Back to California Unemployment

Ravi Patel

What does decision dismissing appeal mean after department reversed its position on California EDD?

Got the strangest piece of mail from the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board last week and I genuinely don't know how to read it. Background: I was laid off from my warehouse job in March, filed my UI claim, everything seemed fine until EDD sent a Notice of Determination saying I was disqualified — the reason given had to do with something about my separation from the employer. I appealed immediately using the DE 1000M, sent it in well within the 30-day window. Fast forward about six weeks. I never got a Notice of Hearing. Instead I got a letter that says something like 'Decision Dismissing Appeal' — but here's what's confusing me. The letter also mentions that the department reversed its position. So EDD apparently changed its mind and now says I do qualify, but then the CUIAB dismissed my appeal? I'm reading this in circles. My UI Online Claim History still shows some weeks as Pending. I still haven't been paid for the weeks between when I got disqualified and when this reversal apparently happened. Were those weeks supposed to get certified? I kept certifying through the whole thing like I'd read to do. Does the dismissal mean I lost? Does it mean I won? Is there a difference when the department flips its position before the hearing even happens? Really lost on this one.

Somewhere in week nine of my own appeal mess when I finally got a straight answer on this exact situation, so let me try to explain what happened to me and what I was told. When EDD reverses its position before the administrative law judge holds a hearing, there's nothing left to adjudicate — the original determination that caused the disqualification is essentially off the table. The CUIAB then issues a 'Decision Dismissing Appeal' not because you lost, but because the appeal itself is moot. You got what you appealed for: EDD changed its mind. The dismissal is the procedural close to an appeal that resolved on its own before reaching a hearing.

0 coins

That actually makes the letter click for me finally. So 'dismissed' in this context isn't the same as 'denied'? The word dismissed had me convinced I'd somehow lost even though EDD switched sides.

0 coins

Appeals vocabulary is brutal, honestly. 'Dismissed' in a court or quasi-judicial setting usually means the case didn't go forward — but it doesn't mean the underlying issue went against you. When the department is the one who blinked, dismissal is basically the finish line, not a wall.

0 coins

Exactly. The confusion is totally understandable because 'dismissed' in everyday language sounds like rejection. In this process it's more like the case is closed because the original problem was fixed.

0 coins

Disqualification notice came in mid-April for me after I was let go from a retail position, and I appealed the same week. About five weeks in, EDD reversed before any hearing was scheduled — same situation as the person above. Getting through to an actual EDD agent to understand what it meant for my pending weeks was what I needed. Claimyr (claimyr.com) handled the hold for me and I ended up speaking with someone at EDD directly. There's a video walking through how to reach a live person at EDD — https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 — which is what made me try it. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the weeks I'd certified during the appeal period were still in Pending because a manual review step had to be completed after the reversal, and that I should watch Claim History over the next few business days. Payments started posting within the week after that call.

0 coins

This is exactly what I needed to hear. The manual review piece is what I think is holding up my Pending weeks too. So certifying through the whole thing was the right call?

0 coins

Certifying through the whole appeal period is critical — the agent was pretty clear that EDD can only release payment for weeks that were actually certified, so any gap would just be a gap.

0 coins

Manual review after a reversal is real. Had something similar with an adjudication issue last year, not an appeal, but same idea — the system doesn't automatically unlock everything the second EDD changes its decision. Someone on their end has to process it.

0 coins

Ask EDD what your current obligation is now that the Decision Dismissing Appeal has been issued — specifically whether any weeks from the disqualification period require anything additional from you before they release. That's the question because once EDD reverses, the weeks you certified should theoretically be payable, but there can be processing steps that aren't communicated well in the letters. The rule is simple in principle: if you were able and available for work, you certified those weeks, and EDD reversed the disqualification, those weeks fall back into the payable queue. The letter itself won't walk you through what happens next on the payment side, which is why so many people end up confused.

0 coins

I did keep certifying every two weeks the entire time, never missed one. The letter mentions nothing about what I'm supposed to do next, which is part of why I ended up here trying to figure it out.

0 coins

EDD's letters are honestly written as if they expect you to already know the whole system. The Decision Dismissing Appeal closed the CUIAB case — your outstanding weeks are now purely an EDD payment processing question, separate from the appeal outcome.

0 coins

Right, and that's worth emphasizing. The CUIAB and EDD's payment processing are different pieces. The appeal closing means the CUIAB is done with your case. Getting paid is EDD's side of it, and that's where you need to follow up.

0 coins

WEEKS STILL SHOWING PENDING AFTER A REVERSAL IS SO COMMON AND EDD DOES NOT EXPLAIN IT. I went through almost the same thing — disqualified, appealed, EDD reversed before the hearing, got the dismissal letter, and then just... waited. No payment. No explanation. Called for days. The phone system was a wall. Eventually I got through after multiple attempts across a week and a half and someone told me a supervisor had to manually clear a flag on my account. This was not in any letter, not in UI Online, nothing. The system just sat there while I stressed out.

0 coins

How long did it end up taking after you finally got through to someone?

0 coins

Payment posted about four days after the agent cleared whatever was flagged. Still no letter explaining what the flag was or why it was there. Just — money appeared.

0 coins

The flag thing is frustrating because there's no way to know it's there from your side. UI Online just shows Pending indefinitely without any note that it's waiting on internal action.

0 coins

Pending weeks after a department reversal during an appeal — the DE 429Z on my claim showed a weekly benefit amount of $390 and those weeks sat in limbo for almost three weeks post-dismissal letter. Used Claimyr to get on the phone with an EDD agent and asked specifically about the status of the weeks certified during the appeal period. The agent told me two weeks were cleared and one was still under a secondary review because of a wage reporting question from one of my certifications. That was actually useful — I hadn't known there was a secondary issue stacked on top of the appeal.

0 coins

Secondary issues stacked on top — that's a scenario I hadn't thought about. My certifications were all straightforward but I guess I should confirm there's nothing else flagged.

0 coins

Worth asking EDD specifically to look at each week's status individually, not just the overall claim. When there's been an appeal and a reversal, individual week statuses can differ even if the overall claim looks the same in UI Online.

0 coins

Retail job ended in February, disqualification notice came about three weeks later, I appealed, and then — maybe two months into the process — EDD reversed. Got the Decision Dismissing Appeal letter and was relieved, then confused when payment didn't come. Eventually worked through Claimyr to get an agent on the line and found out my identity verification through ID.me had a flag that predated the appeal entirely. The agent said the reversal had cleared the disqualification but the ID.me issue was a separate hold. Had to go back into ID.me and re-confirm something before EDD could release payments.

0 coins

ID.me being a separate layer is something I didn't even consider. I did my verification when I first filed but I'll go double check that nothing is flagged there.

0 coins

My ID.me verification looked complete on my end too — the issue was something on EDD's side that showed the link to my account as needing re-confirmation. Only found out because the agent specifically checked.

0 coins

ID.me holds and disqualification holds are completely independent systems as far as EDD is concerned. Getting one resolved doesn't automatically clear the other, which is exactly the kind of thing you'd only know if you asked.

0 coins

Can I ask something that's probably obvious but I'm not sure — if EDD reversed its position does that mean the employer's side of the story didn't hold up, or does it just mean EDD decided internally to change? My situation is different, I was fired and I'm still in the middle of an appeal, but I'm trying to understand what it looks like when EDD reverses before a hearing.

0 coins

EDD can reverse for a variety of reasons — sometimes after reviewing the employer's response to the claim, sometimes after looking at additional documentation you submitted with your appeal. It's EDD's own determination, separate from whatever the employer argued. The administrative law judge never enters the picture when a reversal happens before the hearing.

0 coins

To the fired situation specifically: EDD's standard is that your employer has to show misconduct to deny a claim for someone who was fired. Whether that played out in your case would be in whatever Notice of Determination you got. If you're still mid-appeal, focus on the hearing notice — the DE 4800 gives you the date and time, and you need to be available for that call from the interviewer.

0 coins

My DE 4800 shows a date next month. So I still have the interview coming up regardless of what I read in this thread. Good to know I should just be ready for that.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone reading this who is earlier in the process than the original poster: keep certifying even when your claim is in adjudication or under appeal. The original poster did this right. EDD can only process payment for weeks that were certified — there's no way to retroactively certify a gap if you stopped because you assumed you wouldn't get paid during an appeal period. The certification keeps the weeks in the queue so they can be paid if and when EDD decides in your favor.

0 coins

This should be somewhere on the appeals form itself honestly. I stopped certifying for two weeks during my appeal because I thought the whole claim was frozen and I lost those two weeks entirely when EDD eventually paid out.

0 coins

The loss of those weeks is unfortunately permanent. EDD can only pay certified weeks. It's one of the most common and painful mistakes during the appeal process.

0 coins

Really glad I read that advice in a thread early on. I genuinely don't know if I would have kept certifying without it — the disqualification felt like it meant everything was on hold.

0 coins

My whole read on 'decision dismissing appeal' was wrong before this thread. I saw someone post about getting that letter and I told them they'd lost their appeal because I thought 'dismissed' meant rejected. Turns out I was completely off base. When the department reverses before the hearing, dismissed just means there's nothing left for the judge to decide. I'll be more careful about what I say going forward.

0 coins

The language is genuinely counterintuitive. Most people outside legal or administrative proceedings would read 'dismissed' as a loss. EDD could do a much better job explaining what the letter means in plain language.

0 coins

Even a one-line note in the letter saying 'this dismissal is not a denial' would prevent so much confusion.

0 coins

What I'm still not fully clear on after reading through this — after EDD reverses and the CUIAB dismisses, does EDD automatically send another Notice of Determination saying you now qualify, or is the dismissal letter itself the only official thing you get? Because I appealed last month and I'm trying to know what to watch for in the mail.

0 coins

EDD mails a Notice of Determination when it makes a decision on your eligibility — if they reversed, there should be a new one or a revised one reflecting the updated decision. The CUIAB's dismissal letter comes from the appeals board side, not EDD's. Keep an eye on both the mail and your UI Online Claim History.

0 coins

So two separate pieces of mail potentially — one from EDD with the new determination and one from CUIAB with the dismissal. Got it. And the pending weeks in Claim History are the EDD side, not the CUIAB side.

0 coins

Exactly. UI Online reflects EDD's payment processing. The CUIAB's letter closes the appeal case. They're parallel, not the same thing.

0 coins

Pension payment from my prior employer hit the same period as my pending appeal weeks and I had no idea how to untangle it all — I reported it when I certified but wasn't sure if it was creating a secondary hold. Reached EDD through Claimyr after spending several mornings unable to get through on the main line. The agent looked at my specific weeks and confirmed that the pension was noted, that EDD decides how it affects each week's payment, and that two of my weeks had already been calculated and cleared while one was still pending their review. That pending week resolved about a week later.

0 coins

The pension reporting question is something I hadn't thought about but it's good to see that reporting it correctly is what matters, not whether it creates a hold.

0 coins

The agent was clear that reporting it is the right move — EDD makes the determination from there. The hold on that one week wasn't because I reported it wrong, just because the calculation takes extra processing time.

0 coins

Pension income during a UI claim is one of those things where the right answer is 'report it and let EDD figure out the math' — which is what you did. Trying to calculate it yourself and then deciding whether to report or not is where people get into trouble.

0 coins

Came here because I got a Decision Dismissing Appeal letter too and panicked. Reading through all of this — the department reversed before my hearing was scheduled and that's why the CUIAB dismissed. I never got an explanation in the letter and I still have pending weeks in UI Online. At least now I know what I'm looking at.

0 coins

The letter itself is maddeningly short on context. Keep certifying, follow up with EDD about the pending weeks, and check your Claim History daily until things update.

0 coins

Certifying every two weeks regardless, haven't missed one. Just needed to understand what the dismissal meant before I could think about anything else.

0 coins

The timing question matters too: how many weeks were you disqualified before EDD reversed? Because each of those weeks that you certified while disqualified is a separate item in Claim History. Some might clear faster than others if anything about them triggers a secondary review — a week where you reported partial wages, a week that crossed a pay period boundary, anything like that. If you have UI Online access, checking individual week statuses in Claim History gives you more detail than the overall claim view.

0 coins

The disqualification covered about seven weeks. I reported no wages during any of them — I wasn't working. So hopefully that means no secondary issues on those individual weeks.

0 coins

Seven weeks with no wages reported is about as clean as it gets. If the reversal cleared the disqualification finding, those weeks should process without secondary complications, but the manual step some people mentioned is still probably in the queue.

0 coins

Seven clean weeks should move faster than a mix of partial wage weeks — anytime there's earnings to calculate, those tend to sit longer in my experience.

0 coins

What the original poster is describing is actually the best-case outcome in an appeal scenario — EDD reversed before the administrative law judge got involved, the CUIAB closed the case, and the remaining task is getting EDD's payment processing side to release the certified weeks. Compared to actually going through a full hearing with testimony under oath and waiting for a written decision from the judge, a pre-hearing reversal is the fastest path to resolution even if the letter is confusing.

0 coins

When you frame it that way it does feel like a better outcome than I realized. I was so thrown by the letter that I lost track of the fact that EDD changing its mind is actually the goal.

0 coins

The letter is written for record-keeping purposes, not for clarity. It's bureaucratic closure language, not a verdict. The actual verdict in your favor happened when EDD reversed.

0 coins

Waiting on EDD to process those pending weeks after any kind of adjudication or appeal outcome is genuinely the hardest part. The decision part at least gives you something to react to. The processing wait is just silence from UI Online while you check Claim History every morning wondering if today is the day something changes.

0 coins

The daily Claim History refresh is my whole routine right now. Even knowing things are moving in the right direction, the pending status sitting there is hard.

0 coins

Claim History updated overnight for me eventually — I checked before bed, still pending, woke up and payment was posted. No notification, no explanation. Just there.

0 coins

EDD's payment information also updates on the Tele-Cert line — 1-866-333-4606 — 24 hours a day, so you can check that at odd hours if you don't want to keep refreshing UI Online.

0 coins

Whether the employer responded to EDD's initial claim notice affects how quickly EDD can resolve its side of things, by the way. If the employer never responded to the DE 1101CZ, EDD still makes a decision — employers who don't respond lose certain rights to appeal EDD's determination. That's separate from your appeal as the claimant. Mentioning it because sometimes reversals happen when EDD reconsiders after a late employer response, which can complicate the timeline.

0 coins

I don't actually know whether my former employer responded. I assume they did since EDD issued a disqualification, but I don't know what they said or when.

0 coins

EDD's process goes: employer gets the DE 1101CZ, has 10 days to respond, EDD considers both sides and makes a determination. If a reversal happened, EDD reconsidered something — whether that was employer documentation, your appeal materials, or an internal review, the letter won't say.

0 coins

Employer not responding to the DE 1101CZ actually means EDD decides from your side of the story alone, and the employer gives up their own right to appeal EDD's decision. The original disqualification suggests the employer did respond in some capacity, but that's behind-the-scenes from your perspective.

0 coins

Does a Decision Dismissing Appeal affect future UI claims at all? I know this claim is for the current benefit year but I'm wondering if there's any mark on the account that would cause problems if I had to file again down the road.

0 coins

An appeal that was dismissed because EDD reversed its own position isn't a finding against you — the original disqualification is what got overturned. Future claims go through their own eligibility review from scratch. The fact that you appealed and won isn't a negative record.

0 coins

That's reassuring. I've been worried about that one too, almost as much as about the current pending weeks.

0 coins

Reached out via Ask EDD through my UI Online account after getting a dismissal letter in a different situation and the written response took about nine days. For payment-related questions after an appeal outcome, the phone is faster than the message system if you can get through. Live chat from the Help button in UI Online is available weekdays 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. if that's easier than navigating the phone line.

0 coins

I haven't tried the live chat yet. I'll start there Monday morning and try the phone if I can't get answers that way.

0 coins

Live chat agents can see your Claim History the same way a phone agent can. For a straightforward question about pending week status, it should work. More complex questions sometimes get transferred to a phone follow-up anyway.

0 coins

The 9 to 2 window for live chat goes fast — logging in right at 9 a.m. is better than trying later in the day when the queue fills up.

0 coins

For anyone who gets a Decision Dismissing Appeal because the department reversed, one thing worth asking EDD when you do reach someone: specifically which weeks have been released for payment and which are still pending review. UI Online's Claim History shows Pending for all of them in a lump without differentiating between weeks that are cleared and waiting to post versus weeks that have an active review step. Getting that breakdown from an agent is the fastest way to know if you have anything to do or if you just need to wait.

0 coins

That specific question — which weeks are cleared versus which have an active review step — is exactly what I'll ask when I get through. That's more useful than a general 'what's going on with my claim' question.

0 coins

Framing the question that specifically gets you much more actionable information from an agent. Vague questions get vague answers; asking about individual week status by the actual weeks usually gets you specifics.

0 coins

Agents can see each week's status code on their end even if UI Online only shows you Pending. Those codes tell them whether it's a processing queue or an active hold, which changes what you should do next.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure