Back to California Unemployment

Joy Olmedo

UI account shows file new claim instead of existing claim - what does this mean for California EDD?

Okay so I'm kind of freaking out right now. I was laid off from my warehouse job back in mid-October and filed for unemployment through myEDD maybe three weeks ago. Got the DE 429Z in the mail showing my weekly amount, certified for my first two weeks, everything seemed fine. Then I logged into UI Online yesterday to certify again and instead of seeing my usual claim dashboard with my pending weeks and payment info, the homepage is showing me a 'File New Claim' button like I don't have an open claim at all. My Claim History is completely blank. No pending weeks, nothing. I haven't received any Notice of Determination saying I was denied or anything like that. I didn't quit or get fired for cause - straight layoff from a company downsizing. Has anyone seen their UI account show 'file new claim' instead of their existing claim? Is my claim gone? Do I actually have to start over? I'm supposed to certify this week and I don't know if I should click that button or if that'll mess something up.

DE 429Z arrived and showed a solid weekly amount on my claim too, then the same thing happened to me - logged in and saw 'File New Claim' where my dashboard used to be. Spent two days trying to reach anyone at EDD before I found Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got on the phone with an actual EDD agent. The agent pulled up my account and told me the system had flagged my claim for an identity re-verification step that hadn't been completed, which is why the UI Online homepage was showing me the new claim prompt instead of my existing one. They walked me through what I needed to do in ID.me to clear it. Here's a short video Claimyr put out about reaching a live person at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10

0 coins

Wait, an identity re-verification thing? I thought I already did the ID.me step when I first applied. Is that something they can flag again mid-claim?

0 coins

Yeah, apparently EDD can flag it at any point, not just at the start. The agent told me it was because something in their system didn't match after I certified. Once I went back into ID.me and redid the photo step it was resolved within a couple days.

0 coins

Did clicking the 'File New Claim' button cause any problems for you or did you avoid it? That's the part scaring me about my own situation right now.

0 coins

Logging back into myEDD after a weekend and seeing that screen where your claim should be is honestly one of the worst feelings. My weekly benefit amount was showing fine one day, gone the next. Called EDD the regular way for three days straight, couldn't get through. Eventually I used Claimyr to reach an agent and they found that my claim had been placed into adjudication because my former employer had responded to EDD's notice disputing the reason for separation - said I resigned when it was actually a layoff. The agent told me I'd be getting a DE 4800 scheduling a phone interview to go over my side of it.

0 coins

That's exactly what I'm scared of - that my employer said something wrong. How long did your adjudication take once you knew what was going on?

0 coins

Employer disputing a layoff as a voluntary quit is unfortunately really common. EDD does interview both sides, so your version of events matters a lot. Make sure you have any paperwork from the layoff - an email, a letter, anything - when that interview happens.

0 coins

How did you find out the specific reason it went into adjudication? The agent just told you straight up when you called?

0 coins

Yeah the agent looked at my account notes and laid it all out. The 'File New Claim' display was a side effect of the adjudication hold - the main claim was still there in the system, just frozen while EDD was sorting out the dispute.

0 coins

Had a panic moment when I saw something similar. Before assuming the worst, try logging out of myEDD completely, clearing your browser's cache and cookies, then logging back in. A few people in another thread mentioned the UI Online homepage sometimes glitches and shows the wrong screen, especially after a system maintenance window. Worth ruling out a display bug before you spend hours on the phone.

0 coins

Already tried that - cleared everything, tried a different browser, same result. It's not a cache thing unfortunately.

0 coins

Browser stuff fixed it for my roommate but not for me. Mine turned out to be an actual account issue, not a display glitch. If the cache clear doesn't work the technical fix route isn't going to get you anywhere.

0 coins

Yep, the browser trick is worth five minutes but if it's real it's real. The 'File New Claim' showing up consistently across browsers usually means something is actually flagged on the account.

0 coins

Whatever you do, do NOT click the 'File New Claim' button if you already have an open benefit year. Filing a second claim while one is active can create a whole mess with duplicate claims and EDD has to manually sort it out, which adds weeks to everything.

0 coins

Good to know, I was hovering over that button last night not knowing if I should just try it.

0 coins

Is that actually a rule or just what people say? I'm asking because I've seen people say you can't file a new claim until the benefit year ends, which would mean EDD's system just wouldn't let you even if you tried.

0 coins

Both things are true - EDD's own info says you can't file a new California claim until the benefit year ends, so the system should block it. But I've also heard of edge cases where the system got confused. Either way not worth finding out the hard way.

0 coins

To be clear on this: the benefit year runs 52 weeks from when you filed, and you can't use another California claim during that window. If the system is showing 'File New Claim' it's almost certainly a display or account status issue, not an invitation to actually start over.

0 coins

Has anyone tried the live chat through the Help button in UI Online? I know you can only get to it once you're logged in, but if the OP can still log in even with the wrong screen showing maybe that's an option to try before the phone lines.

0 coins

I tried that this morning actually. Got into chat and the agent said they couldn't pull up claim details through chat and I'd need to call the main line. Super unhelpful.

0 coins

Ugh, that's so frustrating. The chat is so inconsistent - sometimes they help, sometimes they just punt you to the phone line.

0 coins

Chat only works 9 to 2 on weekdays and even then the agents vary so much. Some will dig into your account, some just send you to call 1-800-300-5616.

0 coins

The 'File New Claim' screen showing up instead of an existing dashboard usually falls into one of a few buckets: identity verification flagged, adjudication hold, or the claim actually did lapse for some reason (like missing certifications for a long enough stretch). Did you certify every two-week period without any gaps? Missing a cycle can sometimes trigger a weird account state.

0 coins

I've only had two certification periods so far and I completed both. No gaps that I know of.

0 coins

Then it's very likely either an ID.me thing or an adjudication hold based on what others are describing here. Neither of those should require you to actually file a new claim - your existing one is just frozen.

0 coins

Missing certifications was my issue last year. Went on a family trip and missed my two-week window, came back and the homepage looked like a completely different account. Had to call EDD to get it reopened but my claim was still there in the system.

0 coins

Something weird - did you get a DE 1326C in the mail by any chance? That's EDD's identity verification request letter. Sometimes they send that mid-claim and if you don't complete it the account goes into a sort of limbo where the homepage looks like you have no active claim.

0 coins

Let me check my mail pile... actually yes. I got something from EDD about two weeks ago that I set aside thinking it was just informational. It has that number on it. Oh no.

0 coins

That's almost certainly it then. The DE 1326C is a request to verify your identity through ID.me. If you didn't do it within their timeframe, that's why the account looks the way it does. The good news is your underlying claim should still be there. Go to ID.me right away and complete the verification.

0 coins

The DE 1326C situation is so common and EDD does not make it obvious enough that ignoring it basically pauses your whole claim. Glad you found that letter.

0 coins

Weeks of pending weeks sitting in limbo and EDD's phone line just rings forever - that was my situation too. My former employer had also flagged something on my separation, so my Claim History went blank even though I'd already gotten the DE 429Z. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr after the hold music loop got old. The agent confirmed the adjudication was open and told me the DE 4800 for my phone interview had already been mailed - I just hadn't gotten it yet. Went looking and found it in a pile on my counter, with an interview time I nearly missed.

0 coins

This is making me want to go dig through every piece of mail I've gotten from EDD. Sounds like there might be letters I've been setting aside.

0 coins

The interview time being on the UI Online homepage too is worth knowing - once you have a DE 4800, the scheduled time should also show up on your homepage so you don't have to rely only on the letter.

0 coins

Yeah after I found the letter I checked UI Online and the time was right there on the homepage under my claim. I'd just been so focused on the 'File New Claim' button that I hadn't looked past it.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be dumb - when EDD eventually fixes whatever is causing this and the account goes back to normal, do the pending certification weeks get backdated? Like if the OP's claim is on hold for two more weeks and then it clears, will those two weeks of certified benefits still get paid out?

0 coins

Not a dumb question at all. If EDD decides the claimant is eligible, it goes back and processes the payments for all the weeks that were certified during the hold. The key is to keep certifying during whatever review period you're in - EDD can pay those weeks only if they were certified. Stopping certification because the account looks weird would actually create a gap.

0 coins

Okay so keep certifying even if the homepage looks wrong. Got it. That's actually really good to know, I was wondering the same thing for my own claim.

0 coins

How do I certify if the homepage is showing 'File New Claim' and not my usual options?

0 coins

Try EDD Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606, option 2, with your PIN. That phone system runs 24 hours and sometimes lets you certify even when UI Online is showing you the wrong screen. It's worth trying right now.

0 coins

Someone mentioned identity verification earlier and I want to flag something. The DE 1326C letter people are talking about only gets sent to people who applied by phone, fax or mail, or whose ID.me verification EDD couldn't confirm on its own. If you applied online and did the ID.me step during your original application, getting that letter mid-claim usually means something changed or didn't match in EDD's records. It's not just a standard notice everyone gets.

0 coins

That's a good distinction. The letter is specifically a 'we need you to verify again' or 'we couldn't verify' notice, not a routine thing. Which is why it matters so much and why ignoring it freezes the account.

0 coins

Mine said something about their system being unable to confirm my identity from the information provided. So sounds like mine is the second type - something didn't match.

0 coins

Had the exact same screen problem after my employer submitted their response to EDD's notice. Adjudication opened up and the homepage went blank except for 'File New Claim.' The DE 4800 came about five days after the account changed, so if yours changed recently the letter might be on its way.

0 coins

Mine changed about four days ago so if that timeline holds the letter could show up any day now. I'm going to watch the mailbox.

0 coins

Also check your UI Online homepage carefully because the interview time often shows up there before the physical letter arrives. Even with the weird 'File New Claim' display, scroll past it and see if there's other info showing.

0 coins

How long after the interview did your account go back to normal? I'm two weeks post-interview and still seeing the same blank screen.

0 coins

Two things I did that helped while my account was stuck in that state: registered in CalJOBS right away (caljobs.ca.gov) and made sure my resume was posted there, because that 21-day window from your DE 8405 notice keeps ticking even when your claim looks frozen. Didn't want to miss that deadline on top of everything else.

0 coins

Oh I hadn't even thought about CalJOBS during all this. Good point. I need to check if I have a DE 8405 somewhere.

0 coins

The DE 8405 is a separate notice from EDD telling you that you're required to register. Not everyone gets it - EDD sends it if you need to register. If you haven't gotten one yet, you might not need to, but worth checking your mail pile since you mentioned having some EDD letters you set aside.

0 coins

The CalJOBS registration and resume posting is not optional if EDD sends you that notice. Missing the 21-day deadline can pause payments independently of whatever else is going on with your claim.

0 coins

Went through two weeks of adjudication where my Claim History was completely empty and the homepage just showed that stupid new claim button. Nobody at EDD could tell me how long it would take. The uncertainty was the worst part - not knowing if my claim was alive or dead.

0 coins

The uncertainty is exactly what's killing me. I could handle knowing it's going to take X weeks, but not knowing if the claim even exists is really stressful.

0 coins

What helped me was writing out exactly what happened with my layoff - dates, emails I had, who told me what - so I'd be ready for the phone interview when it was scheduled. Having something to do made the waiting feel less passive.

0 coins

The interview prep is genuinely worth doing even before you know when it's scheduled. EDD asks about your last day, why you stopped working, whether you were offered any kind of severance or continuation. Having your dates straight matters.

0 coins

EDD's phone interview is not the same as an appeal hearing, just want to make sure people reading this know that. The phone interview is early on when EDD is deciding eligibility - it's the interviewer phoning you at the time on the DE 4800. The appeal is a whole separate formal process with an administrative law judge if EDD denies you and you disagree with the Notice of Determination.

0 coins

Wait I thought the interview WAS the appeal? I've seen people use those terms interchangeably in other threads and I was confused.

0 coins

Nope, completely different things. The phone interview is EDD gathering information before they decide. The appeal comes after they decide and you get a Notice of Determination that you disagree with. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing.

0 coins

Exactly right. And if you do get denied, the Notice of Determination will come with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) right there in the same envelope so you don't have to hunt for it. But you're nowhere near that stage yet - the interview comes first.

0 coins

Went through pretty much this exact situation in the spring. Account went to 'File New Claim' out of nowhere, Claim History blank, panicked. Turned out to be an ID.me issue on EDD's end, nothing I had done wrong. Once I completed the verification again the account came back to normal and all my pending certifications processed within about three days.

0 coins

Three days after the ID.me step and everything processed? That's honestly really encouraging to hear.

0 coins

Yeah it was fast once the flag was cleared. The frustrating part was the two weeks before I figured out what was wrong. If I'd opened that DE 1326C right away it would have been a much shorter ordeal.

0 coins

EDD's answer to 'why does my account show File New Claim' is almost never obvious until you actually get someone on the phone. My layoff paperwork had a weird end date that caused a wage mismatch in EDD's system. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr after a week of trying the regular line. The agent found that my base period wages weren't matching what my employer had reported and my account was flagged pending a correction. She told me to watch for a Notice of Wages Used (DE 1545) in the mail.

0 coins

A wage mismatch - I hadn't thought about that angle. How did EDD fix it?

0 coins

The employer had to submit a corrected wage report on their end. EDD sent them a notice. I didn't have to do anything except wait and keep an eye on my mailbox. Took about two weeks from when the agent explained it.

0 coins

The base period stuff trips people up so often. EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site can help you estimate whether your wages look right before you even file, but once you're mid-claim there's not much you can do except wait for the system to sort it out.

0 coins

Something worth trying right now if you haven't: the Ask EDD contact form on EDD's website. You can send a message directly to EDD about your account without having to get through on the phone. You don't get a fast answer but it creates a record of your inquiry and sometimes triggers someone to actually look at your account.

0 coins

I didn't know Ask EDD could do that. I thought it was just for general questions. I'm going to send something today.

0 coins

You can ask account-specific questions through it. Just include your claim ID or Social Security number so they can actually look you up. The response time is slow - usually several days - but it's another avenue.

0 coins

Ask EDD responses are slow but they're better than nothing, especially when the phone lines are brutal. I got a response in about a week that at least confirmed my claim was still active even when UI Online showed otherwise.

0 coins

Just to run through what people have mentioned works in this situation: check your physical mail pile for a DE 1326C or a DE 4800, check the UI Online homepage carefully for a scheduled interview time, try Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 to certify while the account looks weird, and send a message through Ask EDD if you can't get through by phone. Do all of those before clicking that 'File New Claim' button.

0 coins

This is a really useful summary. I found the DE 1326C in my mail pile and I'm going to handle the ID.me step today. Will report back on how long it takes to clear.

0 coins

Good luck - based on what others said here, once that ID.me verification clears things usually move quickly. Keep certifying through Tele-Cert in the meantime so you don't have uncertified weeks.

0 coins

Report back when it clears, genuinely curious if the three-day timeline others mentioned holds for your case too.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the account looks different once whatever the hold is gets resolved? Like does the homepage just snap back to normal one day or is there some kind of notice?

0 coins

In my case it just snapped back. Logged in one morning and my Claim History was there, pending weeks showing, everything normal. No separate notice saying it was resolved - it was just fixed.

0 coins

Same for me. No fanfare, the homepage just looked right again. The payments for the pending weeks posted within a day after that.

0 coins

EDD doesn't send a 'your hold is resolved' notice. You'll know because your Claim History comes back and UI Online starts showing your actual claim status again instead of that new claim prompt.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure