Back to California Unemployment

Fatima Al-Sayed

Does commission based sales job affect unemployment benefits and claim? California EDD explained

So I got laid off from my sales position about three weeks ago and I'm kind of in limbo trying to figure out what EDD is going to do with my claim. The thing is, my pay was almost entirely commission-based - I had a small base of like $800/month but the rest was all commissions that varied wildly month to month. Some months I pulled in $3,200, other months maybe $900. I filed my UI claim right away but now I'm sitting here wondering if commission income even counts the same way as regular wages when EDD calculates my weekly benefit amount. My Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award (the DE 429Z) came in and my weekly amount looks lower than I expected - I think they might have used a quarter where my commissions were really low. Does anyone know how commission based sales job affect unemployment benefits and claim calculations specifically? Like does EDD count all those variable commissions the same as a salary? And is there anything I can do if the base period they picked catches my worst earning months?

Retail auto sales was my job for four years before the dealership cut the whole floor team last spring. Variable commission every single month - I completely understand the DE 429Z shock when the number came in lower than expected. Filed right after the layoff and kept hitting walls trying to reach anyone at EDD to ask about how they counted my commissions. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent after I'd spent days getting nowhere. The video showing how to reach a live person at EDD - https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 - was what made me try it. When I finally got the agent, I asked specifically which quarters they used for my base period and whether my commission checks had all been reported correctly by the dealership. The agent pulled up my claim and walked me through the exact four quarters in my standard base period - turns out my employer had filed all my W-2 wages including commissions, so that wasn't the problem. The issue was just that two of my four base period quarters had been my slower sales months. The agent confirmed EDD uses whatever wages your employer reported, commissions and all, and that there wasn't an error on my claim.

0 coins

Just checked my own UI Online Claim History and I'm in almost the same boat - commission sales for a staffing firm and my DE 429Z came in at $310/week. Didn't know the agent could actually walk you through the specific quarters like that. That's genuinely useful to know.

0 coins

My DE 429Z showing $275 is exactly what has me anxious. If the agent confirmed they count commissions the same as salary wages, that at least answers part of my question. The variable quarter problem is what I'm stuck on.

0 coins

Your situation with the uneven commission months is really the core of how base period math can sting sales workers. EDD takes the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your claim started - so if your layoff was recent, your most recent quarter probably isn't even in the calculation yet. That's just how the standard base period works, not a mistake. Commission income your employer reported to EDD counts exactly like any other wages - there's no distinction between base salary and commission when EDD adds up your quarterly wages. The weekly benefit amount comes from whichever of those four quarters had your highest earnings, and runs between $40 and $450. You can run the numbers yourself using the Unemployment Benefit Calculator on EDD's site before you call anyone - it'll at least tell you if your DE 429Z is in the right ballpark given your reported wages.

0 coins

Jumped on EDD's site calculator after reading this and yeah, my commission quarter estimates line up with what the DE 429Z says. At least now I know it's not a data entry error.

0 coins

wait so the most recent quarter before you filed doesn't count?? that seems backwards if that's your highest earning quarter

0 coins

The most recent completed quarter usually falls into the base period just fine - what gets left out is the quarter that's still in progress when you file, since it isn't closed yet. So if you filed in, say, October, the July-September quarter might just barely be completed and included. EDD switches to the alternate base period automatically only when the standard one doesn't give you enough wages for a valid claim at all - it doesn't use the alternate just to get you a higher weekly amount.

0 coins

Twelve weeks into my claim and I had this same confusion about commissions when I was in pharmaceutical sales. The alternate base period question comes up a lot with commission workers and I want to flag something before it goes sideways in this thread: the alternate base period isn't a way to get a bigger weekly check. EDD only uses it when your standard base period wages don't meet the minimum threshold for a valid claim in the first place. If your standard base period already makes your claim valid, they won't switch to alternate even if your most recent quarter was your best.

0 coins

Okay this clears something up - I was reading in another forum that you could request the alternate base period if you thought your recent quarters were higher. That's not how it works?

0 coins

Exactly right that it's not how it works. EDD's alternate base period is automatic and only kicks in when the standard base period can't support a valid claim. No one requests it - EDD runs it on their end if your standard wages fall below the threshold. If your claim is already valid under the standard base period, that's the one being used, full stop.

0 coins

I just went through this whole alternate base period confusion with my own claim from solar panel sales. The agent I finally reached confirmed the same thing - standard base period was used because my wages were above the minimum, even though my most recent quarter would've been higher. The math just is what it is.

0 coins

Worth flagging for anyone reading: commissions are wages, full stop. I see people assume EDD treats 1099 commission income differently, but that's a separate issue. If you were an employee getting W-2 wages that included commission - which it sounds like you were - all of it counts. The employer reports it all to EDD. The only scenario where commission gets complicated is if you were actually an independent contractor getting 1099s, because that's a whole separate question about whether you even had covered wages.

0 coins

W-2 employee the whole time, so I think I'm in the clear on that piece. My commissions showed up on my W-2 as regular wages.

0 coins

My cousin did 1099 sales for years and couldn't get UI at all when that company dried up - completely different situation. Good point to separate those two.

0 coins

The 1099 independent contractor path is a different world for UI eligibility. If someone worked as a 1099 contractor and is trying to get UI, that eligibility question needs to go straight to EDD because whether the work was legally covered employment is what's at stake - not just the wage calculation.

0 coins

Mortgage origination work, almost entirely commission, and my claim got weird during the certification step because I picked up one partial commission check after my layoff while wrapping up a deal that closed late. EDD's report-wages step had me stumped on how to enter it. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent about that specific week. The agent told me to report the commission for the week the work was actually performed, not the week the check arrived - which mattered a lot because the work had been done before my layoff but the payment came after. The agent noted my account to reflect that, and that week cleared without any pending issue.

0 coins

The timing of when to report vs. when you actually did the work is something I hadn't even thought about. I have a commission from a deal I closed the week before my layoff that might pay out in a couple months. I need to look into that more.

0 coins

My situation after reading this - pulled up UI Online and saw a pending week that I think is from exactly this kind of timing issue. Didn't realize the report-wages rule was about when the work happened, not when the money landed.

0 coins

The rule there is wages reported for the week they're earned, not received. So a commission from work done before the layoff but paid after - you'd report it for the week the work was done. UI Online's Report Wages section is for before you certify; if a week already got certified wrong, you'd need to contact EDD through a UI Online message or by phone to correct it.

0 coins

Something I want to add from going through commission-income UI myself last year: once you're on a claim and you pick up any commission work part-time while still collecting, the partial-week earnings rule applies. EDD takes the first $25 or 25 percent of whatever you grossed that week, whichever is bigger, and doesn't count it. Everything above that threshold gets subtracted from your weekly benefit amount. So if your weekly benefit is $350 and you earn $200 in commission one week, $200 times 25 percent is $50, and $200 minus $50 is $150 that gets subtracted, leaving you $200 in UI that week. It's worth knowing before you assume any commission work automatically disqualifies the week.

0 coins

Looked at my own certification history after reading this and I think I reported a partial commission week correctly but wasn't sure how EDD would apply it. Seeing the actual math spelled out helps.

0 coins

i thought any work at all in a week just made you ineligible for that whole week?? thats been stressing me out

0 coins

Full-time work does end eligibility for that specific week regardless of how much it pays. The partial earnings formula is for part-time or occasional work. If you worked full-time hours in a week, that week is out regardless of the commission amount. But one commission check from a deal closed before your layoff paying out now isn't the same as working full-time - you'd want to look at whether work was actually performed in that week.

0 coins

Eight days after my layoff from real estate sales and I'm already stressed about certification. Reading this thread is helping but I keep second-guessing whether EDD considers real estate commissions 'regular' wages. I had a broker who issued W-2s for all my commissions, so I'm an employee on paper, but the nature of real estate income feels different. Does that matter at all?

0 coins

W-2 wages from a broker count the same as wages from any employer. EDD doesn't evaluate whether the type of work felt like traditional employment - what matters is that your employer reported wages to the state. Real estate agent W-2 wages go into the base period calculation exactly like retail or pharmaceutical sales commissions would.

0 coins

Checked my W-2 from last year and all the commissions are listed as wages, so that's a relief. Still waiting on my DE 429Z to arrive so I can see what weekly amount they calculated.

0 coins

The CalJOBS requirement tripped me up after my sales job layoff and I don't see it mentioned here yet. After my claim was processed, I got the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (the DE 8405) and had 21 days to register on CalJOBS and post a resume. I didn't think it would apply to me because I figured I'd find another sales job fast. Almost missed the deadline. If you get that notice, do not sleep on it - missing it can pause your payments.

0 coins

Got the DE 8405 in my stack of EDD mail and honestly hadn't opened it yet. Pulling it out now. When you say 21 days from the date on the notice - is that calendar days?

0 coins

Calendar days from the date printed on the DE 8405, not from when it arrived in your mailbox. So if the notice is dated three days before you got it, those three days already count. The caljobs.ca.gov registration itself is pretty straightforward but the resume upload step takes some time if you haven't updated it in a while.

0 coins

My mail situation is unreliable and I missed a DE 8405 deadline on a previous claim. Had to call EDD to sort it out. Didn't lose all my benefits but there was definitely a gap. Open your EDD mail the same day it arrives.

0 coins

Two-year insurance sales background and my claim was fine until a pending issue showed up in my Claim History with no explanation. Spent a full week trying to reach EDD and getting cut off. Claimyr got me to an actual live agent - asked about the pending weeks and found out EDD had flagged my account because one of my commission paystubs had a date discrepancy my employer's payroll vendor had entered wrong. The agent put notes on my file and told me EDD would contact my former employer to verify. Those pending weeks resolved about 10 days later.

0 coins

Payroll date discrepancies causing flags is something I wouldn't have thought to check. My former company used a third-party payroll processor and I have no idea if everything was entered correctly on their end.

0 coins

Pulled up my own Claim History just now and I have one week showing pending from two certifications ago with no note. No idea if it's a payroll data issue or something else entirely.

0 coins

If a week has been pending for more than a week or two with no explanation in Claim History, that's usually when it makes sense to contact EDD. Sometimes it resolves on its own, but a flag from a payroll discrepancy won't fix itself without someone looking at it.

0 coins

Came back to add something from my own commission-sales claim that might help others in this thread: I called EDD about my lower-than-expected DE 429Z and the agent told me which exact quarter was used as my highest-earning quarter for the weekly benefit calculation. Knowing that helped me understand why the number was what it was. The base period isn't a mystery - EDD can tell you exactly which quarters and what wages they used. It's not a black box.

0 coins

Knowing they can actually read you the specific quarters is reassuring. I'm going to try to get through to someone to ask the same question about my claim.

0 coins

My situation is that I keep getting the busy signal before I even reach a hold queue. Getting to an agent at all has been the obstacle.

0 coins

Dental equipment sales was my background and I had a commission structure where my employer paid out quarterly bonuses on top of monthly commissions. EDD treated both as regular wages since they all showed up on my W-2. Filed my claim and my DE 429Z came in at $390/week. Had one situation where I needed to reach EDD fast about a form issue, and Claimyr got me talking to an EDD agent that afternoon. Asked the agent whether my quarterly bonuses had been pulled into the base period correctly - the agent confirmed they were counted in the quarter they were paid, which happened to be one of my highest quarters, so it actually helped my weekly amount.

0 coins

quarterly bonuses counting toward the base period quarter they were paid is good to know, not when they were 'earned' over the year

0 coins

Exactly - the agent was clear that it goes into whichever quarter it was actually paid in. So if a big annual bonus lands in December, it counts toward the Q4 wages for base period purposes.

0 coins

my situation is a little different - i do door to door solar sales and my income is 100% commission w2. filed last month after the company downsized. my de 429z came in at like $220 which feels really low but i have no idea what quarter they used or if my employer even reported everything correctly

0 coins

Your employer's payroll records submitted to EDD are what determines your base period wages. If you think your employer may not have reported your commissions correctly, that's something to bring up with EDD directly - give them your quarterly earnings from your own records and ask them to compare. The Unemployment Benefit Calculator on EDD's site can also give you a rough estimate to see if $220 lines up with what you earned in your highest quarter.

0 coins

ran the calculator and something seems off, my highest quarter should have been around $7,800 in commissions but the number it spits out is higher than what my de 429z says. gonna try to get through to someone at EDD this week

0 coins

Five weeks after my layoff from B2B tech sales and still certifying. One thing I didn't expect was how the work search requirement applies even when you were in sales. You still have to be actively looking for work every week you certify, same as anyone else. EDD doesn't have a specific number of contacts you need to log each week, but keeping your own record of where you've applied is a habit worth building in case anything ever comes up.

0 coins

Still job searching actively so that isn't a problem for me, but I hadn't thought about keeping a record. I've been applying through LinkedIn but haven't saved anything systematically.

0 coins

Even a simple notes app or spreadsheet with the company name, position and date you applied is plenty. It's just good to have if EDD ever asks you about your work search activity for a specific week.

0 coins

Just registered on CalJOBS after reading this thread and the work search section there is at least a good place to track your applications. I'd been ignoring that part of the site.

0 coins

Went back through three months of my UI Online Claim History after reading everything in this thread and realized I may have made an error when I certified. Had a week where a small commission check arrived for work done before my layoff, and I reported it for the week the check came in - not the week the deal closed. If the rule is wages get reported for when the work was done, not when paid, I may have misreported that week.

0 coins

If a week already certified has wrong wage information, the path is to contact EDD - either through a UI Online message or by phone - to let them know and have them look at it. The Report Wages section in UI Online is only for fixing things before a certification goes in. Don't just leave a known reporting error sitting there.

0 coins

Sent a message through my UI Online account about it. Not sure how long it takes for someone to respond but at least I flagged it.

0 coins

UI Online messages can take a while to get a response. If you need a faster answer or the error affects a pending week, phoning EDD is the quicker path.

0 coins

okay so i made a mistake earlier in this thread where i said any work at all in a week kills your whole UI payment. that's wrong and i got corrected above and i appreciate it - part-time commission work reduces your payment using the formula but doesn't automatically wipe out the week. i had no idea about the $25 or 25% threshold thing

0 coins

Honestly that's a mistake a lot of people make on their first claim. The partial earnings formula is buried and not intuitive at all.

0 coins

i certified saying i worked in a week and just assumed EDD would zero out my payment for that week. they didn't - they applied the formula and i still got a partial payment. made sense once i saw the deposit.

0 coins

Pending week from my Claim History finally resolved after about 12 days. No explanation ever appeared in UI Online, it just switched from Pending to showing a payment. I think it was the commission timing issue that someone mentioned above - work done in one period but paid after the layoff. EDD sorted it without me having to call.

0 coins

Mine did the same thing on week three of my claim. The pending status can clear quietly in the background. Doesn't always mean there's a problem being held against you.

0 coins

Seeing that pending weeks can resolve on their own is at least a little reassuring. Though I'll still try to reach someone if mine goes more than two weeks.

0 coins

the whole base period explanation in this thread finally made it click for me. i'd been confusing the base period calculation with the appeal process - like i thought if you disagreed with your weekly amount you were appealing your claim. that's not the same thing at all right

0 coins

Two completely different things. An appeal is specifically for when EDD mails you a Notice of Determination saying you're disqualified or denied benefits - you then have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to file an appeal using the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) or a letter. Disagreeing with your weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z is handled by writing to EDD within 30 days of that notice too, but it's not the same as an adjudication issue going to appeal. The DE 429Z itself even says to contact EDD in writing within 30 days if anything on it is wrong.

0 coins

got it - DE 1080CZ is the denial notice and that's when appeal applies, DE 429Z is the award amount and that's a separate thing to dispute if the number is wrong. thanks for clearing that up

0 coins

Final thing I'll add from my solar sales claim experience: once my weekly benefit amount was set, the payments were pretty reliable as long as I certified on time through UI Online. Direct deposit hitting within about a day of certifying has made the cash flow manageable. The uncertainty at the beginning about whether commission wages would count right was the stressful part - once the DE 429Z came and I confirmed the base period quarters, it's been pretty routine since then.

0 coins

After all the anxiety about the commission calculation, hearing it becomes more routine once things are set up is actually helpful. I feel like I understand the whole process a lot better now than I did when I posted this.

0 coins

Payment timing through UI Online certification has been consistent for me too. The first claim processing takes a few weeks but after that it's been predictable on my end.

0 coins

Still waiting on my DE 429Z after two weeks. The post says about two weeks for claim processing so I'm right at the edge. Hopefully it shows up this week.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure