Back to California Unemployment

Dylan Fisher

Refile ineligible not enough earnings payments disqualified on old claim - California EDD help

So I'm stuck in a really confusing situation with California EDD and I need to figure out what my options are. My original claim from last year got disqualified partway through - EDD decided I didn't have enough earnings in my base period to keep it valid after they did some kind of review. The payments I already received got flagged and now the whole claim is showing as ineligible. I work in event coordination and my income was pretty inconsistent last year with a lot of gigs being short-term contracts, so the quarterly wages were all over the place. What I'm trying to understand is whether I can refile a new unemployment claim at all, or if the disqualification on my old claim blocks me from starting fresh. My benefit year on that old claim ended a few months ago, so technically it's not active anymore. But I'm unemployed again now - my last gig contract wrapped up in October and I haven't been able to land anything consistent since then. I've been trying to get answers through UI Online messages but nothing is coming back. Has anyone been through something like this where their old claim had eligibility problems and they needed to start over? Did you end up being able to refile? What did EDD actually tell you about whether the disqualification carries over to a new claim?

Last October my gig contract ended too and I went through almost the exact same thing - disqualified on old claim, payments flagged, wasn't sure if I could even start fresh. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is how I got an EDD agent on the phone after the UI Online message system left me hanging for weeks. The video Claimyr has on reaching a live person at EDD walked me through what to expect: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I asked the agent whether my old disqualification for insufficient earnings would block a new filing, and she pulled up my record and said the benefit year had closed out, so I was clear to apply again under a new base period. She also told me which quarters EDD would look at for the new claim and confirmed the old flagged payments were a separate issue being handled through a notice. Filed the same week and got my DE 429Z in about two weeks showing my new weekly amount.

0 coins

DE 429Z came and showed a valid weekly amount - that's genuinely the clearest sign a new claim has legs. Good to know the old disqualification didn't automatically carry over. I'm in a similar boat and have been terrified to refile.

0 coins

Really appreciate the detail on what the agent actually said. The base period being different for a new claim is what I figured but couldn't confirm anywhere. Did you have any issues with the old overpayment or flagged payments coming up during the new application process?

0 coins

The agent said the flagged payments from the old claim were tracked separately and wouldn't stop the new application from going through. I did get a Notice of Overpayment later for one of those weeks, which I had to deal with on its own.

0 coins

Whether your old claim's disqualification follows you to a new one is actually the right question to put to EDD directly, because the answer depends entirely on what kind of disqualification it was. If it was just an insufficiency issue - meaning EDD found your base period wages didn't meet the threshold - that's not a fraud disqualification and it doesn't automatically block future claims. It just means that particular claim was invalid from the start. A new claim starts fresh with a completely new base period: the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you file the new one. Your gig income from recent quarters, if it's higher or more evenly distributed now, might actually give you a valid claim this time around. The minimum to watch for is $1,300 in one quarter, or at least $900 in your best quarter with total base period wages at 1.25 times that. EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site can give you a rough estimate before you even apply.

0 coins

My recent quarters actually have more consistent income than the period that got disqualified, so that's encouraging. The base period shifting forward makes sense - I just didn't know if the disqualification itself was some kind of permanent mark.

0 coins

The 1.25 times calculation tripped me up when I was first looking at this. For anyone confused: if your best quarter had $900, your total base period wages need to be at least $1,125. EDD's calculator on their site makes this easier to check.

0 coins

Honestly didn't realize a disqualification for insufficient earnings was different from one for misconduct or fraud. I always thought any disqualification was basically a permanent black mark. Good clarification.

0 coins

November is when my own last gig ended and I had almost this exact panic. My old claim had been marked ineligible after an earnings review and I thought I was totally locked out. What actually helped me was going into UI Online and looking at my Claim History to see when my benefit year officially ended. Once that date had passed, I just applied again through myEDD as if it were my first claim. EDD processed it under a completely different base period and I never got any pushback about the old ineligible status. The first certification covered the waiting week plus one paid week and I got paid within two days after that.

0 coins

Seeing it in Claim History to confirm the year closed - that's what I should do first before even attempting to refile. I'll check that today.

0 coins

The benefit year closing is the key thing. The confusion I see a lot is people trying to reopen an old claim instead of filing fresh. If the year is done, it's a new application entirely.

0 coins

UI Online sometimes shows old claim info in a confusing way even after the year closes. If the status still looks weird, applying anyway usually works since EDD reads the new base period independently.

0 coins

Something worth flagging: the disqualification on the old claim could mean different things and it changes what you need to do. If EDD determined the claim was just invalid due to earnings - which sounds like your case - there's no penalty period that bleeds into a new filing. But if EDD issued a false statement disqualification or a fraud finding at any point, that actually carries a penalty that runs for a set number of weeks and can affect a new claim. Worth reading the Notice of Determination you got on the old claim very carefully to understand which category it fell into. The notice should say if there's a disqualification period and how long it runs.

0 coins

Mine definitely says insufficient earnings, not fraud or false statement. So I think I'm in the clear on that front. I'll reread the notice to make sure there's no penalty language hiding in it.

0 coins

Had a fraud disqualification once from an error I made - the penalty weeks were brutal to work through. The insufficient earnings situation is completely different and way less complicated to move past.

0 coins

The Notice of Determination wording is so dense it's easy to miss the important parts. Looking for the word 'penalty' and 'weeks' in close proximity is a quick scan to know if there's a disqualification period.

0 coins

Filing that new claim, the agent I reached confirmed something I didn't expect: the alternate base period option exists specifically for people whose standard base period doesn't have enough wages. EDD files it automatically if your standard base period doesn't produce a valid claim, using the last four completed quarters instead. I'd been scrambling to figure out which quarters to reference when I used Claimyr to get through to someone at EDD and spoke with an agent about my own refiling question. She looked at my wage history and said EDD would try the standard base period first, and only use the alternate if needed to make the claim valid. I'd assumed I had to request the alternate manually, but it's automatic.

0 coins

Didn't know the alternate base period was automatic and not something I had to ask for. That's a relief because I was worried about which quarters would even count for me given how irregular my gig income was.

0 coins

Correct on the automatic part. The alternate base period pulls in the most recent quarters, which often helps people with gig or seasonal work since recent earnings are more likely to reflect current income. EDD doesn't offer it if the standard base period already makes the claim valid, though - it's not a tool to get a higher benefit amount.

0 coins

EDD not letting you use the alternate to boost your amount when you're already valid is something a lot of people get wrong. Useful to have it spelled out clearly here.

0 coins

The gig economy situation with EDD is genuinely rough because the quarterly income swings are so dramatic. One quarter you're billing $8,000 and the next it's $1,100 and EDD's formula doesn't understand the nature of that work. I went through a whole cycle where my claim kept running into eligibility questions because of a quarter where I was between contracts. The alternate base period ended up being what saved my claim. If you've had any steadier gig income in the more recent quarters, the new base period timing might actually work in your favor.

0 coins

Q3 this year was actually decent for me - better than the quarters that caused the original problem. So shifting to a new base period that includes that quarter could genuinely help.

0 coins

Gig income being lumpy is exactly why the base period timing matters so much. Filing at the right time of year can swing whether you have a valid claim at all. If Q3 was strong, filing now rather than waiting is probably the right call.

0 coins

WAIT - does refiling mean losing the appeal rights on the old disqualification? I'm panicking a little because I thought you could appeal the original decision and potentially get those old weeks paid. If you just refile and move on, do you give up the right to fight the old claim?

0 coins

Appealing an old decision and filing a new claim are completely separate processes. You can do both. The appeal on the old claim would be about those specific weeks and that specific disqualification - filing a new claim doesn't waive any appeal rights you have. The window to appeal is 30 calendar days from the mailing date on the Notice of Determination, so if that window is still open, file the written appeal and also apply fresh at the same time if you're currently unemployed.

0 coins

DE 1000M form in front of me right now and the mailing date was three weeks ago so I'm still in the window. Going to submit the appeal AND refile. Didn't know I could do both at the same time.

0 coins

The appeal and new claim being parallel tracks is not obvious from anything EDD mails you. Good to have it said clearly.

0 coins

Quick thing I want to add about certifying: if you do appeal the old disqualification, keep certifying for those old weeks through the appeal process. EDD can only pay back weeks you certified for. I didn't know this when I first appealed something and I lost out on weeks I could have been paid for because I stopped certifying while I waited. For the new claim once you refile, that's a fresh certification cycle starting from scratch.

0 coins

This is exactly what I needed to hear. I stopped certifying on my old claim when it got disqualified because I figured there was no point. Is it too late to certify those back weeks now?

0 coins

If the benefit year on the old claim has closed, those back weeks are probably not certifiable anymore through the standard process. That's a question to ask EDD directly - there may be nothing that can be done, or there may be an exception process. I'd phone EDD to ask.

0 coins

The lesson about not stopping certifications during an appeal is something I wish someone had told me earlier in this whole mess.

0 coins

My situation was a little different - I got disqualified mid-claim because EDD found out about some side work I hadn't reported properly, not an earnings insufficiency issue. Had to pay back about $2,100 in benefits. I eventually refiled when my benefit year was done and EDD processed my new claim without any extra hurdles from the overpayment still being outstanding. The overpayment and the new claim went through separate channels. Sharing because I was scared the outstanding debt would stop my new claim cold.

0 coins

An outstanding overpayment not stopping a new claim from being processed is really useful to know. I'd assumed EDD would just refuse to pay anything new until the old debt was cleared.

0 coins

EDD eventually offset some of my new benefit payments to collect on the overpayment, but the new claim itself went through. So I was getting reduced payments rather than nothing.

0 coins

The flagged payments on my old claim are small enough that an offset situation would be manageable. Good to know that's the more likely outcome than a full block on a new claim.

0 coins

For anyone refiling after an ineligible claim, CalJOBS registration is worth getting ahead of. When I refiled, the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work showed up pretty fast and I had 21 days to get my CalJOBS profile and resume posted. The first time around I nearly missed it and that would have stopped my payments. The site is caljobs.ca.gov and it links to your EDD claim.

0 coins

CalJOBS catching people off guard on a refile is super common. First time you file you hear about it. Second time you assume you're already registered and forget the new claim triggers the requirement fresh.

0 coins

My CalJOBS account from the old claim was still active, so I just had to update my resume and confirm the profile was current. Took about 20 minutes total.

0 coins

The 21-day window sounds long but it goes fast when you're also trying to certify and track down income documents. Setting a calendar reminder the day you get the notice is worth doing.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the weekly benefit amount on a new claim gets calculated from scratch or if EDD uses whatever they had on the old claim? I'm asking because my income went up between the old claim period and now and I'm hoping the new amount would reflect that.

0 coins

Every new claim calculates the weekly benefit amount from the new base period wages, completely independent of any old claim. EDD takes your highest-paid quarter in the new base period and derives the weekly amount from that. If your income was higher in the quarters the new base period covers, your weekly amount should reflect that. The range runs $40 to $450 a week - the DE 429Z you get after filing shows what EDD calculated.

0 coins

DE 429Z is what I should look at to verify the amount once I file. And if the amount on it looks wrong I have 30 days from that mailing date to appeal it in writing?

0 coins

Exactly right on the 30-day window to appeal the DE 429Z if anything looks incorrect. That's the same form and same window as any other Notice.

0 coins

EDD's phones being impossible to reach is what's making all of this harder for people. If the UI Online message system would actually respond within a reasonable time, half these questions would be answered before people start panicking. I sent a message in September about my own refiling question and got a response 31 days later. By then I'd already figured it out myself.

0 coins

31 days for a UI Online message response is infuriating. The live chat through the Help button in UI Online is supposed to be faster but the hours are only 9 to 2 on weekdays and it fills up almost immediately.

0 coins

Live chat was my next attempt after the message response took forever. I got through twice and both times the agent was helpful but could only see what was in my file, not give me the kind of detailed wage calculation walkthrough I needed.

0 coins

The 31-day message response time is basically what I'm dealing with too. I've been sitting on a message for three weeks with nothing back. That's what's driving me here to try to piece together what I can.

0 coins

Spent two months trying to sort out whether my refile would even be valid after a disqualification on the previous claim. The hold music on EDD's main line is basically psychological warfare. Eventually I got an actual agent on the phone through Claimyr - the agent confirmed my new base period had enough wages to meet the threshold, told me which week my prior benefit year had officially ended, and said I could file immediately. Filed that afternoon and had my DE 429Z mailed within about 10 days.

0 coins

Getting the official end date on the old benefit year from an agent is exactly the kind of specific thing that's hard to find any other way. UI Online doesn't display it cleanly in my experience.

0 coins

Knowing the exact benefit year end date is something I need to confirm before I do anything else. That's the piece I've been missing. Did the agent give you that date right on the call?

0 coins

Agent pulled it up immediately from my account. Had the full picture in probably 10 minutes of actual conversation after two months of trying other ways.

0 coins

Watch out for the identity verification step when you refile. If your ID.me connection has lapsed or there's a mismatch, EDD will send a DE 1326C requesting verification and your claim just sits until it's resolved. I re-filed after my old claim ended and hit the ID.me issue right away. It delayed my first payment by almost three weeks. Verifying through ID.me before you even apply, or making sure your existing ID.me account is still linked, can save you that delay.

0 coins

ID.me account from last year is still active but I have no idea if it's still connected to EDD. Probably worth checking on that before I file.

0 coins

The ID.me connection timing out is way more common on refiles than on first applications. EDD's system seems to flag it even when the same person has verified before.

0 coins

Logging into myEDD before you file and checking whether your identity shows as verified in your profile is the fastest way to know if you'll hit that issue.

0 coins

Nobody told me when I first filed that the disqualification reason matters enormously for what happens next. I assumed all disqualifications were equal. They're not. Insufficient earnings means EDD couldn't validate your wage history - it's an administrative finding, not a conduct finding. A misconduct disqualification or a false statement finding is a whole different level and comes with a penalty period measured in weeks. If what you got was purely an earnings validity issue, you're in a much simpler position for refiling than you might think.

0 coins

EDD's paperwork does not make this distinction obvious at all. The language they use on the notices all sounds equally final.

0 coins

The difference between an administrative ineligibility and a conduct-based disqualification is real and significant. The notice type matters: a DE 1080CZ with a penalty period is a conduct finding. An award notice that never issued because wages were insufficient is a different situation. What you received should indicate which category applies.

0 coins

Paycheck I got from a part-time job during the period in question is what complicated my own claim - I'd done some W-2 temp work between gigs and EDD's base period math put me in a weird spot where I had wages but not quite enough in the right quarters. Used Claimyr to get an agent to walk me through how EDD was counting my quarters, and she told me my highest quarter came in at $1,050, which met the $900 floor but my total base period wages were only about $1,200 when they needed to be $1,125. So I was just barely valid. She said it would go through but the weekly amount would be on the lower end. Good to know rather than finding out from the DE 429Z.

0 coins

The math on the 1.25 times requirement is confusing until you see it applied to actual numbers like that. So $900 best quarter means $1,125 total needed. Got it.

0 coins

To be precise: if your highest quarter had $900 in wages, total base period wages need to be at least 1.25 times $900, which is $1,125. If your best quarter was $1,300 or more, that threshold formula doesn't apply - you're automatically valid on the first test. EDD checks both conditions and uses whichever one makes the claim valid.

0 coins

There's also the question of work search requirements once you do refile and start collecting. The requirement to look for work is active from the beginning - every week you certify you're confirming you were able to work, available for work and looking for work. The CalJOBS registration and resume posting feeds into this too. EDD doesn't publish a specific number of contacts you have to make per week on their current guidelines, but keeping your own records of where you've applied is a habit worth having.

0 coins

Record-keeping on work search was something I let slide during my first claim and it caused me anxiety even though EDD never asked me to produce anything. Second time around I kept a simple spreadsheet. Peace of mind if nothing else.

0 coins

Work search and CalJOBS are things I know I'll need to keep up with. At least those are manageable once I know the new claim is actually valid to file.

0 coins

Rereading this whole thread I keep thinking how different the experience would be if EDD just had a clear page explaining what happens when an old claim was invalid due to earnings and you want to refile. All the information exists in these comments but I had to come to a forum to find it. The official guidance on their site is so buried.

0 coins

EDD's site is designed to process claims, not to explain what all the edge cases mean for people who've already had something go wrong. The gap is real.

0 coins

edd.ca.gov has the rules but no real plain-language explanation of how they interact. What's here in this thread took a lot of people's real experiences to piece together.

0 coins

If the new claim goes through and you end up with weeks that are still pending from the new application, don't panic at the pending status right away. It usually just means EDD is still processing. Claim History in UI Online shows pending until EDD either decides eligibility or verifies something. If it's been more than a few weeks and pending weeks aren't moving, that's when it makes sense to reach out through live chat or the phone line.

0 coins

Knowing that pending is normal for the first few weeks will save me from spiraling if I see it after I file. Good to have that set as an expectation.

0 coins

Pending drove me completely crazy on my first claim. I'd refresh UI Online multiple times a day. Eventually learned that the claim was just sitting in the queue and nothing was actually wrong.

0 coins

The 24-hour update cycle in UI Online means refreshing constantly doesn't give you new information. Once a day check is about all you can usefully do.

0 coins

Last thing worth mentioning: if you are still within 30 days of the mailing date on any Notice of Determination you got about the old claim's disqualification, file a written appeal with the DE 1000M form even if you're not sure it'll succeed. Mailing it in preserves your rights. You can always withdraw an appeal if you decide not to pursue it, but you can't file one after the window closes. The appeal goes to the address on the notice. You can also refile your new claim at the same time - appealing doesn't put a hold on new filings.

0 coins

DE 1000M printed and ready to go. The mailing date window comment earlier in this thread is what pushed me to actually do it rather than just think about it.

0 coins

Appeal filed this morning. New claim going in tomorrow once I confirm the benefit year end date through Claim History. Feels like a plan finally.

0 coins

Having a plan and knowing what order to do things in is genuinely half the battle with EDD. The system is confusing but it does have rules that work in predictable ways once you understand them.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure