Back to California Unemployment

Ella Cofer

Former employer appealing my unemployment approval months later what happens

Got my approval letter back in early September and have been certifying every two weeks without a hitch. Payments have been coming through fine, weekly benefit amount of $310, everything seemed settled. Then last week I got a notice in the mail saying my former employer is now challenging the approval — this is FOUR months after I was approved and already collecting. I was laid off when my department got cut, not fired for anything I did wrong. Does EDD reopen the whole thing? Can they take back the money I already received if the employer wins? I have no idea what to expect from this process and I'm kind of freaking out.

Approval came through on my claim in October after a furlough that turned into a permanent cut, $285 a week, and I thought I was done with the bureaucratic maze. Then a letter showed up saying my former company had filed a late appeal on my eligibility. I ended up talking to a live EDD agent about it — used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through the phone queue, there's a video explaining how to reach a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me a Notice of Hearing from CUIAB would be mailed at least 10 days before the scheduled date, and that I should keep certifying in the meantime no matter what, because uncertified weeks can't be paid back even if I win. That piece of advice alone was worth the call.

0 coins

The part about certifying through the whole process — nobody had told me that yet and it's exactly what I needed to hear. Did the agent say anything about whether the employer filing late changes how the hearing goes?

0 coins

Four months does feel late for an employer to just decide to challenge. The 10-day Notice of Hearing before the date is good to know though.

0 coins

The notice about keeping up with certifications is crucial. So many people stop because they assume it's being handled and then lose out on back weeks they should have gotten.

0 coins

Employer appeals after an approval go to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board — CUIAB, also called the Office of Appeals. An administrative law judge handles the hearing, not EDD directly. You'll get a Notice of Hearing by mail at least 10 days before it's scheduled. At the hearing your testimony is under oath, but you can represent yourself, bring a union rep if you have one, or have an attorney. The judge issues a written decision after.

0 coins

Does EDD show up to argue against me at the hearing, or is it just me versus my former employer?

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date on the determination is the standard window to appeal — four months later genuinely surprises me. Though I guess if the employer gave a reason for missing the deadline the board might still accept it.

0 coins

Nobody argues EDD's side at those hearings from what I understand — it's really the claimant and the employer presenting their accounts to the judge. The late filing question is a real one; the employer would need to explain why they missed the original window.

0 coins

My layoff paperwork said 'position elimination' which should have been clean, but my former company disputed whether the whole department was actually cut or just restructured. Got a notice about a hearing scheduled six weeks out. I ended up speaking with an EDD agent — Claimyr got me through the hold on the EDD line so I could ask what documents to bring. The agent said to gather anything that shows the layoff was a real elimination: internal emails, the official notice I got, the severance agreement if there was one — and that the judge would look at both sides' accounts.

0 coins

My situation is similar — the department literally no longer exists but I'm worried they'll try to reframe it at the hearing. What did you end up bringing to yours?

0 coins

Position' elimination 'versus' restructuring is a distinction employers sometimes try to exploit. If the whole team got laid off at the same time, that seems pretty clear-cut tome.

0 coins

I brought the email announcing the department closure, the written layoff notice with the date, and printed my employment dates from the company portal. The judge asked both sides questions and then said the written decision would come by mail.

0 coins

Keep certifying — I want to second that point hard. When I went through an appeal situation two years ago I made the mistake of thinking I should pause certifying while it was being decided. Lost three weeks of potential payments I could have gotten back if I'd won. EDD can only pay certified weeks. Don't stop.

0 coins

The same thing happened to a former coworker — stopped certifying thinking the appeal froze everything and ended up with a gap they couldn't recover.

0 coins

Already certified for this week before I saw this thread, so at least I didn't pause. Going to keep going no matter what until this is resolved.

0 coins

It seems counterintuitive to keep certifying when you're unsure if you even qualify, but the logic makes sense — you have to have certified weeks on record to get paid for them if the ruling goes your way.

0 coins

The 30-day window to appeal a Notice of Determination is what trips people up on both sides. Claimants miss it, employers miss it. A late appeal needs a reason given for why the deadline was missed — the board still has discretion to accept it or not. If the employer's reason isn't strong enough, the late appeal might just get dismissed before a hearing even happens.

0 coins

How would I even know if the appeal was dismissed for being late? Would EDD notify me, or would it just go quiet?

0 coins

You'd get written notice from CUIAB either way — either a Notice of Hearing or something indicating the appeal was rejected. It won't just go silent without any mail.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date, not the date you received it. That's a detail that catches people — the clock starts when EDD mailed it, not when it landed in your mailbox.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact sequence — approved in spring, employer appeal came in late summer. At the hearing I just told the truth about how the layoff happened, brought my termination letter, and the judge ruled in my favor. Layoffs with no misconduct involved are genuinely hard for an employer to overturn unless they can show the separation wasn't a layoff at all.

0 coins

Did the employer show up to the hearing in person or by phone? I'm not even sure what format these hearings take now.

0 coins

Mine was by phone — both sides called in at the scheduled time. The judge ran it, asked questions, and that was it. Much less intimidating than I'd feared.

0 coins

Phone hearings are pretty standard now. The judge controls the whole thing, so it's not like a courtroom where you're facing the other side across a table.

0 coins

Something that surprised me when I looked into this: the employer appealing doesn't automatically freeze your payments. Unless the judge issues some kind of interim ruling — which isn't standard — you keep receiving benefits while the appeal works through CUIAB. The concern about repayment only kicks in if you ultimately lose.

0 coins

If I lose at the hearing level, is there another appeal step I could take after that?

0 coins

There is — a second-level appeal goes to the CUIAB board itself after the administrative law judge's decision. So you're not completely out of options if the first hearing doesn't go your way.

0 coins

Worth knowing there are two levels there. A lot of people think the judge's decision is final and give up, when actually the board review exists.

0 coins

The overpayment question you raised is real and worth thinking about. If an appeal hearing results in a ruling that you weren't eligible for some or all of those weeks, EDD can issue an overpayment notice for the amount already paid. If it wasn't fraud — and a layoff dispute definitely isn't fraud — there's no penalty added, but you'd still owe the amount. There is a waiver process if repaying would be a serious hardship for you, but it's not guaranteed.

0 coins

Is the waiver something I'd apply for proactively or only after getting an overpayment notice?

0 coins

Only after — the waiver form, DE 1446UI, is a response to an overpayment notice. You'd submit it and EDD weighs whether repaying would create an extraordinary hardship. Best to focus on winning the hearing first and cross that bridge only if you have to.

0 coins

The non-fraud distinction matters a lot here. No 30 percent penalty on top, no false statement disqualification — just the repayment itself, and the waiver option exists. Much different from a fraud finding.

0 coins

My determination letter from EDD showed up five weeks after I filed, and the employer appeal notice landed about three months after that. The notice I got at first said the original decision remained in effect pending the hearing, which helped me stay calm about payments continuing. I'd been having a hard time getting through on EDD's line, used Claimyr to reach an agent and confirm my account status, and the agent told me the pending appeal flag on my claim didn't stop the payment cycle — just meant a hearing date would be scheduled.

0 coins

Original decision remains in effect pending the' hearing — did that exact language appear on your notice, or was it something the agent toldyou?

0 coins

It was on the notice itself. The notice from CUIAB confirming they'd received the employer's appeal had a line about the original determination staying in effect. The agent confirmed it matched what I was seeing.

0 coins

That framing makes the whole thing feel less panicky. The approval isn't reversed the moment an appeal is filed — it stays unless the hearing overturns it.

0 coins

Pulling together documentation now is smarter than waiting for the Notice of Hearing to arrive. Anything that confirms the layoff was real and not performance-based: the written layoff notice, any emails from HR about the department closure, your final paystub, and the dates of employment. The judge will want to understand the full picture of the separation.

0 coins

I have the email from HR saying the entire division was being dissolved and the date my last day would be. That should be solid, right?

0 coins

That's about as direct as it gets. An email explicitly naming the division dissolution and your last day is exactly the kind of contemporaneous documentation that holds up well.

0 coins

Save that email somewhere besides your work email if you haven't already — a lot of people realize too late their old work account got cut off and they can't access anything.

0 coins

Heard a misconception in this thread I want to flag: someone mentioned the employer has to 'prove misconduct.' That's the standard EDD applies when you're fired — the employer has to show misconduct on your end. For a layoff, that's not really the frame at all. The question in a layoff appeal is usually whether it was actually a layoff versus something else like a voluntary quit or a performance termination.

0 coins

That's the right read. For a layoff the employer is more likely arguing the separation should be categorized differently — not that there was misconduct, because misconduct is specifically about firings.

0 coins

So what my former employer would need to argue is essentially that I wasn't really laid off — that I quit or was fired for cause? That feels like it should be easy to disprove with the HR email I mentioned.

0 coins

Exactly. If they're disputing the nature of the separation, your documentation showing it was an involuntary department elimination is directly on point.

0 coins

Twenty-six weeks is the outer limit of a standard California UI claim, and that clock doesn't pause for an appeal. While you're waiting for the hearing date and the written decision, those weeks are still counting against your benefit year. If the hearing drags out and you're still eligible, you want to have used your certified weeks wisely.

0 coins

Mine started in September so I'm well within the 52-week benefit year — I hadn't thought about the 26-week payment limit running in the background though.

0 coins

The 52-week benefit year window and the 26-week payment limit are two different clocks. The benefit year just determines when you'd need to file a new claim; the 26 weeks determines how long payments can run.

0 coins

This is a good thing to have clear before you think everything's fine because the year hasn't ended yet. Two separate limits doing two separate things.

0 coins

At the hearing level you can represent yourself, and a lot of people do. But if the weekly benefit amount and the number of weeks still on your claim add up to a significant amount you'd potentially owe back, it might be worth talking to someone who handles UI appeals. Some legal aid organizations take these cases. Union representation is another option if that applies to you.

0 coins

I'm not in a union. The legal aid angle is worth looking into — do you know if they typically represent people at the CUIAB level or just at the EDD stage?

0 coins

From what I've seen, legal aid groups that do employment work often handle CUIAB hearings. Worth searching for a workers' rights clinic in your county.

0 coins

The America's Job Centers of California sometimes know referrals to legal aid in the area. Not that they handle the claim, but they can point to resources.

0 coins

The week my department closure was announced, our whole team of twelve got the same letter. When my former employer filed an appeal two months after my approval, I needed to get clarity on what documents EDD itself would have on file from their review. Getting to an EDD agent through Claimyr, I asked specifically what was in my claim record — the agent said the reason for separation that EDD had documented was 'lack of work,' which matched my layoff notice exactly. That gave me something concrete to bring to the hearing: EDD's own record of how the separation was categorized.

0 coins

EDD having 'lack of work' already in their own record of my claim — that's a genuinely useful piece of information going into a hearing where the employer is trying to characterize things differently.

0 coins

The employer disputing something EDD already categorized and documented as a layoff is an uphill situation for them. The record is set from the initial review.

0 coins

That's what the agent indicated — the documentation from when EDD first processed the claim stays on record and the judge has access to it.

0 coins

Thirty days from the mailing date on the Notice of Determination is the window for anyone to appeal — claimant or employer. Four months is well outside that. The late appeal doesn't get automatically rejected, but the employer needs to give a reason, and the board has to decide whether to accept it. This procedural question might actually be your first line of defense before the substance of the case even gets heard.

0 coins

So I could potentially raise the timeliness issue at the hearing itself, or would that have to be addressed before the hearing is even scheduled?

0 coins

CUIAB may address it on their own review, or it might come up at the hearing. Worth mentioning in writing when you respond to the notice, and then again at the hearing if it isn't resolved beforehand.

0 coins

Raising it in writing early is smart. CUIAB might dismiss the appeal without even getting to a hearing if the lateness can't be explained.

0 coins

My aunt had benefits cut off mid-claim after her employer appealed and won at the hearing level, and she told me she wished she'd known about the second-level board appeal before giving up. She thought the judge's decision was the end of the road. By the time she found out about the CUIAB board review, the deadline to file had passed.

0 coins

The deadline piece there is worth knowing — there is a window to file for the second-level board review and missing it matters. After the judge's written decision comes, don't sit on it.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of thing you don't know to ask about until it's too late. How long is the window to file the second-level appeal after the judge's decision?

0 coins

The appeal window for a second-level CUIAB review is also 30 days from the mailing date of the judge's written decision. Same pattern as the original determination.

0 coins

Read the Notice of Hearing carefully when it comes — it will specify what issues the judge plans to address, and sometimes the scope is narrower than you'd expect. If the employer's appeal focuses on one specific eligibility question, you can prepare your documents and your account directly around that issue rather than trying to relitigate the entire claim.

0 coins

Mine should be pretty narrow — either the department was eliminated or it wasn't. I'll have that HR email and I'll be ready to speak to the timeline.

0 coins

That's exactly the right approach. Clear factual question, direct documentation, your own straightforward account of what happened. Don't overcomplicate it.

0 coins

Payments are federal taxable income, which means every week you get paid during the appeal period still counts toward your 1099G at the end of the year. If you end up with an overpayment ruling and the amount gets paid back or waived, the tax situation gets more complicated. Flagging it only because people sometimes don't think about the tax piece until January.

0 coins

That's actually something I hadn't thought about at all. If I end up owing money back, does EDD adjust the 1099G or do I report the repayment separately?

0 coins

Honestly that gets into territory where a tax person would know better than any of us here. Worth a question to EDD or a tax preparer if that scenario happens — I just know it gets more complicated than a clean year of benefits.

0 coins

California UI benefits aren't subject to state income tax, only federal. So that part at least is simpler — no state tax calculation to worry about on whatever you received.

0 coins

Went through a CUIAB hearing last year for a different reason — my former employer claimed I quit when I was actually told my position was cut and I could either resign or be let go. I chose not to sign the resignation they offered. At the hearing I described exactly what happened and the judge ruled it was an involuntary separation. The hearing itself was about 25 minutes total.

0 coins

25 minutes — shorter than I expected. Did the employer actually participate or did they just file the appeal and not show up?

0 coins

They sent an HR rep who testified by phone. It was weirdly civil. The judge asked each of us questions and that was it.

0 coins

Employers filing an appeal and then not showing up to the hearing does happen. If they don't appear, the hearing may proceed without them and the judge rules on what's in the record.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is easy to overlook during appeal stress — you still have to have it done within 21 days of getting the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work if EDD sent you one. The appeal doesn't pause that obligation.

0 coins

Already had CalJOBS set up from when I first filed, resume posted and everything. Good reminder for anyone who might have missed it though.

0 coins

Good — that's one less thing to worry about. Some people skip it thinking the appeal makes everything stop, but EDD's requirements keep running.

0 coins

The notice that triggers the CalJOBS requirement is the DE 8405. If you got that and registered within 21 days, you're covered regardless of what happens with the employer's appeal.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure