Back to California Unemployment

Giovanni Mancini

How long after section 1277 invalid claim letter can I certify again?

Got hit with a section 1277 invalid claim determination last month and I'm completely lost on what happens next. My situation: I left my retail job in September after almost two years because the commute became impossible when my car broke down and I couldn't afford to fix it right away. Filed my UI claim, did everything right as far as I knew, then got a letter saying my claim was invalid under section 1277. The letter mentions something about not having enough wages in my base period to establish a valid claim. Here's what's confusing me - I definitely worked those two years and made decent money, at least I thought. The Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award (DE 429Z) even showed a weekly benefit amount before this 1277 letter showed up. So how can the claim be invalid if they already sent me an award notice? And my biggest question is how long after section 1277 invalid claim letter can I certify again? Like is it even possible to certify at all while this is being sorted out, or do I have to wait for something to happen first? I appealed the determination in writing using the DE 1000M within the 30 days, but no one will tell me what comes next. I've been going without income for six weeks now and I'm starting to really panic about rent.

Section 1277 came up on my claim too, about eight months ago. The situation was a job I held for about 14 months before a layoff, and my DE 429Z showed $285 a week before EDD sent the invalid claim letter two weeks later. The timing confused me completely. Ended up reaching EDD by phone using Claimyr (claimyr.com) - there's a video they have specifically on reaching a live person at EDD, https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10, which I watched first. The agent I talked to pulled up my account and explained that my wages in the standard base period fell just under the threshold for a valid claim, and that EDD had automatically checked the alternate base period but that one came up short too. She confirmed both periods had been calculated and neither met the minimum. She said the DE 429Z going out before that determination was a timing issue in EDD's processing, not a signal that benefits were approved. She also told me I couldn't certify on the existing claim while the invalid claim determination stood, but that I should absolutely appeal within 30 days of the letter's mailing date if I thought the wage figures were wrong - which I did, the same day.

0 coins

The part about both base periods being checked automatically - that's actually really helpful to know. Mine showed wages I know I earned, so I'm wondering if the employer reported them wrong to EDD. Would the appeal process catch that or is there a separate way to flag it?

0 coins

Alternate base period being checked automatically tracks with what I've read. EDD doesn't make you ask for it separately, it just runs both and picks the one that works - but only if one of them actually meets the minimum wage requirements.

0 coins

DE 429Z going out before the final determination really does cause so much confusion. People see that letter and think they're good to go, then the 1277 hits and it feels like a total reversal.

0 coins

Thought the alternate base period was something you had to specifically request - turns out that's wrong. EDD runs it automatically whenever the standard base period doesn't produce a valid claim. The standard period covers the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your claim starts. The alternate covers the most recent four completed quarters. EDD moves to the alternate on its own, no form or request needed. For the wage minimums: a valid claim needs either $1,300 in one quarter of the base period, or at least $900 in the highest quarter with total base period wages adding up to at least 1.25 times that highest quarter amount. If neither base period hits those numbers, section 1277 applies and the claim is invalid. On the certifying question - with an active 1277 determination, there's nothing to certify on. The appeal is the path forward. If the appeal succeeds and the determination gets reversed, EDD processes the weeks from when you would have been eligible, but only if you certified those weeks. So keep track of your weeks regardless.

0 coins

Keeping track of weeks regardless - does that mean I should actually be certifying through UI Online even with the 1277 showing, or just keeping my own personal record of which weeks I was available and looking for work?

0 coins

Personal record for now. Without a valid claim on record there's nothing in UI Online to certify on. But document everything - dates you were available, jobs you applied to, all of it - so if the appeal goes your way you have that history ready.

0 coins

The wage minimums are really specific. A lot of people assume any work history at all qualifies you, but those thresholds are real and EDD applies them strictly. The alternate base period being automatic is a good thing but it doesn't save everyone.

0 coins

Had a situation where my employer flat out reported my wages wrong to EDD. Showed up as one full quarter of wages when I'd actually worked across three quarters. The mismatch pushed my claim into invalid territory even though I'd made plenty. The way to address this in an appeal is to bring your pay stubs or W-2 showing the actual wages and quarters they were earned. The appeal form DE 1000M has space to explain the basis of your appeal, and incorrect employer wage reporting is a solid ground. The administrative law judge at the CUIAB hearing is the one who actually looks at your documentation - EDD reviews it first, then it goes there if EDD doesn't reverse the determination on its own.

0 coins

So EDD could potentially reverse it before it even goes to a CUIAB hearing? I didn't know there was an internal review step. How long does that typically take before it moves to the appeals board stage?

0 coins

EDD reviews appeals before sending them to CUIAB but the timeline varies - no set number of days is published. The Notice of Hearing from the appeals board comes at least 10 days before your hearing, so you'll have time to prepare once that's scheduled.

0 coins

Bringing actual pay stubs to the appeal is key. I've heard of people trying to dispute wage reporting with just their own recollection and that doesn't go anywhere. Paper documentation of what you earned and when is what actually moves the needle.

0 coins

Section 1277 landed on my claim and I was completely sure it was a mistake because I remembered making good money that year. When I finally got to look at my actual pay history by quarter though, most of my earnings had been in the last quarter - which fell outside the standard base period. The standard period looks at earlier quarters, so a raise or a big earning stretch near the end doesn't always help as much as you'd think. The alternate base period fixed it for me because it captured those recent quarters. But EDD had already run both and found my claim invalid, which made me think - maybe my situation was different than the person above's. If you had steady earnings spread across two years, the issue is more likely employer reporting than base period timing.

0 coins

That timing issue with which quarters get counted is exactly the kind of thing nobody explains clearly when you first file. Two years of steady retail work should have been spread across multiple quarters so I'm leaning toward the reporting error theory.

0 coins

The base period math trips up so many people. The last completed quarter before your claim is actually excluded from the standard period - so if you earned a lot right before filing, those wages might not count at all in the standard calculation.

0 coins

Employer reporting errors are more common than people think. Big retailers especially sometimes have payroll issues that affect what actually gets sent to EDD.

0 coins

BEEN DEALING WITH EDD FOR MONTHS and the certifying question is what gets everyone. With a 1277 determination, the system literally won't let you certify because there is no valid claim for the system to attach certifications to. It's not like adjudication where you're waiting on a pending decision and can keep certifying in the meantime. Invalid claim is a different category entirely. The appeal is your ONLY path. You need that determination reversed before any certifications happen. And then yes, if it's reversed, the question of back weeks comes up - but that only matters if you kept records of your availability during the gap.

0 coins

The distinction between invalid claim and adjudication is one I definitely did not understand at first. I thought invalid claim just meant it was under review. The adjudication/invalid split is completely different and knowing which one you're dealing with changes what you do next.

0 coins

Okay so to make sure I have this right - adjudication means EDD is evaluating eligibility on an otherwise valid claim, and 1277 means the claim itself wasn't established in the first place. Those are two separate issues with completely different processes.

0 coins

Exactly right. Adjudication is about whether you qualify for benefits on a valid claim. Section 1277 is about whether a valid claim even exists. Can't get to eligibility questions until the claim foundation is established.

0 coins

Two quarters into what I thought was a solid claim, an employer-side wage discrepancy knocked mine into 1277 territory. The DE 1101CZ notice EDD sends the employer apparently gives them 10 days to respond, and sometimes what they report back doesn't match the actual payroll records. Phoned EDD through Claimyr to ask an agent to read me exactly what wage amounts were on file for each quarter. The agent went through it quarter by quarter and I could compare right there to my W-2. Found two quarters where the figures were off - one was understated by almost $1,100. That specific discrepancy went into my appeal letter with the actual W-2 attached. Appeal is still pending but at least the documented discrepancy gives me something concrete to bring to the hearing.

0 coins

Getting the exact wage figures on file is something I hadn't thought to do. I've been assuming my appeal was just going to be my word against whatever EDD has, but if I can show a specific dollar discrepancy with my own documents that's a much stronger position.

0 coins

W-2 versus what EDD has on file - that comparison is genuinely the first thing anyone with a 1277 and normal work history should do. The employer reporting piece is often where the error lives.

0 coins

EDD agents can read you your wage records by quarter over the phone. That's not something a lot of people know. Useful for exactly this situation.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact chain of events. Filed, got the DE 429Z with a weekly amount of $310, thought everything was fine, then 11 days later the section 1277 letter arrived. Spent two weeks thinking the DE 429Z was an approval before I actually understood what it was. DE 429Z is NOT an approval. It shows what the claim is set up to pay if everything checks out. EDD still runs the actual wage validation after sending it, which is how you can receive both a DE 429Z and then a 1277 determination within the same few weeks. The timing makes it look contradictory but that's just how EDD's processing is sequenced.

0 coins

The DE 429Z came with a $240 weekly amount and I honestly thought that meant I was approved. I even told my landlord I'd have income coming. Having that pulled back two weeks later was awful.

0 coins

DE 429Z confusion is incredibly common. EDD should include a clearer note on that form explaining it's a potential amount, not a determination that benefits will be paid. Most people read it as an approval because why else would EDD send you your weekly amount.

0 coins

The form says 'award' in the name which absolutely makes it sound final. 'Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award' implies something has been awarded. EDD's internal processing sequence doesn't match the impression that name gives.

0 coins

While the appeal is pending, CalJOBS registration is worth doing even now if you haven't. The Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) gives a 21-day window, and if the appeal resolves in your favor, any delay in having CalJOBS set up could create a separate issue with your certified weeks. Used Claimyr on my own claim when I had a wage dispute similar to this thread's situation - an agent confirmed that my CalJOBS registration was already flagged as overdue and that it needed to be current before any back weeks could be released even after a successful appeal. Getting that handled while waiting saved a step later. CalJOBS is at caljobs.ca.gov and you just need to post a resume - takes about 30 minutes total.

0 coins

CalJOBS being overdue causing a separate hold on top of the 1277 is not something I had on my radar at all. I never got a DE 8405 in the mail - does that mean I'm exempt or did it just not arrive?

0 coins

If EDD says you don't need to register, they communicate that separately. If you got a DE 8405 or weren't told you're exempt, the 21-day clock applies. Worth checking through Ask EDD or the UI Online message option to verify your status on that.

0 coins

Proactive CalJOBS registration is smart regardless. Even if it turns out not to be required in your case, having it done removes one potential snag if the appeal goes through.

0 coins

The appeal timeline feels unbearable when you're already six weeks without income. For anyone at that stage - keep certifying through any other program you might be eligible for, like Disability Insurance if that applies, and look into CalFresh while you wait. Unemployment benefits count as proof of income when applying for CalFresh even before they're in your bank, and CalFresh eligibility is based on income requirements the county determines. Apply at BenefitsCal or call 1-877-847-3663.

0 coins

CalFresh hasn't even occurred to me as something to look into while this plays out. I've been so focused on the EDD piece that I forgot there are other resources. Applying for that this week.

0 coins

Covered California is also worth checking for health coverage if you lost that through your job. Calling 2-1-1 can connect you to other local assistance programs depending on where you are.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up at first - section 1277 is specifically about not having enough wages in either base period to establish the claim. It's not related to why you left the job or whether you're available for work. Those are eligibility questions that only come up once a valid claim exists. So if someone has a 1277 AND a reason-for-leaving question like a quit, those are two completely separate issues and the wage one has to be resolved first.

0 coins

This is a distinction that would have saved me a lot of confusion early on. I kept thinking the 1277 was about the reason I left my job and was trying to gather documentation about my commute situation when actually it had nothing to do with that.

0 coins

The commute-related quit is what I thought the determination might be about too. Finding out it's purely a wage calculation thing actually makes me feel like the appeal has stronger ground, because I do have the pay stubs showing what I earned.

0 coins

Exactly - section 1277 is a math problem, not a conduct question. If the math is wrong because of employer reporting, documentation fixes it. That's a different and often easier case to make than arguing a quit had a good reason.

0 coins

Had my appeal scheduled before the CUIAB, and the Notice of Hearing arrived about three weeks after I submitted my DE 1000M. The hearing itself was by phone, which I hadn't expected. The administrative law judge reviewed my pay stubs and the wage records EDD had, asked me to walk through what I earned each quarter, and that was essentially the whole thing. Decision came by mail after.

0 coins

Hearing by phone - that's actually relieving to know. I was imagining having to appear somewhere in person which felt stressful on top of everything else.

0 coins

Phone hearings are standard now for most appeals. The notice tells you the date and time and you just need to have your documentation in front of you so you can reference specific numbers when the judge asks.

0 coins

Having the documentation organized by quarter is worth doing before the hearing. The judge will likely want to go quarter by quarter through the base period, so if your pay stubs are sorted that way it's much smoother.

0 coins

After the appeal decision comes, IF the determination is reversed - the question about certifying comes back. At that point EDD processes the claim as valid from the original effective date, and you'd need to have your certifications for each two-week period on file. Since you couldn't certify through UI Online while the 1277 stood, the restored weeks would need to be addressed directly with EDD. This is one more reason to document everything during the gap.

0 coins

Documenting every week during the gap is my homework assignment from this thread apparently. Available for work, actively looking, keeping records of applications submitted.

0 coins

Every week of availability and job search activity that you can document is a week that could potentially be paid if the appeal succeeds. The certification process formally covers those weeks but EDD needs to know you were actually meeting the requirements during them.

0 coins

The idea of going back and certifying weeks that passed months ago is confusing to a lot of people. It's not exactly certifying in the normal forward-looking sense - it's EDD processing those back weeks based on your established eligibility and your records of that period.

0 coins

For the person who mentioned getting the employer's reported wages read by an EDD agent - that is genuinely one of the most useful calls to make early in this process. EDD's records show exactly what each employer submitted for each quarter. If those numbers don't match your pay stubs, you have your appeal argument right there in black and white.

0 coins

EDD's quarterly wage records versus actual pay stubs is the core comparison in most wage dispute appeals. Sometimes the gap is huge and obvious, sometimes it's a few hundred dollars that pushed a claim under the threshold.

0 coins

Even a relatively small discrepancy matters when the threshold is $1,300 for a quarter or the 1.25x total wages calculation. A $200 difference could be the whole reason a claim hit 1277 instead of clearing the threshold.

0 coins

Section 1277 appeals are probably one of the more winnable types of appeals when employer wage reporting is the actual issue, because it's factual and documentable rather than subjective. The appeal is essentially asking EDD and then CUIAB to look at the real wage records and correct the math. That's very different from arguing about whether a reason for quitting was justified or whether something constituted misconduct. Used Claimyr when my own certification was stuck in a pending status tied to a wage question - the agent confirmed which quarter EDD had flagged and what figure they were working from, and that let me pull the right quarter's pay stubs immediately instead of guessing which records to gather. If you're at the stage of prepping for a hearing, knowing EDD's specific quarterly figures is essential so you're addressing the same numbers the judge will be looking at.

0 coins

The point about knowing EDD's exact figures before the hearing is well taken. If I walk in with my numbers and the judge has different numbers on record and I don't know what those are, I'd be flying blind.

0 coins

Factual wage documentation appeals do move more cleanly than judgment-call appeals. That's not a guarantee of anything but documentation-based arguments have a clear logic that the judge can follow step by step.

0 coins

One thing nobody's mentioned: if your appeal ultimately fails and both base periods genuinely don't have enough wages, section 1277 would mean you can't collect on that claim at all. But the benefit year question comes into play. Each claim has a 52-week benefit year from the Sunday you filed. If your situation changes - say you work more and build up wages - you'd file a new claim after the benefit year ends. That's the last-resort scenario and not what you should be thinking about with an active appeal in front of you. But understanding the full picture helps.

0 coins

Benefit year ending before you can refile is a painful scenario I hadn't thought through. That would mean waiting out almost a full year before even having the chance to try again. Really motivates me to push hard on this appeal.

0 coins

The 52-week benefit year clock is running from the original filing date regardless of the 1277. So if someone waits too long to pursue the appeal and then it fails, they might be waiting for a new benefit year to file a new claim.

0 coins

Tried to certify after getting a similar notice once and the system just showed no certifications available. Wasn't even an error message, just nothing there to click on. That blank screen is essentially EDD's way of showing you there's no active valid claim to certify on.

0 coins

The blank screen is somehow worse than an error message because it gives you no information. At least an error tells you something went wrong. No certifications available just leaves you staring at it.

0 coins

Called the number on the letter and eventually got an explanation but it took multiple attempts. The UI Online help chat during 9 to 2 on weekdays is sometimes faster for a specific account question like why certifications aren't available.

0 coins

UI Online live chat being available 9 to 2 on weekdays is something more people should know about. It's not 24/7 but it's faster than holding on the phone for a lot of account-specific questions.

0 coins

Mailed my appeal to the wrong address once - took a week longer than it should have because I used the main EDD address instead of the one on the actual Notice of Determination. The mailing address for the appeal is on the determination notice itself, and that's the right address. The 30-day clock from the mailing date on the notice is tight and mailing to the wrong address wastes days you don't have.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date moves fast especially if the letter sat for a few days before you opened it. The date on the notice is the one that counts, not when you received it or when you read it.

0 coins

I sent mine to the address on the notice and got a confirmation letter about 10 days later, so at least I know it landed in the right place. For anyone still in the process of sending theirs - check the envelope address twice.

0 coins

For the CalJOBS question that came up earlier - the DE 8405 is what triggers the 21-day clock. If you never received one, it's possible EDD determined you don't need to register, but that's worth confirming rather than assuming. Sending a message through Ask EDD or through UI Online asking specifically about your CalJOBS requirement status takes the guesswork out of it.

0 coins

Ask EDD confirmation in writing is also better than relying on what someone said on the phone, especially for something like CalJOBS status where a misunderstanding could create an additional barrier to getting paid when the appeal resolves.

0 coins

Written confirmation through Ask EDD creates a paper trail too. If there's ever a question later about whether you were told you were exempt, you have the response on record in your account.

0 coins

The person who mentioned documentation during the gap - that's probably the most important practical thing in this thread for someone in the middle of a 1277 appeal. Available for work, able to work, actively looking for work, every week. That's what unemployment requires for each week you'd want to eventually be paid for. Even with no claim to certify on right now, meeting those requirements in reality and being able to show it matters.

0 coins

I have been applying to jobs during all of this, partly out of necessity and partly because I figured I should be. Didn't realize documenting it formally might actually matter for the back weeks. Keeping better records starting now.

0 coins

Even a simple spreadsheet with the date, employer name, position, and how you applied works as documentation. Nothing has to be fancy, it just has to be specific and accurate.

0 coins

The requirement is being able to work, available for work and looking for work for every week you certify. During the appeal gap you can't formally certify, but keeping that documentation means if back weeks come through you can show you met the requirements during them.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure