Back to California Unemployment

Drake

How to backdate an unemployment claim while on workers comp - California EDD question

So I got hurt on the job back in late September and went straight onto workers comp. My employer's insurance was paying me temporary disability through the workers comp claim, so I didn't even think about filing for unemployment at the time. Fast forward to about six weeks later - workers comp cuts me off because they're claiming I've 'reached maximum medical improvement' even though I still can't go back to my regular duties. Now I'm stuck trying to figure out if I can go back and get unemployment benefits for those weeks I was just sitting at home getting workers comp payments, and also going forward now that those payments have stopped. I filed a UI claim last week but the rep I talked to said something about backdating. Has anyone dealt with this overlap between workers comp and unemployment? Can you even collect both at the same time, or does one cancel out the other? I'm mostly confused about whether those six weeks I was on workers comp count toward anything or if I just lost them completely.

Workers comp cutting off at 'maximum medical improvement' when you're still not 100% - went through almost the same thing two years ago and it was a nightmare to untangle. The short answer on backdating: you can request it when you apply, but EDD needs a reason why you didn't file when you first became unemployed. In your case, being on workers comp is actually a documented reason they may accept. When I called EDD about mine they said to explain the gap in writing through my UI Online account.

0 coins

Drake

Author

DE 429Z hasn't even shown up yet since I just filed last week - does the backdating request have to happen before that comes or can I do it after?

0 coins

Mine came about two weeks after I applied, so you should have time. The request really needs to be in before they process your claim fully, so I wouldn't wait around.

0 coins

The 'write in through UI Online' advice is solid - I did a message through my account when I had a date issue and it created a paper trail which mattered later.

0 coins

Wait, so were you able to work during those six weeks on workers comp or were you completely off? Because unemployment has this thing where you have to be able to work and available to work every week you're claiming, and if you were medically restricted that whole time, that's a problem for those weeks specifically.

0 coins

Drake

Author

I was completely off - doctor had me on a no-work restriction the entire six weeks. So does that mean I can't claim those weeks at all even if EDD backdates?

0 coins

Yeah that's the sticky part. If a doctor said no work for those weeks, you technically didn't meet the 'able and available' requirement that UI needs. Those weeks might not qualify even if EDD backdates to them.

0 coins

Had a restriction like that myself and was told the same thing. Disability Insurance through SDI is actually the program that covers you when you can't work because of an injury - unemployment is for when you CAN work but don't have a job.

0 coins

Workers comp stopping on me in December is what started this whole mess for me too. What I actually needed to know was whether the week workers comp ended counted as my first UI-eligible week, and I couldn't get a straight answer from anyone online. UI Online just showed Pending on everything. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get through to an actual EDD agent on the phone - there's a video showing how the whole reaching-a-live-person part works at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my UI start date would be the Sunday of the week my workers comp medical restriction was lifted, which is when I became able and available again. That's the week that matters for backdating purposes, not the week workers comp stopped paying.

0 coins

Drake

Author

This is actually really helpful - so the date my doctor cleared me for work is probably the right starting point for my UI claim, not the date workers comp stopped the payments?

0 coins

Exactly what the agent told me. The release date from your doctor is the key document. I had to upload mine through UI Online.

0 coins

Makes sense that it's the medical release date. EDD cares about when you became able and available, not when an insurance company decided to stop paying you.

0 coins

Does the doctor release have to be for full duty or does limited duty count? Because my situation has me cleared for light work only.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up early on - I thought workers comp and unemployment were basically the same thing and you'd just pick one. They're actually totally separate programs. Workers comp is through your employer's insurance for a work injury, unemployment is through EDD for being out of a job. The overlap issue is about being able to work, not about which checks you're getting. When I finally understood that distinction, the backdating question got a lot simpler for me.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Yeah I was definitely conflating the two. So once my doctor cleared me, that's when I should have filed - and now I'm asking EDD to backdate to that cleared date?

0 coins

That's exactly the right framing. The question becomes: were you able and available starting on the date of your clearance, and did you have a good reason for not filing right away on that date? The workers comp situation and the confusion around it is usually considered a good reason.

0 coins

The 'good reason' part is actually evaluated case by case - EDD has discretion on whether the reason holds up. Document everything, keep copies of your workers comp paperwork and the doctor's release.

0 coins

Nobody mentioned yet that workers comp payments themselves need to be reported when you certify. Even if EDD backdates your claim, those weeks where you were getting workers comp payments - that income gets reported and EDD figures out how it affects your weekly amount. It's on the list of things you report during certification.

0 coins

Drake

Author

So I don't just leave those weeks blank even if I was on workers comp? I have to report the payments I was getting?

0 coins

Report everything when certifying. EDD decides what it does to your payment amount. Don't try to calculate it yourself - just report accurately.

0 coins

Yep, the certification asks about all income for the week it was earned. Workers comp is on that list. EDD handles the math.

0 coins

My certification period included some overlap like this and I really wasn't sure what counted as 'wages' vs just payments. Called EDD to ask and they clarified - report it and let them sort the formula out.

0 coins

Can I jump in here - does backdating affect the CalJOBS registration deadline? Because I think you have to register in CalJOBS within 21 days of getting the DE 8405, and if EDD backdates my claim start date that might push the deadline way back and make me already late on the CalJOBS thing.

0 coins

The 21 days runs from the date on the DE 8405 notice EDD sends you, not from whenever your claim technically starts. So backdating the claim start shouldn't retroactively make you late on CalJOBS - but check the actual date on that notice when it arrives.

0 coins

DE 8405 hasn't shown up in my mail yet - I'll watch for it. So I register at caljobs.ca.gov once that notice arrives and go from there?

0 coins

Right. And EDD will tell you if you're exempt from that requirement - most people aren't, so plan on doing it.

0 coins

Every week I didn't file was a week I couldn't get back - that's the brutal reality of how I learned about this. Filed my UI claim almost a month after my layoff because I thought I had to wait for some paperwork from my employer. When I finally filed and asked about backdating, EDD said they needed documentation of why I waited. I didn't have clean documentation and only got approved for a partial backdate. If you have any records - workers comp denial letters, medical notes, anything dated - keep all of it.

0 coins

Drake

Author

I actually have a stack of workers comp paperwork with dates on it and the letter saying they were terminating my payments. That should count as documentation right?

0 coins

That termination letter is probably your most useful document for explaining the gap. It shows you were on another program and thought you were covered.

0 coins

The doctor release paperwork with the specific date they cleared you is probably just as important as the workers comp end notice. EDD needs both ends of that timeline.

0 coins

Wanted to flag something about the SDI piece mentioned earlier - the person above who said Disability Insurance covers you when you can't work due to injury is correct, but the deadline to file SDI is 49 days after the disability starts. If your injury was late September and you're just finding this out now, that SDI window is likely long closed. So SDI probably isn't an option for those past weeks anymore - unemployment going forward from your clearance date is likely your path now.

0 coins

49 days is the cutoff, and yeah for someone injured in late September that clock has definitely run. This is a really important point because some people hear 'file for SDI' and assume they can still do it months later.

0 coins

Drake

Author

That's discouraging but good to know. I guess I'm not crying over that SDI ship since I didn't know about it - focusing on getting the UI claim sorted from my clearance date forward makes more sense now.

0 coins

PFL has a 41-day deadline too, just for context in case anyone reading this is dealing with a family care situation rather than their own injury.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD actually deny a backdating request? I'm curious what happens - do they just start your claim from when you filed and you lose those weeks, or do you get to appeal it?

0 coins

If EDD denies the backdate you'd get a Notice of Determination explaining why. From there you have 30 days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing using the DE 1000M form or a letter sent to the address on the notice.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date - got it. And you'd appeal to the CUIAB?

0 coins

EDD reviews it first after you submit the appeal, then it goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board if needed. An administrative law judge handles the hearing.

0 coins

Keep certifying through the whole appeal process even if weeks are denied or pending - you can only get paid for weeks you certified, so don't stop just because there's a dispute open.

0 coins

Termination of my workers comp happened after a 'functional capacity evaluation' that my employer's insurance didn't like the results of - basically same situation as the person posting here. Getting EDD to understand that timeline was hard over the phone. After weeks of busy signals and getting hung up on, I tried Claimyr and got through to a live EDD agent. What I needed to know was whether my workers comp termination date was in EDD's system correctly and the agent confirmed the date they had on file, then told me my pending weeks were waiting on a phone interview to be scheduled. That explained why nothing was moving on UI Online.

0 coins

Pending weeks just sitting there with no explanation is the worst. At least knowing a phone interview is in the queue gives you something to track.

0 coins

Exactly - once I knew what was actually holding things up I could stop guessing and just wait for the interview notice.

0 coins

Drake

Author

DE 4800 is the interview notice right? And the interview time is on that notice and also on the UI Online homepage?

0 coins

That's the one. The interviewer phones you at the time listed on it, so make sure your phone is on and you're somewhere you can actually talk.

0 coins

Light duty clearance - to answer the person who asked earlier - does count. If your doctor releases you for light or limited duty work, you're considered able and available for work you can physically do. That's what matters for UI eligibility. You don't have to be cleared for your old full duties, just for some work. The catch is you're supposed to be actively looking for work in that category, not just waiting for your old job to take you back on light duty.

0 coins

DE 429Z still hasn't arrived for me yet, so I haven't confirmed my weekly amount - but this is reassuring. I was worried light duty clearance would disqualify me completely.

0 coins

Shouldn't disqualify you. EDD looks at whether you can do some kind of work, not necessarily the specific job you were doing before.

0 coins

The work search piece matters here too - you're expected to be applying to jobs suited to your current restrictions, not just sitting on the clearance. Keep records of what you're applying to.

0 coins

Missed this point in the thread - who files the CalJOBS resume? Like is it the claimant doing that themselves at caljobs.ca.gov or does EDD do anything on that end? First time going through this and the CalJOBS step feels like a separate whole thing to figure out.

0 coins

You do it yourself at caljobs.ca.gov - set up an account, fill in your work history, post your resume. EDD doesn't do it for you. It's tied to your UI claim through your info. The deadline is 21 days from the date on your DE 8405 notice, so don't wait on it.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. So I log into CalJOBS myself and post the resume before the deadline on that notice.

0 coins

America's Job Centers of California can help you with the resume and CalJOBS setup if you need a hand - they don't process claims but they have staff who help with the job search stuff including CalJOBS registration.

0 coins

Reading this thread made me realize I might have screwed up my own certification. When I was getting some workers comp settlement payments I reported them under wages but I wasn't sure if that was right. EDD hasn't flagged anything yet but now I'm nervous.

0 coins

Settlement payments are a bit different from weekly workers comp temporary disability payments. If you're not sure you reported it correctly, contact EDD through a message in your UI Online account or call them. It's always better to self-report a potential issue than wait for EDD to find it.

0 coins

Yeah I'll send a message through UI Online. I'd rather deal with it now than get an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

Overpayment notices are really stressful to deal with - better to flag it proactively. The form for requesting a waiver if one comes is the DE 1446UI, but hopefully it doesn't come to that.

0 coins

Waiting week question for this situation - when EDD backdates the claim to the medical clearance date, does the waiting week start from there or from the original filing date? Mine got processed weird and I still don't understand why one week shows as unpaid.

0 coins

Every claim has one unpaid waiting week, it's just the first eligible week - doesn't matter when you filed or when EDD backdates to. The first week in your claim window is always that unpaid week. It doesn't change what the total claim can pay, it just means week one doesn't cut you a check. Had to get this explained to me by an EDD agent when I was going in circles on it - ended up using Claimyr to get through since the phones were impossible that week. The agent confirmed my waiting week was correctly applied from my claim start date.

0 coins

Okay so that unpaid week is just always going to be there regardless - it's not a penalty or an error. That's what confused me, I kept thinking something was wrong.

0 coins

Not an error. The DE 429Z explains it too once you have that in hand - there's a line that shows your waiting week date.

0 coins

Something I wish I'd known at the start of my injury situation - the programs don't talk to each other automatically. Workers comp has no obligation to tell EDD anything, and EDD doesn't pull data from workers comp. So EDD only knows what you tell them and what your employer reports. If your employer's workers comp insurer sends them information about your restrictions ending, the employer might report to EDD differently than what your doctor says. Getting in front of any discrepancy early is worth doing.

0 coins

Drake

Author

This is a really useful heads up. My employer and their insurance company were not exactly on my side during the workers comp process - I'll make sure the story I tell EDD is backed up by my own documents, not just what my employer might say.

0 coins

EDD does contact your employer when you file. What your employer says and what you say both go into the mix, especially if there's a phone interview scheduled.

0 coins

And the employer has to respond within 10 days of EDD's notice to them - if they don't respond, they lose certain rights in that process.

0 coins

Following this thread because I have a related situation - hurt at work, workers comp is still ongoing, but I reduced my hours to part-time before the injury because of an unrelated thing and now I'm wondering if UI even applies. I feel like I read somewhere that you have to be fully unemployed which isn't true right?

0 coins

Not fully unemployed - UI covers partial employment too. If your hours or wages are reduced you can potentially collect the difference depending on your weekly benefit amount and what you're earning. The formula is the first $25 or 25% of your weekly gross earnings (whichever is bigger) doesn't count, and the rest comes off your weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

Oh so if I'm earning something part-time I'd still potentially get a partial UI payment? That changes things for me.

0 coins

Apply and let EDD calculate it - the Unemployment Benefit Calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate but the actual number comes from EDD's review of your base period wages.

0 coins

Didn't know about that calculator - I'll look it up on edd.ca.gov before I do anything else.

0 coins

Phone interview prep for this kind of workers comp crossover case - the DE 4800 notice will tell you the questions they're likely to cover. For a workers comp situation they'll probably want to know your last day of work, why you're no longer working, what the workers comp situation was, and when your restrictions were lifted. Having your dates lined up - last day of work, when workers comp started, when it ended, when doctor cleared you - will make the interview much smoother.

0 coins

Drake

Author

DE 4800 hasn't arrived yet but I'm starting to put together a timeline document now so I have everything ready when it does. Last day worked was September 28th, workers comp started September 30th, payments stopped November 10th, doctor cleared me November 14th. Does that look like the right way to lay it out?

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of timeline that will help you during the interview. The interviewer phones at the time on the DE 4800, so when that arrives double-check that the time listed works with your schedule.

0 coins

If the interview time doesn't work for some reason, contact EDD at least one day before - they can try to give you a different open slot. Don't just miss it, because if you do, EDD decides from whatever information they have and that usually doesn't go well.

0 coins

Final thing worth flagging - does anyone know if the backdated weeks require separate certifications or if EDD handles those retroactively when they approve the backdate? I keep seeing conflicting info on this.

0 coins

You still have to certify for those backdated weeks - EDD doesn't automatically certify them for you. Usually when a backdate is approved they'll prompt you to certify for the weeks going back. Certifying in UI Online is the fastest way to get those processed.

0 coins

Okay, so the backdate gets approved, then you go in and certify for each of those prior weeks in UI Online? That's what I'll plan for.

0 coins

Exactly that. And for those past weeks you'll need to accurately answer how much you earned, whether you were able and available, and whether you looked for work during each week - same questions as normal certification but going backward.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure