Back to California Unemployment

Noah Lee

Does unemployment look at all employers wages if moved to new payroll LLC?

So my situation is kind of complicated and I haven't been able to find a clear answer anywhere. I worked for the same company doing the same job for about two and a half years, but partway through they switched everything over to a new payroll LLC. Same office, same boss, same duties, same everything — just a different entity cutting my checks after the switch. I got laid off a few months ago and filed for California EDD unemployment. My Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award (DE 429Z) came and the weekly benefit amount looks way lower than I expected. I'm guessing EDD only pulled wages from the new LLC and ignored everything I earned under the old one. Is that how it works? Does EDD actually look at ALL employers' wages across the whole base period, or does the LLC switch basically wipe out the first chunk of my earnings history? I really need to know if there's something I can dispute or if this is just how the system handles it.

Eight months into my own layoff situation, so I've been through the whole California EDD base period thing myself. EDD pulls wages from what's reported to the state under employer account numbers — so if the old LLC and the new one have different accounts, only the wages reported under whichever ones show up in your base period quarters get counted. The twist is that if your old employer never properly transferred or reported those wages, EDD might not even see them. Your DE 429Z shows your weekly benefit amount, but it doesn't tell you which employers' wages went into the calculation. What you'd want to do is contact EDD directly and ask them to walk through which quarters and which employers were included. If wages are missing, that's the kind of thing that can sometimes get corrected.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

The DE 429Z showing only the amount without breaking down which employers contributed is exactly my frustration — I genuinely can't tell from the letter alone whether the old payroll LLC wages are in there or not.

0 coins

Payroll switches like that mess up wage records more often than people realize. The old entity has to report those wages under its own account separately, and if there was any gap or error in that reporting, EDD just doesn't see them.

0 coins

Exactly what I found out the hard way — EDD can only work with what's been reported to them, so if the wages aren't showing on their end, the weekly benefit amount reflects that gap.

0 coins

DE 429Z came in the mail about two weeks after I filed, and my weekly amount looked off too — I'm a freelance-to-staff situation where I had two different employers in my base period and wasn't sure both made it in. Getting anyone at EDD on the phone felt impossible for about two weeks straight. Ended up reaching a live agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) — there's a video showing how reaching a live person at EDD works at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my account right there and read me exactly which employer accounts and which quarters EDD had on file. Turned out one employer's wages from Q1 were missing entirely because of a reporting delay. She told me I'd need to contact that employer and ask them to verify the wages were submitted to EDD, then follow up. That's probably the fastest way to figure out whether both LLCs' wages showed up for your base period.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

Two weeks of busy signals is what I've been dealing with too. Knowing there's a way to actually reach someone and get them to read off which employer accounts are in the file is exactly what I need — I'll look into it.

0 coins

Same dead end with the phones. My situation was a company reorg and I never knew if my old division's wages made it into the system under the right account number.

0 coins

The agent reading the specific quarters and employer accounts off the screen was the only way I finally had something concrete to work with instead of guessing.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone reading this thread — EDD's base period covers specific calendar quarters, not just 'the last year and a half.' The standard setup is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you filed. So if you worked under the old LLC two or three years ago but filed recently, some of those wages might already be outside the window even if they were reported correctly. The LLC switch itself isn't necessarily the problem — it's whether those wages fall inside the base period quarters and whether the old entity reported them under a California employer account.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

The payroll LLC switch happened about fourteen months before my layoff, so the wages from before it should land somewhere in my base period quarters — that's part of why the low weekly amount is confusing me.

0 coins

Quarters are what trips everyone up. I kept thinking EDD would look at my last 12 months of pay stubs but they don't — it's the completed calendar quarters before you file, so the timing can really shift which wages count.

0 coins

Came here thinking the same thing, that my pay stubs from the last year were what mattered. The quarter system is not intuitive at all when you're used to thinking about annual salary.

0 coins

My layoff was last spring and my DE 429Z weekly amount was also lower than I calculated. The rep at EDD explained that if two separate legal entities both employed you in the base period, they each should have reported wages under their own California employer account numbers. The key question is whether your old payroll LLC filed its quarterly payroll taxes with the state under a registered California employer account. If it was a brand-new entity that maybe hadn't set up its EDD employer account properly before they switched you over, those wages might not exist in EDD's system at all. It's not about whether you worked there — it's purely about what got reported.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

That's a really useful frame — it's not about whether I actually did the work, it's about whether the entity cutting those checks was properly registered and reporting to EDD. I need to track that down.

0 coins

Former HR person here, and payroll LLC setups are often done specifically to consolidate liability — the reporting side doesn't always get cleaned up correctly and workers end up with gaps exactly like this.

0 coins

The HR angle is a good one. Whoever handled that LLC setup should have records of whether California payroll taxes were filed under the new entity versus the old one, and for which quarters.

0 coins

EDD's alternate base period is something worth knowing about here. If the standard base period doesn't capture enough wages to give you a valid claim, EDD is supposed to automatically check the alternate base period — which uses the most recent four completed quarters instead. This doesn't apply if your standard base period already produces a valid claim, but if wages are genuinely missing because of the LLC switch and your standard quarters don't have enough, the alternate period might pick up more recent wages. The threshold for a valid claim is at least $1,300 in one quarter, or $900 in your highest quarter with total base period wages of at least 1.25 times that. Worth knowing whether your situation even gets to that threshold with the wages EDD currently has.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

So EDD checks the alternate base period automatically if the standard one doesn't get me to the threshold — I didn't know that. If the missing LLC wages pushed me below the minimum, maybe the alternate period would pull in more recent earnings.

0 coins

The alternate base period thing confused me for a long time. I thought I could just request it to get a higher weekly amount, but it only kicks in when the standard period doesn't get you to a valid claim at all, not just to boost the number.

0 coins

Exactly right — it's not a way to increase your weekly amount on a claim that's already valid. It's a fallback when the standard quarters don't produce a qualifying claim. EDD runs it automatically, so you don't have to ask.

0 coins

EDD CANNOT read your mind about which employers you had. When you filed, did you list BOTH the old payroll LLC and the new one as employers in the last 18 months? Because if you only listed the most recent one, EDD might not have even looked for wages from the prior entity. The application asks for every employer in the last 18 months — if you left the old LLC off, that's worth fixing.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

I listed both because I knew the same underlying company switched entities — but I'm honestly not sure if EDD treated them as two separate employers or just saw the same address and lumped them together somehow.

0 coins

EDD goes by the employer account number registered with the state, not the address or the name. Two LLCs can be at the same address and EDD treats them as completely separate employers for wage purposes.

0 coins

The employer account number point is exactly it. Two entities, two accounts, and EDD only tallies wages reported under each one separately. The physical location means nothing to their system.

0 coins

Went through a similar restructuring when my company was bought out and the buyer set up a new LLC mid-year. My base period ended up spanning both entities and my weekly benefit amount came out roughly where I expected — which meant both LLCs had properly reported California payroll taxes in their respective quarters. I never had to do anything special about it. But the person above is right that it only works that way if both entities were reporting correctly to EDD. If the old LLC stopped operating and filed a final return before transferring wages, that affects how the records look.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

Hearing that it worked cleanly in a buyout situation is reassuring — maybe mine is fine and I'm just calculating my expected weekly amount wrong. But I want to verify by getting someone at EDD to actually confirm the quarters they used.

0 coins

Verifying with EDD directly is the right move regardless. Even if everything looks fine on paper, knowing exactly which quarters they used gives you something concrete to compare against your own pay stubs.

0 coins

My company did a payroll LLC thing too and nobody told any of the employees. First I found out was when my W-2 had a different entity name on it than the one on my badge. Filed for unemployment after a layoff and my claim went into adjudication for a few weeks because EDD flagged that the employer I listed didn't match what was showing in their wage records. Eventually got cleared but it was a stressful few weeks of my UI Online claim showing Pending on every week.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

The W-2 with a different entity name is exactly what happened to me. So that mismatch between what I reported and what's in the wage records could be part of why my weekly amount seems off.

0 coins

Worth checking your W-2s from each year to see exactly which entity names appear — those are the entities reporting wages to the state, and they're what EDD pulls when calculating your base period.

0 coins

Adjudication just because the employer names didn't match what EDD had on file is frustrating. For something that common — companies restructuring under new LLCs — you'd think EDD would have a cleaner way to handle it.

0 coins

DE 429Z appeal window is 30 days from the mailing date on the letter. If you believe wages are missing from your base period calculation and that resulted in a lower weekly benefit amount than you're entitled to, you can appeal in writing within that window using the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) or just a letter sent to the address on the notice. Don't let the 30 days slip by while you're waiting to figure out what happened — you can appeal and still be gathering information at the same time.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

30 days from the mailing date — I need to check exactly when my DE 429Z is dated. I've been sitting on it while trying to figure out what happened and I don't want to miss the window.

0 coins

The mailing date is on the letter itself, usually at the top. If you're within 30 days of that date, file the appeal now and explain in writing that you believe wages from a prior payroll entity are missing from your base period. You can add documentation later.

0 coins

Missed my own appeal window on a different issue last year because I thought the 30 days started when I received the letter, not when it was mailed. Those are not the same thing if delivery takes a few days.

0 coins

Payroll switch with no break in service was my situation too — same desk, same manager, new LLC name on the check starting January of last year. When my weekly benefit amount came out at $218 and my own calculation had me closer to $340, I called EDD through Claimyr and got an agent on the line to go through my account. She confirmed EDD had Q3 and Q4 wages from the old entity but was showing zero wages for Q1 and Q2 under the new LLC because those quarters hadn't been reported yet when I filed — the new LLC was behind on its quarterly filings. The agent told me to follow up once the employer caught up on the filings and EDD could recheck the base period. That kind of specific answer is what I needed.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

A $120-a-week gap from missing quarters is exactly the kind of discrepancy I might be dealing with. And the fact that EDD could flag which specific quarters were showing zero for the new LLC — that's exactly the information I need.

0 coins

The quarterly filing lag from the new LLC was something I never would have figured out without asking EDD to pull up the account. It looked on paper like both entities had the same ownership, so I assumed wages would flow through automatically.

0 coins

Employer filing delays with the state can really hammer a claimant who had no idea the new LLC was behind on its payroll tax filings. That's completely outside your control as the employee.

0 coins

Gonna be real — I thought when you file for unemployment you just list your jobs and they look at your paystubs. Finding out it all hinges on whether your employer filed with the state correctly made me genuinely upset. My old retail job was run through three different LLCs over two years and nobody warned me any of this mattered.

0 coins

EDD doesn't collect your pay stubs — they pull wages from employer quarterly tax filings. So if your employer is behind on those filings or used a new entity without proper registration, EDD has nothing to pull for those quarters.

0 coins

Honestly that should be way more clearly explained when you file. I spent two weeks trying to calculate my weekly amount off my own pay stubs not realizing that wasn't even the number EDD was using.

0 coins

Pay stubs and what EDD actually has in their wage records can be really different numbers, especially in restructuring situations. That's why it's worth asking EDD directly which employer accounts and quarters they used.

0 coins

Ask EDD through the message option in your UI Online account about the base period wage breakdown. Put the question in writing so you have a record — something like asking which employer accounts and which quarters contributed to your weekly benefit amount calculation. The written message takes longer for a response than a phone call but it creates a paper trail if you end up needing to appeal.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

The paper trail angle is a good reason to send the message even if I also end up calling. Having it in writing that I asked the question early matters if the appeal clock is running.

0 coins

The UI Online message option is under your account once you're logged in at myEDD. Response times vary but you at least have a timestamp showing you raised the issue.

0 coins

Both is better — message through UI Online for the record, phone for a faster real-time answer. The agent can tell you right away which quarters are populated with wages and which are showing zero.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is separate from the base period question but don't forget about it while you're focused on the wage issue — if your Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) came in the mail, you've got 21 days from that date to register at caljobs.ca.gov and post a resume or payments can be stopped. I got so deep into chasing my own wage calculation question that I nearly missed that deadline.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

I did get the DE 8405 and I already registered at CalJOBS — good reminder though, I know other people reading this might be overlooking it while focused on their own claim issues.

0 coins

Buried in the CalJOBS registration for a week and also didn't realize EDD had a question about my wages from a prior employer. Both things can be happening at the same time and EDD's notices about each one are easy to mix up.

0 coins

My layoff came right after my company did exactly what you're describing — moved all employees onto a new payroll LLC without telling anyone. Two quarters of wages from the old entity, two from the new one, all within my base period. EDD picked up all four quarters without any issue because both entities had been reporting properly to California. The difference in your situation might just be whether the old entity's final quarterly filings were submitted before it went inactive. That's the question I'd push your former HR department on first before spending too much time with EDD.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

Going to HR first to verify whether the old LLC filed its final California quarterly payroll reports is a step I hadn't thought of — faster than waiting on EDD and might give me something concrete to bring to them.

0 coins

If the old LLC's final quarterly payroll filings are on record with California, EDD should be able to see those wages. If they're not, then you know the problem is on the employer's side and you have something to push on with HR.

0 coins

Payroll records for each entity are something HR should absolutely have. Ask them specifically for the EDD employer account number for each LLC and the dates of their California quarterly filings — that's the information EDD will be looking for.

0 coins

Waiting week thing tripped me up when I was first looking at my DE 429Z — I expected my first payment to cover two weeks but it came out to one week of pay. The first certification usually covers the waiting week and one paid week, and the waiting week is unpaid. Not related to your base period question but if your first payment looked low for that reason, it might not be a wage calculation issue at all.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

The waiting week is already accounted for in my math — my concern is specifically the weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z being lower than what I'd calculate from my pay stubs, which now makes sense given the LLC wage reporting question.

0 coins

Makes sense — just wanted to flag it since it confused me initially and I went into a panic about my weekly amount before realizing it was just the waiting week doing what it was supposed to do.

0 coins

The waiting week panic is real. I called EDD in a full spiral only to find out my weekly amount itself was correct and I'd just misread how the first payment worked.

0 coins

EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site at edd.ca.gov lets you estimate what your weekly amount should be based on your highest quarter wages. If you punch in what you know your highest quarter earnings were — including both entities if applicable — and the estimate comes out significantly higher than your DE 429Z, that's your signal that wages are missing from EDD's calculation and worth pursuing.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

Just used the calculator with my highest quarter wages including both LLCs and the estimate is about $85 a week higher than what's on my DE 429Z. That's a meaningful gap and confirms something is probably missing.

0 coins

An $85-a-week gap over a 26-week claim adds up to over $2,000 in potentially missing benefits. Absolutely worth the effort to track down which wages EDD is missing and get it corrected if possible.

0 coins

The calculator estimate versus the DE 429Z is a solid way to check whether the weekly amount looks right. Keep in mind the calculator is an estimate and EDD uses a specific formula, but a gap that large is a real flag.

0 coins

Spent three weeks after my layoff trying to figure out if EDD had all my wages — I was at a company that went through two entity changes in eighteen months. First paycheck under the third LLC and then the layoff happened. Got on the phone with an EDD agent using Claimyr and asked whether my account showed wages from each entity separately. The agent confirmed two of the three entities had wages on file and the third was showing nothing for my last quarter. She told me EDD couldn't update the wage records until the employer filed, and that I should appeal my DE 429Z before the 30-day window closed if I believed wages were missing, which I did.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

Three entities, same situation as me structurally, and the agent was able to see which ones had filed and which hadn't — that's the kind of specific account lookup I need. And filing the appeal before the 30-day window while still investigating is exactly the move.

0 coins

Following the advice to appeal before the deadline while still gathering information is what I wish I'd done on my own claim. I waited too long thinking I'd have more answers first and the 30 days slipped.

0 coins

Filing the appeal is just preserving your options — the actual hearing doesn't happen immediately, so you have time to gather the employer's filing records and bring them as documentation.

0 coins

Payroll LLCs being used to restructure companies is incredibly common right now and EDD's system isn't set up to handle it cleanly. I had a gap in my wages too from an entity switch and ended up working it out by getting EDD on the phone through Claimyr, asking them to confirm which employer accounts had wages reported for each quarter of my base period. The agent also confirmed my identity verification was complete on the account, which was holding up one of my pending weeks separately. Got two separate issues answered in one call.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

Two separate issues in one call is efficient — I have both the wage question and some weeks still showing Pending, so having an agent pull up the full account picture at once makes sense.

0 coins

Pending weeks showing in Claim History while also having a wage calculation question is a situation where talking to a live agent really does make a difference over trying to piece it together from letters.

0 coins

The agent confirmed the pending weeks were waiting on identity verification to clear, which had nothing to do with the wage issue — two completely separate things that looked connected from my end but weren't.

0 coins

For what it's worth — if EDD ultimately determines that wages are missing because of the employer's failure to file, the weekly benefit amount on your DE 429Z can be revised. It's not a final number carved in stone if you can show the wages were actually earned and the employer just didn't report them on time. That would likely require the employer to submit corrected filings to California for the quarters in question. EDD then has what they need to recalculate. The appeal protects your rights in the meantime.

0 coins

Noah Lee

Author

So the appeal protects me while the employer corrects the filings, and EDD can revise the weekly amount once the missing wages show up in the system — that's the clearest path forward I've seen in this whole thread. Thank you.

0 coins

Exactly the sequence. File the appeal to protect the 30-day window, push your former employer's HR to verify and submit any missing quarterly filings, then follow up with EDD once those wages appear in their system.

0 coins

This is the clearest summary of the whole situation. Appeal first, employer correction second, EDD recalculation third. Each step depends on the one before it.

0 coins

Former HR here again — if the old LLC has been dissolved, getting corrected filings submitted is harder but not impossible. The company's payroll provider usually retains records even after an entity is closed and can often refile for prior quarters.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure