Should I attend unemployment appeal hearing after finding a new job? California EDD question
So here's my situation - I got laid off from my marketing coordinator position back in August, filed my claim, and EDD eventually denied my benefits saying something about misconduct even though I was absolutely laid off, not fired for cause. I appealed it and the CUIAB scheduled a hearing for next month. Meanwhile I managed to land a new job two weeks ago and I start full time next Monday. Here's the thing that's been eating at me - there were about 11 weeks between when I got laid off and when I started this new position where I was certifying and got nothing because of the denial. If I win the appeal those weeks could potentially get paid out. But my new employer is kind of strict about time off and I'm nervous about asking for time off during my second week there to attend an administrative law judge hearing, especially since I'll be in my probation period. Does attending the hearing even matter at this point since I have income now? Like does the fact that I found a new job somehow affect what happens with the back weeks I already certified for? I'm honestly not sure if it's worth the possible awkwardness with my new job over a hearing for benefits from months ago. Anyone dealt with this before?
75 comments

Haley Stokes
DE 1000M on my denial letter said 30 days to appeal and I almost missed that window scrambling to find work at the same time - so you did the right thing filing when you did. To answer your actual question though: getting a new job has zero effect on those back weeks you're appealing. You were unemployed during those weeks, you certified, and if the judge decides EDD was wrong to deny you, they pay those weeks. The appeal is about whether you qualified back then, not about where you are now. The hearing is absolutely worth attending. An administrative law judge hearing where you don't show up almost always goes badly - the judge decides from whatever EDD and the employer already submitted, and you lose your chance to give your own testimony.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorThat's a relief to hear about the back weeks. I was genuinely worried finding work somehow 'cancelled out' whatever I might be owed. So if I skip the hearing it basically defaults to EDD's version of events?
0 coins
Haley Stokes
Pretty much exactly that. The judge takes testimony under oath from whoever shows up, and if that's just the employer's side, the picture they paint is the only one on record.
0 coins
Asher Levin
Same thing happened with my appeal timing, almost missed the 30 days too. The mailing date on the Notice of Determination is what the clock starts from, not when you actually receive it - learned that the hard way.
0 coins
Serene Snow
Missed my own CUIAB hearing two years ago because I thought since I'd found part time work it 'wasn't worth it anymore.' Lost $2,800 in certified weeks I'll never get back. The hearing takes maybe an hour, the back pay if you win covers weeks you already lived through without income. Show up.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
$2,800 is a lot to walk away from. Did you try to reschedule or was it just done at that point?
0 coins
Serene Snow
Once you no-show without contacting them beforehand it's basically done. The notice they mailed me had a number to call if I needed to reschedule but I convinced myself it wasn't worth dealing with.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
Rescheduling before the hearing date is definitely the move if the timing is impossible. But skipping entirely with no contact is almost never recoverable.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
My appeal was scheduled during the same stretch where I was starting at a new company last spring - a retail management job, so the schedule was locked tight my first few weeks. The Notice of Hearing that came by mail had the exact date and a number to request a different time, and I called EDD about it because I needed to know whether my new start date would affect the weeks I was fighting for. Claimyr (claimyr.com) was how I actually reached a live EDD agent - I'd burned two full mornings trying the phone line with nothing. There's a video they put out showing how reaching a live person at EDD by phone actually works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my case and confirmed the appeal covers only the weeks I was out of work and already certified - my new job didn't touch any of that. She also told me to contact the Office of Appeals directly about the hearing date if the conflict with my new employer was real, because EDD and the CUIAB are separate.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorEDD and the CUIAB being separate is something I did not know - I'd been trying to figure out who to even call about rescheduling. So the actual hearing date is set by the Office of Appeals, not EDD?
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
Exactly - the Notice of Hearing has the Office of Appeals contact on it. EDD handles the claim side, the CUIAB handles the hearing itself. Two different places to call.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
That separation trips up a lot of people. EDD can tell you what's on your claim but they can't move a CUIAB hearing date. The notice itself has what you need.
0 coins
Alana Willis
Good to know there's another way to reach someone when the phone line is a dead end. I've been leaving messages through UI Online but haven't heard anything in over a week.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
The probation period concern is real but maybe smaller than it feels right now. Most employers, even strict ones, aren't going to know why you need a couple hours off in your second week - 'a prior legal commitment I need to handle' is a completely normal thing to say. Administrative law judge hearings often run under two hours. The math is pretty simple: a few hours of potential awkwardness versus losing the entire payout from 11 weeks of certified claims.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorPrior legal' commitment is honestly perfect. I was overthinking how'I d even explainit.
0 coins
Sara Unger
Hearings are also sometimes held by phone now depending on the judge and the case, which removes the whole time-off issue entirely. Worth asking the Office of Appeals when you contact them about the schedule.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
Phone hearings have been more common since they modernized the process. Definitely worth asking - the notice usually says the format but it can sometimes be changed by request.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
Something I want to flag about the certification piece: you said you kept certifying during the denial period. That's exactly right and it's what makes those weeks payable if you win. Keep certifying through your appeal even now that you're working - for the weeks you've already certified while unemployed, those are locked in as the weeks the appeal covers. Any week you're working full time now you wouldn't certify for anyway.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorI did keep certifying through the denial - read somewhere that you have to do that or the weeks can't be paid back even if you win. Good to know I did that part correctly at least.
0 coins
Freya Ross
A lot of people stop certifying when they get denied thinking it's pointless. Then they win the appeal and find out there's nothing to pay because the weeks were never certified. Always keep certifying through an appeal.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
Exactly - EDD can only issue back pay on weeks that exist in the system as certified weeks. No certification, no payment, even with a winning decision from the judge.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
What I don't get about your situation is why EDD called it misconduct when you were laid off. Like did your employer tell them something different when they responded to the claim? Because that's usually where the disconnect happens - employer says one thing, you said another, EDD goes with the employer's version since you weren't there to push back during their interview.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorThat's exactly what I think happened. My old company was being weird about the whole situation and I think they characterized the separation differently than it actually was. The hearing is basically my shot to give my own account of what happened.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
Then showing up is not optional for you. The whole point of the appeal is that the employer couldn't prove misconduct - EDD's own standard is that if you're fired, the employer has to show it was misconduct. You telling your side to the judge is the whole appeal.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
EDD's rule is that if you get fired, the employer has to prove misconduct happened. The appeal hearing is literally the place where you can make that case if EDD got it wrong the first time. Not showing up means only the employer's account is on record.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
Eleven weeks of certified weeks is not nothing - even at a mid-range weekly benefit amount that's real money you're entitled to if the judge agrees EDD wrongly denied you. Skipping a hearing over new-job nerves when that much back pay is on the table is the thing you'd regret.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
Weekly benefit amounts run up to $450 for California EDD, so depending on what the OP qualified for 11 weeks could be anywhere from a few hundred to close to five thousand dollars. Worth a couple hours in front of a judge.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
Right - and the amount was set when the claim was filed based on base period wages. Finding a new job now doesn't change what the weekly amount was for those back weeks.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorWhen you put it that way in actual dollar terms it really crystallizes why I need to just go. I think I've been letting the new job anxiety make me doubt something that's actually straightforward.
0 coins
Amy Fleming
Timing on my own appeal was a mess - the Notice of Hearing came about two weeks before my scheduled date and I'd already started a new position, similar to yours. Tried calling EDD's main line about the case status and couldn't get through. Ended up using Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line, who confirmed what was already in my claim file so I understood exactly what documentation I needed to bring to the hearing. I went, presented my termination paperwork, and the judge ruled in my favor three weeks later.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorThe documentation angle is something I hadn't thought enough about. What kind of paperwork actually matters to bring?
0 coins
Amy Fleming
Anything showing the layoff was not for misconduct - an official layoff notice if you have one, any emails about position elimination or company downsizing, your performance reviews if they were positive. Basically whatever counters whatever your employer told EDD.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Pay stubs from that employer can help too if the case touches on what you earned during the base period, and your original separation paperwork. The judge tells you at the start what's already in the record so you know what you're working with.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
My cousin went to her appeal hearing while she was already working at a new place and won back pay for 8 weeks - she told me the judge explicitly said it doesn't matter what your current employment status is, the question is what your status was during the weeks being appealed. I know that's just one case but it's consistent with what others here are saying.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
That's the right rule - the appeal covers whether you qualified during those specific weeks, not your situation now. Current employment is irrelevant to that question.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
Yeah she was worried the new job would somehow disqualify her from the back pay and it didn't come up at all in the hearing.
0 coins
Esteban Tate
PLEASE GO TO THE HEARING. I know starting a new job feels fragile and you don't want to rock anything but listen - you have a legitimate wrongful denial case if what you're describing is accurate. The administrative law judge hearing is the entire point of the appeal system. The whole thing exists because EDD gets things wrong sometimes and you deserve a fair shot at correcting it.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorThe 'EDD gets things wrong sometimes' part is kind of what I needed to hear honestly. I've been second-guessing myself like maybe I'm missing something obvious about why I shouldn't bother.
0 coins
Esteban Tate
EDD processed a denial based partly on what your employer told them and you never got to respond to that directly. The hearing is literally your first real chance to do that.
0 coins
Asher Levin
Testimony is under oath at these hearings, which is worth knowing before you go. Write down exactly what happened with your layoff while it's still fairly fresh - dates, who told you, what they said, any documentation you have. The judge is an administrative law judge, not someone from EDD, so they're genuinely independent.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
The independence piece matters. CUIAB judges aren't EDD employees deciding in EDD's favor - they're reviewing whether EDD applied the rules correctly.
0 coins
Asher Levin
Exactly. And they can represent themselves, have an attorney, or have a union rep there if they have one. No requirement to show up alone.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorCan anyone attend with me for support or does it have to be someone with an official role? I'd feel better having someone there even if they just sit there.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
About attending with support: the rules say anyone can represent the claimant at the hearing. That could mean an attorney, a union official, or just someone helping you organize your presentation. Someone sitting with you for moral support isn't an official role but nothing prevents it - ask the Office of Appeals when you contact them about the specific format.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorThat makes me feel a lot better. Even having someone there to keep me calm would help since I've never done anything like this before.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
First hearings are always a little nerve-wracking. The judge usually walks through how testimony will work at the start, so you'll have a moment to settle in before it gets into the actual questions.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
The Notice of Hearing that was mailed to you has the hearing date, time, format (phone or in person), and the Office of Appeals address and number on it. That's your document for everything - not EDD's main line, not UI Online. If you need to request a time change, contact the Office of Appeals directly using what's on that notice, and do it well before the hearing date.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
This is exactly right - the notice is the thing to hold onto. Everything about the hearing logistics comes from the Office of Appeals, not from EDD itself.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
And the hearing format matters for your planning - phone hearings mean you can literally call in from your car during a lunch break without taking any formal time off from the new job.
0 coins
Freya Ross
For anyone reading this in a similar spot - work search is still a topic that comes up during the appeal if the denial has anything to do with availability. Keep records of job applications during the appeal period. For the OP's situation it's a misconduct question not a work search question, but just flagging it since appeals cover whatever the original denial was about.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
Good point about appeal scope. The hearing only covers the reason for the original denial - if EDD denied for misconduct that's what the judge is evaluating, not unrelated eligibility questions.
0 coins
Freya Ross
Right - the OP's hearing is specifically about whether the employer proved misconduct. That's the whole record. New job, current income, none of that is relevant to that question.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
My denial was also a misconduct call that I thought was completely wrong - worked in a warehouse, got laid off in a facility reduction, and EDD somehow decided it was a firing for cause based on something my old employer said in their response. Filed the appeal, had the hearing coming up around the same time I landed something new. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent because the main line was impossible during the week I had questions about what documentation was already in my file. The agent confirmed what documents EDD had submitted so I knew exactly what I was walking into. Went to the hearing, judge ruled for me, got the back pay deposited about four weeks after the decision came through.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorFour weeks from the judge's decision to actual deposit is really helpful to know timeline-wise. And knowing what EDD already submitted before you walked in sounds like a real advantage.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
The judge reads you what's in the record at the start of the hearing anyway, but knowing beforehand let me prepare the right counter-documents instead of scrambling.
0 coins
Alana Willis
The warehouse layoff situation where the employer frames it differently sounds almost identical to what the OP is describing. Glad you went and glad it worked out.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
For the actual hearing day - print everything twice, get there or get on the phone line a few minutes early, and have a simple clear narrative of your layoff ready to give in a few sentences. Administrative law judges run a lot of these hearings and they appreciate when claimants can state their situation clearly and directly without a long preamble.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
The 'clear narrative in a few sentences' advice is gold. The judge has read the file already - you're not explaining from scratch, you're responding to the specific reason EDD gave for the denial.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
Exactly - anchor everything back to why the employer's misconduct claim doesn't hold up. That's the standard they had to meet and apparently didn't, based on what the OP is describing.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
Just want to address the new job anxiety one more time because I think it's distorting how the OP is thinking about this. Starting a new job doesn't mean you forfeit rights you already have from a previous situation. Those 11 weeks happened. You certified them. You appealed a decision you think was wrong. Those facts don't disappear because you found work. The appeal is about what happened then, not what's happening now.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorThis is a good reframe. I think I was treating the new job like a fresh start that somehow meant I had to leave the old situation behind, but legally those are just two separate things.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
Completely separate tracks. EDD's appeal system exists precisely so claimants can get a fair review. You're using it exactly as intended.
0 coins
Esteban Tate
New employment during a pending appeal is actually pretty common - people can't just stop job searching while waiting for hearings. The CUIAB sees this regularly.
0 coins
Sara Unger
Missed payment period on my own appeal dragged out six weeks before the hearing, and I was counting on those funds to cover a gap between jobs. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD while the appeal was pending because I had a specific question about whether my certified weeks were still in the system properly - been a while since I'd checked UI Online and wanted to confirm nothing had fallen off. The agent said all my certified weeks were showing in Claim History. Went to my hearing and the judge covered exactly those weeks in the decision.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorChecking that certified weeks are still showing properly in Claim History before the hearing is something I hadn't thought to do. Good practical step.
0 coins
Sara Unger
UI Online Claim History shows the status on each certified week. If anything looked off before the hearing I would have had time to flag it.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
Smart move to verify before walking into the hearing. Knowing your certified weeks are in the system correctly means you can focus on the misconduct question itself rather than worrying about the paperwork side.
0 coins
Alana Willis
Following this thread because my appeal is also scheduled while I've already returned to part-time work. Really reassuring to see that the back weeks are evaluated based on what happened during those weeks, not based on current status. Going to call the Office of Appeals to ask about the format before my hearing date.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
Part-time work during the appeal period is worth flagging - for the weeks you're working part time now, report earnings accurately when you certify. For the back weeks from before that are part of your appeal, those were certified already and are what the judge will cover.
0 coins
Alana Willis
My appeal is specifically about weeks before I started the part-time work, so the structure sounds the same as what the OP described. Good to know the current part-time situation doesn't muddy it.
0 coins
Freya Ross
For part-time weeks going forward, California EDD's earnings rule means the first $25 or 25 percent of gross weekly earnings, whichever is more, isn't counted against your benefit - the rest reduces what you get paid that week. Keep reporting every week accurately.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
Final practical note: once the judge issues a written decision in your favor, any back pay for weeks you certified gets processed. It doesn't come instantly but it's not months either - typically a few weeks after the written decision is mailed to you. Make sure your payment method in myEDD is still current since your old direct deposit or Money Network card info should still be on file from when you were actively certifying.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
AuthorHadn't thought about whether my payment info was still active after all these months. I'll log in and check that before the hearing so if I win it doesn't sit in limbo waiting on outdated info.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
UI Online at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is where your payment preference shows. Worth a quick check - and it's also where you can confirm all your previously certified weeks are showing in Claim History the way you expect.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
Good call verifying it ahead of time. Winning an appeal and then having a payment delay for a fixable reason would be an aggravating way to end what sounds like an already frustrating situation.
0 coins