UI backdate claim denied new base period - what happens now with California EDD?
So I got hit with something I honestly wasn't expecting and I'm still trying to wrap my head around it. Filed for unemployment back in March after getting laid off from my warehouse job, and I requested a backdate because I had no idea you were supposed to file the week you stop working - I waited almost six weeks before I figured that out. EDD denied the backdate, which I kind of saw coming after reading around, but here's where it gets complicated: because of the denied backdate, my claim start date stayed where it was, and now EDD is telling me my base period is different than what I expected and I apparently don't qualify under the standard calculation. Got a Notice of Determination in the mail last week saying I'm denied. The DE 429Z I got showed a weekly amount but now that seems meaningless if the whole claim got kicked. I had solid wages in the quarter right before this mess started but it's falling outside whatever window they're using. Has anyone dealt with a backdate denial that then triggered a base period problem? Do I appeal the backdate denial, the eligibility denial, or both? And is there any fix here with an alternate base period or am I just done?
73 comments

Liam Murphy
Last quarter of my previous job, the one that ended in December, had my highest wages by a wide margin - nearly $12,000 in that three-month stretch. When my claim got processed in February, EDD's standard window completely skipped over it. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent because the phone line was impossible - been hanging up on me for two weeks straight - and I ended up talking to someone who pulled up my actual claim file. She told me the alternate base period uses your four most recently completed quarters, so that December quarter I thought was lost was actually in the window. She walked me through what my new weekly amount would be under that calculation. There's a video about reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if the phone is giving you the same runaround. After that call I sent a written request asking EDD to check whether the alternate base period applied, and they processed it without me having to file a full appeal.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorThe December quarter thing is exactly what I'm worried about - my biggest earnings quarter was September through November of last year, right before everything fell apart, and I think that's the one getting cut off. So the alternate base period might actually save me here if the standard one truly doesn't work. Did EDD apply it automatically or did you have to specifically ask?
0 coins
Amara Okafor
EDD is supposed to run the alternate base period automatically when the standard one doesn't produce a valid claim. But I've seen people on here say it didn't happen without them asking, so calling to confirm isn't a bad idea.
0 coins
Liam Murphy
EDD moved to it on their own for me, but honestly I wouldn't have known to even check if the agent hadn't explained it on that call. The standard notice doesn't spell it out clearly.
0 coins
CaptainAwesome
Denial letter for the backdate sitting on my kitchen table right now, same situation basically. The thing that caught me off guard was that appealing the backdate denial is separate from whatever eligibility question they raise about the base period. Two different notices, two different 30-day clocks. I missed that at first and almost let one of them expire while I was focused on the other.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorTwo separate appeal deadlines - that's the part I was not clear on at all. I've been treating this like one problem but it sounds like I need to track the mailing dates on each notice individually.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Exactly right. Each Notice of Determination has its own date and its own 30-day window. If you appeal one and ignore the other, you're stuck with the other decision.
0 coins
Esmeralda Gómez
DE 1000M is the form, or you can just write a letter and mail it to the address printed right on the notice. Keep a copy of whatever you send.
0 coins
Klaus Schmidt
Something that tripped me up when I was fighting my own backdate denial: EDD needs a specific reason for why you delayed filing, and vague answers don't help. 'I didn't know' on its own usually doesn't meet the bar. Things like hospitalization, a documented emergency, or being actively misled by EDD itself carry more weight. If you have any documentation of why those six weeks passed without you filing - texts, medical records, anything - dig it out before you write that appeal.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorHonestly the reason was just that I didn't know the rules, which I realize now probably isn't strong enough. I wasn't in the hospital or anything like that, just genuinely clueless. That might mean the backdate appeal is a lost cause and I should focus energy on the base period angle instead.
0 coins
Aisha Patel
That's a fair read of it. The backdate argument is an uphill fight without documented circumstances beyond not knowing. But the base period question is entirely separate and worth pursuing on its own.
0 coins
LilMama23
Had a friend go through the same thing. The backdate appeal went nowhere but the alternate base period fixed the whole wage calculation and she got paid. Focus on that piece.
0 coins
Dmitri Volkov
Administrative law judge hearing on a denial I had last spring, and the one thing the judge kept coming back to was whether my wages in each quarter were actually verifiable through employer records. If your September-November quarter wages are on file with EDD from your employer's tax reports, the alternate base period calculation should be straightforward - EDD pulls those numbers directly, you don't have to submit pay stubs just to establish the wage total.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorMy employer was a large company so payroll reporting should be solid on their end. I'm less worried about the wage verification piece and more about whether that quarter even falls inside the alternate window given my claim date.
0 coins
Gabrielle Dubois
Claim date timing is everything for which quarters land in which window. The alternate base period shifts the window forward by one quarter compared to the standard one, which is what makes it useful for people in exactly this situation.
0 coins
Tyrone Johnson
EDD phone lines turned me away about nine times in a row during my adjudication fight. What actually helped was the live chat in UI Online, available Monday through Friday from nine to two. It's not great for complex questions but I got an agent to flag my account for a callback - wait, no, they flagged it for a supervisor review. It's buried in the Help button once you're logged in to myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorThe live chat window is something I hadn't tried yet. I've been burning time on the phone. Worth a shot if it gets eyes on my account faster.
0 coins
Ingrid Larsson
Live chat is hit or miss honestly. Some agents can see your full claim file and answer real questions, others just paste canned responses. But it's free and doesn't require sitting on hold so worth trying before anything else.
0 coins
Carlos Mendoza
Chat helped me figure out which weeks were actually pending vs which ones had been decided. Didn't resolve anything but at least I knew where things stood.
0 coins
Zainab Mahmoud
Appeals hearing I went through last year, the judge explained the alternate base period rule pretty plainly: EDD uses your four most recent completed calendar quarters, but only steps in with that calculation if the standard base period doesn't get you to a valid claim. Valid means at least $1,300 in your best quarter, or at least $900 in your best quarter and total wages across the base period that come to at least 1.25 times that amount. If the alternate window pulls in that big September-November quarter, you'd want to run those numbers against those thresholds before you get too hopeful or too discouraged.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorRunning the numbers right now - I had just over $9,800 in that quarter. That clears $1,300 easily. The question is whether the total base period wages also work out but I think they do if that quarter is included.
0 coins
Zainab Mahmoud
At $9,800 in your best quarter you're looking at a weekly benefit amount somewhere in the range EDD's calculator would estimate - but the exact number comes from EDD's own formula off the highest quarter. The DE 429Z shows it once they process the new calculation.
0 coins
Ava Williams
Worth double-checking against EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site before you get too attached to a number. It gives a rough estimate so you know what ballpark you're in.
0 coins
Raj Gupta
Went through almost this exact sequence about eight months ago. Backdate denied, then the standard base period came up short, and I honestly thought I was just out of luck. What turned it around was appealing the eligibility denial specifically - not the backdate, which I let go - and in the appeal hearing I argued that the alternate base period made me eligible regardless of the backdate issue. The judge agreed and EDD had to recalculate.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorThis is the most useful thing I've read in this whole thread. So you essentially said 'even if the backdate stays denied, the alternate base period makes me eligible anyway' and that argument held up?
0 coins
Raj Gupta
Exactly that. The two issues are legally separate. The backdate determines your claim start date, but eligibility is determined by wages in whatever the correct base period is. The judge treated them independently.
0 coins
Lena Müller
Two weeks into my own eligibility denial fight, every phone attempt was dropping. EDD's automated line kept disconnecting after the hold music. Claimyr got me to an actual EDD agent - found it after searching for ways past the busy signals - and the agent confirmed that my alternate base period had already been calculated and was showing a valid claim, which the written notice hadn't made clear at all. Knowing that before the hearing genuinely changed how I prepared.
0 coins
TechNinja
Nobody told me until way too late that you're supposed to keep certifying even while an appeal is in progress. Learned that one the hard way. If you stop certifying because you assume the whole claim is dead, EDD can't back-pay those weeks even if you win the appeal later. Keep filing the certifications every two weeks no matter what.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorHad not thought about this at all. I stopped certifying after the denial notice because I figured what's the point. How far back can they go on those missed weeks if I win?
0 coins
TechNinja
EDD can only pay weeks you actually certified. Uncertified weeks are gone even after a successful appeal. You need to contact EDD and ask about certifying for the missed weeks - some agents will let you catch up during an active appeal, some won't. But stop waiting and start certifying now for current weeks at minimum.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
EDD's own materials say to keep certifying through an appeal. The certification is what creates the payment record. Without it there's nothing to release even if the judge rules for you.
0 coins
Keisha Thompson
DE 4800 came in my mail about ten days after my adjudication issue was flagged - that's the notice with the phone interview date and time. Missing that interview is what killed my claim the first time around. EDD decided based on whatever information they already had, which wasn't enough, and I got denied. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent after the fact, told the agent I'd missed the interview, and she told me to phone EDD that same day if it ever happened again so they could try to reschedule before the decision locked in. By then it was too late for me but that's the rule - same day, not the next morning.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorNo missed interview in my case - I did do the phone interview, it just didn't go the way I hoped. But good to know about the same-day rule for anyone else reading this.
0 coins
CaptainAwesome
Thought the interview being done meant the decision would automatically go my way if I'd told the truth. Turns out EDD still weighs both sides and can still deny. The interview is just their chance to get your version of events.
0 coins
Esmeralda Gómez
The DE 4800 notice also lists the specific topics they're likely to ask about. Actually reading that ahead of time and thinking through your answers for each one makes a difference.
0 coins
LilMama23
CalJOBS registration is one of those things people forget about while fighting a denial. If you do win an appeal and your claim becomes active, EDD typically expects you to register in CalJOBS and post a resume within 21 days of whatever notice triggers that requirement. Missing that deadline can pause payments even after a successful appeal.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorHad not even thought about CalJOBS in the middle of all this appeal stuff. Good catch - I'll get registered now so it's not a problem later.
0 coins
Ingrid Larsson
The notice that triggers the CalJOBS clock is the DE 8405. If you get one, the 21-day window is real and EDD does check.
0 coins
Aisha Patel
EDD will tell you if CalJOBS doesn't apply to your situation - some claimants are exempt. But if you haven't gotten anything saying you're exempt, assume you need to register.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Adjudication sitting at pending for eleven weeks on my end before anything resolved. What nobody explained to me early on was that an open adjudication issue and an eligibility denial are two different statuses in the system. Pending means they're still deciding. A Notice of Determination means they decided. Sounds obvious but I conflated them for weeks and was taking the wrong action.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorHad the same confusion early on - I kept thinking pending meant I might still get paid without doing anything. The notice arriving clarified that they'd actually made a decision and the appeal clock had started.
0 coins
Dmitri Volkov
Pending with no notice means wait and keep certifying. Notice of Determination with a denial means the 30-day appeal window is running. Those are two completely different situations requiring two completely different responses.
0 coins
Carlos Mendoza
DE 1446UI crossed my mind when reading this - that's the overpayment waiver form, not what you need here. What you're describing is an eligibility appeal, not an overpayment situation. Just flagging it because someone in a similar thread confused the two and filed the wrong form entirely.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorNo overpayment in my case - they never paid me anything yet, which is kind of the whole problem. But I appreciate the flag because I'd read about that form somewhere and briefly wondered if it was relevant.
0 coins
Gabrielle Dubois
Overpayment waiver is for when EDD paid you and then wants the money back. Eligibility denial is for when they won't pay in the first place. Completely different tracks.
0 coins
Aisha Patel
September through November wages falling outside the standard base period window is actually a timing issue that affects a lot of people who file in the first few months of the year. The standard calculation looks at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters, so a Q4 that just finished can end up in that excluded fifth quarter. The alternate base period shifts things so that Q4 is included. EDD is supposed to do this automatically but confirming it happened is worth a call.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorThis explains why my numbers looked fine on paper but EDD was coming up with a different answer. The fifth-quarter exclusion is exactly what's happening here.
0 coins
Zainab Mahmoud
Same thing happened with my Q3 wages when I filed in January. Standard base period left out the most recent quarter entirely. Alternate fixed it.
0 coins
Klaus Schmidt
Worth noting: the alternate base period can only help you if the standard one doesn't produce a valid claim. If you already clear the wage threshold under the standard calculation, EDD won't apply the alternate one to give you a higher weekly amount. It's a qualifying tool, not a raise.
0 coins
Esmeralda Gómez
Writing the appeal letter for a base period question - tried that last spring. The key is to be specific about which quarter you believe should be counted and what your wages in that quarter were. Vague appeals that just say 'I disagree with the decision' don't give the judge anything to work with. If you have pay stubs or W-2s covering that September-November period, attach copies to the letter.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorPay stubs from that job are still in my email from the HR system. I'll pull those and attach them. Having the actual numbers on paper seems obviously better than just asserting the quarter should count.
0 coins
Raj Gupta
Even if EDD already has the employer wage records, bringing your own copies to the hearing shows you know exactly what the numbers are. Judges notice when a claimant is prepared.
0 coins
Ingrid Larsson
Looked at the wrong column on my DE 429Z for about two weeks before realizing it. The form shows a maximum benefit amount and a weekly benefit amount - two separate figures. The maximum is the total the claim can pay over its life. The weekly amount is what you get per certification period. I was quoting the maximum number when people asked about my weekly rate.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorDefinitely have been reading that form wrong. Going to pull it out again and find the actual weekly figure separately.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
The weekly benefit amount is the one that matters most day to day. The maximum just tells you how many weeks you can potentially draw.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
Work search requirement is something to get right before your claim activates. EDD requires that you be able to work, available for work and actively looking for work for every week you certify. There's no specific number of contacts EDD publishes for California, but keeping your own record of where you applied is a good habit - if EDD ever questions a week, you'll have something to show.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorHaven't been tracking my job applications as carefully as I probably should because I figured the claim was dead anyway. If the appeal works out I'll need to get more organized about that.
0 coins
LilMama23
CalJOBS also has resources like job fairs and workshops through the America's Job Centers of California if you want support beyond just online applications.
0 coins
Carlos Mendoza
The AJCC doesn't process or decide claims but they do help with resumes, job search strategy and referrals. Worth knowing they exist if the job search piece feels overwhelming.
0 coins
Gabrielle Dubois
Waiting week confusion tripped me up at the start of my claim. Everyone talks about the first payment coming late and assumes something is wrong, but the first week a claim is active is an unpaid waiting period by design. The first certification usually covers that unpaid week and one paid week. Backdating a claim doesn't skip the waiting week - it just moves where the waiting week falls in the timeline.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorHadn't even gotten to thinking about the waiting week yet given the base period issue, but good to know that piece is built into the structure no matter what happens.
0 coins
CaptainAwesome
Thought the waiting week was something EDD could waive if the backdate worked out. Turns out it's just part of how every claim works, not something that changes with timing.
0 coins
Dmitri Volkov
The waiting week doesn't change the total the claim can pay. It doesn't subtract from your maximum benefit amount - the 26 weeks of potential benefits are still there after it passes.
0 coins
Ava Williams
Contacted EDD through Ask EDD - the online contact form - when the phone was completely useless during my own base period dispute. Response took about a week but it created a paper trail of my question and their answer. When I brought that correspondence to my hearing, the judge treated it as evidence that I'd made reasonable efforts to clarify the issue before the hearing date.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorCreating a paper trail hadn't occurred to me as a strategy for the hearing itself. That's smart. I'll submit something through Ask EDD this week and keep the confirmation.
0 coins
Keisha Thompson
Ask EDD responses sometimes get routed to a general inbox and don't go to anyone who can actually change something on your account. But for creating a dated record of your questions and EDD's replies, it's exactly right.
0 coins
Lena Müller
Appeal hearing scheduled for three weeks out in my own case, and the whole week before I kept second-guessing whether I'd remembered the wage amounts correctly. Claimyr put me through to an EDD agent the morning before the hearing - I needed to confirm the exact wage figures EDD had on file for each quarter so I wasn't contradicting their own records at the hearing. The agent read off the quarterly amounts directly from my claim file. Went into the hearing knowing the numbers matched.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorConfirming what EDD has on file versus what I think they have - that's exactly the kind of prep I need to do. I'd rather find out before the hearing if there's a discrepancy in the wage records.
0 coins
TechNinja
Wage record mismatches between what you have and what EDD shows are more common than people expect, especially if an employer filed a corrected report. Finding out at the hearing is the worst time.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
DE 1080CZ in hand and the appeal form right behind it - that's where I am right now on a separate adjudication question. One thing worth knowing: the appeal goes to EDD first for an internal review, and if EDD doesn't reverse its decision, it gets sent to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. The administrative law judge who hears it is independent of EDD. That matters because a lot of people go in thinking they're arguing with EDD, but they're actually presenting to a neutral judge.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
AuthorThat reframing helps. It's not EDD judging their own decision - it's a separate process. Makes me feel like there's a real shot here if the alternate base period argument holds up.
0 coins
Raj Gupta
The administrative law judge genuinely does rule independently. I've seen decisions go both ways on nearly identical facts. Preparing a clear, documented argument makes more difference than people expect.
0 coins
Klaus Schmidt
Testimony at the hearing is under oath. You can represent yourself, have a union rep, or bring an attorney. Whatever you decide, have your documents organized and know the specific quarters and wage amounts you're arguing about.
0 coins