EDD eligibility interview with judge tomorrow - Legal to record the call?
I've been struggling with my unemployment claim for weeks and finally got scheduled for an eligibility interview with an administrative law judge tomorrow morning. I'm super nervous and want to make sure I don't forget anything they say. Is it legal to record the phone call? I'm in California and don't want to do anything that might hurt my case, but I also want to have a record of everything discussed. Has anyone done this before? Any other tips for my interview? This is for a regular UI claim after I was let go from my warehouse job.
19 comments
Olivia Evans
DON'T DO IT!!! California is a two-party consent state, which means BOTH parties need to agree to being recorded. If you record without telling them, it's actually illegal and could be used AGAINST you in your case. I made this mistake during my first appeal and the judge was NOT happy when I mentioned I was recording. Just take detailed notes instead.
0 coins
Daniel Price
•Oh wow, thank you for the warning! I definitely don't want to start off on the wrong foot. Is it okay if I ask the judge for permission to record at the beginning of the call?
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
I had my eligibility interview last month. The judge will actually tell you at the beginning that THEY are recording the call for official purposes. What worked for me was having all my documents ready (separation letter, past communications with employer, pay stubs, etc.) and taking notes during the call. Focus on answering questions directly and honestly rather than worrying about recording. Good luck!
0 coins
Daniel Price
•Thank you! That's really helpful to know they'll be recording it already. I'll make sure to have my termination paperwork and everything organized before the call.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
Here's my advice after going through three of these interviews: 1. Have a notepad ready to take detailed notes 2. Ask the judge to clarify anything you don't understand 3. Stick to facts, not emotions 4. Have your employment dates, final pay amount, and reason for separation ready 5. If the judge asks you a yes/no question, just answer yes or no without elaborating unless they ask for more details And most importantly, be honest. The judges have heard everything, and they're looking for inconsistencies. Good luck tomorrow!
0 coins
Daniel Price
•This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I've been so stressed about this interview. The EDD has been so hard to reach with questions, I'm glad I asked here.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
i got denied on my first interview cause i wasnt prepared lol then had 2 wait another month 4 the appeal hearing just make sure u can explain why u lost ur job without it being ur fault thats what they care about mostly
0 coins
Daniel Price
•Sorry that happened to you! I was let go because they eliminated my position, but my former employer tried to say I had performance issues (which isn't true and was never documented). I'll make sure to be clear about that.
0 coins
Christopher Morgan
If you're really nervous about missing information, you could try reaching out to EDD beforehand to get clarity on what to expect. I tried calling them for days before my interview and couldn't get through because of the call volume. I finally used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to an EDD rep in under 10 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. The rep was super helpful and explained exactly what the judge would be asking about and how to prepare. Made me feel 1000% more confident going into my interview.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
•does that actually work?? ive been calling EDD for THREE WEEKS trying to get someone to explain why my payments are still pending even after the judge ruled in my favor
0 coins
Christopher Morgan
•@random_redditor It definitely worked for me. I was skeptical too but was desperate after spending hours getting busy signals. The EDD rep I talked to even helped expedite my case since I was about to miss a rent payment.
0 coins
Grace Johnson
The judge interviews are actually pretty straightforward. They're just trying to verify the facts of your case. Don't overthink it or try anything fancy like recording - just be honest and direct. I was super nervous for mine and it ended up being a 15-minute conversation where they just confirmed details about why I left my job.
0 coins
Daniel Price
•That's reassuring. I hope mine goes quickly too. Did they give you a decision right on the call or did you have to wait?
0 coins
Grace Johnson
•I had to wait about a week before I saw the decision in my UI Online account. Then another week before the payments started processing. Just keep certifying while you wait!
0 coins
Olivia Evans
ALSO make sure you're in a quiet place with good phone reception!!! My first interview got rescheduled because I was in a noisy area and the judge couldn't hear me properly. And have your claim ID number ready - they'll ask for it at the beginning.
0 coins
Daniel Price
•Good call, I'll make sure to be somewhere quiet. Would my bedroom with the door closed be okay? And I'll definitely have my claim ID ready.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
•Bedroom is perfect as long as you don't have noisy roommates or family members who might interrupt. Turn off any fans or music too!
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
One more important thing - this isn't a regular judge like in a courtroom, it's an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) who specializes in EDD cases. They're usually pretty understanding and just want to get the facts straight. Just explain your situation clearly, and if you made any mistakes in your application, be upfront about them. It's much better to acknowledge and explain than to have them think you were trying to hide something.
0 coins
Daniel Price
•Thanks for clarifying! That makes me feel better knowing they're specialized in EDD cases. I think I filled everything out correctly, but I'll be upfront if there are any discrepancies they find.
0 coins