Back to California Unemployment

Christian Bierman

Someone withdrew money from bank of america debit card without the card - California EDD payment issue

Okay so I need help figuring out what happened with my California EDD payments. Applied for unemployment about a month ago after getting laid off from my warehouse job, and I finally got my first payment deposited. Except when I went to use the card there was way less than there should have been - about $180 missing from what UI Online showed as paid. I haven't lost the card or given anyone the number. Called my bank and they said there were two transactions I didn't make. EDD has me on the Money Network debit card for payments and I'm honestly not sure if this is an EDD problem, a card problem, or something else entirely. Has anyone had unauthorized charges on their EDD payment card before? Who do I even contact first - EDD or the card issuer?

DE 429Z on my claim showed a weekly benefit amount of $390, but after my first two weeks got certified UI Online showed only $312 had actually landed on my card. Took me forever to get through to EDD on the phone until I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it held the line for me and I ended up talking to an EDD agent directly. Asked her why the amount was short and she pulled up my claim and said one week had a wage offset applied because I'd reported some part-time hours and the formula knocked down that payment. She also confirmed that my card was Money Network, not any other bank, and that any unauthorized transaction disputes go to Money Network's card services line, not to EDD. That was actually the most useful call I ever had about my claim. Here's the video EDD put together on reaching a live person at EDD by phone, same thing I used: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10

0 coins

The Money Network detail is exactly what I needed - I kept thinking this was an EDD issue but sounds like the dispute goes to the card company directly. Did the agent say anything about how long a dispute investigation takes?

0 coins

Had the same confusion about which number to call. Money Network has their own fraud line separate from anything EDD-related, and they're the ones who can freeze the card and issue a replacement.

0 coins

Worth noting the agent can also confirm whether EDD shows the full payment as sent on their end, which tells you if the shortage happened at EDD or after the money hit the card.

0 coins

Thought the EDD payment card was still through Bank of America for the longest time - went to a BofA branch in person to report a problem with mine and they had no idea what I was talking about. EDD's debit card program moved to Money Network, so any card disputes, replacements or fraud claims go through Money Network's customer service. BofA has nothing to do with EDD payments anymore.

0 coins

Had no idea about the switch - nothing in my paperwork said anything about Money Network specifically, just said a debit card would arrive. That explains why I was going in circles trying to figure out which bank to call.

0 coins

Same thing happened to a guy in my building - spent two days trying to reach BofA before someone told him the card program changed. The card itself has the Money Network name on it but it's easy to miss.

0 coins

The DE 429Z that arrives after you apply shows your weekly benefit amount and payment info, but it doesn't spell out the card issuer name very clearly. EDD's site at edd.ca.gov has the current card program details.

0 coins

Unauthorized transaction on a debit card tied to unemployment benefits is two separate problems happening at once. First issue is the missing money itself - that's a dispute with Money Network and they can investigate the transactions and potentially reverse them. Second issue is figuring out how someone accessed the card if you still have it physically - that usually means the card number was skimmed or exposed somewhere, not that someone has the card itself. Report the fraud to Money Network, ask for a replacement card with a new number, and change your PIN as a precaution.

0 coins

The card skimming angle hadn't occurred to me at all - I've been using it at a couple of ATMs and apparently that's a common place for skimmers. Going to report to Money Network today and ask for a replacement.

0 coins

ATM skimmers are super common right now. Used one at a gas station near my house and had the same thing happen with a different card - someone cloned the number and used it online where the physical card isn't needed.

0 coins

Also worth checking UI Online to confirm EDD shows the full payment amount as disbursed. If EDD sent the right amount and it was taken from the card after, that's purely a card dispute. If EDD shows a lower amount, then there's a certification or wage-reporting question to sort out first.

0 coins

Made the mistake of thinking I had to wait for EDD to investigate before the card company would do anything. Spent almost a week going back and forth before I realized Money Network can open a dispute on their own - EDD and the card company are separate entities and their processes don't have to run in the same order. File the card dispute as soon as you can because there are time limits on disputing unauthorized transactions.

0 coins

Time limits - good to know. How much time do you usually have to file a dispute on a prepaid debit card? I'm already a few days in from when I noticed it.

0 coins

Prepaid debit dispute windows vary but generally the faster you report it the better your position. Money Network's fraud line can tell you exactly what applies to their card program.

0 coins

Federal rules around prepaid cards have tightened up in recent years. The key is reporting promptly - delays can limit what you recover. Don't wait on EDD to give you the go-ahead before calling Money Network.

0 coins

Pending weeks on my Claim History in UI Online had me completely stumped for about three weeks after I got laid off from my restaurant job. Couldn't figure out if the holdup was identity verification or some adjudication issue, and the phone line just kept dropping me. Used Claimyr to get a live EDD agent on the line and she checked my claim right there - said my CalJOBS registration hadn't been completed within the window on my DE 8405, which had paused my payments. Got my registration done the same day and payments started moving. Separately confirmed with her that any card-side issues go to Money Network, not EDD.

0 coins

The CalJOBS deadline on the DE 8405 trips up so many people - 21 days sounds like a lot until you're dealing with everything else that comes with losing a job. Glad you got that sorted before too many weeks piled up.

0 coins

Pending status is exactly what I was seeing too before the first payment came through. Good reminder to double-check my CalJOBS registration is complete - I did it but never confirmed it went through properly.

0 coins

Had a similar CalJOBS issue - the registration went through on my end but EDD showed it as incomplete because the resume wasn't posted yet. Resume posting is a separate step from just creating the CalJOBS account.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD can reverse a card transaction or investigate card fraud - that's genuinely outside their scope. EDD releases the funds to Money Network and from that point it's Money Network's system. So for missing card money you need Money Network, and for a question about whether EDD released the right amount in the first place you go to EDD. Two calls, two companies, but only if the UI Online payment amount doesn't match what hit your card - if UI Online shows a lower amount, that's the EDD question first.

0 coins

UI Online shows $392 as paid but only $212 is showing on my card balance after I add up all the transactions. So EDD sent the right amount - the $180 disappearance is on the card side. Calling Money Network now.

0 coins

That amount discrepancy tells you everything. EDD did their part - this is a Money Network fraud dispute. When you call, ask them to flag the account for suspicious activity and get a case number for the dispute.

0 coins

Keep a screenshot of UI Online showing the payment amount EDD processed. Having that number on hand when you call Money Network makes it clear exactly how much should be on the card, which helps their fraud team.

0 coins

Adjudication hold on my claim dragged on for almost six weeks after I quit my last job - I'd told EDD it was due to unsafe working conditions and they needed to do an interview before deciding. That whole time I kept confusing the phone interview with an appeal hearing, thought I had to show up somewhere with documents. The DE 4800 that EDD mailed me had the interview date and time printed on it and said the interviewer would phone at that specific time, so I just had to keep my phone nearby. EDD sent my payments for the pending weeks after they decided in my favor. Completely separate from your card issue, but pending weeks and card fraud can both eat into your money fast - Claimyr got me to an EDD agent when I needed to confirm my interview had been rescheduled after I missed the first one.

0 coins

The phone interview vs. appeal hearing confusion is so common. An appeal is filed after you get a denial - the DE 1000M form or a written letter within 30 days of the Notice of Determination. The phone interview is just EDD gathering information before they decide anything.

0 coins

Exactly - I thought an appeal was just a fancier interview at first. The Notice of Determination is what tells you there's been a decision, and only after that does the 30-day appeal window open.

0 coins

Good to know the difference - I've been seeing 'adjudication' in comments around here and wasn't sure if that meant my situation needed an interview or not. Mine was a straightforward layoff so hopefully no interview required.

0 coins

Pay stub from my last employer showed a CASDI deduction and for a while I thought that meant I'd paid into unemployment insurance directly, so I assumed EDD had to fix any payment discrepancy personally. Turned out the CASDI deduction covers State Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave, not unemployment - employers pay the UI tax separately and nothing comes out of your paycheck for unemployment specifically. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent about an overpayment notice I'd gotten, and while I was on with her I also asked about card discrepancies - she was clear that the card side is Money Network's department entirely.

0 coins

The CASDI vs. UI tax thing confused me too. Workers don't pay into unemployment insurance - that's the employer's side. So chasing EDD for a card refund because you feel like you're owed it from your contributions doesn't work - EDD sends the money to the card, card issues are Money Network's.

0 coins

Right, and the overpayment notice ended up being a data entry error on a week I'd reported wages - the agent walked me through what the system showed and it got resolved. Completely separate from the card situation but good to know who handles what.

0 coins

Lots of people assume wages withheld from their checks funded their unemployment, so they think EDD is the right place to dispute everything money-related. The employer's contribution structure doesn't really come up anywhere obvious until someone digs into it.

0 coins

Skimmed this thread looking for the same answer about my own card situation and want to add: when you file a fraud dispute with Money Network, ask specifically whether the disputed transactions came from an online purchase (card-not-present) or a physical terminal. That distinction can tell you whether someone skimmed your number remotely or if the card was compromised at a physical reader. Online unauthorized charges are extremely common with prepaid debit cards because the number alone is enough to make a purchase.

0 coins

Both transactions look like they were online purchases based on the merchant names - no physical store, both digital services I've never heard of. So sounds like skimming or phishing got my card number.

0 coins

Digital service charges are almost always card-not-present fraud. Someone got the number, the expiration and the CVV somehow - could be from any site you've used the card on, not necessarily an ATM skimmer. Money Network will ask you to list transactions you recognize, and everything else becomes the dispute.

0 coins

Prepaid card numbers can also get exposed in data breaches on retail sites. Worth checking if any accounts you've used that card for sent breach notifications recently.

0 coins

Certification schedule getting thrown off is another thing that can make your card balance look wrong in a confusing way. EDD pays out in two-week blocks after each certification, so if you certified and then certified again before the first payment fully posted, the balances from two separate payment events can overlap and make you think something's missing when it's just processing timing. UI Online updates payment info daily and the EDD phone line at 1-866-333-4606 has payment information 24 hours a day if you need to check without logging in.

0 coins

Checked 1-866-333-4606 and it confirmed the same amount UI Online shows - EDD released $392, only $212 is on the card. So timing isn't the issue here, actual money is gone.

0 coins

That confirmation from the automated line is exactly the kind of paper trail to have. Write down the date and time you called and what it said - useful if Money Network asks for documentation of what EDD shows on their end.

0 coins

Good point about the two-week payment cycle. First certification usually covers the waiting week (unpaid) plus one paid week, so the first payout often looks smaller than expected even without any fraud involved.

0 coins

Waiting week tripped me up hard on my first claim - thought the first certification paid two weeks but only saw one week's worth land on the card and panicked. The waiting week is the first eligible week of a claim and it's unpaid. After that the first week of actual benefits processes. So if someone's weekly benefit amount is $310, the first card deposit would be $310 not $620, even if the certification covered two weeks. Has nothing to do with fraud.

0 coins

Mine cleared the waiting week in my first certification - UI Online shows $392 paid which lines up with one week at my benefit amount. The issue is the $180 that disappeared from the card after that, not the initial amount.

0 coins

Got it - so the waiting week already passed and the amount EDD sent is correct. Pure card fraud then. Hope Money Network makes it right quickly.

0 coins

Waiting week confusion causes so much unnecessary panic. Good that it's already sorted in this thread before someone ran with the wrong explanation.

0 coins

Direct deposit is an option on California EDD claims - you can switch from the Money Network card to direct deposit into a bank account through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/. If you're worried about the card being compromised going forward, switching to direct deposit into a bank you already trust and monitor closely might be worth considering. Can't take back the transactions that already happened but you can protect future payments.

0 coins

Switching to direct deposit is actually a great idea - hadn't thought of that as a next step. Dispute the missing money with Money Network, then switch future payments to my own bank account where I already have fraud alerts set up.

0 coins

Exactly the move. Once you have the dispute open with Money Network, changing the payment method in myEDD is straightforward. Payments going to a monitored account with your existing bank gives you a lot more visibility.

0 coins

Direct deposit also means UI Online payment info still updates daily, so you're not losing any tracking ability by moving off the card. Same confirmation tools, just the money ends up somewhere you're more familiar with managing.

0 coins

Overpayment concerns sometimes come up in situations like this - people worry that if they dispute card fraud EDD will think they're trying to claim money they already received. For the record, disputing an unauthorized transaction isn't an overpayment situation. An overpayment under EDD's rules is when benefits are paid to a claimant who wasn't eligible for them - card fraud is the opposite, it's money that was paid to you but then taken without your authorization. Those are completely different things and disputing card fraud doesn't trigger any EDD overpayment process.

0 coins

Had that exact worry in the back of my head - glad someone addressed it directly. Contacting Money Network for fraud is not telling EDD I want extra money.

0 coins

Right. And just to close the loop on the EDD side: once Money Network investigates and finds the transactions unauthorized, the funds come back to your card. EDD sees that as the card dispute resolving, not as an additional payment from their system.

0 coins

EDD overpayment notices come from EDD directly - there's a whole process with a Notice of Overpayment and 30-day appeal window. A Money Network card dispute is entirely outside that process and doesn't generate any EDD paperwork.

0 coins

PIN security on the EDD Money Network card is easy to overlook. If someone got your card number and also somehow got your PIN - maybe from a skimmer that also had a camera, or from somewhere you wrote it down - they could potentially make ATM withdrawals even without the physical card at some terminals. When you call Money Network to dispute the transactions, ask them specifically how the transactions were authenticated: PIN, signature, or card number only. That answer tells you a lot about how the fraud happened.

0 coins

Both transactions were described as online purchases so I don't think the PIN was involved - those don't require a PIN. But I'm going to change it anyway when I call Money Network.

0 coins

Smart to change it regardless. And if the transactions were card-not-present online purchases, that actually improves your dispute position because there's no PIN or signature that could be used to argue you authorized them.

0 coins

Card-not-present fraud is generally easier to dispute than in-person transactions. Online merchant transactions without 3D Secure authentication leave the card issuer more liable, which is in your favor.

0 coins

Reached out through the message option in UI Online about a wage reporting question on my claim once and got a response within a couple of business days. For the card situation specifically it won't help since EDD can't touch Money Network's system, but for any EDD-side questions like confirming payment amounts or checking your claim for open issues, the UI Online message option is cleaner than sitting on hold.

0 coins

Good to know the UI Online message option works for EDD questions - I'll use that if I need to confirm anything on the EDD side after I deal with Money Network directly.

0 coins

The message goes through your account so they can see your claim details when they respond, which speeds things up compared to calling and reading off your info.

0 coins

Live chat through the Help button in UI Online is another option on weekdays between 9 and 2. Faster than waiting for a message reply if you have a quick EDD question.

0 coins

Work search requirements don't pause because of a card fraud situation - worth remembering while dealing with all this. Each week you certify, you have to be able to work, available for work, and looking for work. The card issue doesn't change that, and if you let certifications slip while chasing down the fraud dispute you could end up with gaps in your claim.

0 coins

Good reminder - been so focused on the money problem that I almost forgot the certification is coming up. Going to get that done on schedule regardless of where the dispute is.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration and resume also need to be in order - the DE 8405 gives you a deadline from when you filed, and payments can stop if that lapses. Worth double-checking if you haven't already.

0 coins

Certifying every two weeks is one of those things that slips when people are stressed about other claim problems. Clock doesn't stop ticking on the work search requirement just because something else is happening.

0 coins

Ask EDD, EDD's online contact form at edd.ca.gov, is useful for getting a written record of questions you've sent to EDD - not for the card dispute, but for anything where you want documentation that you contacted EDD about an issue on a certain date. If down the road someone questions whether you reported a problem, having a timestamped Ask EDD submission helps.

0 coins

Using Ask EDD to document that I'm aware of the payment discrepancy and confirmed EDD released the correct amount - good thinking for protecting myself.

0 coins

Exactly. And if there's ever an overpayment question later, having a paper trail showing you flagged an issue immediately works in your favor.

0 coins

Ask EDD also auto-generates a confirmation number. Screenshot or write that down along with the date - gives you something concrete to reference if EDD ever needs to look it up.

0 coins

Pension or retirement income is something some people on EDD claims miss reporting - if you have any coming in while collecting UI benefits, it may reduce your weekly payment and EDD decides the adjustment. Completely separate from your card situation but I saw someone upstream mention money coming in from multiple places and wanted to flag it. Social Security benefits are not deducted and don't get reported, but other pensions may matter.

0 coins

No pension - I'm 31 and this was a warehouse job. No retirement income to worry about. But good general info for the thread.

0 coins

Makes sense, just throwing it out there since it trips people up sometimes. Good luck with the Money Network dispute - hope they get your $180 back fast.

0 coins

Social Security not being reportable or deductible surprises a lot of people. The list of what does get reported is pretty long - wages, vacation pay, severance, workers' comp - but Social Security is specifically not on it.

0 coins

Appeals process is different from the initial adjudication and I want to flag a thing I see confused in this thread and others - adjudication just means EDD is evaluating eligibility, usually because there's an open question about why you stopped working. The appeal is a formal step that only happens after EDD mails a Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) saying you don't qualify. If you disagree with that decision, you have 30 days from the mailing date to file an appeal using DE 1000M or a written letter sent to the address on the notice. No denial notice means no appeal yet.

0 coins

Had that exact mix-up on my own claim - thought any delay in payment meant I had to appeal. Adjudication is EDD working through the question, an appeal is what comes after a denial decision on paper.

0 coins

Right. And filing an appeal before receiving a Notice of Determination doesn't do anything useful - there's no decision yet to appeal. The DE 1080CZ is what starts that 30-day clock.

0 coins

Also important: keep certifying even during an appeal. EDD can only pay back weeks that were certified - if you stop certifying while waiting for an appeal outcome you lose those weeks permanently.

0 coins

Form 1099G for California EDD benefits lands in UI Online by January 31 of the following year under Payments, then Form 1099G. It covers the total benefits paid to you, which will include whatever amounts EDD released to your card - including the weeks where the card was later compromised. If Money Network reverses the fraudulent transactions, the 1099G won't reflect that because EDD records their payment as sent. The tax question for recovered fraud funds can be nuanced so worth keeping your dispute documentation for tax time.

0 coins

Had not thought at all about the tax angle. So even if Money Network gives me back the $180, EDD's 1099G will show the full amount as income because EDD released it. I'll keep all my dispute documentation for my tax preparer.

0 coins

California state income tax doesn't apply to unemployment benefits anyway, but the federal taxable income piece is real. Keep everything - Money Network case number, dispute confirmation, whatever they send you in writing.

0 coins

EDD also lets you opt into 10 percent federal withholding at each certification which some people use to avoid a tax surprise later. Worth knowing if you're not already doing it.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure