Back to California Unemployment

Olivia Clark

Unemployment overpayment after quitting job during covid - how to appeal in California EDD

Got hit with a Notice of Overpayment out of nowhere for $4,100 from claims I filed back when I quit my restaurant job. The notice says I wasn't eligible for the weeks I collected and they want it back. Here's the thing - I reported everything honestly when I certified, every single week. I listed the exact reason I quit (the place I worked was operating in conditions I genuinely couldn't work in anymore) and I never hid anything. Now it's years later and EDD is saying I owe this money back. I've been trying to understand what my options even are. The notice came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) but I don't know if I should appeal or ask for a waiver or both. The mailing date on the notice was about two weeks ago so I know I'm within the 30-day window still. I have all my old pay stubs and I took screenshots of my certifications back then showing what I reported. Does anyone know how to actually fight one of these or at least reduce what I owe? Really stressed out about this.

Overpayment notice showing $3,800 was what I woke up to about six months ago, so I know exactly how that gut-drop feeling hits. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live EDD agent on the phone without spending my entire day redialing. The video on their site about reaching a live person at EDD - https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 - made it clear what I'd actually be doing. When I got through, I asked the agent whether the overpayment on my claim was flagged as fraud or non-fraud, because that changes everything about your options. She pulled up my account and confirmed it showed as non-fraud, which meant I could file the DE 1446UI waiver request alongside my appeal. She also told me the 30-day window ran from the mailing date printed on the notice itself, not the day I received it, so I should count from that date. I sent the appeal letter and the waiver request the same day.

0 coins

The mailing date detail is something I almost missed too. My notice sat in my mailbox for four days before I picked it up and I was terrified I'd lost time.

0 coins

Fraud vs. non-fraud is exactly what I needed to know to ask. I'm going to call and get that confirmed before I do anything else. Thank you for laying that out so specifically.

0 coins

DE 1446UI is the waiver form - worth writing that down. A lot of people don't know that form exists and just pay without asking.

0 coins

Two things you should send at the same time, and here's why asking EDD which category your overpayment falls under matters so much: if it's non-fraud, you have a shot at a waiver on top of the appeal. The question to put to EDD is literally 'is this overpayment coded as fraud or non-fraud on my account.' Once you know that, your path is clearer. The Appeal Form DE 1000M goes to the address printed on the Notice of Overpayment itself - don't mail it anywhere else. In your appeal letter, write out the specific weeks and what you reported during each certification. If you have screenshots or pay stubs, reference them and attach copies. For the waiver, the DE 1446UI form asks you to show the overpayment wasn't your fault and that paying it back would cause extraordinary hardship. EDD weighs both together.

0 coins

Sending both at the same time - does EDD process them separately or does one pause the other?

0 coins

They run on separate tracks. The appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board if EDD doesn't reverse it first. The waiver is EDD's own review. You want both moving at the same time because if the appeal doesn't succeed the waiver is still alive.

0 coins

Mailing both to the address on the notice is right. I made the mistake of mailing mine to a general EDD address and it caused a delay.

0 coins

Keep certifying while all this is happening - I want to flag this because people stop and then lose weeks they can't recover. If your benefit year is still open and you're still eligible for any weeks, certified weeks are the only ones EDD can pay if the appeal goes your way. Weeks you didn't certify during the appeal period are just gone.

0 coins

My benefit year ended a while ago so certifying isn't the issue anymore, but this is good for anyone else reading who's mid-claim.

0 coins

Genuinely did not know this. Stopped certifying when I got my denial letter and lost about five weeks because of it. Wish someone had told me earlier.

0 coins

It's one of those things EDD doesn't make obvious. The rule is that back weeks can only be paid if they were certified, so stopping during an appeal basically forfeits them.

0 coins

The difference between appealing and requesting a waiver trips a lot of people up. An appeal says the overpayment determination was wrong - you're contesting whether you owed the money at all. A waiver says okay maybe I was overpaid but paying it back would be a real hardship and it wasn't my fault. You can and probably should do both simultaneously. For the waiver specifically, the question EDD will ask you to answer is whether repaying would be an extraordinary hardship - that means documenting your current income, expenses, and financial situation honestly.

0 coins

My denial came as a DE 1080CZ and I genuinely thought that was just about eligibility, not that it could also trigger an overpayment demand later. The system is confusing.

0 coins

DE 1080CZ is the Notice of Determination - that's the letter EDD sends when it decides you weren't eligible. When they decide that for past weeks you already collected, it creates the overpayment. The overpayment notice is a separate document that follows from that decision.

0 coins

So the DE 1080CZ came first and the overpayment notice is downstream of that decision. That helps me understand the chain of events a lot better.

0 coins

What documentation actually helped my waiver get approved was a simple one-page letter explaining my financial situation at the time I collected benefits and my situation now. I listed monthly income versus monthly expenses and showed I had basically nothing left over. EDD wants to see that paying $4,100 back would cause real hardship, not just be inconvenient.

0 coins

A one-page letter with income and expenses - that's concrete. Did you attach bank statements or just the letter?

0 coins

I attached two months of bank statements and a list of fixed monthly bills. Kept it simple and factual. No drama, just numbers.

0 coins

Numbers over narrative is good advice. I wrote a long emotional appeal once and the reviewer seemed to care way more about the actual dollar figures.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date goes fast so the first thing to do is get that DE 1000M in the mail, even if it's just a basic letter saying you disagree and you're requesting a hearing. You can supplement with documentation later. A bare-bones appeal filed on time beats a detailed appeal filed on day 32 every time.

0 coins

File something now and add detail later - that's the move. I've been stressing about getting every document perfect before sending anything.

0 coins

Exactly. The administrative law judge at the CUIAB hearing is where you present your full case anyway. The initial appeal just preserves your right to that hearing.

0 coins

Appeals that miss the 30-day window need a written explanation for why they're late, and EDD doesn't have to accept that reason. I was stuck with a late-appeal situation on a different claim and ended up using Claimyr to get through to EDD and ask an agent what my options were. She looked at my account and told me which weeks were still within the window and which ones weren't, so I knew exactly what to include. Filed the same afternoon.

0 coins

Supplementing after the initial filing is standard. The Notice of Hearing comes at least 10 days before the hearing date and you use that time to organize everything.

0 coins

An administrative law judge hearing is way less scary than it sounds. You're testifying under oath but you can represent yourself - no lawyer required. I went through a CUIAB hearing on a different issue and the judge genuinely read the documents I submitted beforehand. Bring organized copies of everything: the notice, your certifications, any pay stubs, the appeal letter you sent.

0 coins

Can anyone attend with me for support or is it just me and the judge?

0 coins

You can have anyone represent you at the hearing - yourself, a union rep if that applies, or an attorney. The judge's decision comes in writing by mail after.

0 coins

I had a union rep attend mine and it made a big difference having someone who knew the process. If you have access to that it's worth asking.

0 coins

Something worth asking EDD directly: whether the original determination that created this overpayment was based on information from your former employer or on something in your certifications. If the employer submitted information that contradicts what you reported, you'll want to know exactly what they said so you can address it in your appeal.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about the employer's side of this at all. EDD does contact them when someone quits, right?

0 coins

When someone quits, EDD interviews both sides - you and the employer - to decide if there was good cause for leaving. If the employer gave a different account of why you left, that could be what triggered the determination against you. Your appeal is the place to tell your side clearly.

0 coins

This happened to me. My former employer told EDD I quit without notice and I had documentation showing I gave two weeks. That documentation was what flipped the determination on appeal.

0 coins

Penalty question since you mentioned the amount: a non-fraud overpayment has no penalty on top of the principal. A fraud finding adds 30 percent and can bring a false statement disqualification of anywhere from 2 to 23 weeks. So confirming which one yours is isn't just academic - it changes the total you're facing and what happens to future benefits if you file again someday.

0 coins

30 percent penalty on top of the balance would make this significantly worse. Really need to get that fraud vs. non-fraud question answered.

0 coins

Right, and EDD can also collect from future UI payments, state tax refunds, or lottery winnings if the balance goes unpaid. Knowing your category tells you exactly what you're dealing with.

0 coins

They can take it from future disability and PFL payments too if I remember right. EDD has a lot of ways to collect.

0 coins

That's correct per EDD's overpayment rules - they can collect from unemployment, disability, Paid Family Leave, state tax refunds, state lottery. Worth knowing the full picture.

0 coins

The question about whether your quit had good cause is what the whole eligibility determination probably turned on. EDD's standard is that if you quit, you need to show you had a good reason. What counts as good reason is EDD's call after hearing from both you and your employer. Your appeal is basically a second chance to make that case in front of a judge with all your documentation.

0 coins

The conditions I was working in felt like a genuinely compelling reason but I never got to explain it beyond the certification questions. The hearing is where I'd actually be able to lay that out?

0 coins

Exactly - the certification process doesn't give you space to explain context. The hearing in front of the administrative law judge is where you tell the full story and the judge can ask questions. Put together a clear timeline of what the conditions were and when you raised concerns before quitting if you did.

0 coins

Any written record from that time is gold - texts, emails, anything that shows you tried to address the issue before leaving.

0 coins

DE 1101CZ notification to your employer is something a lot of claimants don't realize happened - EDD mailed your former employer when you first filed your claim and gave them 10 days to respond. Whatever your employer said in that response may be in EDD's file. At the hearing you can ask the judge what information EDD relied on. I had a totally different situation - my claim was stuck because a week from earlier in the year showed as pending and I couldn't figure out why. Used Claimyr and got on the phone with an EDD rep who found that one week hadn't been certified correctly on my end. That was fixable once I knew what it was.

0 coins

EDD has a file on each claim with what the employer submitted? Can I request to see that before the hearing?

0 coins

The Notice of Hearing that comes before the CUIAB hearing usually comes with the documents EDD has submitted. That's when you'd see what the employer actually said. Some people request documents earlier through Ask EDD but the official packet comes with the hearing notice.

0 coins

Getting the hearing packet early enough to actually review it matters. 10 days before sounds like enough time but if you've never read EDD's claim language before it takes a while to parse.

0 coins

Hardship documentation for the DE 1446UI waiver: EDD looks at whether repaying would cause extraordinary hardship and whether the overpayment was not your fault and not fraud. For 'not your fault' - if you reported everything accurately in your certifications and the overpayment came from EDD's eligibility determination rather than from you misreporting wages or hours, that's the argument to make. Your screenshots of what you certified support that.

0 coins

I've got screenshots and I kept a folder of all my certification confirmations from back then, almost like I sensed this might come up someday.

0 coins

That folder might be your most valuable asset here. Certification records showing you reported accurately, combined with pay stubs, build the 'not my fault' argument clearly. Attach them to both the appeal and the waiver.

0 coins

EDD can also set up a repayment plan if the waiver doesn't go through - worth knowing that the full $4,100 doesn't necessarily have to arrive in one lump. I'd still pursue the appeal and waiver first obviously but a repayment plan is an option if neither succeeds.

0 coins

Repayment plans aren't something the notice mentioned at all. Good to know that's on the table.

0 coins

The notice focuses on the amount owed and your appeal rights - it doesn't advertise all your options. Calling EDD directly is usually how people find out about repayment arrangements.

0 coins

My sister's friend went through this and ended up on a repayment plan after the waiver was partially approved. So sometimes you end up with a reduced balance and then a plan on what's left.

0 coins

Something I haven't seen mentioned: file the appeal by certified mail with return receipt. It costs a few dollars at the post office but you have proof of the mailing date and proof EDD received it. In an administrative process where the 30-day deadline is a hard cutoff, having that green card come back to you is worth it.

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt - writing that down right now. I was just going to drop it in a regular mailbox.

0 coins

The mailing date on your certified mail receipt is what matters for the deadline, not the date EDD stamps it received. So even if it takes a few days to arrive you're protected as long as you sent it within 30 days.

0 coins

Honestly the hardest part of my own overpayment appeal was just keeping track of which document was which. I made a simple spreadsheet: document name, date I sent it, date EDD received it (from the return receipt), and any reference number. When EDD sent follow-up requests I could answer immediately instead of hunting through a pile of mail.

0 coins

A spreadsheet for tracking - this is the kind of practical detail that actually makes the process manageable. I'm going to do this.

0 coins

Add a column for deadlines too. The appeal has a 30-day clock from the notice. Any follow-up response EDD requests will have its own deadline. Missing those can reset you back to square one.

0 coins

Organization saved me too. Had three separate EDD matters going at once at one point and without a tracking system I would have lost something.

0 coins

For the CUIAB hearing itself: the Notice of Hearing comes at least 10 days before and it's under oath, but you're not in a courtroom. It's usually a phone hearing these days. The administrative law judge reads the file, hears your testimony, and may ask the employer's representative questions if they attend. You can ask questions too. It's more of an interview than a trial.

0 coins

Phone hearing is way less intimidating than I was picturing. I kept imagining a courtroom.

0 coins

It's fairly conversational compared to what people expect. Clear and organized beats legal language every time in my experience. Judges respond to 'here's exactly what I reported and here's the documentation' better than anything complicated.

0 coins

Arrived at my phone hearing with every document printed and tabbed and was able to reference anything the judge asked about instantly. That prep matters.

0 coins

Don't forget taxes - EDD mails Form 1099G each January for benefits paid, and it's also in UI Online under Payments then Form 1099G. If the overpayment gets partially or fully reversed, the tax picture changes. Might be worth talking to a tax person if the amount is significant, since you may have already paid federal income tax on benefits you're now being told you shouldn't have received.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about taxes at all. If I win the appeal and the overpayment gets reversed, do I somehow get that tax back?

0 coins

That question is beyond EDD's lane - it's an IRS question about how to handle repaid income. A tax professional could tell you if there's a deduction or credit for repaid benefits in the year you repay them. Worth asking.

0 coins

Came here to say the same thing about taxes. The 1099G only shows what was paid, not whether it was later disputed. It gets complicated if the determination reverses.

0 coins

Every piece of correspondence you get from EDD during this process, photograph it the day it arrives with your phone. Timestamps, envelopes, everything. I went through an overpayment dispute that dragged on and at one point EDD claimed they had mailed me something I never received. Having photos of every letter I actually got let me show exactly what arrived and when.

0 coins

Photographing mail I hadn't even thought of that. This whole thread has been incredibly practical.

0 coins

The other thing is keep the envelopes. The postmark date matters sometimes and the envelope proves it.

0 coins

Physical postmarks alongside certified mail receipts create a solid paper trail. EDD moves a lot of mail and things get lost.

0 coins

One more thing worth confirming: if you disagree with what comes out of the CUIAB hearing, there's a second-level appeal to the CUIAB board itself. And beyond that there are court options, though by then most people have either settled or moved on. The point is the first appeal isn't your last chance if you have a solid case.

0 coins

Knowing there's a second level if the first hearing doesn't go well makes me feel less like this is all-or-nothing.

0 coins

The judge's written decision comes by mail after the hearing. Read it carefully - if you want to go to the second level you'd appeal that decision. It has its own deadline.

0 coins

Second-level CUIAB appeals are less common but they exist for a reason. The first hearing is where most cases get resolved one way or another though.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure