start the conversation over. If you're going to withdraw, make sure you have some confirmation from EDD in writing - or at minimum from an agent - that the pending weeks situation is going to be addressed. Otherwise you might withdraw and then have nothing move.

0 coins

The 'original denial just stood there uncontested' part is exactly what I needed to hear. So the withdrawal itself doesn't trigger EDD to do anything new?

0 coins

Nothing automatic, in my experience. EDD still had the original determination on file and that's what was driving my pending weeks. The appeal withdrawal just closed out the CUIAB case - EDD's side of things didn't update until I contacted them and explained the new employer information.

0 coins

This is making me rethink my own situation. I was about to withdraw an appeal because things seemed to be resolving but now I'm wondering if I should wait and see what EDD actually does first.

0 coins

Eight pending weeks sat in my Claim History for almost two months while my appeal was open. The appeal was about a fired-for-misconduct determination that I disagreed with - my employer couldn't actually show what the misconduct was supposed to be. While that was pending at CUIAB, I kept certifying like I was supposed to because if the appeal went my way, EDD could only pay weeks that had been certified. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone and confirmed those eight weeks were directly tied to the appeal outcome. The agent said once CUIAB issued a decision in my favor, EDD would process those weeks. That's what ended up happening - won the appeal, all eight weeks processed within a few days. For your situation, definitely find out from EDD directly whether your pending weeks are tied to the appeal decision before you withdraw.

0 coins

Won the appeal and all eight weeks processed - that's the outcome I'd want. And you kept certifying the whole time?

0 coins

Every two weeks without fail. If those weeks hadn't been certified, EDD couldn't have paid them even after the appeal won. That's just how the system works - certifying keeps the weeks eligible to be paid if EDD eventually decides in your favor.

0 coins

The 'keep certifying during an appeal' thing is so important and not obvious at all. A lot of people stop because they assume nothing will happen until the appeal is decided.

0 coins

Wondered the same thing about withdrawals affecting future appeal rights, and I want to add one more piece - the CUIAB case gets closed when you withdraw, but the case record doesn't disappear. If EDD ever audits your claim or questions those same weeks later, the fact that you appealed and withdrew is in the system. It's not necessarily a problem but it's worth knowing. The administrative law judge never issues a decision when you withdraw, so there's no ruling for anyone to point to - which can cut both ways.

0 coins

The case record staying in the system is something I hadn't considered at all.

0 coins

Not trying to alarm you - in most cases it's a non-issue. Just meant that withdrawing isn't the same as the appeal never having happened. If EDD issues a new determination on the same separation question, they'd have the history of the prior appeal on file.

0 coins

This is really thorough. I went through an appeal last year and had no idea the CUIAB case record persisted even after I withdrew. Glad to know it doesn't necessarily cause problems.

0 coins

Before I understood the appeals process, I thought withdrawing your appeal meant you were admitting EDD was right - like it was some kind of legal confession. That's not what it is. Withdrawing just means you're choosing not to pursue that particular hearing. EDD's determination is what it is regardless; you're not validating it by withdrawing. If new information comes in and EDD issues a corrected determination, that's EDD's own process working, not a consequence of your withdrawal. The withdrawal and EDD's eligibility decision are on two separate tracks.

0 coins

Two separate tracks is the clearest way I've heard this explained. The withdrawal doesn't equal agreeing with EDD's determination.

0 coins

Right. And if EDD mails you a new DE 1080CZ after reviewing the employer letter, you get a fresh 30-day window on that new notice. You're not locked into the original denial just because you withdrew.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet - once you withdraw, the hearing date goes away and you can't un-withdraw. If you change your mind after submitting the withdrawal, the CUIAB case is closed and you'd need a new appealable determination to start over. So if there's any uncertainty about whether your pending weeks are connected to this appeal, the safer play is usually to get that answer first and then decide about the withdrawal rather than the other way around.

0 coins

Can't un-withdraw is a really important point. I nearly withdrew mine impulsively and then realized I had no idea what would happen to my specific weeks.

0 coins

Exactly why it's worth taking a few days to actually contact EDD before submitting the withdrawal. The hearing isn't going anywhere in the meantime - you have until the date approaches to make the call.

0 coins

This is probably what I'll do - contact EDD first to ask about the pending weeks specifically, then decide on the withdrawal.

0 coins

Ending up talking to an EDD agent about my pending weeks situation was the thing that finally made the decision clear for me too - Claimyr got me through when I couldn't reach anyone for days. The agent told me exactly which weeks were held for the appeal and which were pending for a different reason entirely, which changed what I did next.

0 coins

Employer cooperating is actually a big deal and not everyone gets that. In a lot of these 'voluntary vs involuntary' disputes, the employer either doesn't respond to EDD at all or doubles down on how they characterized the separation. If yours is willing to put in writing that it was a layoff, that's the documentation EDD needs to potentially issue a corrected determination on its own. That said, 'willing to write a letter' and 'actually submitting it to EDD in time to matter' are two different things. I'd make sure the employer knows where to send it and what information EDD needs, and I'd follow up with EDD to confirm they received it.

0 coins

Good point about following up to make sure EDD actually received it. I've been assuming the employer would handle that but I should probably verify.

0 coins

EDD gets a lot of correspondence and things can get separated from claims. If the employer can send it through Ask EDD or attach it to your claim file somehow, that's better than just mailing a letter and hoping it gets connected to the right account.

0 coins

The employer not responding to EDD is so common. Mine didn't respond to the initial claim notice at all and then tried to get involved later - EDD had already processed my weeks by then.

0 coins

Honestly just want to validate that this whole situation is confusing and you're asking exactly the right questions before doing anything. The number of people I've seen on this forum who withdrew an appeal thinking it would speed things up and then had everything stall - it's a lot. The pending weeks question is the crux of it. If those weeks are held because of the appeal determination, withdrawing without getting EDD to change that determination first could leave you with nothing resolved and no open case.

0 coins

Appreciate this. I almost just sent the withdrawal letter without thinking any of this through.

0 coins

The fact that some weeks are already paying is actually a decent sign - it might mean EDD is already reconsidering on its own. But 'might mean' isn't good enough when you're deciding whether to close a live appeal case.

0 coins

Had an overpayment notice land while my appeal was open, which made everything more complicated. The appeal was about whether I qualified in the first place, and separately EDD was saying I owed money back. Got to an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask whether the overpayment collection would be paused during the appeal - the agent confirmed the overpayment was tied to the same determination and explained what would happen with those weeks depending on how the appeal resolved. Worth knowing that if you have any overpayment concerns connected to the denied weeks, those don't automatically resolve when an appeal is withdrawn either.

0 coins

No overpayment notice in my case yet, but that's a whole other layer I hadn't considered. Good to know that's also tied to the determination, not just the appeal status.

0 coins

The overpayment notice came with its own 30-day appeal window too, separate from the eligibility appeal. I ended up appealing both on the same form but listing both notice dates.

0 coins

Two separate 30-day windows for two separate notices - this is exactly the kind of thing that gets people. Easy to assume it's all one process.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration requirement tripped me up during my own appeal period. Was so focused on the appeal that I almost missed the 21-day window to register in CalJOBS after getting the DE 8405. Missing that can pause payments independent of whatever the appeal outcome is. If you haven't already done the CalJOBS registration and resume posting, make sure that's not adding to why some weeks are pending.

0 coins

Already registered in CalJOBS early on - that's one thing I did right. But it's a good thing to flag for anyone else reading this.

0 coins

Good - it's easy to forget about when you're dealing with an appeal and pending weeks and employer letters all at once. The DE 8405 gives the deadline and once you're past it you have to contact EDD to explain why.

0 coins

DE 8405 deadline is real and EDD takes it seriously. Miss it and your payments can stop even if everything else with your claim is fine.

0 coins

My appeal involved a 'quit vs layoff' dispute too and I want to share one thing that surprised me about the hearing itself. The administrative law judge asked very specific questions about the timeline - exactly when I found out my position was being eliminated, whether I was offered another position, whether I signed anything. If your appeal goes forward, having that employer letter plus any emails or documents about the layoff announcement would be way stronger than the letter alone. The hearing is under oath but it's also genuinely a conversation about what happened.

0 coins

Timeline questions and documentation - I actually do have some emails from when they announced the elimination. Hadn't thought about those as evidence.

0 coins

Those emails could be really useful if the hearing proceeds. The ALJ is trying to establish what actually happened at the separation, and contemporaneous emails are more persuasive than recollection alone.

0 coins

Emails with dates are exactly the kind of thing ALJs find credible. They show what was communicated and when, before anyone had a reason to frame it differently.

0 coins

One thing to flag for the period after you withdraw or after the appeal resolves - if EDD issues a new determination and pays the back weeks, those payments count as income for federal taxes. The Form 1099G will reflect whatever EDD paid in that calendar year. Just something to be aware of if a bunch of back weeks get processed at once.

0 coins

Good heads up. I know UI benefits are federal taxable income - didn't think about how a lump of back weeks would hit the 1099G.

0 coins

EDD gives you the option to have 10 percent withheld for federal taxes when you certify. If a lot of weeks are about to process, might be worth thinking about whether you have that withholding set up.

0 coins

Form 1099G is available in UI Online under Payments each January, so you can see the total there even if the paper copy hasn't arrived yet.

0 coins

The practical next step seems pretty clear from everything in this thread - before submitting anything to CUIAB about withdrawing, get on the phone with EDD and ask two specific things: first, are the pending weeks in Claim History held because of the appeal determination, and second, what will EDD do when the employer letter comes in. Those two answers will tell you whether withdrawing helps, hurts, or doesn't change anything about the pending weeks situation.

0 coins

Two specific questions - this is a useful frame. I've been thinking about the withdrawal as the main decision but really it's those answers that should drive the decision.

0 coins

The withdrawal itself is easy to do once you know it's the right move. It's the information-gathering beforehand that takes the most effort, especially when getting EDD on the phone is its own challenge.

0 coins

Getting EDD on the phone is the main obstacle for a lot of people dealing with these exact situations. The hold times on 1-800-300-5616 can be brutal on a regular day, let alone when there's something complex to discuss.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact sequence - layoff documented as something else by the employer, appeal filed, then employer came around. The thing that resolved mine was EDD issuing a new determination on its own after reviewing the employer's corrected information, before the hearing date arrived. CUIAB scheduled the hearing for about 45 days out and EDD moved faster than that. Ended up not needing to formally withdraw because EDD's new determination was favorable and I just let the appeal lapse. That's not always how it goes but it's worth knowing EDD can move faster than a CUIAB hearing timeline.

0 coins

EDD moving faster than the CUIAB timeline - hadn't thought about that possibility at all. So sometimes the appeal becomes moot on its own?

0 coins

In my case yes. EDD issued a new DE 1080CZ in my favor before the hearing date. The CUIAB case essentially had nothing left to decide. I still got a letter from CUIAB closing the case but it was a non-event at that point.

0 coins

This is actually a decent outcome because there's no ambiguity - EDD's own favorable determination is cleaner than a withdrawal with the original denial still technically on file.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later - the DE 1000M appeal form and the written withdrawal are both going to the Office of Appeals, but they're different documents. The form itself has instructions about where to send it. If you're withdrawing, write a clear letter with your name, Social Security number, claim ID, and the date of your original appeal, and state clearly that you're withdrawing the appeal before the hearing. Send it to the address on your Notice of Hearing.

0 coins

Name, SSN, claim ID, date of original appeal, and a clear statement of withdrawal - noted. And send to the Notice of Hearing address.

0 coins

Certified mail is worth the extra cost so you have a record of when it was received. CUIAB has to process it and you want to know it got there, especially if the hearing is coming up soon.

0 coins

Certified mail for anything time-sensitive with EDD or CUIAB is just the right habit. Gives you something to point to if there's ever a question about timing.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure