Back to California Unemployment

Amina Bah

Does quitting new job affect existing unemployment claim after being fired from original employer?

Okay so my situation is kind of layered and I'm having trouble finding a clear answer anywhere. I got laid off from my logistics coordinator job back in August and filed for unemployment right away. EDD processed everything, I got my DE 429Z showing my weekly amount, did all my CalJOBS stuff, and started certifying. Everything was going fine. Then about six weeks in, I took a job at a fulfillment warehouse thinking things were looking up. The job was genuinely awful though - management was chaotic, they kept changing my shift with zero notice, and after three weeks I couldn't make it work anymore and quit. Now I'm back to certifying on my original claim but I have NO idea if quitting that second job just blew up everything. The weeks I worked at the warehouse I reported my earnings like I was supposed to. But now UI Online is showing some of those weeks as Pending and I'm freaking out a little. Does quitting new job affect existing unemployment claim after being fired from your original employer? Is the quit from the second job going to trigger a whole new eligibility review? Has anyone been through something like this?

About five weeks after getting laid off from my retail management job, I took a part-time stocking position just to have something coming in, then quit that after a month when the hours kept getting cut to almost nothing. My UI Online showed pending on three weeks almost immediately after I reported quitting. Getting through to EDD to ask about it was its own nightmare until I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it held the phone line with EDD while I went about my day, and I ended up talking to a live agent about my specific weeks. The agent pulled up my claim and said the pending weeks were flagged because EDD needed to do a separate eligibility review on the quit from the secondary job, but that my original claim wasn't automatically disqualified. She said I'd likely get a DE 4800 with a scheduled phone interview to go over why I left that second job. There's a video about reaching a live person at EDD that way: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 The interview happened about ten days later. I explained the hours situation honestly, and eventually those weeks were processed. The original claim kept running.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

The DE 4800 thing - did you get that notice in the mail or was it on your UI Online homepage? I want to make sure I don't miss the scheduled time.

0 coins

Mine came in the mail and the date was also listed right on the UI Online homepage. Keep an eye on both. The notice has the questions they're likely to ask too, which helped me prepare.

0 coins

The hours getting cut is a real thing EDD considers. Good you documented what was happening with your schedule.

0 coins

The question you actually need to ask EDD is whether the quit from the second job creates a brand new eligibility issue separate from your layoff - because it does, and here's why that matters for your situation. When you left that second job voluntarily, EDD treats it as a new separation event. Your original claim was established on the layoff, which is a qualifying separation. But the quit layers on top. EDD will schedule a phone interview (you'll get the DE 4800 notice by mail and the time shows on your UI Online homepage) to hear your side of why you left. Their standard is that if you quit, you need to show you had a good reason. The shift changes you mentioned - that could matter depending on how significant they were and what you told EDD when you certified. Keep certifying every two weeks no matter what while this gets sorted out. If EDD decides the quit doesn't disqualify you, those pending weeks get paid. If they decide against you, you get a Notice of Determination with an Appeal Form. The original layoff separation doesn't get reopened - it's just the quit from the warehouse that's under the microscope.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

The shift changes were pretty significant - I was hired for a set overnight schedule and they kept flipping me to days with like two days notice. Would that be something worth mentioning at the interview?

0 coins

Absolutely bring that up. The conditions changing from what you were hired for is exactly the kind of thing EDD considers. Write down dates if you can remember them and be specific about what the original offer said versus what actually happened.

0 coins

Does the pending status mean they already flagged it or is that just normal processing? My claim has pending weeks and I didn't quit anywhere.

0 coins

Pending just means EDD is still working on that week - could be the quit flag, could be identity, could be they're just backed up. Doesn't automatically mean something is wrong.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact sequence last year. Original claim from being let go from a property management company, then took a temp office job, left that job after two months when they refused to extend my contract the way they originally said they would. The thing that tripped me up was I thought the second quit would restart the entire adjudication process from scratch and undo my original eligibility determination. It doesn't work that way. EDD opens a new inquiry on the new separation. Your layoff is already decided. What they're reviewing now is specifically whether the quit from the warehouse was for good cause. I kept certifying through the whole review period and when it was resolved those weeks were paid retroactively. The waiting week situation confused me too but that only applies once per claim, the first eligible week at the start.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Retroactively - so even the weeks that were pending during the review period got paid once it was resolved?

0 coins

Exactly, every week I certified during the review came through once EDD made its determination. That's why continuing to certify even when things look uncertain is so important.

0 coins

My temp situation was similar and the retroactive payment thing was real for me too. The weeks just sat in pending for a while and then a bunch of them processed at once.

0 coins

The CalJOBS requirement doesn't pause during a secondary quit review either, just want to flag that. If your Notice of Requirement to Register (the DE 8405) said you needed to register and post a resume within 21 days, that clock keeps running regardless of what's happening with pending weeks. Missing that can stop payments completely, which would add a whole separate headache on top of what you're already dealing with.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

I did register in CalJOBS back when I first filed, within the first couple weeks. The DE 8405 had a deadline and I hit it. At least I have that covered.

0 coins

Good, that's one less thing. Some people don't realize it's separate from the application and then have to deal with that issue on top of everything else.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration tripped me up the first time I filed. Didn't realize it was mandatory until payments stopped. Second claim I did it on day one.

0 coins

EDD's system is INFURIATING when you have a situation that doesn't fit their standard templates. A straight layoff they can process fine. Add a second job and a quit on top and suddenly everything goes into some kind of review limbo with zero explanation of what's actually happening or how long it takes. The pending weeks just sit there and you're supposed to what, just trust it'll work out?? Meanwhile rent doesn't pause.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

The rent not pausing thing is hitting hard right now. I'm trying to stay calm about it but week three of pending weeks is getting difficult.

0 coins

Three weeks pending was my breaking point too. Eventually got resolved but the radio silence from EDD while you wait is brutal.

0 coins

The frustration is real. The system isn't built for people who do what you're supposed to do - try to work - and then end up in a worse spot than if they'd just stayed on the claim without trying.

0 coins

Something that helped me when I was in a secondary quit situation - I sent a message through my UI Online account explaining the circumstances of the quit from the second job before the phone interview even happened. Not sure if it actually moved anything along but I wanted EDD to have context in writing before we talked on the phone. The agent during the interview had already noted it in my file.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

The message option in UI Online - is that through the regular account messages section or somewhere specific in Claim History?

0 coins

It's in the account messages section, not Claim History. Just explain your situation clearly, the dates you worked there, and why you left. Keep it factual.

0 coins

Writing it out before the interview also helps you organize what you want to say. I did something similar and felt more prepared when the interviewer phoned at the time on my DE 4800.

0 coins

One thing I want to flag - someone above mentioned the burden shifting to the employer to prove misconduct but that's about being fired, not about quitting. For a quit, EDD's position is that you need to show good cause for leaving. Those are two different standards for two different situations. The original layoff already passed the fired test. The warehouse quit is now under the quit standard. Keep those separate in your head when you're preparing for the interview.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

That's actually really clarifying. I was mixing up the two in my head and thinking about the burden of proof stuff when that's about the firing, not the quit.

0 coins

Good correction. The layoff determination is done. What EDD is looking at now is specifically whether leaving the warehouse voluntarily had good cause - conditions changed from what you agreed to when hired is worth explaining clearly.

0 coins

So for a quit EDD basically starts from the position of not paying unless you can justify it? That seems harsh.

0 coins

That's EDD's standard for voluntary separations, yes. Doesn't mean they deny everything - shift changes significant enough to change the fundamental job you were hired to do can count - but the claimant explains the reason and EDD makes the call.

0 coins

DE 4800 came to my house about two weeks after I reported quitting a retail job mid-claim. Was worried the interviewer wouldn't understand my situation but they were actually pretty straightforward about it. I'd gotten through to EDD beforehand using Claimyr to ask a question about which weeks were actually flagged, and the agent walked me through which specific weeks were pending and why. By the time the actual interview happened I already knew exactly what period we were discussing. The interviewer asked about the conditions when I was hired versus what actually happened, how I tried to address it before leaving, and whether I gave notice. Those are the questions they care about.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

How they tried to address it before leaving - does that mean I should have documented attempts to fix the schedule issue with management before I quit?

0 coins

DE 4800 actually lists the questions they plan to ask. Mine specifically had something about whether I spoke to a supervisor about the problem. If you did talk to management about the shifts, mention that. If you didn't, just be honest about why.

0 coins

Similar thing on my end - the interview questions are pretty formulaic once you know what they're looking for. The notice really does prep you if you read it carefully.

0 coins

The earnings you reported while working at the warehouse - make sure those are reflected correctly in your Claim History. When I had a mid-claim job, I found one week where my reported wages didn't match what actually processed. The UI Online Report Wages function only works for weeks before you certify, so if something looks off on a week already certified you have to contact EDD directly to fix it.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

I did use Report Wages before certifying each week I worked there. The numbers looked right to me but I'll double check Claim History just to be sure.

0 coins

Good habit. The Report Wages tool is exactly for that pre-certification check. Once a week is certified the only way to fix a reporting error is reaching EDD by phone or through a UI Online message.

0 coins

Learned that the hard way. Had a week where I'd earned a few hundred dollars and thought I'd reported it right but the certification question phrasing confused me and I underreported. Had to contact EDD to correct it.

0 coins

My layoff claim had a complicated middle chapter too - took a contract gig for about six weeks, the contract ended (not my choice), and then I was back on the original claim. That involuntary end to the second job was much simpler than a quit would have been. The pending weeks resolved pretty fast because the separation was clearly not my doing. What you're dealing with is harder because the quit requires EDD to make a judgment call. But the fact that the conditions changed significantly from your original offer is a legitimate thing to explain.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

The contract ending involuntarily versus quitting - that makes sense why yours resolved faster. Mine's definitely going to need the interview before anything moves.

0 coins

Exactly. And just for what it's worth - the interview isn't adversarial. They're asking questions, you answer honestly. That's really all you can do.

0 coins

Has anyone been told by EDD that quitting a second job automatically disqualifies the entire original claim? I've seen people say that in other threads and I'm worried about giving the wrong advice here.

0 coins

Not accurate. The quit triggers a new eligibility review for that specific separation - it doesn't automatically void a claim that was established on a qualifying layoff. EDD decides the quit issue separately. The original determination doesn't get undone.

0 coins

That's what I thought but wanted to make sure before it got repeated as fact. Good to have it confirmed.

0 coins

Yeah that version of events would be way too harsh even by EDD standards. A person is supposed to try to work - penalizing the whole claim for making that attempt doesn't make sense.

0 coins

Two months into my original layoff claim I took a bookkeeping contract, hated the working conditions, quit after five weeks, and had the same pending week situation as this thread. What eventually moved things was actually getting to talk to an EDD agent directly - used Claimyr for that, and ended up on the phone with someone who confirmed my DE 4800 had already been generated and mailed, it just hadn't reached me yet. So I knew to watch for it instead of wondering if anything was even happening. The interview itself focused almost entirely on what the job had been when I accepted it versus what I was actually asked to do once I started.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

The DE 4800 generated but not received yet - so the review process was already moving, the mail just hadn't caught up. Good to know that the status in the system can be ahead of what's physically in your mailbox.

0 coins

Right, the agent could see it had been created and what date it was mailed. Knowing that the process was already in motion helped more than anything else at that point.

0 coins

The gap between when EDD generates something and when it actually arrives can be like a week sometimes. UI Online often reflects activity before mail shows up.

0 coins

For the work search requirement during the pending period - you still need to be looking for work and keeping track of your efforts every week you certify, even while the quit review is pending. The pending status on weeks doesn't pause that obligation. EDD could ask about work search activities going back to any week.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

I've been continuing the job search and noting down what I apply to. Good to know that doesn't stop just because weeks are sitting in pending.

0 coins

Exactly. The claim doesn't go on pause from your end just because EDD is reviewing something. Certify when you're supposed to, look for work, report any earnings.

0 coins

They could ask about it going back and you'd need to account for it. Definitely keep documenting everything during this period.

0 coins

Something nobody's mentioned yet - the weekly benefit amount during the weeks you worked at the warehouse would have been reduced by your earnings there, since your original WBA minus the portion above the $25 or 25 percent threshold gets subtracted. So those pending weeks, once they process, might show different payment amounts than your normal weeks depending on what you earned at the warehouse. Just so you're not confused when payments come through.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

I did see the lower amounts for the weeks I worked there. The formula makes sense - the first $25 or 25 percent of what I earned didn't count against me and the rest reduced the payment. That part I understood. The quit review was what I wasn't prepared for.

0 coins

Makes sense you'd have the earnings part figured out. The quit triggering a separate review is the part that catches people off guard because EDD doesn't exactly announce it's happening.

0 coins

My claim went pending after I took a short freelance project mid-claim and then it ended. I wasn't sure if I needed to treat that like a new separation or just continue certifying normally. Turned out since the project ended on its own it was treated differently than if I'd quit it.

0 coins

Freelance ending on its own versus quitting a regular job are genuinely different situations in terms of how EDD classifies the separation. Sounds like yours resolved cleanly.

0 coins

It did. Took about two and a half weeks for those pending weeks to clear and then everything processed normally.

0 coins

This is a good data point for people - not every pending situation involves a formal eligibility review. Sometimes it's just processing time.

0 coins

The original poster's situation raises something I genuinely didn't know until I went through it - EDD considers the full history of your claim period, not just the initial separation. Taking a job mid-claim and then leaving it doesn't erase the original eligibility but it absolutely opens new questions. I wish the EDD website was clearer about this for people who are trying to do the right thing by attempting to work.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

That's exactly what caught me off guard. I thought trying to work would be straightforward and that if it didn't pan out I'd just go back to certifying. The quit from the second job creating a new eligibility question wasn't something I anticipated at all.

0 coins

The system is designed around clear-cut cases. When you're a person trying to do the right thing and it gets complicated, the lack of clear guidance from EDD is genuinely frustrating.

0 coins

The EDD website has the basic rules but the way real-life claims play out when there are multiple separations is something most people only learn from going through it.

0 coins

Practical note on the phone interview timing: the DE 4800 says what date and time the interviewer phones you. EDD's page on this is clear that you need to have your phone available at that exact time. If something comes up and you can't be available, contact EDD at least a day before to try to change it - and that only works if there's an open slot. Missing the scheduled time and not reaching out to EDD the same day can mean EDD decides the case with just the information they already have, which is usually not in the claimant's favor.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

The 'same day' part is important - so if I somehow miss it I shouldn't wait until the next day to reach out to EDD?

0 coins

Phone EDD the same day if you miss the interview. The longer you wait, the more likely it is EDD makes its determination without your input. Same day is what EDD expects.

0 coins

The notice really does spell out the time and what questions to expect. I'd read it twice before my interview and felt much more prepared than the first time I went in cold.

0 coins

Appeal rights are worth understanding even before you need them. If EDD sends a Notice of Determination that goes against you on the quit issue, you have 30 calendar days from the mailing date to appeal in writing using the DE 1000M form that comes with it. Keep certifying during any appeal - EDD can only pay pending weeks that were actually certified, so stopping certification while you wait for a decision would forfeit those weeks.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

The 30 calendar days from the mailing date - not 30 business days. Good to be clear on that.

0 coins

Correct, calendar days. The mailing date is on the notice itself. Count from that date, not from when you actually receive it in the mail.

0 coins

And the appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board for a hearing before an administrative law judge if EDD's review doesn't change the decision. You can represent yourself at the hearing.

0 coins

Came back to update my own situation from a few weeks ago - similar secondary quit, went through the interview, EDD determined I had good cause based on the schedule changes from my original agreement. Pending weeks processed within about a week of the determination. The original claim continues. Keep certifying and go into the interview prepared with specifics about what changed from what you were hired for.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

This is genuinely good to hear. Specifics about what changed from the original terms of the job - that's the core of it.

0 coins

That's exactly what the interviewer kept coming back to. What were you told the job was, and what did it actually turn out to be.

0 coins

Updates like this are helpful for people going through the same thing. Good outcome on yours.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure