Back to California Unemployment

Yuki Ito

Do I owe quarterly estimated tax on unemployment 1099-G TurboTax - California EDD question

Laid off from my warehouse job back in March and have been collecting unemployment since then. Got a letter from EDD with my weekly benefit amount and have been certifying every two weeks like clockwork. Here's what's tripping me out though - my buddy told me that because unemployment counts as income, I might owe estimated quarterly taxes to the IRS and that if I don't pay them I'll get hit with penalties when I file. I pulled up my UI Online account and saw the 1099-G option sitting there under Payments, but I'm not sure what to do with it mid-year. Do I owe quarterly estimated tax on unemployment 1099-G TurboTax situation or is this something I deal with at the end of the year? I did not elect the 10% federal withholding when I was certifying. I honestly had no idea I was supposed to think about this during the year and now I'm stressed. California state taxes I think I'm fine on? Someone please help me with this.

Got my DE 429Z showing $410 a week back in April and the withholding question tripped me up too. Here's how it actually shakes out: unemployment benefits are federal taxable income, so yes the IRS considers them ordinary income, but California does not tax them at the state level. That's actually one of the few claimant-friendly things about filing in this state. The quarterly estimated tax question is real though - if you didn't elect the 10 percent federal withholding through EDD and you expect to owe more than a certain threshold to the IRS when you file, the IRS can charge an underpayment penalty. You can still turn on the 10 percent withholding now for future payments by updating your preference in myEDD. It won't cover what's already been paid out but it stops the bleeding going forward. TurboTax will walk you through the 1099-G entry and can estimate whether you owe quarterly payments, so running those numbers there is a reasonable move.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Wait so the California part I don't have to worry about at all? That takes a little pressure off. It's the federal side that could bite me. I'm going to go into myEDD right now and see if I can flip that withholding switch.

0 coins

Confirmed on the California side - EDD's own materials say unemployment is exempt from state income tax. Federal is the one to watch.

0 coins

Thought for sure California taxed it too, since it taxes pretty much everything else. Good to know that one's off the table.

0 coins

Had my adjudication issue resolved a few months back and once payments started flowing I looked into this exact same thing. The 1099-G for the full year lands in UI Online under Payments by January 31 but that doesn't help you now if you're already partway through the year without withholding. The IRS safe harbor rules are what matter here - if you pay at least 90 percent of this year's tax liability or 100 percent of last year's total tax (110 percent if your adjusted gross income was over a certain amount), they generally won't hit you with the underpayment penalty. TurboTax actually has an estimated tax calculator that takes your situation into account. Worth running it now rather than waiting.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

The 90 percent or 100 percent of last year's thing is helpful framing. Last year I was working full time so my income was way higher. Does that mean I'd need to match last year's full tax bill even though I'm making way less this year?

0 coins

The safe harbor based on last year's tax is a fixed number regardless of what you earn this year. So yes if you had a bigger tax bill last year you can use that number as your target and avoid the penalty even if you end up owing more than that at filing. TurboTax handles this calculation - it's one of the things it's actually good at.

0 coins

that safe harbor thing saved me last year, didn't know about it until my accountant mentioned it, really useful to know

0 coins

My Notice of Award came in showing $385 weekly and I'd gone almost four months without withholding because nobody told me to set it up. EDD's phone line was the only way I could actually get clarity on what options I had mid-claim. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent - there's a video they put out about reaching a live person at EDD that I watched first: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent confirmed I could switch to the 10 percent federal withholding at any point mid-claim and that it would apply starting with my next payment. They also confirmed the 1099-G would reflect the full year total including weeks before I turned it on. Knowing that, I turned withholding on that same day.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Four months without withholding and you got it sorted - that's exactly where I am. Good to know the agent could actually confirm those details.

0 coins

Didn't know you could switch withholding mid-claim. Assumed it was locked in from when you first filed.

0 coins

The 1099-G showing the full year total makes sense, it just captures everything paid out regardless of when withholding started.

0 coins

EDD phone lines were a wall of busy signals for me after my layoff from a logistics company last fall. Ended up using Claimyr to get through and talked to an agent who pulled up my account and confirmed my withholding election wasn't saved properly from my original application. Got it corrected on the spot. My 1099-G ended up reflecting some weeks with withholding and some without, which TurboTax handled just fine when I entered the box amounts.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

The 1099-G having mixed withholding weeks makes sense - good to hear TurboTax deals with that without issue.

0 coins

EDD phone lines being impossible to get through is basically a universal experience at this point. Glad you found something that worked.

0 coins

Ten percent federal withholding on a $410 weekly check is $41 taken out each week, which over a full claim year adds up to over two grand sent to the IRS on your behalf. Whether that covers your actual liability depends on your whole tax picture - other income, filing status, deductions. TurboTax's estimated tax tool is genuinely the right move here because it accounts for all of that, not just the unemployment piece.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Running the numbers like that makes it feel more manageable. I'll plug everything into TurboTax tonight and see where I actually stand.

0 coins

people always forget their filing status changes what they owe, single vs head of household makes a real difference

0 coins

Also worth remembering that if you did any part-time work during weeks you certified, you would have reported those wages to EDD, and that income is separately taxable too. The 1099-G only reflects what EDD paid you, not what you earned working.

0 coins

Had a Notice of Determination sitting in my mailbox after a dispute about my last employer, and while all of that was going on I completely missed the withholding election window early in my claim. The IRS underpayment penalty isn't catastrophic - it's calculated on what you actually owe over what you paid, and it's typically a percentage rate applied to the gap. If you're close to the safe harbor thresholds the penalty ends up being pretty minor. Still better to avoid it, but it's not a disaster if you're a little short.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Okay that's reassuring - I was imagining some massive penalty. If it's just a percentage of the gap and I'm somewhat close to safe harbor I can live with that.

0 coins

Agreed - people sometimes think missing estimated payments is an automatic audit trigger or something serious. It's really just a small interest-style charge.

0 coins

my accountant said the same thing, it's annoying but it's not the end of the world if you end up slightly short

0 coins

My claim opened in January and I am still dealing with this question going into the fourth quarter. One thing worth flagging: some people assume that because the EDD takes the 10 percent federal withholding out, you're completely covered. That is not always true. If your total income - even just from unemployment - is high enough, 10 percent may not cover your full federal liability. TurboTax's withholding estimator can tell you if 10 percent is enough for your situation or if you should be sending additional estimated payments directly to the IRS.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Had no idea 10 percent might not even be enough depending on income level. I'll check the estimator to make sure I'm not undercovering even after I turn it on.

0 coins

This is an underappreciated point. For a lot of people at the lower benefit amounts 10 percent is plenty. But if you have other income - a spouse working, freelance gigs, whatever - it stacks up fast.

0 coins

Filing status got me last year - I was head of household and had my UI benefits plus about six weeks of part-time work I reported through the Report Wages option in UI Online. When I finally sat with TurboTax my total federal tax bill was more than what 10 percent withholding had covered. Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask whether my mid-year wage reporting had been processed correctly, since I wanted to make sure the 1099-G amounts matched what I'd reported. The agent verified all six weeks of partial wages were on file. After that it was just a TurboTax entry problem, not an EDD error.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Using the Report Wages screen to check that mid-year - that's a smart move before you even get to TurboTax so you know the EDD numbers are right.

0 coins

i didn't know you could check your wage reports in UI Online, thought you just entered them and hoped for the best

0 coins

The agent being able to confirm the wages on file is exactly the kind of thing worth a phone call for. TurboTax can't tell you if EDD has the right data.

0 coins

My benefit year runs through next October and I hadn't thought about estimated taxes at all until a friend asked me about my 1099-G. Used Claimyr after getting nowhere with the main EDD phone line to reach an agent who confirmed my current withholding election and checked whether my direct deposit information was current while I had them on the line. The agent said my 10 percent withholding had been active since week three of my claim, which I honestly didn't remember selecting. Knowing that was set let me calculate forward in TurboTax with accurate numbers.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Verifying the withholding election is actually active - that's worth confirming because I'm not certain mine ever got saved either.

0 coins

i thought i set mine up too and then found out it never went through, check it in myEDD to make sure

0 coins

The TurboTax side of this is actually pretty straightforward once you have the right numbers. When you enter your 1099-G, there's a box 4 for federal income tax withheld - if EDD took out 10 percent it shows up there. Box 1 is total benefits paid. TurboTax uses both to figure out if you owe more or if you're getting a refund on the federal side. The quarterly estimated payment question pops up in TurboTax's interview as it calculates forward.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Box 1 total benefits and box 4 federal withheld - got it. I'll make sure I have both when I sit down with it.

0 coins

The box 4 thing is what people miss. They see the total in box 1 and panic without realizing box 4 reduces what they actually owe.

0 coins

Worth adding - if EDD's withholding for prior weeks isn't in a mid-year 1099-G you can still check UI Online under Payments for a running total of what's been deducted so you can estimate where you stand before the January 1099-G comes.

0 coins

NOBODY told me any of this when i applied and i had a full freak out in april when my tax person mentioned quarterly payments. ended up being fine because my income last year was low enough that i hit the safe harbor off my prior year taxes easy. but EDD definitely does not explain any of this to you when you sign up

0 coins

Same honestly - the EDD application process tells you nothing about the tax side, you have to find it out yourself.

0 coins

to be fair EDD's job is eligibility not tax advice, but a bigger notice at setup would be nice

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Finding this thread has probably saved me from that exact same April panic.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration doesn't affect your tax situation but it did come up when I got my Notice of Requirement to Register for Work - I want to make sure people here aren't confusing the two. The tax piece is entirely federal and handled through TurboTax and IRS rules. The CalJOBS and work search requirements are separate, managed by EDD, and not related to what you owe April 15.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Glad you separated those out - I did get the CalJOBS notice and registered there, so at least that box is checked. The tax question is a whole separate lane.

0 coins

People confuse the EDD obligations with the IRS obligations constantly, good to call that out clearly.

0 coins

my layoff from a restaurant group was effective january 2 so my entire benefit year is falling in one calendar year which actually simplifies the 1099-G situation. all my payments will be in one tax year and i only have to deal with one federal filing for all of it. people who get laid off in october or november end up with benefits straddling two tax years which makes the 1099-G math a little annoying

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Mine started in March so I'm also all in one calendar year which is cleaner.

0 coins

The year-straddling situation is real - the 1099-G reports what was paid in each calendar year regardless of when the claim started, so you get one for each year with benefit payments. TurboTax handles it fine as long as you enter each year's 1099-G separately.

0 coins

i got laid off november 15 last year and had to deal with two separate 1099-Gs, was not fun but turbotax did walk me through it step by step

0 coins

Just turned off the 10 percent withholding last week because I picked up part-time work and thought I wouldn't need it anymore - then read that partial work doesn't necessarily end your claim and I might still be getting partial UI benefits for a bit. Got confused about whether I should turn withholding back on.

0 coins

If you're still getting partial UI payments after reporting your part-time wages through EDD, those payments are still taxable federal income. Whether to turn withholding back on depends on how much you're getting and what your overall tax situation looks like - TurboTax's estimator is the right tool for that call.

0 coins

okay that makes sense - i'll run the estimator with the partial amounts and see if 10 percent is worth turning back on for the remaining weeks

0 coins

the turbotax software really does handle the 1099-G well in my experience. i was nervous entering it the first time because i thought i'd have to do some complicated worksheet but it just asks you the box amounts and does the math. the quarterly estimated tax question comes up naturally in the interview flow, it's not a separate thing you have to hunt for

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Good to know it surfaces naturally in the interview flow - I was afraid I'd have to know to go look for it.

0 coins

Same experience - TurboTax makes it less scary than it sounds, just follow the prompts and answer honestly about your income.

0 coins

just make sure you're using the right version, free file doesn't always handle 1099-G with withholding correctly depending on your situation

0 coins

Went through a messy appeal last year after a denial on my initial claim - appeals board hearing, the whole thing - and even during all of that I had to keep certifying every two weeks so any weeks that got approved would actually get paid. That whole period my tax situation was a mess because I didn't know if I'd end up getting paid or not. The 1099-G at the end only reflected what EDD actually paid out, so the tax bill matched reality even if the year itself was chaotic.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

The 1099-G reflecting only what was actually paid out makes sense - so if someone has weeks on appeal and they're not paid yet, those weeks don't show up until payment is processed.

0 coins

Exactly - my appeal covered some weeks from earlier in the year and when the back pay finally came through, those weeks showed up in the 1099-G for the year they were actually paid, not the year I would have received them normally.

0 coins

That's correct - EDD reports benefits in the year paid, not the year earned. Important distinction if you have a long-running adjudication or appeal situation.

0 coins

something i got wrong for a long time: i thought the EDD 1099-G would arrive by mail automatically. it only does if you haven't set up paperless. if you signed up for paperless in myEDD you have to go into UI Online under Payments and get it there. almost missed it last january

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

I think I did set up paperless - I'll look under Payments in UI Online to make sure I know where to find it in January.

0 coins

got burned by this same thing, spent two weeks waiting for mail that was never coming because i had paperless on

0 coins

EDD says the 1099-G is available in UI Online by January 31 either way, so checking there first is always the safer move regardless of paperless settings

0 coins

Wanted to correct something I've seen float around: some people say you can avoid the 1099-G entirely by turning down benefits or repaying them. That's not how it works. If EDD paid you, you get the 1099-G for that amount. If you later repay an overpayment, that gets handled on the following year's taxes as a possible deduction, it doesn't erase the original 1099-G.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Good to know - no way to retroactively avoid the 1099-G on what's already been paid.

0 coins

The overpayment repayment deduction thing is worth knowing for anyone in that situation. The IRS does allow a deduction for repaid benefits in certain circumstances.

0 coins

yeah i heard someone in my old workplace say you could just 'give the money back' and not owe taxes on it, that's not accurate at all

0 coins

Something I learned from my claim that started in February: even if you stopped collecting benefits mid-year because you found work, EDD still sends the 1099-G for whatever was paid before you went back. Some people assume if they're employed by December they don't have to deal with the 1099-G at all.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

Author

Mine might end if I find work before December - good to know the 1099-G still shows up for whatever was paid before that.

0 coins

And you'd enter both the 1099-G from EDD and your W-2 from the new job in TurboTax, each in their own section. TurboTax handles multiple income sources without issue.

0 coins

yeah when i went back to work partway through a prior claim i had both and turbotax handled it just fine, took a little longer to enter everything but no issues

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure