EDD penalty weeks with part-time job - how will 20hrs/week affect my benefits?
Hey everyone, found myself in a tricky spot with EDD and wondering if anyone's been through something similar. I got hit with penalty weeks from a mistake I made last year (didn't understand how to properly report some 1099 work). Already served 10 of the 20 penalty weeks they slapped me with, and now EDD says it's too late to appeal the decision. The situation just changed though - I managed to land a part-time position at a warehouse working about 20 hours weekly. Been there for just 3 weeks now. First two weeks were exactly 20 hours, and last week they bumped me up to 25 hours. I've reported all of this honestly on my certifications. How does this part-time work affect my remaining penalty weeks? Do I still have to serve all 10 remaining weeks even with this part-time job? Does the income reduce the "debt" of penalty weeks somehow? The EDD website is super confusing about this specific situation and I can't get through on the phone. Any insights would be appreciated!
21 comments
Clay blendedgen
your still gonna have to serve all those penalty weeks regardless of if ur working or not... thats why their called PENALTY weeks lol
0 coins
Mary Bates
•Ugh, that's what I was afraid of. So even if I'm working and making some money, those weeks still count against me? Seems like a double penalty.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Penalty weeks don't work the way most people think. They're not a time period - they're specifically weeks where you qualify for benefits but don't receive payment. If you're working part-time and still qualify for partial unemployment (meaning your earnings are less than your weekly benefit amount), then yes, you'll still serve those penalty weeks while working. However, if your part-time earnings are high enough that you wouldn't qualify for any benefit payment for that week, then that week won't count as a penalty week. The system only "uses up" penalty weeks when you would otherwise be eligible for payment. So it really depends on your weekly benefit amount compared to what you're earning at this warehouse job.
0 coins
Mary Bates
•Thank you for explaining this! My weekly benefit amount is $350, and I'm making about $320 at my part-time job (before taxes). So I'm still under my WBA, which means I'd normally get a small payment. It sounds like I'll still have to serve those penalty weeks even with the part-time work.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
i had penalty weeks last year and it SUCKED!!!!! Even when i found a part time job they still made me do all the dumb penalty weeks. EDD is seriously the worst and they never explain anything properly smh
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
Wait I'm confused about something... are you actually getting ANY money from EDD right now? Because if you're in penalty weeks, you shouldn't be getting payments at all, right? Or are you just asking about what happens AFTER your penalty weeks are over?
0 coins
Mary Bates
•No, I'm not getting any payments during the penalty weeks - that's the penalty part. I'm just trying to figure out if working part-time somehow impacts how the penalty weeks are counted or if I still have to go through all 10 remaining weeks with no benefits even though I'm working part-time now.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
•Got it! That makes sense. Sorry for the confusion. The whole EDD system is so complicated sometimes.
0 coins
Kai Santiago
Based on your situation, you'll still need to serve all 10 remaining penalty weeks. Here's how it works: 1. Penalty weeks are weeks where you qualify for benefits but receive no payment 2. Since you're earning less than your WBA ($320 vs $350), you would normally qualify for partial benefits 3. Because you would qualify for benefits, these weeks WILL count toward serving your penalty weeks 4. You must continue certifying during all penalty weeks 5. Once all penalty weeks are served, you'll start receiving payments for any weeks you qualify One thing to watch: if your hours increase to where you earn more than your WBA, those weeks won't count as penalty weeks (since you wouldn't qualify for benefits anyway).
0 coins
Mary Bates
•Thanks for breaking it down so clearly! So basically I just need to keep certifying and eventually get through these 10 weeks. Though it sounds like if I could somehow get more hours and earn above my WBA, those weeks wouldn't count against my penalty weeks? Is that right?
0 coins
Kai Santiago
•Exactly. If you earned more than your WBA (over $350 in your case), that week wouldn't count as a penalty week since you wouldn't be eligible for benefits anyway. The week would just be a regular excessive earnings week. The penalty weeks would remain "on hold" until you have a week where you would qualify for benefits again.
0 coins
Lim Wong
I went through something similar last year with penalty weeks. Trying to call EDD about it was IMPOSSIBLE. I spent literally weeks trying to get through - constant busy signals, disconnects, or being on hold for hours only to get disconnected. I finally found this service called Claimyr that got me through to an EDD rep in under 25 minutes. You can see how it works at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. Their website is claimyr.com - it basically calls EDD for you and then connects you when they get through. Saved me so much frustration and the rep I spoke with clarified everything about my penalty weeks situation. Since you're trying to understand how your specific part-time work affects your remaining penalty weeks, I'd recommend talking directly to an EDD specialist. That's the only way to get a definitive answer for your specific situation.
0 coins
Mary Bates
•Thanks for the recommendation! I've been trying to call for days with no luck. I'll check this out because I really need to speak with someone who can look at my specific claim and explain exactly how these penalty weeks will work with my part-time job.
0 coins
Dananyl Lear
Not sure if this helps but I went thru penalty weeks in 2024 and ended up getting a full time job halfway thru. When I started making more than my benefit amount I just stopped certifying altogether because there was no point. Later I had to quit that job due to harassment and when I reopened my claim, guess what? All those remaining penalty weeks were STILL THERE waiting for me. So they don't just disappear if you stop claiming.
0 coins
Mary Bates
•Wow, that's really important to know! So even if I stopped certifying, those penalty weeks would still be waiting for me if I needed benefits again in the future. Thanks for sharing your experience.
0 coins
Clay blendedgen
just work more hours dude and get paid more at ur job instead of worrying about edd lol
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
•wow super helpful advice 🙄 not everyone can just magically get more hours! some jobs limit part time hours on purpose to avoid giving benefits
0 coins
Kai Santiago
One more important thing: keep reporting your work and earnings accurately during penalty weeks. Even though you're not receiving payments, improper reporting during penalty weeks could result in additional penalties or even a false statement penalty which would mean MORE penalty weeks. The EDD system tracks everything, and accuracy now will prevent problems later.
0 coins
Mary Bates
•Definitely will do! I'm being super careful with my certifications after what happened before. I report every single hour and dollar earned. Not going to risk more penalty weeks!
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
Wait I just realized something - are penalty weeks the same as disqualification weeks? Because my cousin had disqualification weeks and those worked differently I think? I'm so confused by all these EDD terms!
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
•They're different. Disqualification weeks mean you don't qualify for benefits for specific reasons (like voluntary quit without good cause, misconduct, etc.). Penalty weeks are a punishment for misreporting where you qualify for benefits but don't receive payment as a penalty. With penalty weeks, you must continue to meet all eligibility requirements and certify, but you don't get paid for those weeks.
0 coins