Is work sharing program legal if employer does not reduce hours?
So my employer enrolled us in something called the Work Sharing program through California EDD a few months back and I've been collecting partial UI benefits on top of my regular paycheck. The thing is, I've been looking at my timesheets and my hours haven't actually changed at all since the program started. I'm still working the exact same schedule I had before. My coworker told me everything is fine and the employer handles all the paperwork, but it's nagging at me. If my hours were never actually reduced, is it even legal for me to be getting these partial unemployment payments? I don't want to be hit with an overpayment notice or fraud charges down the line. Has anyone dealt with this situation or know how the Work Sharing program is supposed to work?
83 comments

Lucas Lindsey
Termination paperwork from my last job listed me as "laid off due to restructuring" but my employer had actually enrolled that whole department in Work Sharing before letting us go, and nobody told us what that meant. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent because I could not get anyone on the phone after trying for days. The video that explains how to reach a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what it looks like. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my employer had filed a Work Sharing plan that showed a 20 percent reduction in hours, and that the payments I received matched what was certified under that plan. For your situation specifically, the agent would be able to look at what your employer submitted as the reduction percentage on the approved plan — that's the number that drives what EDD pays out, not what you clock in day to day.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorWait, so the employer submits a reduction percentage when they apply for the plan? I had no idea that was how it worked. I just got an email saying I was enrolled and started seeing deposits.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
EDD's Work Sharing unit reviews the employer's plan before approving it, so there's a specific reduction on file — but if your hours aren't actually being reduced to match what's on that plan, that's the gap worth asking about.
0 coins
Austin Leonard
Had the same confusion when my company did this. The employer certifies on your behalf each week in Work Sharing, so the reduction percentage they put on the plan is what EDD goes by, not your personal timesheet.
0 coins
Anita George
My pay stubs looked totally normal for two months while I was getting Work Sharing payments and I panicked about the same thing. Here's what I found out after a lot of digging: Work Sharing is a legit California EDD program where an employer can avoid layoffs by reducing everyone's hours a certain percentage and EDD makes up part of the difference. The employer submits the plan with the actual reduction amount — it has to be somewhere between 10 and 60 percent. If your hours haven't moved at all, the question is whether your employer filed an accurate plan. If they put a reduction on paper that isn't happening in real life, that's on the employer side, but it still touches your claim.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorThat range you mentioned — do you know if EDD audits whether the hours actually dropped? Or do they just take the employer's word for it?
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
EDD can and does request payroll records from employers under Work Sharing. It's not like they just rubber stamp it and walk away.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
Thought the employer just had to tell EDD roughly how many employees and they'd approve it automatically — good to know they look at actual hour reductions.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
Is your employer maybe counting something differently — like, did they reduce the number of days you work and you're making up hours on the days you do come in? Because that happened at my job and on paper the reduction was real, it just looked the same on my check.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorNo, that's what's strange — same days, same shifts, same total hours every week. Nothing changed from what I can tell.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
Could also be a temporary reduction they filed expecting to implement it and then didn't follow through. Either way you'd want that cleared up before you keep certifying.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
SAME SITUATION happened to my entire department and nobody said a word about it until someone got an overpayment notice six months later. The employer had enrolled in Work Sharing and reduced hours on the plan but then just never actually cut our shifts. EDD eventually figured it out through a payroll audit. Everyone had to pay back what they received during the weeks the reduction wasn't real. Nobody was charged with fraud because we hadn't done anything deliberately — the error was on the employer's side — but it was still a nightmare sorting it out.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorThat is exactly what I'm afraid of. Were you able to appeal the overpayment or did you all just have to repay it?
0 coins
Ruby Blake
There was an appeal option on the notice — the DE 1080CZ — but most people in my department just paid it back because the amount wasn't huge per person. A couple people requested a waiver form and went that route.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
An overpayment that wasn't the claimant's fault and wasn't fraud can still be appealed or a waiver requested. The waiver is the DE 1446UI and EDD considers whether paying it back would be an extraordinary hardship. Worth knowing before anyone just mails a check.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Can I ask something that might be dumb — does the employer actually certify for you in Work Sharing or does the employee still have to do anything? I've been on regular UI before and always certified myself every two weeks but Work Sharing sounds like a totally different process.
0 coins
Anita George
Work Sharing is different from regular UI in that way. The employer submits weekly payroll info to EDD directly, so the individual claimant doesn't certify the same way you do in regular UI. It's one of the things that makes it confusing for employees who've only done regular UI before.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Oh that actually explains why I never got any certification notices when my company enrolled us. I thought EDD had just forgotten about me.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
EDD sends the employee a notice when they're added to an approved Work Sharing plan. If you never got one, worth double-checking through your myEDD account that you're actually in the program.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
DE 4800 notice sitting on my kitchen counter reminded me I had a phone interview coming up about a separate eligibility question on my regular UI claim, and while I was talking to the EDD agent I ended up asking about my partner's Work Sharing situation too. Got to that agent through Claimyr after spending a whole morning hitting redial. The agent said when an employer's Work Sharing plan shows a reduction that payroll records don't back up, EDD treats the discrepancy as an employer issue first — they go to the employer for an explanation before anything else touches the employee's account. So if your situation is what it sounds like, EDD's first move would be toward your employer, not you.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorThat's genuinely reassuring to hear. So my best move is probably to contact EDD directly and flag the discrepancy myself rather than wait for them to find it?
0 coins
PrinceJoe
That's what the agent suggested — getting ahead of it by raising it through your UI Online account or phoning in shows you weren't trying to hide anything, which matters for how EDD categorizes it if there is an issue.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Proactively flagging something with EDD is almost always better than waiting. Even if it turns out to be nothing, you've created a record that you asked.
0 coins
Austin Leonard
Something that tripped me up early on: a lot of people think Work Sharing and regular UI are basically the same thing with a different name, but the employer is really the driver in Work Sharing. They apply, they set the reduction percentage, they submit the weekly payroll data. The employee's role is mostly to exist in the approved group. So if something is off, the employer is the one who either made a mistake on the plan or is operating outside what the plan says.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorMakes sense. So I should probably also be documenting my own hours somewhere — like keeping screenshots of my timesheets — in case this comes up later?
0 coins
Austin Leonard
Absolutely keep copies of your timesheets and pay stubs covering the whole period. If EDD ever asks for your side of things, having that documentation ready makes the conversation much faster.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
Pay stubs are especially useful because they show gross hours worked each pay period. That's the clearest way to show what actually happened vs. what the employer submitted.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
Honestly thought work sharing was just something employers made up to sound nice while cutting hours. Had no clue it was an actual California EDD program with its own rules and filings. This thread is teaching me things.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
EDD's Work Sharing program has been around for a while — it's specifically designed to let employers avoid full layoffs. The idea is EDD pays a partial benefit to cover the reduction so employers keep their workforce intact.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
Thought it was something they invented during COVID. Okay, so if an employer never actually cuts hours but enrolls anyway, that's basically them collecting money they're not entitled to, right?
0 coins
Anita George
Not exactly — the employer doesn't collect the money, the employees do. But the employer would be filing inaccurate information with EDD to get those payments flowing, which is a problem on their end.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
Did you check whether your employer gave you any paperwork when they enrolled you in Work Sharing? There should have been something — even just an email or a memo — that mentioned the percentage your hours were being reduced. If they never told you what the reduction was supposed to be, that's worth noting too.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorI got one email that just said the company was enrolling in a Work Sharing program and that I'd receive some additional compensation through EDD. Nothing about a specific percentage or what the reduced schedule would be.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
That vague communication is itself a little telling. A real Work Sharing implementation usually comes with specifics — here's your new schedule, here's what the reduction percentage is, here's what your partial UI amount will be.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
My employer sent an entire FAQ when they enrolled us. Had the percentage, the expected weekly EDD amount, and the duration they planned to run the plan. Total lack of that info seems like something went sideways before it even got to your hours.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
Before anyone assumes the worst here, there is one scenario where this could be less alarming: some employers file a Work Sharing plan at a certain percentage and then phase in the reduction over a few weeks. If the plan was just approved and the employer hasn't adjusted schedules yet, the payments might be running ahead of the actual reduction. That's still a problem, but it's a different kind of problem than an employer just pocketing the program's benefits while not actually cutting anyone's hours.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorHow long has the program been approved for employers before they have to actually show the hour reduction?
0 coins
Micah Franklin
EDD's Work Sharing plan approval comes with specific start dates and terms. The employer is supposed to implement the reduction from the start of the plan period — there's no grace window built in where they can collect on a reduction they haven't made yet. If weeks have passed and hours haven't moved, that's outside the plan terms.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
Exactly. The plan isn't speculative — it's based on a stated reduction the employer says is already in effect or is immediately going into effect.
0 coins
Owen Devar
Weekly benefit amount on my Work Sharing payments never matched what I expected from the EDD calculator, so I needed to ask someone who actually knew the program. Spent about two weeks trying to reach EDD the regular way before I tried Claimyr — ended up talking to an agent who explained that my Work Sharing weekly amount is a percentage of my regular UI weekly benefit amount, tied to whatever reduction percentage my employer filed. The agent also told me the weeks where my employer's submitted hours didn't line up with the plan were showing as under review. That's what your pending weeks would look like on the UI Online Claim History screen if EDD flags a discrepancy.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorMine actually do show some pending weeks in Claim History right now. I figured it was just normal processing time but maybe it's related to this.
0 coins
Owen Devar
Worth phoning in specifically about those pending weeks. When the agent walked me through my Claim History, they could see notes on each week that I couldn't see from my end.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Pending in Claim History while on Work Sharing can mean a few different things — employer payroll submission timing is one, eligibility review is another. Getting an agent to look at the notes on each week is the fastest way to know which you're dealing with.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
The bigger risk I'd flag: if EDD determines the employer submitted inaccurate information, they will likely go to the employer first for repayment. But the employee's claim can still be affected — benefits paid under a Work Sharing plan that shouldn't have been active can come back as an overpayment on the employee's record even if the fault is entirely on the employer side. It's not fair, but it's how the administrative process works. Getting in front of this now is much smarter.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorYeah, I'm going to contact EDD this week. I'd rather surface this myself than have it come up later.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
Document everything before you call. Write down the dates the payments came in, what your timesheets show for those same weeks, and what the enrollment email said. Having all of that organized when you get an agent will make the call more useful.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
Also keep a copy of whatever communication EDD sends after you raise this. If they open a review, any notice they mail you will have the information you need and an appeal deadline on it.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Is there anything stopping someone from just stopping certifying — or in this case, stopping whatever Work Sharing participation they have — while they sort it out? Like, is it better to pause and ask questions or keep going and risk more overpaid weeks?
0 coins
Anita George
Work Sharing is employer-driven so the employee can't really just unilaterally stop. The employer would need to remove them from the plan or EDD would need to flag the account. What you can do is contact EDD and explain the situation so they're aware, which creates a record and may prompt a review.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
If EDD puts the weeks under review, payment stops on its own until the review is resolved. That's probably the cleaner outcome than trying to self-remove from a plan you were enrolled in by your employer.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Okay that makes sense. So the right move is contact EDD, explain the situation, and let the review process do its thing rather than trying to shortcut it.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
EDD's Work Sharing unit is separate from the main UI claims people. If you call 1-800-300-5616 and ask specifically about a Work Sharing plan discrepancy, make sure you're being transferred to someone who handles that program, not just a general UI rep. They may know some basics but Work Sharing has its own rules and the specialized staff understand the employer-side filings better.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorGood to know. I'll ask specifically for the Work Sharing unit when I call. Any idea what information I should have ready when I call?
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
Have your Social Security number, the approximate date you received the enrollment notice, the weeks you've received payments, and your pay stubs showing hours actually worked. The more specific you can be, the faster the agent can pull up the right parts of your claim.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
Also write down approximately when the Work Sharing payments started hitting and what the amounts were. If the agent can compare those deposits to what the employer submitted, they can often spot the discrepancy on the spot.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
My employer did something similar where they filed for Work Sharing, got it approved, and then business actually picked back up so nobody's hours were actually cut. The HR person told everyone to just keep accepting the payments because it wasn't our problem. I never felt right about that and ended up not accepting further payments — but I was also terrified that the ones I'd already received would come back as an overpayment. EDD eventually closed the plan after the employer stopped submitting payroll data and I never heard anything after that. Not saying that's a strategy, just that outcomes seem to vary.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorHow long did the whole thing take to resolve from when the employer stopped submitting to when EDD closed the plan?
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
Took about two months before the plan showed as closed in my claim. The pending weeks just resolved on their own eventually without me receiving anything for those periods.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
HR telling employees to just accept payments the company might not be entitled to generate — that's a pretty bold thing for an HR department to recommend.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
Has anyone actually had EDD find in the employee's favor in one of these situations where the employer messed up the Work Sharing filing? Like, did anyone get to keep the payments and not have to repay anything?
0 coins
Ruby Blake
From what I've seen in this thread and my own experience, it really depends on whether EDD classifies it as employer error versus something the employee should have known about. Pure employer error with no notice to the employee that anything was off tends to get handled on the employer side.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
An overpayment that happened through no fault of the claimant is still technically an overpayment, but the waiver process exists for exactly that reason. EDD weighing hardship plus the fact that it wasn't the claimant's fault is what the DE 1446UI waiver is designed for. It doesn't automatically mean you get to keep it, but it's a real option.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
I'd say get everything in writing when you contact EDD about it. Verbal explanations from agents are helpful in the moment but a written notice from EDD is what matters if something gets disputed later.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
EDD's Live Chat through the Help button in UI Online is actually useful for Work Sharing questions in my experience — faster than calling and you get a written record of what the agent says. It's only open Monday through Friday 9 to 2 but if you can get in during that window it's worth trying before you spend a morning on hold.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorI didn't know the chat hours were different from the phone hours. Good to know. I'll try that first since I can usually take a break mid-morning.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
Type your question out in advance and copy-paste it in the moment you get connected. The agents time out fast if you don't send something immediately after they greet you.
0 coins
Austin Leonard
The written record is the best part. Screenshot the whole conversation before you close the window because you can't pull up old chat transcripts later in UI Online.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Does Work Sharing affect the total weeks you can collect UI? Like, if someone is on Work Sharing for 10 weeks and then gets actually laid off, do they have fewer weeks of regular UI available?
0 coins
Anita George
Work Sharing draws from your maximum benefit amount, so yes — the partial payments you receive under Work Sharing count against the total your claim can pay. If your claim had a maximum benefit amount of $11,700 and you collected $3,000 under Work Sharing, you'd have $8,700 left for a potential regular UI period.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Thought Work Sharing was totally separate from regular UI benefits and didn't touch the regular claim at all. That changes how much it matters if someone's getting paid for weeks the reduction wasn't real.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
That's exactly why the overpayment question is serious even if the amounts per week seem small. If those weeks draw down your maximum benefit amount based on payments you shouldn't have received, you end up with less available if you actually need regular UI later.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
Just want to make sure I understand the original question — the employer enrolled in Work Sharing, EDD approved the plan, and payments have been going out, but the actual hours never got reduced. The question is whether that's legal. Short answer is no — the program requires a genuine reduction in hours for each pay period. An employer certifying that hours were reduced when they weren't is filing inaccurate information with EDD. The employee receiving benefits under those conditions could face overpayment liability even if they weren't the one who filed anything wrong.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorThat's pretty much the situation as I understand it. So my options are contact EDD myself, document everything, and potentially file an overpayment waiver if it comes to that?
0 coins
Connor Rupert
Contacting EDD now is the right first step. It opens a record showing you raised the concern, which matters a lot for how EDD evaluates fault. The waiver is the fallback if payments do come back as overpaid, but step one is making sure EDD knows you're not trying to avoid this.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
The 30-day clock for appealing an overpayment runs from the date on the notice, so read the date on whatever EDD mails you carefully. That appeal deadline is strict and you need the written denial in hand to know what you're actually appealing.
0 coins
Molly Hansen
My company did a real Work Sharing enrollment where hours actually dropped 20 percent. The partial UI payments were small — my regular weekly benefit amount was around $310 and the Work Sharing payment on a 20 percent reduction came out to about $62 a week — but it added up over a few months. I cannot imagine going through the whole process and then finding out the reduction was never real. That would be an awful position to be in and I feel for OP trying to sort this out.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
AuthorThose amounts are helpful context. I've been receiving similar figures each week so the percentage on whatever plan my employer filed might actually be in that range.
0 coins
Molly Hansen
Ask EDD to tell you the exact percentage on the approved plan. That alone will tell you what your employer filed as the reduction, and you can compare it to your actual hours to see if there's a mismatch.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
If your hours dropped 0 percent and the plan says 20 percent, the entire payment for every week would technically be an overpayment. That math gets painful fast even at smaller weekly amounts.
0 coins
Brady Clean
Can the employer get in trouble separately from whatever happens to the employee's claim? Like, if EDD audits and finds the employer was submitting inaccurate payroll data to run the Work Sharing payments, what happens to them?
0 coins
Connor Rupert
EDD can terminate an employer's Work Sharing plan and can hold the employer liable for benefits paid under an inaccurate plan. On the more serious end, filing false information with EDD can bring penalties. The employer's reserve account and their UI tax situation can also be affected. It's not a minor administrative slap — there are real consequences on the employer side.
0 coins
Brady Clean
That's good to know. It makes it clearer why the employee reaching out to EDD proactively is the right move, even if it feels like making waves at your own job.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
The tricky part is some employees don't want to flag it because they're worried about the employment relationship. But the alternative — waiting for EDD to find it and then sorting out an overpayment — is usually worse.
0 coins