Back to California Unemployment

Sean Flanagan

Unemployment after being fired for social media post misconduct - what does California EDD actually decide?

Got terminated two weeks ago and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with unemployment. My employer fired me over a post I made on my personal Instagram account - nothing illegal, just something they said violated their social media policy. I didn't even tag the company or mention them by name, but HR pulled me in Monday morning and by Friday I had my termination letter citing 'policy violation and conduct unbecoming of an employee.' I filed my California EDD claim the same day I got the letter. UI Online is showing my weeks as Pending and I know there's going to be a phone interview because the DE 4800 notice showed up in my mailbox yesterday with a date and time scheduled. The interview is about two weeks out. Here's what I'm stressed about: my employer is definitely going to fight this. They've already told me they plan to contest the claim. I honestly didn't think a personal social media post on my own time could be classified as misconduct under EDD's definition, but I have no idea how they actually evaluate this stuff. Has anyone here gone through something similar? Did EDD approve your claim after being fired for a social media policy violation? I want to go into this phone interview as prepared as possible.

DE 4800 sitting on my table right now for a different situation - got let go from a warehouse job after my employer claimed I violated their attendance policy, which I genuinely disputed. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) while I was waiting on the interview. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD walked me through what to expect: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. Asked the agent whether my employer's written policy versus what they actually enforced day-to-day would matter in the interview. The agent said the interviewer would ask both sides separately - me and my employer - and EDD would weigh what each said. Told me to have any written documentation of how the policy was actually applied ready for my interview. Got a Notice of Determination about three weeks after.

0 coins

What documentation did the agent say was most useful - emails, the actual policy document, or records of how other employees were treated?

0 coins

The agent specifically said anything in writing from the employer about the policy itself, plus anything showing how it was applied to others. Text messages, emails, written warnings - whatever I had. The more specific to my case the better, they said.

0 coins

DE 4800 date and time is also visible right on the UI Online homepage after you log in, not just the paper notice - good to have both so you don't miss it.

0 coins

Misconduct under EDD's rules isn't the same thing as violating a workplace policy. Lost my job over a dress code issue of all things, and my employer swore up and down it was misconduct. What EDD actually looks at is whether the employee intentionally disregarded a duty they owed to the employer - that's the threshold. A mistake or a poor judgment call is different from deliberate wrongdoing. EDD decides after hearing both you and your employer in that phone interview. Your employer has to show there was actual misconduct, not just that you broke a rule they wrote.

0 coins

Does the fact that my post wasn't about work at all, just personal stuff on my own time, factor into how EDD weighs it?

0 coins

That context absolutely matters, from what I understand, but EDD's the one who makes the call. Bring up in the interview that it was personal time, personal account, no company name or tag - anything showing the connection to your employment was thin. Don't assume though, let EDD hear it from both sides.

0 coins

My cousin told me that if you get fired for anything on social media it's automatically disqualified. That doesn't match what EDD actually says though right?

0 coins

Not accurate - EDD doesn't have a category of automatic disqualification for social media specifically. It goes through the same misconduct analysis as any firing. Someone should correct that before it spreads.

0 coins

Went through a firing situation last year where my former employer checked off every box they could think of on the reason-for-separation form they sent back to EDD. All of it was exaggerated or flat out wrong. What helped me most going into the phone interview was writing out a timeline of events - what happened, when, and what I did or said at each point. The interviewer asked very specific questions and having dates and details ready made a huge difference versus just saying 'that's not what happened.

0 coins

How long did your interview actually run? The DE 4800 gave a time slot but didn't say how long to block off.

0 coins

Mine was about 25 minutes but I've heard it varies a lot depending on how many questions the interviewer has. Block off at least an hour just so you're not rushing anything.

0 coins

Keep your phone charged and in your hand the whole scheduled window. The interviewer phones at the time on the DE 4800 and if you miss it EDD decides from whatever information they already have, which probably isn't going to favor you.

0 coins

EDD takes the interview really seriously as the main chance to gather both sides. They're not reading your Instagram - they're asking you and your employer to describe what happened and why. Prepare to explain clearly why you posted what you posted, what your understanding of the company's social media policy was, whether you ever received training on it, and whether you had any prior warnings. Those specific details matter a lot more than a general 'I didn't do anything wrong.

0 coins

Prior warnings is a good point - I had zero written warnings before this termination. Is that the kind of thing worth bringing up during the interview?

0 coins

Absolutely mention it. No prior warnings, no progressive discipline, jumped straight to termination - that's information the interviewer needs to hear from you because your employer might not volunteer it.

0 coins

Prior written warnings also matter for showing whether the employer treated this policy consistently. If other employees violated the same policy and kept their jobs, that's worth raising too.

0 coins

My employer fought my claim too and I was terrified the whole time. The wait after the interview was brutal - almost four weeks before the Notice of Determination came. During that time my weeks stayed Pending in Claim History and I kept certifying every two weeks because I was told stopping would mean EDD couldn't pay those weeks even if I won. Ended up qualifying. Keep certifying no matter what.

0 coins

Are you certifying through UI Online or Tele-Cert? I haven't done my first certification yet and don't know which is easier.

0 coins

UI Online at myedd.edd.ca.gov is faster. Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 works fine too but I always found the online version quicker to get through.

0 coins

Seriously never stop certifying during a dispute. Those pending weeks can only be paid back if they were certified - EDD can't go back and pay weeks you skipped.

0 coins

Severance pay from my last job created a whole separate headache on top of my termination dispute. Got a lump sum check on my last day and panicked about whether to report it. EDD's list of things to report on your certification includes severance, so I reported it, then spent two weeks worried I'd messed something up. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the line about it and the agent confirmed my severance was in my record and explained what week it was attributed to. Filed that certification question away: report what you got and let EDD sort the math.

0 coins

What screen in UI Online do you report severance on - is it the regular certification questions or somewhere separate?

0 coins

It comes up in the certification itself as one of the questions about income and pay for the week. You answer it there - there's no separate form for severance.

0 coins

Report Wages in UI Online is a different thing - it's for figuring out a week's wages before you certify, not for fixing something already submitted. If you think you answered a past week wrong, you'd need to contact EDD through a message or the phone.

0 coins

The thing that tripped me up was not understanding that the first certification covers the waiting week plus one paid week. My claim went through, interview went fine, and I was confused why the first payment was only for one week even though I'd been out of work for two weeks by then. Every claim has that unpaid waiting period on week one - doesn't change how much you ultimately get paid out over the life of the claim, just delays the first check.

0 coins

Had no idea about the waiting week. So even if EDD decides in my favor, week one is always unpaid?

0 coins

Exactly - the waiting week is served on the first eligible week of your claim. It doesn't get paid but it doesn't reduce your maximum benefit amount either, it just means your first payment is for week two.

0 coins

The DE 429Z will show your weekly benefit amount once EDD processes your application - usually mailed out within about two weeks of filing. Check it carefully and if the amount looks wrong you can appeal within 30 days of the mailing date on it.

0 coins

Fired situations get more scrutiny than layoffs, that's just reality with California EDD. But more scrutiny doesn't mean denial. What it means is EDD actually interviews both sides instead of taking the employer's word for it. Your employer says misconduct, you say it wasn't, EDD listens to both and decides. That process exists specifically because employers sometimes stretch the definition of misconduct to avoid paying into UI.

0 coins

My cousin also said that if the employer contests the claim you just automatically lose? That's not right either is it?

0 coins

Not right at all. An employer contesting the claim just means EDD hears from them too before deciding. EDD still decides independently - the employer can't deny a claim, only EDD can. And if EDD denies it, you have 30 days to appeal in writing with the DE 1000M form.

0 coins

Clearing up the confusion from earlier: an employer that doesn't respond to EDD's notice at all actually can't appeal EDD's decision later if they miss the deadline. So an employer who's going to fight it is at least engaging in the process, which isn't worse for you - EDD just hears both sides.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is easy to forget about when you're dealing with an adjudication situation. Got so focused on my interview prep that I nearly missed the 21-day deadline on the DE 8405. That can stop payments independent of the interview outcome, so check whether EDD sent you a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work and get your CalJOBS profile and resume up before that deadline.

0 coins

I haven't gotten a DE 8405 yet - does EDD mail that separately from the DE 4800 or is it in UI Online somewhere?

0 coins

Mailed separately. Watch for it in your mailbox in the next week or two. The deadline on it is 21 days from the date printed on the notice, not from when you receive it, so open it immediately when it shows up.

0 coins

Worth noting that not every claimant gets the DE 8405 - EDD determines if you need to register. But if you do get it, that 21-day clock is real and missing it can hold up payments even after an interview goes fine.

0 coins

Appeal clock matters if EDD denies you - 30 calendar days from the mailing date on the Notice of Determination, not from when you get it in your hands. Got caught by this on a previous claim. This time around, disputing a different work separation issue, I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and double-checked which weeks were still open on my claim and what was holding up the determination. The agent pulled up my record and told me the interview notes had been received and it was in the decision queue. Stopped checking UI Online obsessively after that.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date - is that date stamped on the notice itself or do you have to guess from when you received it?

0 coins

The mailing date is printed right on the notice. Keep the envelope too so you have a postmark if anything is ever disputed about timing.

0 coins

If you do end up needing to appeal, the DE 1000M appeal form comes attached to the Notice of Determination, or you can write a letter to the address on the notice. Either way it needs to be in writing and mailed within those 30 days.

0 coins

Work search requirements start the week after your waiting week even with an open adjudication. A lot of people assume the pending status means they're off the hook for job searches until EDD decides. Not the case - you need to be able and available for work and looking for work every week you certify. When adjudication resolves in your favor, EDD can only pay those weeks if you were actually eligible, meaning you were searching.

0 coins

How does EDD verify work search activity? Do they ask for specific contacts during the certification?

0 coins

The certification questions ask if you looked for work that week. Keep your own records of where you applied, dates, company names, positions - that's just a good habit in case EDD ever asks. EDD's pages don't give a specific number of contacts you need to make.

0 coins

CalJOBS is also a resource for actual job search stuff beyond just the registration requirement - job listings, resume help, that kind of thing. Using it actively doesn't hurt.

0 coins

My termination letter said 'insubordination' but the actual facts were way closer to what this person is describing - a disagreement that happened outside work hours. Went into my phone interview, laid out what actually happened, employer gave their version. EDD mailed the determination about a month later and I qualified. The interview felt intimidating but it was mostly the interviewer asking factual questions about what I did, what the policy said, and what I knew about it.

0 coins

Did the interviewer seem to have already read the employer's side before talking to you, or did they come in neutral?

0 coins

Hard to say for certain but they asked me specific questions that seemed to reference details I hadn't mentioned, so probably yes. Answer every question directly and don't assume they know your version already - say everything relevant.

0 coins

The interviewer is gathering facts, not arguing a side. Answer factual questions with facts. If you don't know something, say you don't know. Trying to guess or speculate usually doesn't help.

0 coins

Someone upthread said misconduct only applies to intentional violations - that's pretty much right but I want to add that the burden in a firing situation sits with the employer to show it was misconduct. EDD's framing is that if you got fired, the employer needs to prove there was misconduct. That's different from a quit, where you'd need to show you had good reason to leave. Two completely different standards depending on how the separation happened.

0 coins

So for a firing EDD doesn't start by assuming you did something wrong?

0 coins

Correct. EDD listens to both sides, but it's on the employer to show that what happened rises to the level of misconduct under EDD's definition. Not just 'they broke a rule we have written somewhere.

0 coins

To be really precise about the quit side: EDD's words are 'if you quit, you need to show that you had a good reason.' So yes, completely different standard from a termination situation where the employer carries that burden.

0 coins

Payments go onto a Money Network debit card by default unless you've set up direct deposit in myEDD. Worth choosing your payment method before the first payment processes - changing it after is possible but takes longer to take effect. The card itself gets mailed once your claim is processed.

0 coins

Can you change the payment method through UI Online or does it have to be done on the phone?

0 coins

Changed mine through myEDD without calling. The option is in the account settings area. I don't remember the exact screen name but it was findable without too much hunting.

0 coins

Direct deposit versus the Money Network card - EDD's site doesn't say one is faster than the other for getting paid. Payment info updates daily in UI Online and you can also check it at 1-866-333-4606 anytime, that line runs 24 hours.

0 coins

Something that caught me off guard: the Notice of Determination that comes after the phone interview isn't the same as the DE 429Z. The DE 429Z shows your weekly benefit amount and comes early in the claim. The Notice of Determination is what EDD sends after actually deciding your eligibility question - and if they deny you, the DE 1000M appeal form comes attached to that determination. Two different documents, two different timelines.

0 coins

Already got the DE 429Z. The weekly amount on it looks right. So that's separate from whatever comes after the interview?

0 coins

Completely separate. DE 429Z is about how much your claim can pay if you're found eligible. The determination after your interview is about whether you're eligible at all given the circumstances of your firing. Both matter but they answer different questions.

0 coins

Also worth knowing - the DE 429Z shows the maximum your claim can pay total, not just the weekly amount. The maximum is either 26 times your weekly benefit amount or half of all base period wages, whichever is lower.

0 coins

Benefits are taxable at the federal level but California doesn't tax them. At each certification EDD asks if you want 10 percent withheld for federal taxes. Can turn it on or off at any certification - worth thinking about before you get a surprise on your tax return. EDD mails Form 1099G in January showing what you received for the year.

0 coins

Does EDD automatically withhold state taxes or do you opt in for that too?

0 coins

California doesn't tax unemployment benefits so there's no state withholding option. Only federal withholding comes up at certification. The 10 percent federal option is just a convenience - you can always pay at tax time instead if you prefer.

0 coins

1099G is also available in UI Online under Payments if you need it before the paper copy arrives or want to access older years.

0 coins

CalFresh might be worth looking into while you're waiting this out. UI benefits count as income for CalFresh eligibility purposes and you can still qualify depending on your household situation. Apply through BenefitsCal online or call 1-877-847-3663. The county determines the actual amount based on your situation so it varies, but it's a real option while a claim is in adjudication.

0 coins

Can you apply for CalFresh before EDD decides your unemployment claim, or does it require the claim to be approved first?

0 coins

You can apply regardless - CalFresh eligibility is about your current income situation, not whether unemployment has been decided yet. Even pending or expected UI income counts as income they look at.

0 coins

Covered California is also worth a look for health insurance if you lost coverage when you were terminated. COBRA keeps your old plan but it gets expensive. Covered California has options regardless of income.

0 coins

EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on edd.ca.gov can estimate your weekly amount before you get the DE 429Z - based on your highest paid quarter in the base period, which is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your claim started. If you had a pay raise or high earnings recently, those might not all fall into the base period depending on when exactly your claim started.

0 coins

My highest earnings were in the last six months. Is there any way those factor in if they fall outside the standard base period?

0 coins

There's an alternate base period - the last four completed quarters - but EDD only uses it automatically when your claim wouldn't be valid under the standard base period. It's not used to increase your weekly amount on a claim that's already valid. So if your recent high earnings fall outside the standard base period, that's unfortunately just how it works.

0 coins

The 'recently got a raise' situation trips a lot of people up with this. EDD explains it in the calculator on their site if you want to run the numbers yourself and see which quarters fall into your base period.

0 coins

okay so going back to what i said before, i was wrong about the automatic disqualification and the employer contesting meaning you lose. sorry for spreading bad info. reading the actual replies here cleared it up - misconduct is EDD's call not the employers and a social media thing isn't automatically anything

0 coins

Appreciate that correction. The employer contesting piece especially - a lot of people believe that because an employer fights back it's already over, and EDD genuinely does decide independently after hearing both sides.

0 coins

Good that this got cleared up before the interview. Going in thinking you've already lost because your employer filed a response would affect how you present your side.

0 coins

Payouts from a claim depend on the maximum benefit amount holding up for the full 26 weeks. Twenty-six weeks is the standard duration - there are no extensions currently available in California for general unemployment. The only way to continue benefits past 26 weeks would be California Training Benefits, which requires being enrolled in EDD-approved training and applies a different set of rules. That's a separate conversation but worth knowing as a possibility if the job search runs longer than expected.

0 coins

California Training Benefits - is that something you apply for through EDD or through the school or training program itself?

0 coins

Through EDD, and the timing matters: the application generally needs to be in before the 16th week of benefits. It's not automatic and not everyone qualifies - EDD decides if the training is approved. Something to research sooner rather than later if it seems relevant to your situation.

0 coins

Just flagging that CalJOBS and the AJCC locations in your area can connect you with training resources and job search workshops. AJCC staff don't process or decide claims but they have real tools for the job search side.

0 coins

The fact that your employer already told you they'd contest the claim is actually useful information. It means you can prepare for the interview knowing they're engaged. Write down everything you remember about the post itself, when you made it, what their social media policy actually said, whether you received it in writing, whether you signed anything acknowledging it, and how it reached your employer's attention. All of that is relevant and you should be able to speak to it clearly.

0 coins

The policy - I got it in an employee handbook when I was hired two years ago. Should I have that document with me during the interview?

0 coins

Have it in front of you, yes. The interviewer is on the phone not video so they can't see it but you can reference it directly. If it shows the policy language was vague or only applied to company accounts, say that explicitly.

0 coins

Two years without any written warnings or disciplinary action before this is also worth stating directly. First offense, no progressive discipline, went straight to termination - that's context the interviewer should hear.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure