Back to California Unemployment

AstroAlpha

What does 238 work search requirement change notice mean for California EDD?

Got a notice in the mail yesterday from EDD and I don't even know what I'm looking at. It says something about a 238 work search requirement change and I've been staring at it trying to figure out if this is good news, bad news, or just some administrative thing they send everyone. I've been on UI for about six weeks now, registered on CalJOBS like they told me to, been keeping track of everywhere I apply, and then this shows up and throws me completely. Am I supposed to do something different now? Is my claim at risk? Do I log into UI Online and change something, or just keep doing what I've been doing? Nobody I know has gotten one of these and I can't find anything helpful when I search for it.

Had a notice like that land in my mailbox back when my claim was about four weeks in and my first instinct was to panic, so I completely get the confusion. The 238 is the form number for a notice EDD sends when your work search requirement status changes — either they're adding the requirement, removing it, or modifying something about it. If it says your exemption is ending, it means EDD expects you to be actively looking for work going forward and you'll need to certify honestly about that. If it says you're now exempt, it usually means you're in some kind of approved training or situation where EDD said you don't have to look. What exactly does the notice say at the top — does it say something about an exemption being granted or one ending?

0 coins

Skimming it again right now — it looks like it's saying the exemption is ending. So I guess I was exempt before and didn't even realize it? Does that mean I should have been doing work search stuff this whole time and just wasn't?

0 coins

If you just got the notice, it's telling you going forward from that date, not that you owe anything for before. EDD sends the 238 to give you the heads up that the exemption period is closing and what they expect from you now. Keep applying to jobs and certify honestly — that's what matters from here.

0 coins

Wait, does exempt mean you don't have to register on CalJOBS either? I always thought CalJOBS was separate from the work search thing.

0 coins

Adjudication hold on three weeks of my claim was what made me finally try to get someone on the phone about a work search question. EDD's hold times were brutal every morning I tried, so I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up on the line with a live EDD agent. They have a video showing how reaching a live person at EDD works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my account and told me which specific weeks were flagged and why — turned out a DE 238 had been issued and I hadn't updated my work search activities in my certifications to match. Once I knew exactly what the hold was about I could certify correctly going forward and the weeks processed.

0 coins

So the 238 actually can affect whether weeks get paid or put on hold? That's what I was afraid of. Were your weeks eventually released once you fixed the certifications?

0 coins

Yeah they processed after I certified correctly for the next period. The agent said the weeks before the 238 date weren't the problem, only the ones after.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything specific in UI Online after the call, or did fixing the certifications take care of it on its own?

0 coins

Is there a chance this notice just means EDD is lifting an exemption that was automatically applied when you first filed? Because my understanding — maybe wrong — is that some people get a short automatic exemption right at the start and then the 238 is basically EDD saying that window is over. That's slightly different from being in a formal program.

0 coins

Not sure I'd call it automatic — EDD decides based on the individual claim circumstances. Some claimants do get an exemption early on, like if they're in union hiring hall status or certain other situations, and the 238 is what formally ends it. It's not really a window that closes on a timer for everyone.

0 coins

That makes sense, so it's claim-specific, not a universal new-claimant grace period. Good to know I had that backwards.

0 coins

Mine definitely wasn't a union thing. I was laid off from a warehouse job. Any idea why EDD would have given me an exemption in the first place if I'm not in any special program?

0 coins

EDD bureaucracy at its finest — sending out notices with form numbers and zero plain-language explanation of what it actually means for your money. I went three weeks thinking my claim was fine and then found out a 238 had been sitting in my mailbox and I'd been certifying wrong the whole time. They should put a giant banner in UI Online when something like this changes.

0 coins

Honestly the UI Online Claim History section is pretty bare on details when stuff like this happens. It just shows Pending and you have no idea if it's the 238 or something else holding things up.

0 coins

Exactly. And calling is a nightmare — I spent two mornings trying before I gave up. The notice itself should spell out clearly what you need to do differently, not just that something changed.

0 coins

How did you eventually figure out what to do? Did you get through to EDD or did you work it out some other way?

0 coins

I ended up going through the live chat in UI Online — clicked the Help button while I was logged in. Got an agent who explained which weeks I needed to re-certify and what I'd done differently in my answers. Took forever to get a chat slot but it worked.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration and the work search requirement are actually connected but separate things and I want to clear that up because someone asked above. EDD gives most new claimants 21 days from the date on the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work — that's the DE 8405 — to register on CalJOBS and post a resume. Not doing that can stop payments entirely. The work search requirement is about actively applying to jobs and certifying truthfully about it. The 238 specifically deals with that second part, the active job searching obligation, not the CalJOBS registration deadline.

0 coins

Okay that actually clears something up for me. I thought registering on CalJOBS meant I was done and covered. So I still need to be applying to jobs on top of that?

0 coins

Right, CalJOBS registration is kind of the baseline, but EDD's expectation when you're not exempt is that you're actively out there applying. When you certify, you're answering questions about whether you looked for work that period.

0 coins

Mine asked every two weeks if I was looking for work and I always said yes because I was applying places — did I answer that correctly even before I got the 238?

0 coins

If you were genuinely applying to jobs and said yes, that sounds like you certified honestly, which is what matters. The 238 changing your status wouldn't make your past honest answers wrong.

0 coins

Something I'm wondering after reading the original post — did the 238 come with any other paperwork, or was it just the one page? My claim had a situation where the notice came with a separate sheet that actually explained the reason for the change and what date it took effect. If there's a second page or attachment, that might have the specifics.

0 coins

Pulling it out again — there is a second page actually. It has a date on it that's about two weeks ago. So does the work search requirement start from that date, or from when I actually received it?

0 coins

The date on the notice is what EDD goes by — that's when the change took effect for your claim. If there's a gap between that date and when you got it in the mail, it might be worth contacting EDD to explain that since it could affect how they look at your certifications in between.

0 coins

I had a mail delay situation with an EDD notice once and sent a message through UI Online explaining it. They noted it on the account. Not saying it fixes everything but it's worth having it on record.

0 coins

Doesn't the 238 also sometimes come after a phone interview? My sister got one and she hadn't had any interview — I always assumed EDD had to talk to you before they changed your work search status. Am I mixing something up?

0 coins

The phone interview EDD schedules is for eligibility questions — like if you quit or were fired and there's something to look into. The 238 is an administrative notice about your work search requirement status and doesn't necessarily come with an interview. They're separate processes.

0 coins

Ohh okay so I was completely mixing those two things up. My sister's situation must have been different then. Thanks for straightening that out.

0 coins

Whenever I get EDD mail I don't understand, the first thing I do is log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and check my Claim History to see if anything changed on the account side. Sometimes a notice like the 238 shows up in the mail before the account even reflects the change. If your Claim History shows weeks as Pending that weren't before, that's a signal the work search requirement change is affecting payments and you'd want to get to EDD sooner rather than later.

0 coins

Just checked and my most recent two weeks are showing Pending now. They weren't when I last looked before the notice came. So this is probably related?

0 coins

Almost certainly connected. Pending after a 238 usually means EDD is waiting to see how you certify under the new requirement, or there's something to verify. Keep certifying honestly and completely for each period — skipping certifications while Pending just makes things harder to untangle later.

0 coins

The Pending status is so stressful when you don't know why it's there. I had it for almost three weeks on two separate weeks and kept checking every day waiting for it to flip.

0 coins

Are people generally expected to keep a log of their job applications, or is EDD just taking your word for it when you certify? I've heard different things and it makes me nervous. I've been keeping a spreadsheet but I'm not sure if that's overkill or exactly what they want.

0 coins

Keeping a record of where you applied is genuinely a smart habit — if EDD ever audits your work search, having dates, company names and what you applied for makes it easy to show you were actually looking. EDD doesn't tell you to keep a specific format, but having something is better than nothing.

0 coins

Okay so not overkill. Spreadsheet stays. I'll keep adding to it every time I apply somewhere.

0 coins

Does EDD actually audit work search records or is it just a theoretical thing? I've been on UI for nine weeks and nobody's asked me for anything.

0 coins

EDD can ask — it doesn't happen to everyone but it does happen. If they ever request verification of your work search activities you'll want something to show them. Nine weeks and no audit is normal, it doesn't mean they never will.

0 coins

Pension from my previous employer overlapping with my UI claim had me completely lost on what to report, and I finally got on with an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask about it. The agent looked at my account and said two weeks were pending because of a discrepancy in what I'd reported. I asked about the 238 that was also sitting in my file and they confirmed it was about the work search exemption ending, completely separate from the pension reporting issue. Having both things explained in one call was a huge relief — I knew which problem I actually needed to fix first.

0 coins

So one call can cover multiple issues on your account? I have both the pending weeks and the 238 question and I've been afraid I'd need to call twice.

0 coins

The agent walked through the whole account with me. Having both questions written down before the call meant we didn't have to circle back.

0 coins

DE 1101I my claim was filed on turned out to have a wage entry that was slightly off, and after weeks of pending status I used Claimyr and got through to an agent who spotted the error immediately. Having someone actually look at the account makes such a difference versus just reading the UI Online screens yourself.

0 coins

My biggest confusion when I got EDD mail I didn't understand was whether I was supposed to respond to it or just change my behavior. Some notices want you to do something specific — fill out a form, verify something — and some are just informational. The 238, from what I went through, is usually informational: EDD is telling you what changed, not asking you to send anything back. But if the notice has a checkbox or response section, don't ignore it.

0 coins

Mine doesn't seem to have anything to fill out or send back. So I think I just need to adjust how I certify going forward?

0 coins

That tracks with how mine worked. The change just becomes part of your certification answers from the effective date on the notice. Answer honestly about your job searching each period and you should be fine.

0 coins

This is a good point about checking for response sections. I almost missed a response request on a different EDD notice because I assumed they were all informational.

0 coins

Has anyone had an experience where EDD sent a 238 that turned out to be a mistake? My neighbor is convinced his exemption shouldn't have ended when it did because he's still in an approved situation, but he's not sure how to dispute it.

0 coins

If the exemption ending was a mistake, the right move is to contact EDD directly and explain the situation — through the UI Online message option or by phone. If EDD issues a Notice of Determination about it, there's a 30-day window to appeal in writing using the DE 1000M form or a letter sent to the address on the notice.

0 coins

Does his CalJOBS profile status matter here, or is that a separate issue from the 238 situation?

0 coins

CalJOBS is separate — the 238 is about the work search certification requirement, not the CalJOBS registration. If his approved situation is documented somewhere EDD has access to, that's what they'd need to see to correct the exemption status.

0 coins

Something I keep wondering about with work search requirements — if your industry is really specific and there just aren't many jobs to apply to in a given two-week period, does that cause problems? Like what if you're applying to everything relevant but it's a niche field?

0 coins

EDD asks whether you looked for work, and you certify based on what you actually did. If you're genuinely searching in your field and applying to what's available, you answer honestly. EDD's pages don't set a specific number of contacts you have to make per period.

0 coins

Okay that's actually reassuring. I was worried there was some minimum number I was supposed to hit that I didn't know about.

0 coins

I had that exact fear too. I've been applying to everything remotely relevant just to feel covered but I guess honest is what actually counts.

0 coins

Weekly benefit amount on my DE 429Z wasn't matching what I expected based on my wages, and I had a 238 show up around the same time, so I wasn't sure if the two things were connected. Used Claimyr to get to an EDD agent and they confirmed the 238 was just about work search status — totally unrelated to the payment amount. The agent explained my base period quarters and why the weekly amount came out the way it did, which answered something I'd been confused about for weeks.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about whether the 238 could affect the weekly benefit amount. Good to know those are separate things — one less thing to worry about.

0 coins

The base period wage calculation is one of those things that makes sense once someone explains it but is really hard to figure out from the DE 429Z alone.

0 coins

Reading through this whole thread helped me understand something I'd been fuzzy on — the work search exemption and the CalJOBS requirement really are two separate tracks. I had convinced myself they were the same thing and was more relaxed than I should have been about actually applying to jobs.

0 coins

Exact same boat. I thought posting my resume on CalJOBS basically counted as work searching and I was done. Definitely rechecking my certifications now.

0 coins

CalJOBS is the registration piece and the resume posting — it's the foundation EDD sets up for you. The work search part is the ongoing applying and certifying honestly about it every two weeks. Both matter and both can affect payments if they're not done.

0 coins

For anyone still confused about the actual certification mechanics after a 238: when you certify through EDD Tele-Cert or UI Online, you're answering questions about the two-week period you're certifying for. After the 238 effective date, your answers about work search need to reflect that you're actively looking. The question is basically asking if you looked for work — answer it honestly for each day in that period.

0 coins

The two-week periods are what I certify through UI Online — so I'd answer the work search questions for whatever days in that period fall after the 238 date, right? Not just for the whole period like nothing changed?

0 coins

Honestly, if the 238 date falls mid-period, it's worth calling EDD to ask how they want you to handle that specific certification, rather than guessing. Mid-period changes can get complicated and you want your certifications to be accurate.

0 coins

Mid-period changes were the part that tripped me up on a different notice situation. Getting EDD's direct answer on how to handle it saved me a correction hassle later.

0 coins

Just want to confirm something for my own situation reading this thread — the 238 is a notice EDD sends, not something you request or fill out yourself, right? I keep second-guessing whether I'm supposed to have submitted something and that's why mine is in a weird state.

0 coins

EDD generates and sends the 238, it's not something you apply for or fill out yourself. You receive it, understand what changed, and adjust your certifications from the effective date. If your claim is in a weird state, that's more likely a separate issue to look into with EDD directly.

0 coins

Okay that takes one worry off my list. I was spiraling a little thinking I'd missed a step.

0 coins

The number of things I convinced myself I'd missed on my own claim before I finally read the actual notices carefully — it's a lot. Sometimes the answer really is just adjust what you're doing going forward.

0 coins

Worth mentioning — if the 238 effective date is in the past and you've already certified for weeks after that date without accounting for the work search requirement, it's not too late to reach out to EDD and explain. Contacting them proactively through a UI Online message is better than waiting to see if something gets flagged. EDD's contact form is also an option through Ask EDD on their site.

0 coins

I certified once since the date on the notice. I answered yes to looking for work because I was applying places — does that mean I certified correctly even if I didn't know about the 238 yet?

0 coins

If you were actually applying to jobs and you answered yes, that's an honest certification. The 238 didn't change whether you were looking — it changed what EDD expects going forward. An honest yes is an honest yes.

0 coins

This is the part that confuses me — does EDD know you didn't know about the notice yet, or do they just see the certification answers without context?

0 coins

EDD sees your certification answers and the dates. If your honest answers match the work search requirement for the period, you're in the clear. If there's ever a question, that's when having a record of where you applied helps show your answers were accurate.

0 coins

Final question from me — once the work search exemption is fully lifted per the 238, is there any situation where it could come back? Like if I enrolled in an EDD-approved class or training program, would I get a new exemption notice?

0 coins

EDD's California Training Benefits program lets someone in approved training keep collecting without looking for work. If you get into something EDD approves under that program, the work search requirement can be waived for that period. EDD would issue a new notice about it. That's different from just taking a class on your own — it has to be EDD-approved.

0 coins

How do you even get EDD to approve training? Is that something you apply for through UI Online?

0 coins

You'd want to contact EDD about it before you enroll if you're thinking about it — there are specific requirements and EDD has to approve the training in advance for the exemption to apply. It's worth asking them directly about the California Training Benefits program for your specific situation.

0 coins

The timing matters a lot with the training exemption — there's a window in your claim when you can apply for it, specifically before week 16 of benefits. Missing that window means you can't get the extra weeks that come with it, so don't wait if that's something you're considering.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure