Back to California Unemployment

Liam Fitzgerald

UI Online shows reopen your claim option after system update - should I reopen?

Okay so my benefit year ran out about six weeks ago and I'd just been waiting to see what happened next. Logged into UI Online this morning and there's now a button I never saw before that says something like 'reopen your claim.' I definitely did NOT see this last week before they did whatever maintenance they did over the weekend. My situation is a little complicated because I did a few weeks of contract work in October and November, then that wrapped up and I've been out of work again since early December. I never formally closed anything or filed a new claim after my benefit year ended, I kind of just stopped certifying. Now this reopen option is showing up and I genuinely don't know if clicking it is the right move or if it'll mess something up. Has anyone seen this after a system update? Should I just click it, or is this something I should call EDD about first before I do anything?

EDD's system did push an update recently and a few people in my circle saw weird things pop up in UI Online after it. My own situation was a little different - my claim was still technically open but every week in Claim History showed Pending with no explanation, and I hadn't been paid in almost six weeks. Ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it handles the hold time so you're on with a live EDD agent at the end of it. The video that shows reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what that looks like. The agent I got pulled up my claim and confirmed two specific weeks were held for a wage verification step EDD needed to finish - she told me those would release once the verification cleared and that I'd get a notice in the mail. As far as the reopen button goes, what the agent explained about reopened claims is that UI Online sometimes surfaces that option when the system sees a prior benefit year sitting there with a zero balance, especially after a site update. Whether you should click it really depends on whether a new benefit year has enough wages behind it to open a valid new claim.

0 coins

Appreciate this a lot. The 'zero balance' explanation makes sense because my old claim is definitely exhausted. My worry is I don't have a ton of wages from just those two contract months - probably not enough for a full claim but I'm not sure. I might need to call before clicking anything.

0 coins

Calling before you click is the right instinct here. If the system opens a new claim and your wages don't meet the threshold, you'd get a DE 429Z showing a very low weekly amount or a denial, and then you'd have to appeal if you thought something was wrong.

0 coins

What is the DE 429Z exactly? I keep seeing that form number mentioned but I never got one for my original claim, or if I did I don't remember it.

0 coins

Benefit year ended and you kept doing contract work without reopening - that's exactly the scenario where the reopen button actually applies to you. When a benefit year closes out and there's no active claim, the system flags it differently from someone who just paused a live claim. The reopen option you're seeing is probably EDD's way of saying 'you may have new wages, want to start this process again?' It's not a trap, but it's also not automatic approval for anything.

0 coins

That framing makes a lot more sense. I think I was treating it like it might be a glitch or something left over from the update, but maybe it's just showing up because my situation actually fits the criteria.

0 coins

The system update probably just made it more visible. That option has existed for a while for people whose benefit year ran out and who haven't filed a new claim yet.

0 coins

Exactly. The button being new to you doesn't mean it's new to EDD. Some UI changes just surface things that were already in the background based on account status.

0 coins

Had the same thought when I first saw a reopen option months ago - I assumed clicking it would immediately file something and mess up my current appeal. Turns out reopening a claim and filing a brand new one are handled differently in the system. Reopening is for situations where your benefit year is still open and you stopped certifying after going back to work - you're basically picking up where you left off. Filing new is for when the old benefit year is gone. Since yours ended six weeks ago, the button you're seeing is probably prompting a new claim, not a true reopen in the technical sense. Worth reading the screen carefully before clicking because the language EDD uses on that screen should tell you which one it is.

0 coins

You know what, I didn't even read the full text on the screen before posting here. I'm going back in to read it more carefully right now.

0 coins

Read the whole screen before you do anything on UI Online, always. Learned that the hard way when I clicked past a question about separation reason and had to contact EDD to get it corrected.

0 coins

The separation reason question matters a lot. If the contract work ended because the contract ran out, that's different from being let go for cause, and EDD needs the right information to process it.

0 coins

Used to think the reopen option and filing a new claim were the exact same process - I was wrong. After my benefit year ended the first time, I hit reopen expecting to just pick up my old weekly amount. Instead EDD recalculated everything based on my new base period wages, and my new weekly amount came out different. The DE 429Z they mailed showed a new benefit amount I didn't expect. Point being, don't assume the amount on a new claim after a reopen will match what you were getting before.

0 coins

Oh that's really useful to know. I was vaguely assuming it would just continue at the same rate, but of course it would recalculate since the base period would shift.

0 coins

The base period thing trips a lot of people up. Your new claim's weekly benefit amount is based on the highest-paid quarter in your new base period, which is completely different from whatever earned the amount on the old claim.

0 coins

And if those contract months are in the most recent quarter, they might push your highest quarter higher than before, which could actually work in your favor. Or not, depending on how much the contracts paid.

0 coins

Whether your two months of contract income is enough to open a valid new claim at all is the real question here. The threshold isn't just about hitting a dollar amount in one quarter - there's also a total base period wage consideration. EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site can at least give you a rough estimate before you file anything.

0 coins

I actually did not know the calculator existed. Going to try that right now. If the estimate comes back really low or zero I'll know the contract income probably isn't enough.

0 coins

The calculator is an estimate only - the real number comes from the DE 429Z after EDD processes your actual wages. But running the estimate first is a good way to set expectations.

0 coins

Exactly. Use the calculator to decide whether it's even worth filing. If the estimate shows a valid claim is possible, go ahead and reopen. If it shows nothing, you might wait until you have more wage history.

0 coins

Something I want to flag here - when you say the contract work 'wrapped up,' EDD is going to ask why the work ended. If the contracts just finished and weren't renewed, that's a standard end-of-contract separation that usually goes fine. If you chose not to renew or turned down more work, they may treat that differently. Worth having your answer ready before you file.

0 coins

The contracts genuinely just ended - the clients finished their projects and that was it. I didn't turn anything down. So I think I'm okay on that front but I'll make sure I explain it clearly.

0 coins

End of contract with no work available after is treated as a layoff basically - out of work through no fault of your own. As long as that's accurate you should be in a straightforward spot.

0 coins

Keep any emails or messages from the clients that show the project ended - that kind of documentation is useful if EDD asks follow-up questions or schedules a phone interview.

0 coins

Had a similar reopening question on my own claim last spring - my benefit year had ended and I was confused whether to click reopen or file completely fresh. The DE 429Z from the new filing came back with a lower weekly amount than I expected because one of my higher-earning quarters had rolled out of the base period. I ended up phoning EDD about it. Used Claimyr to get a live agent on the line and asked whether I could request the alternate base period instead. The agent looked at my specific wage record and told me the alternate base period would only kick in automatically if the standard one didn't produce a valid claim at all - since mine produced a valid claim, even a lower one, the alternate base period wasn't going to change it. Ended up just accepting the new weekly amount and kept certifying.

0 coins

The alternate base period thing is news to me. So it's not something you can just choose to use if you think it'll give you a higher benefit?

0 coins

Right - EDD applies it automatically if your standard base period wages don't get you to a valid claim. If the standard base period already works, the alternate doesn't come into play, even if the alternate would give you more.

0 coins

A lot of people ask about switching to the alternate base period after getting their DE 429Z and thinking the amount seems low. But it doesn't work that way - it's not an option you pick, EDD just uses it as a fallback.

0 coins

When your benefit year is fully exhausted and you have new wages from jobs after that, reopening starts a whole new claim with a whole new benefit year. You can't go back and get more from the old one. The contract work you did is what creates the wage base for the new claim. If you have enough wages, you get a new 52-week benefit year starting from whenever you file.

0 coins

So the new claim would start from the Sunday of the week I apply, not from when my last benefit year ended?

0 coins

Exactly - the new claim starts from the Sunday of the week you file, regardless of when the old one ended. Waiting longer doesn't cost you anything from the new claim's perspective.

0 coins

Worth filing as soon as you're ready rather than waiting though, because you can't claim benefits for weeks before the week you apply. There's no going back to get weeks you delayed on.

0 coins

EDD verified my identity through ID.me when I filed my second claim after a gap, even though I had already done it for the first one. Just heads up that they may ask you to verify again - the DE 1326C comes if there's any question. Having your ID.me account still active makes it faster.

0 coins

Good heads up. I still have my ID.me account from the first claim so at least that part should be smooth.

0 coins

Check that the ID.me account is linked to the same email you use for myEDD. Sometimes people change emails and then the verification step gets stuck.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is coming whether you're ready for it or not once you file. After a new claim is processed, EDD sends the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) and you have 21 days to register and post a resume on CalJOBS. Missing that deadline can hold up payments, so do it right when you get the notice rather than waiting.

0 coins

I did CalJOBS for my original claim. Do I have to redo the whole profile or just update what's there?

0 coins

Log back in and update your resume to reflect the recent contract work. The DE 8405 for the new claim will restart the 21-day window so your existing account should still be there.

0 coins

CalJOBS profiles don't disappear between claims. Your old one will still be there, you just update it. I went through this after a gap of almost a year and my profile was right where I left it.

0 coins

Waiting week trips up a lot of people on a new claim after a gap. You'll certify the first time about two weeks after EDD processes your application and that first certification usually covers the waiting week plus one paid week. The waiting week is unpaid - that's normal, it's not a problem with your claim, every new claim has one.

0 coins

I vaguely remember the waiting week from my first claim and was annoyed by it then too. Good to know it's just part of the process and not a flag.

0 coins

Seeing a $0 payment for the first week certified always makes people panic but it's literally just the standard waiting week. As long as the second week pays out, everything is fine.

0 coins

I called EDD in a panic about that exact thing my first time. Wasted like two hours because I thought something was wrong with my payment. It's always the waiting week.

0 coins

My benefit year had just closed and I was in a gap similar to yours when I ran into an issue with my new application - an old employer I'd worked for briefly had reported my wages under the wrong quarter and EDD's calculation came out wrong on the DE 429Z. Got through to a live EDD agent using Claimyr and asked about the wage discrepancy. The agent confirmed the wages were attributed to the wrong quarter in EDD's system and told me to appeal the DE 429Z in writing within 30 days with documentation from that employer showing the correct pay dates. Filed the appeal and mailed my pay stubs with it.

0 coins

How did you even catch that the wages were in the wrong quarter? Did you just notice the weekly amount looked too low?

0 coins

Compared the DE 429Z benefit amount to what I estimated using the calculator on EDD's site. The estimate came out noticeably higher, which made me look more carefully at the quarterly breakdown.

0 coins

The DE 429Z appeal window is only 30 days from the mailing date so if something looks off, you have to move fast on it.

0 coins

Filing the application vs. certifying is something that confuses a lot of first-time filers. Applying creates the claim, certifying every two weeks is how you tell EDD you're still eligible and collect the actual payments. You can file the application today and not start certifying until EDD processes everything and sends instructions - the two steps are separate.

0 coins

Someone actually said to me 'just go in and certify' when I was describing this situation and I think they meant file a new claim. The terminology confusion is real.

0 coins

Yeah 'just certify' makes no sense for a new claim because there's nothing to certify against until EDD processes the application first.

0 coins

Certifying before EDD has set up your claim is a pretty common misconception. UI Online will actually stop you if there's nothing active to certify on - but it's still better to understand the sequence going in.

0 coins

Read the actual text on that reopen screen before clicking anything. I made the mistake of skimming and selected the wrong separation reason on a refile once - said I was laid off when I actually needed to say the contract ended. Had to contact EDD through a UI Online message to get it corrected and it added about two weeks to my processing time.

0 coins

How did you correct it once it was submitted? Just through the message option in UI Online?

0 coins

Sent a message through UI Online explaining the error and what the correct answer should have been. EDD responded after a few days confirming they updated it, and then I had to wait for the standard processing.

0 coins

The UI Online message option is underused. A lot of people don't know it exists and try to phone for things that could just be a message.

0 coins

Came here because I saw the same button this morning and was equally confused. Benefit year ended in September, did a few months of gig work, and now UI Online is showing a reopen option. After reading through all of this I'm going to run the wage calculator first and then call before I click anything.

0 coins

Update: ran the calculator with my gig earnings and the estimate actually showed a valid claim amount. Going to go ahead and file this week.

0 coins

Run the calculator again once you have all your quarterly earnings sorted out before you file. The estimate is only as accurate as what you put in.

0 coins

September through November of last year I had a wage credit issue on my own new claim after a gap - EDD showed a pending status on every week I'd certified and there was no explanation in Claim History. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and asked specifically which weeks were held and why. Agent found that my CalJOBS registration hadn't processed correctly on their end even though my account showed as active on caljobs.ca.gov - there was a mismatch in the systems. She noted the account manually and told me the pending weeks would release within a few business days once it updated, which they did.

0 coins

This is exactly why I'm inclined to call before I click. I'd rather know what I'm walking into before I start the process.

0 coins

Calling first especially makes sense in your case because of the contract work gap - you have more moving pieces than a standard layoff filing.

0 coins

CalJOBS and UI Online being out of sync is surprisingly common. They're separate systems that are supposed to talk to each other but sometimes they don't.

0 coins

Payments go to a Money Network prepaid debit card unless you change it in myEDD to direct deposit or a paper check. If your old card from the first claim is expired - which it probably is after a year-plus gap - you might need to update your payment method before your first payment processes. Worth checking before you're waiting on a payment that has nowhere to go.

0 coins

Oh wow I completely forgot about that. My old card is definitely expired, I actually cut it up months ago. I'll update that in myEDD before I file.

0 coins

Direct deposit is probably the easiest option if you don't want to deal with another card. You change it in myEDD, not in UI Online specifically - the payment preference is in the main account settings.

0 coins

Just to put a bow on what this thread has covered - what you're seeing in UI Online is showing you a path to open a new benefit year claim based on the wages from your contract work. Whether to click it comes down to whether those contract wages are enough for a valid claim, which the EDD calculator will tell you roughly. If yes, go ahead and file. EDD will process it, send you the DE 429Z with your new weekly amount, and from there you certify every two weeks. If the amount on the DE 429Z looks wrong, you have 30 days from its mailing date to appeal in writing.

0 coins

Ran the calculator and it shows a valid claim amount based on my contract income. Going to go ahead and file through UI Online today. Thanks everyone for talking me through this, I would have been much more anxious clicking that button without understanding what it was doing.

0 coins

Filing through UI Online at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is the fastest way to get it processed. Have your contract employer info and dates handy so the application goes smoothly.

0 coins

Let the thread know what weekly amount the DE 429Z comes back with - curious whether the contract quarters moved your highest quarter up or down from your previous claim.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure