Back to California Unemployment

Andre Laurent

Unemployment claim wages showing zero wrong - cancel claim wait for recomputation or keep it?

Filed my California EDD claim about two weeks ago after getting laid off from a warehouse job I'd held for almost three years. The DE 429Z came in the mail this week and my jaw dropped - the weekly benefit amount listed is based on what looks like zero or near-zero wages, which makes absolutely no sense. I earned solid wages the whole time I was there, nothing fancy but definitely not zero. My best quarter was probably around $14,000 in gross earnings. So now I'm staring at this award notice showing a weekly amount that's barely in the double digits when I should be getting something much closer to the $450 maximum. I've seen a few different pieces of advice floating around and I genuinely don't know which direction to go. Some people say cancel the claim entirely, let EDD recompute from scratch, and refile. Others say that's a terrible idea and you should just appeal the award notice directly without touching the claim. What's the actual right move here when your wages are showing zero or completely wrong on the award notice? Has anyone dealt with an unemployment claim wages showing zero wrong situation and actually fixed it? Do I cancel claim, wait for recomputation, or just appeal the existing one?

Wages on my own DE 429Z came in dramatically low last spring - my highest quarter showed about $400 total when I'd actually earned close to $13,500 that quarter at a logistics company. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent after I'd spent days getting nowhere through the regular phone line. The agent pulled up my claim and saw immediately that my employer had not yet responded to EDD's wage request, so the system had defaulted to essentially placeholder figures. She told me to appeal the DE 429Z in writing within 30 days of its mailing date and to keep certifying in the meantime, because those weeks would be paid back once EDD corrected the wage information. She also flagged that if EDD still hadn't gotten my employer's wage records by a certain point, I might want to send in my own pay stubs to speed things up. Here's the video EDD themselves made about reaching a live person at the office by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I sent in three months of pay stubs with my appeal letter and the corrected weekly amount came through about three weeks later.

0 coins

Defaulted to placeholder figures - that's exactly what this feels like. So your employer just hadn't responded yet and the system filled in zeros? That's a terrifying design. Did you send the pay stubs to the same address as the appeal letter?

0 coins

Pay stubs went with the appeal letter to the address printed on the DE 429Z itself. Keep everything together so it doesn't get separated in their system.

0 coins

Useful to know employers can be the bottleneck here and not just EDD. I always assumed EDD had access to all wage data automatically.

0 coins

EDD pulls wage records from the Employment Development Department's tax files, but those only get updated after employers file their quarterly payroll taxes. If your last job is recent enough that the most current quarter hasn't been reported yet, the system may be working off older or incomplete records - hence the zeros.

0 coins

What would I do first in your position? File a written appeal of the DE 429Z before anything else. The appeal window is 30 calendar days from the mailing date printed on that notice - not the day you received it, the date it shows on the document itself. If that window closes without an appeal, your options get a lot harder. Canceling and refiling starts your benefit year over from the new application date, which means you lose all the weeks between your original filing and the refile - weeks that may have been certifiable. Those weeks are gone if you cancel. With an appeal, you keep the original filing date, keep those weeks, and fight the wage discrepancy directly. Send your appeal with copies of your pay stubs and any W-2 or earnings statements you have.

0 coins

Lost weeks from canceling - I hadn't even thought about that. My claim date is already locked in from two weeks ago and I'd lose that if I started over. That alone makes me want to stay away from the cancel option.

0 coins

Had the same instinct to just cancel and refile, thought it would be cleaner. Really glad someone talked me out of it on a previous thread because those early weeks would have been gone forever.

0 coins

Is the 30 days from the postmark or from when you open the envelope? Because mine sat in a pile for a few days before I looked at it.

0 coins

The mailing date printed on the DE 429Z is what counts, not your postmark and not when you opened it. If you are unsure, count back from today to that date and don't wait another day before mailing your appeal.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact scenario and want to add one thing people skip: gather your pay stubs before you even sit down to write the appeal letter. For me the strongest evidence was the pay stubs combined with my W-2 from that employer. EDD needs to see what you actually earned in each quarter of your base period - roughly the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you filed. If your best earnings happened to fall in a quarter that's just outside that window, the standard base period might be legitimately showing lower wages, not a system error. Worth double-checking your quarters before assuming it's purely a data problem.

0 coins

Base period quarters - should I be calculating those myself? I've been assuming the problem is a data error but you're making me think I should actually verify which quarters EDD is looking at.

0 coins

Pull up a calendar and count backward from when you filed. Figure out which four quarters would make up your standard base period and then look at what you actually earned in each of those quarters. If your highest earnings were in the most recent completed quarter, they might not be in the standard base period at all.

0 coins

Learned this the hard way myself. My biggest earning quarter was just barely outside the standard base period and I spent weeks convinced EDD had made an error when the math was actually correct.

0 coins

Does EDD automatically use the alternate base period if the standard one comes out low, or do you have to request it?

0 coins

EDD switches to the alternate base period on its own if your wages under the standard base period aren't enough to establish a valid claim. But if the standard base period already gives you a valid claim - even a tiny one - EDD uses it and doesn't switch, even if the alternate period would give you more money. You can't request the alternate period just to get a higher weekly amount.

0 coins

ZERO wages showing on a California EDD claim is wild and I'm sorry you're dealing with this. Mine showed something similar and I called literally 47 times in one week before getting through. The hold times are absolutely brutal. Whatever path you choose - appeal vs cancel - at least get a human on the phone first so you know what EDD actually has in their system before you do anything permanent.

0 coins

47 calls in a week - that's genuinely alarming. I've been trying every morning and getting either a busy signal or the 'call volume too high' message. At what point did you finally get through?

0 coins

Random Tuesday around 8:05 in the morning was when I finally made it. No magic trick, just kept going until one connected.

0 coins

The early morning timing does seem to help but it's still not reliable at all. Some days I try at 8:01 and still get cut off.

0 coins

Something I want to flag before you file your appeal: make sure you understand what 'wages showing zero' actually means in your specific situation. There are at least three different things it could be. First, employer hasn't reported your wages yet. Second, EDD is looking at the wrong quarters where you genuinely didn't earn much. Third, there's an identity or employer match issue in their system where your wages didn't link to your Social Security number correctly. Each of those has a slightly different fix, and knowing which one you're dealing with before you write your appeal letter will help you frame it correctly.

0 coins

Three different root causes and I don't know which one applies to me. That's what's making this so hard - I don't know what I don't know. How would I even figure out which scenario I'm in without talking to someone at EDD?

0 coins

Your pay stubs will tell you a lot. If your stubs clearly show earnings that match the quarters EDD should be looking at, then it's almost certainly scenarios one or three - either the employer hasn't reported yet or there's a wage-matching problem. If your stubs show your best earnings were in a different period than EDD's base period covers, it might be scenario two.

0 coins

The identity and wage-match issue is more common than people realize. Had a coworker whose hyphenated last name wasn't matching between her employer's payroll system and what EDD had on file, which caused her wages to show incorrectly.

0 coins

Canceling a claim and waiting for recomputation feels logical on the surface but I can't think of a situation where it's actually the better move versus appealing. When you cancel, you're starting fresh with a new filing week. That week will be your new claim start, and all the weeks you could have been certifying under the original claim are simply gone. An appeal on the other hand preserves everything. File the appeal, keep certifying every two weeks like normal, attach your wage documentation, and let EDD sort out the correction.

0 coins

Does keeping up with certifications during an appeal actually matter? Thought you had to wait until the appeal was resolved before you could get paid.

0 coins

Certifying during the appeal is crucial - if EDD ultimately corrects your weekly amount and pays you, they can only pay weeks that were actually certified. Skip certifying while you wait and those weeks are unrecoverable.

0 coins

This is 100% right. Went through an overpayment appeal situation and my attorney specifically told me to never stop certifying. Stopping is basically forfeiting those weeks.

0 coins

Had a DE 429Z that showed my wages from only one of my two jobs last year, which tanked my weekly amount significantly. An EDD agent I spoke with through Claimyr told me the second employer simply hadn't appeared in the wage records yet and that I should include my pay stubs from both employers in my appeal. My appeal letter ended up being pretty straightforward - just explained the discrepancy, listed what I actually earned per quarter at each job, and attached everything. The corrected determination came about a month later at a much higher weekly amount.

0 coins

Both jobs - I'm glad you brought this up. I only had the one employer but I can imagine how confusing it would be if you had two and one just didn't show. Did EDD ask you for anything else after you submitted the appeal?

0 coins

They didn't reach back out before sending the corrected Notice of Determination. All the information must have been enough from what I sent initially.

0 coins

My sister had a similar thing - two part-time jobs and only one showed on her award notice. She didn't realize she could appeal it and just accepted the lower amount. Really wish she'd seen a thread like this before that window closed.

0 coins

The appeal letter itself doesn't need to be complicated. For what it's worth, here's roughly what should be in it: your name, Social Security number, claim ID, the mailing date on the DE 429Z, a clear statement that you're appealing the wage calculation, what your actual earnings were per quarter, and a list of what you're attaching. Mail it to the address on the notice. Keep a copy of everything you send, and if you can send it certified mail, do that so you have proof of the date it arrived.

0 coins

Certified mail for the proof of date - is that actually necessary or just extra caution? I want to do this right but also don't want to overthink it.

0 coins

Not required, just smart. If there's ever a question about whether you appealed within 30 days, the certified mail receipt is clean proof. For something this important I'd spend the few dollars.

0 coins

Can you submit the appeal through UI Online instead of mailing it, or does it have to be physical mail?

0 coins

The appeal goes to the address on your DE 429Z, which is typically paper mail. You can send EDD a message through your UI Online account to flag the wage issue, but that message isn't a formal appeal - the written appeal sent to that address is what starts the official process.

0 coins

Saw someone in another forum suggest just canceling and filing again after getting the tax situation 'cleaned up' and I really hope nobody does that based on bad advice. The appeal process exists exactly for situations like this - wages wrong on a California EDD claim. Canceling when you have a valid appeal option is almost always the wrong call.

0 coins

What counts as 'cleaned up' in that context anyway? Sounds like whoever gave that advice was guessing.

0 coins

Had the same question. I think they meant waiting for employer wage records to be formally filed with EDD, but even that logic falls apart because an appeal accomplishes the same thing without throwing away your original filing date.

0 coins

The certification schedule also has real implications here. Had a wage discrepancy situation and used Claimyr to get through to EDD - the agent confirmed I had certified correctly for all my weeks up to that point and that those weeks were protected during the appeal review. That detail mattered because I was about to stop certifying while I waited, which apparently would have been a costly mistake.

0 coins

Stopping certifications during an appeal is apparently something a lot of people do by mistake. Good to hear that confirmed from an actual EDD agent.

0 coins

Not to pile on the 'don't cancel' side but I'll add that I work adjacent to HR and have seen this from the employer side too. When a company hasn't filed their quarterly payroll taxes yet - which happens especially with smaller employers - EDD literally has no wage data to put in the system. It doesn't mean EDD thinks you didn't work there. It means the employer's records haven't hit EDD's database yet. An appeal with your own pay stubs essentially fills in that missing data while EDD waits for the employer's official filing.

0 coins

HR perspective is really helpful here. So EDD isn't 'wrong' in the sense of making an error, they just don't have the data yet? That makes the appeal process make a lot more sense.

0 coins

Exactly - think of it less as EDD made a mistake and more as EDD is using the most current data they have, which in some cases hasn't come in from the employer yet. Your appeal is the mechanism to give them what they're missing.

0 coins

Framing it that way is so much more useful than the 'EDD messed up' narrative I had in my head. Probably would have been less frustrated going into the process if I'd understood that earlier.

0 coins

Are there situations where canceling and refiling actually is the right move? Genuinely asking because I keep seeing people say never cancel but surely there are some edge cases?

0 coins

Hard to think of many in a wages-showing-wrong situation. Canceling might theoretically help if you filed in a week that happened to give you a terrible base period and you wanted to push the filing date forward - but that's a very specific scenario and you'd still lose the weeks between the original claim and the refile. For a wage discrepancy that's just a reporting lag or data error, an appeal is almost always cleaner.

0 coins

So basically cancel only if the base period itself is the problem rather than the wage data inside the base period?

0 coins

That's close to right, and even then, changing your filing date would only help if waiting longer would bring a materially better quarter into the base period window. And even then you'd need to really run the numbers. It's a niche case.

0 coins

Had a mental breakdown moment when my DE 429Z showed $73 weekly. I'd been making decent money and was counting on close to $400 a week. Spent three days convinced I'd done something wrong on the application before someone in a different forum explained that the wages probably just hadn't populated yet. The system really should communicate this more clearly because zero wages looks like a catastrophic failure when it might just be a timing issue.

0 coins

$73 weekly when you expected $400 - yes, that is a mental breakdown moment. I completely understand the feeling. It's such a severe drop that you can't help but assume something has gone badly wrong.

0 coins

And then you start questioning every step of the application like did I put in my Social Security number wrong did I pick the wrong employer was my end date off and none of that is usually the problem at all.

0 coins

The system defaulting to whatever partial data it has rather than showing 'wages pending' or something clearer is a real design problem. Even just a flag that said 'employer wage data not yet received' would prevent a lot of panic.

0 coins

My claim had the wrong employer listed, not just wrong wages - a former employer I'd left two years earlier was showing as the wage source. Turned out there was some kind of mix-up in EDD's system between two businesses with similar names. Took two phone calls and a formal appeal to fully sort out. Mentioning it because wage discrepancies sometimes go deeper than just a timing lag.

0 coins

Similar business names causing a mix-up - hadn't even occurred to me as a possibility. Did you have to send anything extra beyond pay stubs to prove which employer the wages actually came from?

0 coins

Sent pay stubs, my W-2 from the correct employer, and also my final pay stub showing the company's full legal name and address. Having the official employer name exactly right seemed to help them match it correctly.

0 coins

The similar business name issue is surprisingly common, especially with franchise locations of the same chain. Worth double-checking that the employer EDD has on file is the actual location you worked at.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later: the UI Online Claim History screen showing 'Pending' on certified weeks while a wage appeal is active is completely normal. EDD holds those payments until the wage question is resolved. Keep certifying, keep those weeks alive, and once EDD issues a corrected wage determination the pending weeks typically process together.

0 coins

Pending weeks processing together once it's resolved - so I might see a lump payment rather than week by week? That's actually useful to know so I don't panic thinking something new is wrong.

0 coins

Yes, the Pending status will stay until EDD sorts the wages, and then multiple weeks can clear at once. Payment information updates daily in UI Online and also through the Tele-Cert line at 1-866-333-4606 if you want to check without logging in.

0 coins

How long does the whole appeal process usually take once you mail everything in?

0 coins

Can't speak to a specific timeline because EDD doesn't publish one and it varies. What I can say is that sending your pay stubs with the original appeal letter, rather than waiting for EDD to request them, tends to avoid extra back-and-forth. The faster EDD has everything they need, the fewer delays there are on their end.

0 coins

Before mailing your appeal, double-check that you've signed and dated the letter and included your Social Security number visibly at the top. EDD gets enormous volumes of paper mail and anything that makes it easy to match your letter to your claim is worth doing. Some people also put their claim ID on each page in case the pages get separated.

0 coins

Claim ID on each page - small thing but that's the kind of practical detail that could prevent a document getting lost in the shuffle. Where do I find my claim ID?

0 coins

Your claim ID should be on the DE 429Z itself, and also on your UI Online account when you log in through myedd.edd.ca.gov.

0 coins

Also put your phone number on the letter in case EDD needs to reach you to clarify something before they process it. Can't hurt to make yourself as easy to contact as possible.

0 coins

Waiting week question that tripped me up when I first dealt with a wage correction: the first week of your claim is unpaid regardless of your weekly benefit amount - that's the waiting week every California EDD claim has. So even after your wages are corrected and your weekly amount goes up, you won't see a payment for that first week. I mistakenly thought that was part of the error and spent extra time trying to get EDD to pay that week before an agent straightened me out. Phoned EDD through Claimyr specifically to ask about that, and the agent walked me through which of my weeks were the waiting week and which were payable.

0 coins

Had been thinking the same thing - wasn't sure if the first week issue was part of the wage calculation problem or a separate thing. Good to know upfront that the waiting week is just how the system works.

0 coins

Assumed the first week showing zero payment meant the entire claim was broken. That is a confusing design for new claimants.

0 coins

The DE 429Z doesn't explain the waiting week very clearly in my experience. The agent I spoke to was the one who finally made it click for me.

0 coins

One more scenario worth flagging: if your wages are wrong because of a genuinely unusual employment situation - like you worked for a staffing agency and the agency's name rather than the client company appears in EDD's records - that can cause confusion in the wage data too. Staffing agency wages sometimes hit EDD's system differently. If that applies to you, include any documentation you have of the agency relationship when you send your appeal.

0 coins

Wasn't a staffing agency situation for me but good to know for anyone else reading. My case was direct employment, so hopefully more straightforward.

0 coins

Staffing agency stuff is so confusing for EDD. Had a friend who worked through three different agencies in one year and his wage records were a complete mess.

0 coins

How long should someone wait after mailing the appeal before following up with EDD to make sure it was received?

0 coins

Phoning EDD to confirm receipt is a reasonable thing to do about two weeks after you mail it, especially if you didn't send certified mail. The phone line is 1-800-300-5616, weekdays 8 to 5. If you did send certified mail, the delivery confirmation is your receipt.

0 coins

Two weeks seems reasonable. I always worry that physical mail just disappears into a void at big agencies like this.

0 coins

You can also send a message through your UI Online account mentioning that you've mailed an appeal and asking EDD to confirm it's been associated with your claim. Not a guarantee anything gets done faster but it creates a record that you followed up.

0 coins

The whole situation with wages showing zero or wildly wrong is one of those things that feels like catastrophic system failure but is actually pretty common. The California EDD system processes an enormous volume of claims and the wage data pipeline has real lag time baked into it. That doesn't make it less stressful when it's your claim and your rent money on the line, but knowing it's a known issue with a known fix does help a little.

0 coins

Knowing it's a known issue with a known fix is genuinely the most helpful framing I've encountered in this whole thread. I still need to get it sorted but at least I'm not wondering if I'm the only person who's ever seen this.

0 coins

It's one of the top reasons people appeal DE 429Z notices. You are definitely not alone in this.

0 coins

The fix being clear - appeal within 30 days, attach your pay stubs, keep certifying - makes it a lot less overwhelming than it looks when you first open that letter.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure