Back to California Unemployment

Malik Thomas

How to appeal disqualification for taking classes and training benefits in California EDD

Got denied benefits two weeks ago and the Notice of Determination says I was disqualified because I enrolled in a full-time nursing program while collecting UI. Thing is, I was doing the program through an arrangement my former employer's HR department pointed me toward right after my layoff, and I genuinely believed EDD had something for people going back to school. The denial letter came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) but I don't even know where to start. My weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z was $390 and I've already certified for three weeks that are all sitting Pending now. Did anyone else get hit with this kind of disqualification? Is there actually a pathway to keep collecting while you're in school or did I misunderstand the whole thing? I'm trying to figure out how to appeal disqualification for taking classes and training benefits at the same time, because the notice doesn't explain which one I'm supposed to fight first.

The question to ask yourself before anything else is whether EDD ever approved your training program specifically. If you got into school on your own and started certifying without EDD signing off on California Training Benefits first, that's the gap the denial is pointing at. The DE 1000M you got is the right form to mail back, and the address is printed on the Notice of Determination itself. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice, not from when you received it, so count from that date and don't lose any time.

0 coins

The mailing date on mine is from 11 days ago so I still have time. The notice doesn't say anything about whether EDD approved the nursing program or not, it just says I wasn't available for work. Does the appeal letter need to explain the training benefits angle separately or is one appeal enough for both issues?

0 coins

One appeal covers everything on that notice. Write down every reason you disagree and mail it all together. The appeal goes to EDD first and then they forward it to the CUIAB if EDD doesn't reverse it themselves.

0 coins

What the person above said about one appeal is right. Put in the letter that you believe California Training Benefits should apply and that you want that reviewed as part of the appeal. The administrative law judge at the hearing can look at all of it.

0 coins

Nursing program enrollment while laid off is exactly the situation I was in last spring. The DE 429Z showed $370 a week and after the disqualification notice showed up UI Online had three pending weeks I couldn't get any answer on through messages. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent after I'd spent days getting nowhere on my own. The video at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 shows how reaching a live person at EDD by phone actually works. I asked the agent whether my nursing coursework could qualify under California Training Benefits and what I needed to do about the pending weeks. She looked at my claim and told me the Training Benefits approval has to come before you start school, not after, and that my pending weeks were held up because the availability question wasn't resolved yet. She said to file the appeal and keep certifying every two weeks so those weeks stay on the record for back payment if the appeal goes my way.

0 coins

The timing piece is what I was confused about. I didn't know approval had to come before enrollment. Does that mean the appeal is basically asking EDD to treat the approval as if it happened retroactively, or is the hearing about something else entirely?

0 coins

The 'approval before enrollment' timing is a real sticking point in these cases. At the hearing you're essentially arguing that you meet the conditions for Training Benefits and that the disqualification should be overturned on those grounds. Whether the judge agrees depends on the specifics EDD and you both present.

0 coins

After the agent explained the timing, I focused my appeal letter on demonstrating I was otherwise able and available for work during the weeks before the program started. That framing helped clarify what was actually in dispute.

0 coins

Something worth flagging here: keep certifying even while your appeal is going through the process. EDD can only pay back weeks that were certified, so if you stop certifying because you think the appeal pauses everything, you lose those weeks entirely. This comes up constantly in training benefits situations and people find out too late.

0 coins

Stopped certifying during my own appeal two years ago for exactly this reason and lost four weeks. Had to learn it the hard way. Keep going no matter what the status shows.

0 coins

Already certified the week after the denial came in because I wasn't sure what else to do. Good to know that was actually the right move.

0 coins

For anyone reading later: UI Online is the fastest way to certify each two-week period. The status may still show Pending during the appeal but the weeks get recorded.

0 coins

Does certifying during an appeal affect the appeal outcome at all, or are those two totally separate tracks? Asking because someone told me certifying during an appeal was some kind of admission that you agree with the disqualification, which sounds wrong to me.

0 coins

Certifying and appealing are completely separate. Certifying is just keeping the weeks on record. It has zero effect on what the judge decides about the disqualification.

0 coins

The California Training Benefits program is what you want to research before writing your appeal letter. It lets people in EDD-approved education or training keep collecting without meeting the usual work search requirement, and it may even add weeks through a Training Extension if you request it before your 16th week of benefits. The critical word is EDD-approved: your specific program needs that designation, and the approval process runs through EDD before enrollment, not after.

0 coins

Is the Training Extension automatic once Training Benefits are approved, or do you have to request it separately and before a specific point?

0 coins

You have to request it yourself, before your 16th week of benefits. It's not automatic and EDD doesn't remind you. If you're going to pursue Training Benefits through the appeal, ask EDD about the extension timeline at the same time so you don't miss that window.

0 coins

The 16-week deadline on the Training Extension catches a lot of people off guard. Worth bringing up at the hearing as well, to put it on the judge's radar if the appeal is successful.

0 coins

WAIT does this mean every person who enrolls in school while on unemployment gets automatically disqualified?? I've been taking two evening community college classes and nobody told me I had to get EDD approval first. My claim has been paying normally so now I'm panicking about whether I'm about to get a denial notice too.

0 coins

Part-time evening classes while you're still able and available for full-time work is a different situation from full-time enrollment. The original poster's nursing program is full-time, which is the core of the availability issue EDD flagged. Your situation sounds different but if you're worried, sending a message through your UI Online account to ask EDD directly would give you a clear answer for your specific claim.

0 coins

Two classes on Tuesday and Thursday evenings, still applying to jobs every week. Okay that makes more sense. I was scared for a minute.

0 coins

The availability question is really about whether you're actually free to accept full-time work. Evening courses that don't block daytime job opportunities are a much smaller issue than a full-time program where you'd have to turn down a day-shift job offer.

0 coins

DE 1000M deadline aside, the actual hearing is where most of this gets decided. After EDD reviews your appeal and sends it to the CUIAB, an administrative law judge schedules a hearing and you get a Notice of Hearing in the mail at least 10 days before it. At the hearing, testimony is under oath, and you can bring documentation: enrollment records, any correspondence with your former employer's HR about the program, anything showing you believed the training was approved or that you were otherwise available for work. Used Claimyr to reach EDD before my own hearing on a different training dispute, and the agent confirmed which weeks were still open on my claim and that my identity had already been verified, which was one less thing to worry about going in.

0 coins

The HR correspondence angle is something I actually have. My former employer's HR sent me an email describing the nursing program and I replied asking if it was something EDD would support. That email chain might help show I wasn't just signing up on my own without thinking about approval.

0 coins

That email chain is exactly the kind of documentation to bring. It shows you were asking the right questions, even if you didn't ultimately get formal EDD approval before enrolling. The judge will look at context.

0 coins

Bringing organized documentation to the CUIAB hearing genuinely matters. I've seen appeals where the claimant had a solid case but came unprepared and the judge had nothing concrete to work with.

0 coins

Can you have someone come with you to the hearing, like a family member or a union rep, or do you go alone?

0 coins

You can represent yourself or bring someone, like a union official or an attorney. Family isn't specifically excluded but practically speaking you'd want someone who understands the appeals process.

0 coins

The notice says 'not available for work' as the reason, right? That's the specific finding you're appealing, and your argument is that enrollment in an approved training program is an exception to the availability requirement under California Training Benefits. If the program itself wasn't formally approved, your appeal needs to argue that it should have been, or that EDD should have advised you of the approval requirement before you enrolled. Those are two different arguments and it helps to be clear in your appeal letter about which one you're making.

0 coins

The notice does say 'not available' and it also references the enrollment dates. I think my actual argument is closer to the second one you described, because I genuinely didn't know there was an approval step. How specific do I need to be in the written appeal versus what I can explain at the hearing?

0 coins

The written appeal just needs to say you disagree and briefly why. You don't have to lay out your entire case in the letter. The real detail comes at the hearing, which is where you present documentation and testimony. Keep the letter short, state you disagree with the disqualification, and mention that Training Benefits should apply to your situation.

0 coins

Waiting weeks on a training-related disqualification were exactly what I called EDD about through Claimyr, and the agent told me the weeks certified before the disqualification date were still potentially payable if the appeal reversed the decision. That detail mattered for how I worded my own appeal letter.

0 coins

My appeal on a disqualification took about eight weeks from mailing the form to getting a Notice of Hearing. That was my experience, but I've seen people here say theirs moved faster or slower. EDD reviews it first, and if they don't reverse it, it goes to the CUIAB. Plan for it to take a while and keep certifying the whole time.

0 coins

Eight weeks is longer than I expected but good to mentally prepare for. Does the CUIAB send any kind of update while the case is being reviewed, or is it just silence until the Notice of Hearing shows up?

0 coins

Mostly silence, in my experience. The Notice of Hearing just arrives in the mail. I didn't get any status updates in between.

0 coins

SAME. Appealed last year and there was nothing for six weeks and then suddenly the hearing notice was in my mailbox. No emails, no UI Online notification, just a letter.

0 coins

Before the hearing you should also call the CUIAB's office to confirm they received everything and find out if there's anything else they need from you. I know the EDD phone line is a nightmare but the Office of Appeals has a separate number and I found it slightly easier to get through on. At minimum send a message through UI Online to confirm EDD received the DE 1000M.

0 coins

I mailed the DE 1000M yesterday with return receipt requested so I'll have proof it was received. Is there anything I can do through UI Online to check that EDD has it on record or does the confirmation only come by mail?

0 coins

UI Online doesn't show appeal status in real time. The return receipt is actually the most reliable confirmation you'll have until you get EDD's written response or the CUIAB sends the Notice of Hearing.

0 coins

Return receipt is the move. I sent mine without it and spent three weeks not knowing if it had arrived.

0 coins

Not sure if this helps but I went through a training benefits situation where EDD initially said my program wasn't approved and I won the appeal. The key was getting a letter from the school showing the program's accreditation and job placement rates, which helped make the case that it was legitimate vocational training. Nursing programs are strong on that front.

0 coins

That's genuinely encouraging. My nursing program is through an accredited community college so I should be able to get that kind of documentation from them without much trouble.

0 coins

The school's financial aid office or registrar can usually produce that letter quickly. I emailed mine and had it in two days.

0 coins

Accreditation documentation can also help show the program leads to real employment, which ties back into the whole 'this is legitimate training' argument at the hearing.

0 coins

EDD's own language around training is worth looking up on edd.ca.gov before you write the appeal letter. Knowing exactly what criteria they use to evaluate whether a program qualifies for California Training Benefits helps you write your argument in terms EDD actually uses. The Unemployment Benefit Calculator is on that site too if you want to double-check your weekly amount calculation.

0 coins

The $390 on my DE 429Z matched what the calculator estimated when I first applied, so that part seems right. I'll look at the training benefits criteria page.

0 coins

Reading EDD's own criteria before writing the appeal is a genuinely good approach. It's easier to argue 'I meet criteria 1, 2 and 3' than to write a vague 'I think I should qualify' letter.

0 coins

Quick sanity check: appeal hearings are over the phone, right? I keep seeing people say 'go to the hearing' and I want to make sure nobody is expecting to show up somewhere in person. My CUIAB hearing last year was a phone call.

0 coins

Format can vary. Some hearings are by phone, some are in person. The Notice of Hearing tells you exactly how yours is set up, so check that when it arrives.

0 coins

Makes sense. I assumed phone was standard but I guess they vary. Good to check the notice carefully.

0 coins

Wherever the hearing is, being in a quiet place with good phone reception matters a lot. During a phone hearing especially, being cut off or hard to hear creates real problems.

0 coins

The person above is right that the Notice of Hearing has the format. Also worth noting: if the date they schedule doesn't work for you, the notice explains how to request a change. You need to contact the CUIAB with enough lead time, not just show up and ask for a rescheduled hearing.

0 coins

Good to know. The last thing I want is to end up in a situation where I have a class conflict with the hearing date and don't know how to handle it.

0 coins

Exactly. Contact them as soon as you know there's a conflict, don't wait until the day before.

0 coins

Something that doesn't come up enough in these threads: even if the appeal doesn't go your way, the written decision from the judge explains the specific reasoning. That reasoning is useful if you decide to do a second-level appeal to the CUIAB board itself. You're not out of options after the first hearing.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a second level. So it goes EDD review, then administrative law judge, then CUIAB board if you disagree with the judge?

0 coins

Exactly that order. Each level looks at whether the previous decision was correct, so you want your record as clean as possible at every stage.

0 coins

The judge's written decision also gets mailed to you, which gives you something concrete to understand and respond to if you pursue the second level.

0 coins

Just want to make sure the work search requirement gets addressed somewhere in this thread: when you're appealing a disqualification, you still have to meet all the standard eligibility requirements for the weeks you're certifying, including being able and available for work, unless and until Training Benefits are approved. Don't stop looking for work just because the appeal is in progress.

0 coins

I've been continuing to do work search activities and keeping my own records of where I apply each week. Wasn't sure if that was necessary during the appeal but it sounds like it is.

0 coins

Keeping records of your applications is a good habit regardless of EDD's specific requirements. If your availability is ever questioned again, having that documentation helps.

0 coins

The appeal doesn't pause the weekly eligibility requirements. Each week you certify, you have to honestly answer whether you were able and available. If your nursing classes are making it impossible to take a job during that week, that's the honest answer and it's part of what the appeal needs to address.

0 coins

When I had my own appeal hearing on a totally different issue, the administrative law judge asked me questions I hadn't prepared for about my job search activities during the weeks in question. I'd recommend thinking through your answer to 'were you available for and actively seeking work during each week you certified?' because it's going to come up.

0 coins

The honest answer for some of those weeks is complicated because nursing clinicals have set hours that would conflict with certain shifts. I'll need to think about how to explain that clearly without making it sound worse than it is.

0 coins

Being specific and honest in your explanation is better than vague or defensive answers. Judges in these hearings hear a lot of cases and they can tell when someone is hedging.

0 coins

The clinical hours question is actually central to the whole training benefits issue. If the program were formally approved under California Training Benefits, those clinical hours wouldn't be a problem. That's part of why the approval piece matters so much.

0 coins

Pending weeks on a training-related case can sit for a long time without explanation. After my DE 429Z came in showing $310 a week and three weeks flipped to Pending with no notice from EDD about why, I tried Claimyr to reach an agent and got someone on the line to look at the specific weeks. The agent said one of the pending weeks had an identity verification step that hadn't been cleared, completely separate from the training question. Knowing that let me handle the two issues separately instead of thinking everything was held up for one reason.

0 coins

The idea that there might be separate issues causing pending weeks is something I hadn't considered. My three pending weeks might not all be pending for the same reason.

0 coins

Worth getting clarity on each week individually if you can reach EDD. The pending status in Claim History doesn't tell you which specific issue is holding each week.

0 coins

Finding out there are multiple separate issues stacking up is somehow worse than one big problem. Hope yours turns out to be simpler than that.

0 coins

The appeal letter itself doesn't need to be long or use legal language. I've seen people overthink it and write three pages when a clear one-paragraph letter saying 'I disagree with the disqualification dated [date] and believe California Training Benefits should apply to my nursing program enrollment' would be enough to get the case in front of the judge. The hearing is where you explain everything.

0 coins

That framing is actually really helpful. I was planning to write a very detailed letter but maybe shorter and direct is better for the initial appeal.

0 coins

Short and clear for the letter, detailed and documented for the hearing. That's the approach that makes sense in my experience.

0 coins

Agreed. The letter gets you in the door. The hearing is where the case actually gets made.

0 coins

Last practical note: make sure your mailing address in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is current, because all the notices, the CUIAB correspondence and the judge's decision all come by mail. If EDD has an old address they mail it to, you might miss a notice or a deadline without knowing it.

0 coins

Checked my address in myEDD after reading this and it was still showing my old apartment. Updated it. Really glad you mentioned this because I would not have thought to look.

0 coins

Address updates are one of those things that everybody forgets after a move and then it causes real problems during an appeal when timing is tight.

0 coins

Missing a Notice of Hearing because of a wrong address is exactly the kind of thing that derails an otherwise solid appeal. Good catch.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure