EDD appeal hearing judge cut off all testimony - anyone experienced this?

That DEFINITELY doesn't sound right!!! I had my appeal hearing last summer and the judge let both sides talk for like an hour each. My employer went on forever and I got to respond to everything. Something seems wrong with your judge. Can you appeal the appeal hearing??

Ugh, that sucks. I've heard about ALJs who run super tight hearings like that. Mine was actually pretty fair and thorough, but a friend of mine got a judge similar to yours. Unfortunately, my friend lost their appeal. The big question is whether the judge has enough info in the written record to make a fair decision. Did you submit detailed written evidence beforehand? That's really critical if the judge limits testimony.

I've helped several people through EDD appeals, and while judges do have significant latitude in how they run hearings, they're supposed to ensure all relevant facts are considered. That said, they're also tasked with maintaining efficient proceedings. A few things to know: 1. The judge will make their decision based on the evidence in your file plus what was presented at the hearing. 2. If you lose, you can appeal to the CUIAB board within 30 days. 3. If there were procedural issues that prevented key facts from being considered, definitely mention those in your board appeal. The good news is that judges in these hearings aren't necessarily looking for policy violations but rather whether your actions constitute misconduct under unemployment law, which has a specific legal definition that's often more favorable to employees than employer policies.

i had a similar experience but i actually won my appeal! judge was super dismissive and barely let me talk but still ruled in my favor. dont lose hope!

Man, I feel for you. Spent 2 months trying to reach EDD after my appeal hearing last year cause they never processed my payments even after I won. Kept getting the "we're experiencing high call volume" message until I found Claimyr (claimyr.com). They got me connected to an actual EDD rep in like 20 minutes who fixed everything. Worth checking out their video to see how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km If you do get a favorable decision but don't see payments starting, definitely don't wait around like I did.

I've been through two appeal hearings over the years, and they can vary dramatically depending on the Administrative Law Judge assigned to your case. Some run very tight proceedings while others allow more extensive testimony. What matters most is whether the key facts of your case were entered into the record, either through your written evidence or the limited testimony. The judge is required to make their decision based on applicable unemployment insurance law, not on how much time each side was given to speak. Regarding procedural concerns, if you believe the hearing process itself prevented critical evidence from being considered, you can file an appeal to the CUIAB board (the level above the ALJ) within 30 days of receiving your decision. In your appeal, specifically detail what evidence you were prevented from presenting and why it would have changed the outcome. The board reviews these procedural concerns seriously, particularly if you can demonstrate that the judge's conduct prevented a fair hearing. That said, ALJs do have significant discretion in how they run their courtrooms.

wait so in the appeal hearing you cant actually speak???? im so confused how this even works. my appeal is next month and now im panicking

By the way, don't forget to keep certifying for benefits even while waiting for the appeal decision! So many people stop certifying during appeals and then have to go through another whole process to claim those weeks if they win.

Did the judge tell you when you'll get the decision? With my appeal it took like a month to get the paperwork even though they said it would be 10 days. EDD is literally THE WORST with their timelines!!!