Back to California Unemployment

Sean Murphy

Letter says not eligible because incarcerated - what do I do with California EDD?

Got a Notice of Determination in the mail last week saying I'm not eligible for benefits and the reason listed is that I was incarcerated. I was never incarcerated. I've been working at the same warehouse job in Stockton for four years, got laid off in September when they shut down our whole distribution center, and filed my claim about three weeks after that. Everything seemed fine at first, my DE 429Z came and showed a weekly benefit amount, I certified my first two weeks, and then nothing. No payments, just Pending everywhere in UI Online Claim History. Now this letter shows up with the wrong reason entirely. Has anyone had EDD put completely wrong information on a denial like this? I'm guessing someone's Social Security number got mixed up somewhere but I honestly have no idea how to fix a mistake like this. The appeal form DE 1000M was included with the letter. Do I fill that out and send it in, or is there something faster I should be doing first?

Incarceration on the DE 429Z - wait, no, actually this happened on a Notice of Determination, right? Mine said something similar and completely wrong. The distribution center shutdown I went through last spring left my claim stuck for weeks before a denial showed up with a reason that had nothing to do with my actual layoff. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live EDD agent on the phone about it - there's a video explaining how to reach a live person at EDD that way at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me there was a flag on it from a name and SSN mismatch in EDD's system, not anything I did. She said to appeal in writing within 30 days of the mailing date on the notice using the DE 1000M, and to include a copy of my ID and a short statement saying the incarceration reason is factually incorrect. I sent the appeal the same day and kept certifying every two weeks while it was pending.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date - is that calendar days or business days? The letter is dated October 14th and I just want to make sure I'm not cutting it too close.

0 coins

Calendar days, 30 of them from the date printed on the notice. October 14th gives you until November 13th so get that DE 1000M in the mail this week to be safe.

0 coins

Keeping certifying while the appeal is open is really important here. EDD can only pay back weeks that were actually certified, so don't stop even if everything still shows Pending.

0 coins

Already certified my next two weeks this morning just to stay current. Good to know that matters for the back pay.

0 coins

Did you try calling EDD directly before the letter even came, or did you first find out through UI Online?

0 coins

UI Online just showed Pending for weeks with zero explanation. No notice, no message, nothing in my inbox. The letter showed up completely out of nowhere.

0 coins

Pending with no message is exactly how mine sat for six weeks before the denial came. EDD doesn't send anything through UI Online to warn you, it just goes straight to the mail.

0 coins

That's the part that drives people crazy - you're just sitting there watching Pending and then boom, a denial letter for a reason that makes no sense.

0 coins

The appeal is definitely the right move here, and your situation actually sounds like a stronger appeal than most because the stated reason is factually wrong rather than a judgment call. When I went through mine for a different reason, the written appeal went to EDD first for review before it got forwarded to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. With something as clear-cut as a factually incorrect disqualification reason, include any documents that prove you weren't incarcerated during the claim period - an ID, employment records, even a pay stub from your last week at the warehouse showing you were working. The more concrete the paper trail, the clearer the picture for whoever reviews it.

0 coins

Pay stubs from the warehouse - I have those for my last several months. Would a termination letter from the company count too?

0 coins

A termination letter or any layoff notice from the warehouse would actually be great to include. It shows you were employed and then laid off, which directly contradicts the incarceration reason.

0 coins

The layoff documentation is a solid point. I didn't include enough when I appealed mine and ended up having to send a follow-up packet before the hearing even got scheduled.

0 coins

Wait, so does the appeal actually go to EDD or to some separate board? I thought EDD just reviewed it themselves and sent a new letter?

0 coins

EDD reviews it first, and if that doesn't resolve it, the appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board - that's the CUIAB. An administrative law judge holds a hearing there. EDD reviews internally first though, so a clear factual error like this sometimes gets corrected before it even reaches a hearing.

0 coins

Oh okay that makes more sense. I mixed up the internal review with the hearing level. Thanks for clarifying.

0 coins

Something feels off about how you described getting the DE 429Z showing a weekly benefit amount before the denial came. I used to think that form was EDD approving your claim, but that's not actually how it works - the DE 429Z just tells you what the claim could pay if you're found eligible. It's not an approval letter, there is no approval letter. So getting it and then getting a denial later isn't a contradiction.

0 coins

That is genuinely confusing though. If you get a letter showing a dollar amount for your benefits, it really does feel like you've been approved. I totally read it that way.

0 coins

Basically everyone reads it that way at first. The letter just projects what the claim is worth based on your wages, not that EDD has decided you qualify. The eligibility decision is separate.

0 coins

I made that exact same mistake and was confused for two weeks before someone explained the difference to me. The DE 429Z is more like a potential value notice than an approval.

0 coins

Have you asked your former employer if they responded to EDD's claim notice? Sometimes when an employer says something that doesn't match what the claimant says, it creates flags in the system that lead to weird denials.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about that. The whole distribution center is shut down though - would there even be anyone left there to respond to EDD? The company still exists, it was just that one location.

0 coins

The parent company would still receive the Notice of Unemployment Insurance Claim Filed at whatever address they have on file. Worth a call to HR at the main office to find out if anything was submitted.

0 coins

That's a decent point. When there's a question about the reason someone stopped working, EDD reaches out to both sides. If someone at corporate responded with wrong information about you, that could explain a bizarre denial reason like incarceration.

0 coins

Does certifying while an appeal is open actually do anything if EDD has already denied you? Like why would they pay those weeks if they already said no?

0 coins

EDD can only release payment for weeks that show a certified claim in their system. If your appeal wins and those weeks weren't certified, there's nothing for them to release - the appeal decision doesn't go back and auto-certify weeks for you. So certifying keeps those weeks available to be paid if the appeal goes your way.

0 coins

Oh wow, I did not know that. I stopped certifying when I got my denial and now I'm worried about those weeks.

0 coins

Phone EDD as soon as you can about those uncertified weeks. The sooner the better on that one.

0 coins

My denial last year was for a completely different reason but the appeal process is the same regardless - DE 1000M mailed to the address on the notice, and they tell you to include a written statement explaining why you disagree. Keep your statement factual and specific. 'The stated reason of incarceration is incorrect. I was not incarcerated at any point. I was employed at [warehouse] until [date] and was laid off when the facility closed.' Short and direct is better than a long explanation.

0 coins

Short and direct, got it. I was going to write a whole long explanation but maybe less is more here.

0 coins

You can include a brief timeline if it helps clarify the facts, but the main thing is that every sentence should support your case directly. Anything that wanders off point doesn't help.

0 coins

Agree with keeping it tight. And remember you're writing to whoever reviews the appeal, not to defend yourself emotionally - just lay out the facts and let the documents do the work.

0 coins

November benefit year and a closed distribution center - both of those words popped out at me because my own claim had a strange denial this past summer after a facility closure. Got through to an EDD agent and asked specifically whether a closed location creates an automatic flag in their system when the employer can't respond to the claim notice. The agent said the system itself doesn't flag based on that, but that an unresponsive employer can sometimes lead to EDD relying on information they already have on file, which may be outdated or wrong. Used Claimyr to get the agent on the phone after two weeks of nobody picking up at 1-800-300-5616. She also confirmed which weeks on my claim were still open and pending a decision so I knew exactly what I was appealing.

0 coins

Outdated or wrong information on file from the employer - that's actually a really plausible explanation for my situation. If the company had any kind of old record that got pulled up, who knows what's in it.

0 coins

That was my agent's exact point - she couldn't tell me what the employer filed or didn't file, but she could tell me which issue was flagged on my claim and which weeks were still pending. That alone was worth the call because I knew what to put in my appeal statement.

0 coins

Knowing exactly which weeks are under review before you write the appeal statement is a good idea. Saves you from appealing a week that doesn't even need it.

0 coins

WHAT?? Incarcerated?? EDD put that on your Notice of Determination?? I thought I'd seen every wrong denial reason but that's a new one. They really just pick reasons randomly sometimes I swear.

0 coins

Not randomly but their system does pull from a checklist of disqualification reasons and if something triggers the wrong code it ends up on the notice as an official reason even if it has nothing to do with reality.

0 coins

That is somehow even more frustrating than random. At least random would be chaos, this is just a code error dressed up as an official decision.

0 coins

Can you even attend a CUIAB hearing remotely or do you have to go in person? I'm asking because if this gets to that stage the person above mentioned testimony is under oath and I want to know what I'm looking at.

0 coins

The notice of hearing comes by mail at least 10 days before it's scheduled and it'll have the details for how the hearing is conducted. The administrative law judge runs it, and you're allowed to represent yourself - you don't need an attorney, though you can bring one or a union rep if you have one.

0 coins

Okay, 10 days notice by mail, can represent yourself - that's actually less intimidating than I expected.

0 coins

The hearing format is straightforward once you understand what it is. It's not a courtroom, it's more like a structured phone or video conference where the judge asks questions and both sides give their account.

0 coins

Genuinely confused - if the DE 429Z already calculated a weekly benefit amount based on wages, what exactly triggers EDD to then investigate and deny someone? I thought the wage calculation and the eligibility decision were the same thing.

0 coins

They're completely separate steps. EDD calculates wages first to figure out what a claim could be worth - that's the DE 429Z. Then they look at why you stopped working, whether you're available for work, and whether there are any other eligibility issues. Those two things happen on different timelines and can land at very different conclusions.

0 coins

Okay that actually clears up a lot. So someone could have a perfectly calculated DE 429Z and still end up denied for a reason that has nothing to do with their wages.

0 coins

Exactly. The wage-based calculation and the eligibility determination are two different tracks. The DE 429Z is settled early; the eligibility question can take much longer, especially if there's something in the system that needs to be sorted out.

0 coins

Have you registered in CalJOBS yet? I know it feels disconnected from the denial situation but if your claim does get approved on appeal, not having CalJOBS set up can stall payments for a whole different reason.

0 coins

I did register and posted a resume already. That DE 8405 came in my initial paperwork and I took care of it within the first couple weeks.

0 coins

Good, that's one less thing. Some people don't get to it until after their appeal is resolved and then hit a second delay.

0 coins

The 21-day window on that CalJOBS requirement catches people off guard. Good that it's already done.

0 coins

Has anyone here had EDD actually correct a denial at the internal review stage before it went to a CUIAB hearing? I'm wondering how common it is for them to just fix a clear factual error without making you go through a whole hearing.

0 coins

Internal corrections do happen, especially when the stated reason is flat-out wrong rather than a matter of interpretation. I haven't seen a stat on how often, but EDD reviews the appeal first, and if the error is obvious, it makes sense they'd resolve it without escalating.

0 coins

Mine went all the way to a hearing, but the reason on my denial was a judgment call about my separation. Something that's just factually wrong, like this one, seems like a better candidate for early resolution.

0 coins

Fingers crossed for the person who posted this that it gets fixed at the first step and they don't have to wait for a hearing date.

0 coins

Benefit year timing matters here too - the claim started from the Sunday of the week of application, right? So the 52-week clock is running regardless of the appeal. After a facility closure last winter my claim got tangled in an adjudication issue for about two months and I ended up having to track exactly which weeks were still inside the benefit year. Claimyr got me to an agent at EDD who confirmed the exact dates my benefit year ran through, which let me prioritize which weeks to include in the appeal. Keeping an eye on that date is worth it so you don't run out of time on your year while waiting on the appeal decision.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about the benefit year deadline. My claim started the last week of September so I'd have until late September next year - is that right?

0 coins

Sounds right - the benefit year ends 52 weeks from when the claim opened, which is the Sunday of the week you applied. If the appeal takes long enough, keeping that date in mind helps you plan.

0 coins

Worth double-checking in UI Online too - the Claim History section shows the dates associated with the claim.

0 coins

Just want to flag something I believed for a long time that turned out to be wrong - I thought that if EDD denied a claim, the employer was somehow involved in fighting the appeal too. Someone I know insisted the employer argues against you at the hearing level. That's not how it works. EDD decides, and the administrative law judge runs the hearing. The claimant presents their side. No one is there representing the employer arguing against you, though the employer can respond to EDD's initial notice.

0 coins

That misconception is everywhere. I had someone tell me the same thing before my appeal and it made me way more anxious going in than I needed to be.

0 coins

Wait so the employer doesn't show up at the hearing at all?

0 coins

The employer was contacted by EDD earlier in the process, before the denial. By the time it's a CUIAB hearing, it's between you and the judge. The hearing isn't a back-and-forth argument with your old company.

0 coins

Does filing a written appeal stop the 30-day clock, or do you have to wait for confirmation from EDD before you know the appeal was received?

0 coins

You file and then it's in EDD's hands. Keep a copy of the DE 1000M you send and use certified mail so you have a postmark and delivery confirmation. That postmark is your proof of when you filed if the deadline ever comes into question.

0 coins

Certified mail, keep a copy - noted. That's smarter than just dropping it in a regular mailbox.

0 coins

The postmark is what matters for the 30-day window. EDD goes by the mailing date on the notice, not when they open your envelope.

0 coins

Do you know if there's a faster way to reach EDD to ask about the specific incarceration flag on your claim rather than just waiting on the appeal? Like is live chat useful for something this specific or is it too limited?

0 coins

Live chat through the Help button in UI Online runs Monday to Friday, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. It's real agents but they may not be able to dig into an adjudication issue as deeply as a phone call. For something this specific, a phone call to 1-800-300-5616 between 8 and 5 on weekdays is more likely to get you to someone who can actually look at your file.

0 coins

That tracks - live chat has always felt like it's better for quick questions than anything that requires someone to actually look at a claim.

0 coins

I'll try both. Live chat for a quick status check and the phone line if I need more detail. And sending the DE 1000M this week regardless of whatever I find out by phone.

0 coins

The whole situation is infuriating on behalf of the person who posted this. Four years at one job, laid off when the whole building closes, files a legitimate claim, and EDD sends a denial saying you were incarcerated. The system really does create more problems than it solves sometimes.

0 coins

Every step working correctly until a code error shows up with the most dramatic possible wrong reason. At least the appeal path is clear.

0 coins

The clearer the factual error, the stronger the appeal case. At least it's not a subjective judgment call - it's just wrong.

0 coins

That's true, 'the stated reason is factually incorrect' is about as simple as an appeal statement gets. Fingers crossed it gets resolved at the first review.

0 coins

Curious whether the person who posted is planning to also send a message through UI Online to ask about the incarceration flag in addition to the appeal, or just rely on the appeal alone. I had a wage discrepancy on my claim after a layoff and tried sending a UI Online message first, but weeks went by with no response so I ended up using Claimyr to get to an agent directly. The agent was able to tell me exactly which quarter was showing the wrong wages and that EDD had already sent my employer a notice to verify - info I never would have gotten from a message alone.

0 coins

Sending a message through UI Online while also filing the appeal in parallel sounds like a good approach. Covering both bases.

0 coins

That's what I'd do. The message alone isn't fast enough to rely on, but having it on record that you reached out through the official channel alongside the appeal doesn't hurt.

0 coins

The UI Online message trail can also serve as documentation that you were proactively trying to resolve the issue, which isn't a bad thing to have on record if the appeal goes to a hearing.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure