Back to California Unemployment

MoonlightSonata

Does keep same weekly benefit amount on new claim if lower - California EDD question

Filed a new claim last month after my benefit year ran out on my old one. The job I had during that period paid less than what I was making before, so my new base period wages are lower. UI Online shows a weekly benefit amount of $198 on the new DE 429Z, but my old claim was paying me $312 a week. I was honestly stunned because I assumed it would stay the same or close to it. Does keep same weekly benefit amount on new claim if lower, or is it always recalculated fresh? I keep going back and forth on whether I misunderstood how this works. Did anyone else run into this when their old benefit year ended and they had to refile?

Layoff notice hit my desk on a Friday and by Monday I was filing a new claim, so I know exactly how disorienting that recalculation can be. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live EDD agent on the phone, and there's a short video on reaching a live person at EDD that walks you through it: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my new weekly amount was based entirely on my new base period wages, not carried over from anything before. She confirmed the highest-paid quarter in my new base period was driving the number, and since I'd earned less at the warehouse job I had between claims, the new amount came out lower. Nothing from the old claim carries forward.

0 coins

That warehouse job detail hits close to home. Same situation here, took a lower-paying gig between claims thinking it wouldn't matter much, and then the new DE 429Z showed a weekly amount that was almost $90 less than my previous one.

0 coins

So the agent confirmed it really does start from zero each time. That at least clears up my confusion, even if it's not the answer I was hoping for. I didn't realize how much that in-between job would drag the new base period down.

0 coins

Part-time work between claims gets people every time. The base period for the new claim catches whatever you earned in those quarters, and if you were earning less, the new weekly amount reflects that.

0 coins

EDD recalculates everything fresh when you open a new claim. The weekly benefit amount comes from the highest-paid quarter in your new base period, which is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your new claim started. Whatever you earned on the old claim is completely irrelevant to the new math.

0 coins

My old claim ended in early fall, so the base period for the new one captures the lower-wage quarters from last year. That explains why the number dropped so much.

0 coins

The base period thing confused me for so long. My claim started in March and I kept wondering why a raise I got in December wasn't showing up in my weekly amount, and that's when I finally understood that the most recent quarter sometimes falls outside what EDD actually counts.

0 coins

EDD has a benefit calculator on their site where you can plug in your quarterly wages and get an estimate. Would've saved me a lot of confusion if I'd found that before my new claim processed.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact sequence about eight months ago. Took a retail job between my two claims and thought I was doing myself a favor by staying employed. When the new DE 429Z arrived, the weekly amount was noticeably lower because retail hours were inconsistent and my wages in those quarters were well below what I'd made at my previous full-time job. EDD doesn't grandfather in your old rate; every new benefit year gets its own calculation based on what you actually earned in that period.

0 coins

Inconsistent retail hours are brutal for this. If your wages bounce around quarter to quarter, your highest quarter might still be low in absolute terms, and that's what determines the new weekly amount.

0 coins

Consistency in earnings matters more than people realize when it comes to that highest-quarter calculation. Someone working 30 hours one week and 10 the next is going to have a weaker base period than someone who worked steady hours the whole time.

0 coins

Retail schedules are genuinely unpredictable. I had a similar experience where the quarterly wages on my new base period looked fine on paper but the highest single quarter was lower than I expected because hours got cut near the end.

0 coins

Something I learned the hard way is that the alternate base period doesn't help in a situation like this one. EDD only uses the alternate base period, which is the last four completed quarters, when the standard base period doesn't have enough wages to make a valid claim at all. If your wages are enough to qualify you but just lower, EDD won't switch to the alternate period to try to get you a better weekly amount.

0 coins

I actually wondered about that. I thought maybe EDD would look at all possible periods and use whichever one gave me the higher weekly amount, but that's not how it works at all.

0 coins

Before I knew about the alternate base period rule, I spent probably an hour trying to figure out if I could ask EDD to use a different period because my earnings had picked up recently. An agent explained that the switch only happens when the standard period doesn't produce a valid claim.

0 coins

This is a really common misconception. People hear about the alternate base period and assume it's available any time you want it, like an option you can choose. It isn't. EDD applies it automatically in that one specific situation and that's it.

0 coins

My weekly amount dropped by over $100 when I reopened after my benefit year ended. I had worked a contract role in the middle that paid okay but not great, and those contract wages went into my new base period. The new DE 429Z was a shock when it arrived. EDD's calculator online let me verify that the math was right, and it was. No error, just a lower base period.

0 coins

That's what I keep coming back to. The DE 429Z is the number EDD actually calculated, not an estimate, and if the base period wages are lower, the weekly amount is lower. No way around it.

0 coins

Contract work is especially tricky because sometimes you earn a lot in a short stretch and then nothing for a few months, which can make one quarter look strong and another look almost empty. That can produce a base period that's hard to predict.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site is worth using before you file so you go in with realistic expectations about the weekly amount. I wish I had used it before my second claim instead of assuming it would be close to the first one.

0 coins

Nobody tells you when you take a lower-paying job between claims that you're essentially setting the ceiling for your next unemployment check. That's genuinely important information that I think most people don't have. I took a step down in pay because I needed work, and I didn't connect at the time that those wages would become my new base period if I ever needed to file again.

0 coins

Exactly this. I had no way of knowing when I took the lower-paying position that it would change my next UI amount so significantly. It's not like EDD sends you a warning.

0 coins

There should honestly be a plain-language explainer somewhere in UI Online that lays out how the base period resets when a new claim starts. So many people come into this thinking their old weekly amount is locked in somehow.

0 coins

Spent two weeks assuming the new weekly amount on my claim was an error after my old benefit year ended. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent because I couldn't get anyone on the phone otherwise. The agent looked at both my old and new base periods and explained that the two weekly amounts weren't connected at all - the new figure was correct based on what I'd earned in the intervening months. I had reported a part-time tutoring job during that period, and those wages were in the new base period but weren't enough to get the weekly amount close to what it had been.

0 coins

EDD's base period rule catches a lot of people off guard after they go back to work at a lower wage and then need to file again. The way it was explained to me by someone in a similar situation is that every new claim is essentially a blank slate. EDD goes back to your most recent completed quarters, looks at what you earned, picks the highest one, and builds the weekly amount from that. It has no memory of what your old claim paid.

0 coins

Blank slate is a good way to put it. The old claim, the old weekly amount, none of it matters once the benefit year ends and you file a new one.

0 coins

The highest-quarter amount runs from $40 to $450 a week. So even if someone earned well, they're capped at $450, and if the in-between job was low-wage, there's no floor above $40. It's a wide range.

0 coins

DE 429Z came in the mail two days after I filed my second claim and the amount was way lower than I expected. I ended up using Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and ask them to walk me through how the number was calculated. The agent went through each quarter in the base period and confirmed the highest one, which turned out to be a quarter where I'd only worked about six weeks before hours were cut. That was why the weekly amount came out so much lower than my previous claim.

0 coins

Minimum wages or inconsistent part-time work between claims is what usually causes the weekly amount to drop. The formula EDD uses ties so directly to your highest single quarter that anything below your previous peak earnings just means a lower check on the next claim. There's no adjustment, no transition, no bridge to your old amount.

0 coins

No bridge is exactly right. I kept thinking maybe there was some provision or exception, but reading everyone's responses here, it's pretty clear there isn't.

0 coins

The only thing someone can do is be aware going in. If you know your in-between job pays less, go into the next claim expecting a lower weekly amount. Run the numbers on EDD's calculator before you file so it's not a surprise.

0 coins

Had an adjudication hold on top of a low weekly amount on my second claim and that combination was brutal. Used Claimyr to get to an EDD agent about the hold, and while I had the agent on the phone I also asked about the weekly amount. She confirmed the hold had nothing to do with the amount - those were two separate things. The adjudication was about a gap in my work search reporting from the previous month.

0 coins

Filing that second claim after a lower-earning period is a situation where the alternate base period question always comes up and people almost always assume it works in their favor. It doesn't, the way others have explained here. The alternate period is only triggered when the standard one doesn't get you to a valid claim. EDD makes that call, you don't.

0 coins

I actually called the EDD line to ask about this and got nowhere with the hold times, which is part of why I posted here. Good to know it's not something I'd even be able to request anyway.

0 coins

EDD being unavailable by phone is a whole separate frustration. The live chat in UI Online works Monday to Friday 9 to 2 if you can't get through on the phone, and that sometimes moves faster.

0 coins

Trying to reach EDD during peak hours is almost pointless. The 1-800-300-5616 line is the main one but early morning tends to be slightly better for getting through.

0 coins

Processed a new claim last spring after my benefit year ran out and was equally confused by the lower weekly amount. What helped me understand it was going into Claim History in UI Online and looking at which quarters EDD was counting. That at least showed me the wages they were working from, even if the amount itself was still lower than I wanted.

0 coins

I hadn't thought to look at it that way in Claim History. I'll check that section to see if EDD shows the wage breakdown they used.

0 coins

Claim History doesn't always spell it out in detail but sometimes you can piece it together from the information that is there. If anything looks wrong in terms of which employer wages are listed, that's worth asking EDD about.

0 coins

If the quarterly wages they're using actually have an error, like a missing employer or an incorrect amount, that would be worth getting corrected. But if the wages are right and the weekly amount is just lower because of lower earnings, there's nothing to fix.

0 coins

Maximum benefit amount on a California UI claim is 26 times the weekly benefit amount or half of total base period wages, whichever is less. So a lower weekly amount not only means less per week but also potentially a lower overall balance on the claim. That part sometimes catches people off guard too when they're comparing a new claim to an old one.

0 coins

That double impact hadn't fully clicked for me. Lower weekly amount and potentially lower total balance. The new claim really can be significantly smaller in every way.

0 coins

The math on the maximum benefit amount works both ways though. If your base period wages were spread more evenly, the half-of-total-wages cap might be what limits you rather than the 26 weeks. Someone with steady lower wages across all four quarters might have a lower total balance than the weekly amount alone suggests.

0 coins

So the new claim can be worse in two different ways, the weekly amount and the total it'll pay out. That's not a fun realization when you're already dealing with a layoff.

0 coins

Appeal rights are worth knowing about even though they probably don't apply here. The DE 429Z comes with an appeal option, and if you think EDD miscounted your wages, you have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal in writing. If the wages are correct and the amount is just lower because earnings were lower, an appeal wouldn't change anything. But if an employer reported the wrong quarterly wages, that's a different situation.

0 coins

Worth checking in case an employer underreported wages, especially if any of my work between claims was hourly with inconsistent reporting. I'll at least verify the wage amounts look right.

0 coins

Employer underreporting happens more than people expect, especially with gig work or places that run on tips. If the quarterly wages in your base period don't match your records, that's what the appeal is for.

0 coins

The 30-day window on the DE 429Z appeal is real. If you're going to check your wage records against what EDD has, do it soon after the notice arrives, not weeks later when you've let the deadline slip.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration requirement is the same on a new claim as on a first one, worth remembering. Most people have to register and post a resume in CalJOBS within 21 days of the date on the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work. A lower weekly amount doesn't change that obligation, and missing it can pause payments.

0 coins

Good reminder. I did get the DE 8405 and I already registered in CalJOBS, but I appreciate the heads up for anyone else reading this who might have missed it.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration trips people up because it's easy to assume once you've done it on a previous claim you're covered. EDD can require it again on a new benefit year.

0 coins

The 21-day window on the DE 8405 is tighter than it feels when you're focused on everything else involved in a new claim. Good to get it done right away.

0 coins

Waiting week applies to the new claim too, same as it did on the first one. Even though the new claim is lower than the old one, that first week is still unpaid. The first certification usually covers the waiting week and then one paid week.

0 coins

I did see the waiting week show up in my Claim History, so that lined up with what I expected at least. Just wanted to make sure the weekly amount question was answered before I got too far in.

0 coins

Waiting week has caused so much confusion on second claims because people assume they served it already. It resets with each new claim, and the first certification almost always looks like less than you'd expect because of it.

0 coins

First time I saw the waiting week on my new claim I thought EDD had made a mistake and held a payment. Had to look it up to confirm it's just the standard one-week unpaid period on every new claim.

0 coins

Partial week earnings still count the same on the new claim too. If you pick up any part-time work while certifying, the first $25 or 25 percent of gross earnings in that week, whichever is bigger, isn't counted, and the rest gets subtracted from the weekly benefit amount. With a lower weekly amount, any earned wages reduce it even more noticeably.

0 coins

Part-time work while certifying was something I was planning to do, so that formula matters. With $198 a week instead of $312, those wage deductions will bite more than they used to.

0 coins

The earnings formula on a lower weekly amount is worth calculating in advance before you decide how many hours to pick up. At $198 weekly, the math changes pretty quickly once you're earning more than $25 or 25 percent of whatever you bring in.

0 coins

Report Wages in UI Online helps you work out the weekly earnings before you certify, which is useful if you're going to have variable part-time hours. It doesn't go back and fix a week already certified though.

0 coins

Direct deposit versus the Money Network card doesn't change the timing of when the payment shows up, in case anyone is wondering about that. Payments often post to the card within about 24 hours of certifying online. If you switched from your old claim to a different payment method, you'd change that in myEDD settings.

0 coins

Sticking with the Money Network card for now. At least that part doesn't change between claims.

0 coins

UI Online updates payment info daily, and there's also the EDD TeleCert line at 1-866-333-4606 which runs 24 hours if you want to check status at odd hours without logging in.

0 coins

Someone mentioned earlier that the new weekly amount is a blank slate calculation, and that's accurate. Each new claim gets recalculated entirely from the new base period. The fact that your previous claim paid more isn't something EDD takes into account when setting the new rate. The base period wages are what they are.

0 coins

I've come to accept it even if it's frustrating. The in-between job set the new base period, the new base period set the weekly amount, and there's nothing to dispute because the wages were accurately reported.

0 coins

Accepting it is probably the right move here. If the wages are right and the formula was applied correctly, the DE 429Z is correct. That doesn't make it less painful, but there's no mechanism to adjust it upward based on a previous claim.

0 coins

Certifying on time and reporting all work and wages accurately is the best thing someone can do to avoid further complications on a lower-benefit claim. Missing a certification or misreporting wages would only make a difficult situation worse.

0 coins

Federal income tax applies to unemployment benefits, worth flagging. At each certification you can choose to have 10 percent withheld for federal taxes. California doesn't tax unemployment benefits, but the IRS does. On a lower weekly amount, 10 percent withheld is a smaller dollar hit than it was on the old claim, but it still matters for end-of-year planning.

0 coins

I had withholding set up on my old claim. I'll make sure it's set the same way on this one, especially since I don't want a surprise on the federal return.

0 coins

A lot of people skip the withholding and then get hit with an unexpected tax bill in the spring. The 1099G shows up in UI Online under Payments by January 31 and it covers everything paid out in the year.

0 coins

10 percent withholding on $198 a week is small, but it adds up over several months. Worth deciding intentionally rather than just letting it default.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure