Back to California Unemployment

Abby Marshall

Identity verification approved but now asks to reopen claim - what does California EDD want?

So I finally got through the ID.me process last week - took forever but it's done and EDD confirmed they received it. Logged into UI Online this morning expecting to see my pending weeks move forward and instead it's telling me I need to reopen my claim. I haven't worked anywhere since I was laid off from my warehouse job in September. Never filed a new claim, never closed anything intentionally. My Claim History still shows those same weeks as Pending from before the identity verification was sorted out. Is this normal after ID.me goes through? Do I actually reopen it or is this a glitch? I'm scared if I reopen it, it resets my benefit year or messes up the weeks I already certified. Really need some guidance here because I cannot afford to miss payments any longer.

Fourteen weeks into my own layoff from a logistics company and I ran into the exact same identity verification wall you're describing. After ID.me cleared, my account showed that reopen prompt too and I had no idea what it meant. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get on the phone with an EDD agent - it holds the line for you so you end up talking to a live person instead of hitting that busy signal loop - and the agent pulled up my account and said those pending weeks from before verification was confirmed were just waiting on me to complete that reopen step. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see it. What I asked about was whether reopening would wipe out my certified weeks or change my weekly benefit amount, and the agent said my DE 429Z amount stays the same and the weeks I'd already certified were still in the system. I went ahead and reopened through UI Online right after that call.

0 coins

Seeing your reply is making me feel a lot better. My biggest fear was exactly that - losing those certified weeks. So the agent confirmed the pending weeks from before ID.me cleared were just stuck there waiting on the reopen step? Did they actually pay out after you did it?

0 coins

Same situation played out on my account after verification. The reopen prompt appeared and I panicked thinking I had to start the whole claim from scratch. Turns out it really was just a continuation step.

0 coins

The logistics of this is so confusing because nothing in UI Online explains why it's asking you to reopen vs just continuing. No label, no explanation, just a prompt.

0 coins

My understanding from going through this last spring - when your claim goes dormant because of an identity hold, EDD flags it as needing to be reopened once the hold clears. It's not the same as filing a brand new claim. Your benefit year, your weekly benefit amount from the DE 429Z, the weeks you already certified - none of that resets. Reopening in this context just tells EDD's system you're still unemployed and want to continue claiming. The confusion is that the word 'reopen' sounds terrifying like you're starting from zero, but in this case it's closer to pressing a resume button.

0 coins

That analogy of a resume button is genuinely the clearest way anyone has explained this to me. So my benefit year clock doesn't restart? My claim started in September so I've been worried about losing those earlier weeks.

0 coins

I had the same misconception when I saw the reopen option. Thought it meant my old claim was completely dead. The benefit year stays anchored to when you originally filed, not when you reopen.

0 coins

Quick note though - I think there's sometimes a difference between reopening after an ID hold versus reopening after you found work and then got laid off again mid-year. The second one also uses the reopen flow but the situation is different. If you never went back to work, the first scenario is what you're in.

0 coins

Eight weeks of pending weeks stacked up on my account after my ID.me verification finally went through, and I wasn't sure if the reopen would trigger a new waiting week or not. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who looked at my file and told me my waiting week had already been served in the first week of my claim, so the reopen step wouldn't create another one. I asked specifically about the pending weeks showing in Claim History and she said once I completed the reopen and the eligibility questions were resolved, they'd process in order.

0 coins

Wait - there's only ever one waiting week per claim right? Not one per reopen? That's something I didn't know and was worried about.

0 coins

Every claim has exactly one waiting week, served the first time you're eligible and have certified. Reopening mid-claim doesn't add another one. The person above is right that the agent confirmed this.

0 coins

I lost sleep over the waiting week question too. Someone told me reopening always triggers a new waiting week and that sent me into a spiral. Good to know that's not accurate.

0 coins

I used to think 'reopen claim' and 'file a new claim' were basically the same thing - I even read somewhere that you have to file fresh every time. That's wrong. A new claim is only when your benefit year has ended or you need to establish new earnings. Reopening is what happens mid-benefit-year when your claim was interrupted - by an ID hold, or because you briefly went back to work, or because there was an adjudication issue. Your original claim dates and the weekly benefit amount from your DE 429Z all carry through.

0 coins

Filing a new claim while your benefit year is still active wouldn't even let you access a higher benefit amount from recent earnings, right? The alternate base period thing I've read about.

0 coins

Exactly - EDD only uses the alternate base period automatically if the standard one doesn't give you a valid claim at all. It doesn't come into play just because you reopen mid-year. Your DE 429Z amount stays what it is.

0 coins

Genuinely did not know that about the alternate base period. I thought if you had a big raise recently you could ask for a recalculation. Sounds like that's not how it works.

0 coins

The ID.me bottleneck that caused this whole situation is so frustrating. My identity verification took almost three weeks and the whole time I had certified weeks just sitting there pending. Then when verification finally cleared, I got that same reopen prompt and had to figure out what it meant with zero guidance from EDD's system. For anyone reading this later - reopen it. Don't sit on it hoping the prompt goes away because it won't pay out those pending weeks until you do.

0 coins

Three weeks on ID.me verification sounds awful. Mine took about a week and I thought that was bad. The pending weeks just pile up and you have no way to know if it's the identity hold, adjudication, or something else causing them.

0 coins

The pending limbo during the ID.me process was genuinely unbearable. No explanation of what was holding things up, no estimate. Just 'Pending' next to every week.

0 coins

UI Online does not tell you enough. 'Pending' could mean ten different things and they don't distinguish between them on the screen.

0 coins

After my own identity clearance came through in July, I called EDD to ask about the reopen prompt and the agent said the pending weeks from during the ID hold would be reviewed once I completed the reopen and finished certifying any weeks I hadn't yet. The key thing she told me was not to skip certifying just because the weeks were already showing as Pending - keep certifying every two weeks so the weeks stay in the queue.

0 coins

Okay so I should absolutely keep certifying even with the reopen pending? I stopped after I saw the prompt because I didn't know if certifying while in this weird state would mess anything up.

0 coins

Keep certifying. Stopping creates a gap that EDD has to look at separately. The reopen and the continuing certifications happen alongside each other.

0 coins

Stopping certification during an ID issue was the mistake I made and it added weeks to my wait. Keep going even when the account looks frozen.

0 coins

November of my benefit year and my claim had been in that reopen-required state for almost two weeks after ID.me cleared. Reached an EDD agent through Claimyr after the regular phone line kept cutting off - ended up talking to someone who went through my Claim History line by line. She confirmed the weeks from the identity hold period were still attached to my claim and would process once I completed the reopen step and EDD finished reviewing the eligibility period.

0 coins

How long did it take for the pending weeks to actually pay out after you reopened? I have six weeks stacked up and I'm trying to figure out what kind of timeline to prepare for.

0 coins

Mine paid out in stages over about two weeks after I reopened and finished certifying. Not all at once.

0 coins

Six weeks of pending is a lot to have stacked. Glad to hear they don't just disappear after the reopen - they actually process eventually.

0 coins

Something I got wrong before my own identity verification experience - I thought EDD would automatically reopen the claim once ID.me confirmed me. Like the system would just see the green light and resume everything. That's not how it works. The claimant has to log into UI Online and complete the reopen step themselves. EDD is not going to do it on your behalf. The notification to reopen is there in the account, but if you don't see it or ignore it, the pending weeks just keep sitting.

0 coins

Checked my UI Online account after reading this and I see the exact same prompt. I've been waiting for EDD to do something automatically for nine days. Going to do the reopen right now.

0 coins

Do it right away. The sooner you reopen, the sooner EDD can start processing those weeks.

0 coins

The assumption that EDD auto-resumes after a hold is cleared is so easy to make. The UI Online interface doesn't make it obvious that action is required on your end.

0 coins

I had a gap in my claim from an ID hold that lasted almost a month, and when I finally reopened, I was worried the weeks during the hold period were just gone. What actually happened is those weeks were reviewed individually - some paid out, a couple needed me to verify my work search activities for those weeks. The work search part is worth knowing about: EDD expects you to have been looking for work during those pending weeks even though your claim was essentially frozen. Keep records of where you applied.

0 coins

Work search records during the ID hold period - I didn't even think about that. I was applying to jobs the whole time but I didn't keep detailed notes. Should I document what I remember now?

0 coins

Document what you can remember - company names, positions, dates if you have them in your email or browser history. If EDD asks during certification, give honest answers about what you were doing.

0 coins

EDD's certification questions about work search are for each week you're claiming. Even during the pending period, you're attesting to those weeks when you certify them.

0 coins

My benefit year started last spring and I had an identity hold partway through that created this exact reopen situation. The thing that confused me was my Claim History showed Pending for the held weeks but it wasn't clear at all whether those weeks had been certified or not from EDD's perspective. Turns out some of them were in a certified-but-pending state and some I still had to certify. Worth checking your Claim History carefully to see which weeks show as certified vs which ones you haven't touched yet.

0 coins

Went into my Claim History just now and trying to parse which weeks are certified-pending vs uncertified-pending. The labels aren't super clear but I think I can figure it out. This was a helpful tip.

0 coins

The Claim History screen is genuinely one of the more confusing parts of UI Online. 'Pending' can mean so many different things at different stages.

0 coins

If you're really unsure, contacting EDD through the message center in your UI Online account is an option - ask them directly which weeks still need certification versus which are just waiting on a decision.

0 coins

I used to think an identity hold and an adjudication were the same thing. They're not. An adjudication is when EDD has a question about whether you're eligible - like why you left your job. An identity hold is just verification of who you are. After ID.me clears, you might still have a separate adjudication pending if there was a question about your separation from your employer. Worth checking if there's anything beyond just the reopen prompt on your account.

0 coins

How would I even know if there's a separate adjudication going on? Is there a notice for that or does it just show as more Pending weeks?

0 coins

Usually EDD sends a notice by mail and schedules a phone interview - there'd be a DE 4800 in your mailbox with the date and time, and that same date appears on the UI Online homepage. If you don't see that, the hold was probably just the ID issue.

0 coins

I mixed up the two too and kept asking about my 'adjudication' when what I actually had was an ID hold. EDD has to ask you to clarify which one you mean sometimes.

0 coins

Got the DE 429Z about two weeks after my original application came through. When I finally understood what it was - the award notice showing my weekly benefit amount - I realized I'd been confusing it with an approval letter. EDD doesn't send an approval letter. The DE 429Z just shows what your claim can pay based on your earnings history. Eligibility is a separate determination that happens claim-by-claim, week-by-week. Clearing the identity hold doesn't automatically mean every week gets paid - EDD still looks at each week.

0 coins

I definitely thought the DE 429Z was an approval. Spent two weeks thinking I was confirmed eligible and wondering why nothing was paying out.

0 coins

Super common misread. The number on the DE 429Z is the potential amount, not a promise of payment.

0 coins

EDD's own documents could be clearer about this honestly. 'Award notice' sounds like you won something.

0 coins

Calling EDD directly after weeks of busy signals and disconnects finally worked when I tried Claimyr - sat with an agent who confirmed my reopen had processed and walked me through which weeks in my Claim History were still pending a decision versus which had been approved and were queued for payment. Actually knowing what was in the queue instead of just staring at 'Pending' made the wait bearable.

0 coins

Knowing the breakdown of which weeks are queued vs still being decided sounds like exactly the information I need right now. Glad that call gave you clarity.

0 coins

Just having someone read off what's actually in the system is so valuable. 'Pending' on the screen tells you nothing about where in the process things are.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is something I completely forgot about during my identity hold period and it almost cost me. After ID.me cleared and I reopened, EDD sent a notice that I needed to register in CalJOBS and have a resume posted within 21 days of my original requirement notice. The deadline had basically crept up while I was focused on the identity issue. If you got a DE 8405 in the mail after you first applied, check the date on it.

0 coins

Oh no - I got that DE 8405 and I did register in CalJOBS but I'm not 100% sure I actually posted a full resume. Going to check right now.

0 coins

Log into caljobs.ca.gov and make sure your resume is published, not just saved as a draft. That was the mistake I made - I uploaded something but didn't mark it active.

0 coins

The CalJOBS step being separate from the EDD step is so easy to overlook when you're already stressed about the main claim stuff. Good reminder.

0 coins

Fourteen weeks of benefits I collected before my claim had an ID hold put on it, and I was terrified the hold meant I owed back those fourteen weeks somehow. That is not how it works. An identity hold going forward doesn't retroactively undo weeks EDD already paid you. The hold only affects weeks processed while it's active. What you already received stays with you.

0 coins

That fear was sitting in the back of my mind too. Really glad to hear that an ID hold doesn't claw back what was already paid.

0 coins

The overpayment concern is real though for a different reason - if EDD later determines you weren't actually eligible for some of those weeks, that's a separate issue. But an identity hold alone doesn't trigger a claw-back.

0 coins

Right - the person above is correct about that distinction. The identity hold is about verifying who you are, not about eligibility for past weeks. Eligibility is a separate question entirely.

0 coins

EDD's phone line at 1-800-300-5616 is available Monday through Friday 8 to 5. I know it's hard to get through, but the specific question you're dealing with - reopen after identity clearance - is the kind of thing where talking to an actual agent is worth the effort. They can see your specific account and tell you exactly what state each pending week is in and whether anything else is flagged beyond the reopen prompt.

0 coins

I've tried that line a few times and gotten the high-volume message. Going to keep trying, especially in the early morning.

0 coins

Early Monday mornings right at 8 AM have worked better for me historically. Still not guaranteed but better than midday.

0 coins

The live chat through the Help button in UI Online is also an option on weekdays between 9 and 2. Sometimes easier to get a response there than on the phone.

0 coins

My whole experience with EDD and identity verification took longer than expected because I didn't realize ID.me needed me to actually take a live selfie, not just upload a photo. It kept rejecting my documents and I had no idea why until someone in a different forum explained the live selfie requirement. If anyone is still stuck on the ID.me step, that might be what's happening.

0 coins

The ID.me interface is not intuitive at all. I went through three separate attempts before it accepted my state ID photo.

0 coins

Mine was similar - the face scan part especially was finicky. Took me a few tries in good lighting.

0 coins

Bright, even lighting and holding the phone still made the biggest difference for my ID.me scan. Sounds obvious but it really matters.

0 coins

After finally getting through the whole ID.me and reopen process myself, I want to flag one more thing: keep an eye on your physical mailbox in the weeks after you reopen. EDD mails things that don't appear in UI Online, and if there's a determination being made about any of your pending weeks - especially if you had a phone interview coming - the notice comes by mail. Missing a DE 4800 and not being available at the scheduled interview time causes its own complications.

0 coins

I've been checking mail more carefully since all of this started but good reminder. The DE 4800 would have the interview date and time on it and I should have it on the UI Online homepage too right?

0 coins

Yes - if EDD has scheduled a phone interview, the date and time for it should show on the UI Online homepage in addition to the DE 4800. Check both.

0 coins

And if you need to reschedule a phone interview, do it at least one day before the scheduled time by contacting EDD directly. Missing it without rescheduling means EDD decides based on whatever information it already has, which is not ideal.

0 coins

For the person who originally posted - after you reopen in UI Online, give it a couple of business days before expecting the pending weeks to move. EDD processes things on their end and UI Online doesn't update instantly. The Payments section of UI Online and the automated line at 1-866-333-4606 both show payment info and update daily. That's how I tracked mine after reopening.

0 coins

Good to know there's a daily-updating way to track this beyond just the main Claim History screen. I've been refreshing UI Online constantly and it's not helping my anxiety.

0 coins

The 1-866-333-4606 line is available around the clock too, so you can check at whatever hour the anxiety hits rather than waiting for business hours.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure