Back to California Unemployment

Miguel Harvey

Disqualified claim after moving out of verification appeal - what do I do with California EDD?

Last month I finally got a Notice of Determination in the mail after weeks of my claim sitting in pending status on UI Online. EDD disqualified me and the reason on the notice pointed to an identity verification issue that I thought I had already resolved through ID.me weeks before this. Now I'm staring at an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) wondering if I should even bother fighting it, because I genuinely did verify my identity, I uploaded everything they asked for, took the photos, got the confirmation email from ID.me that it went through. Backstory: I was laid off from my warehouse supervisor job back in September, applied right away, went through the CalJOBS registration, posted my resume within the timeframe on the notice, was certifying every two weeks through UI Online like I was supposed to. Everything seemed fine until my Claim History started showing all my weeks as Pending with no explanation. I figured it was just normal processing time. Then the disqualification notice showed up out of nowhere. The notice does have an appeal deadline 30 days from the mailing date. I'm already about 10 days in. What I don't understand is whether the appeal is my only path here, or if there's something else I can do at the same time to get EDD to actually look at my ID.me verification and fix this before the 30 days is up. Has anyone dealt with a disqualified claim after moving through the verification process and getting hit with this anyway? Do I appeal, do I call, do I do both simultaneously?

DE 1326C sitting on my desk is what started my whole nightmare with this exact issue. EDD sent me that Request for Identity Verification letter and I completed everything through ID.me, got the confirmation, assumed it was done. Weeks passed and my claim stayed Pending in UI Online. Then a Notice of Determination came saying I was disqualified for identity reasons even though I had verified. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent on the phone after getting nowhere through messages in UI Online. The video at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 is titled something like reaching a live person at EDD, which is exactly what I needed. The agent pulled up my account and told me EDD had not yet received the confirmation from ID.me on their end, even though I had the confirmation on my side. She told me to also send in the DE 1326C with my documents directly by mail since the electronic path had a gap, and to file my appeal before the 30-day deadline while that got sorted. I mailed the documents the same day and filed my appeal, and the disqualification was eventually reversed.

0 coins

Mailing the DE 1326C separately while also appealing is exactly the double-track approach I was wondering about. Did the appeal decision come back before or after EDD confirmed they received your mailed documents?

0 coins

EDD's ID.me confirmation not matching what shows on EDD's end is way more common than people realize. The gap between what ID.me records and what EDD actually receives can hold a claim up for weeks.

0 coins

The mailed documents showed up on my account first, actually. The appeal decision came about two weeks after that. Keep certifying through UI Online the whole time too, every two-week period, even during the appeal.

0 coins

Filing the appeal within 30 days of the mailing date on that Notice of Determination is the absolute priority here. The appeal form is DE 1000M and the address to mail it to is right on the notice itself. A lot of people sit on it hoping EDD fixes things on its own and then miss the deadline. On the ID.me side: sometimes the issue is that EDD's system flags a verification as incomplete even when ID.me shows it finished, especially if there was any lag between creating the ID.me account and linking it to the EDD claim specifically. When I went through this after my layoff from a logistics company, I had verified in ID.me first but hadn't connected it to my EDD account properly. That was the gap that caused my disqualification. My Notice of Determination was about the same thing as yours.

0 coins

Pulling up my UI Online account right now to check whether the ID.me link actually shows as connected to EDD specifically, not just as a confirmed ID.me account. That distinction you're making is something I hadn't thought about.

0 coins

Same trap caught me. Had the ID.me account working fine but the EDD link was what broke. Two different steps that look like one.

0 coins

you should also keep certifying every two weeks even while this is all getting sorted, right? don't want to miss weeks and lose out on back pay if the appeal goes through

0 coins

Certifying through the whole appeal period is exactly right. EDD can only pay certified weeks if the appeal is decided in your favor, so stopping would mean losing those weeks entirely even if you win.

0 coins

Appeals at EDD go to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board after EDD does its own review first. An administrative law judge handles the hearing. You'll get a Notice of Hearing in the mail at least 10 days before it's scheduled. At the hearing you testify under oath and can represent yourself, bring a union rep, or have an attorney. For a verification disqualification specifically, your strongest evidence is the ID.me confirmation you got, the dates on it, and anything showing when you completed the steps. I lost an appeal once because I didn't bring printed documentation and was just saying 'I did it' without proof. Bring printed proof of every step.

0 coins

Printing everything ID.me related right now. Confirmation emails, timestamps, the works. Thank you for the reminder about documentation, I would have assumed the electronic record was enough.

0 coins

what if you cant make the hearing date they send you? is there any way to change it?

0 coins

Contacting EDD before the hearing date is how you request a change, but they can only give you an open time slot, so it's not guaranteed. Missing the hearing without contacting them first is the worst outcome.

0 coins

I went through almost this exact sequence after my retail management job ended. Applied, certified, hit Pending across every week, then got the disqualification notice for identity verification despite having done everything through ID.me. What nobody tells you upfront is that you should be appealing AND trying to get EDD on the phone at the same time, not treating them as alternatives. The 30-day clock doesn't pause for anything. File the appeal first, then work on the resolution. The appeal protects your right to those weeks; the phone call might actually fix the underlying ID.me issue faster.

0 coins

Running both tracks simultaneously is the clearest framing I've seen of what I need to do. Sending the appeal form today.

0 coins

parallel tracking it is the right move. appeal protects you legally, phone call or message might fix it faster but isnt guaranteed

0 coins

Eight weeks of pending certification sitting in my Claim History is what I was looking at before I got the disqualification notice. Same ID.me verification gap as what you're describing. I ended up getting a live EDD agent through Claimyr after my messages through UI Online went unanswered for two weeks. The agent looked at my account and saw that EDD's system showed my identity verification as still open even though I had the ID.me confirmation from weeks earlier. She walked me through submitting a correction through the portal and told me to appeal regardless, because the disqualification would stay on record until an administrative decision reversed it even after the ID issue got fixed. I filed the appeal the same day.

0 coins

The part about the disqualification staying on record even after the ID fix is important. So the appeal isn't optional even if you resolve the verification issue separately.

0 coins

Trying that route myself this week. Had four weeks pending and just got the disqualification notice yesterday so I'm still inside the 30-day window.

0 coins

Filing the DE 1000M as soon as possible is what I'd do. Don't wait until the fix is in because you don't know how long that takes.

0 coins

Something I want to flag about the ID.me process that tripped me up: there are two separate things happening. One is creating and verifying your identity in ID.me itself. The other is specifically connecting that verified ID.me account to your EDD myEDD account at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/. I only did the first part when I initially applied, thought I was done, and ended up with a pending claim that turned into a disqualification because EDD never received the second half of the connection. If you log into myEDD and don't see your identity showing as verified on the account itself, that's your sign that the EDD-specific link didn't go through even if ID.me's side is confirmed.

0 coins

Logging into myEDD right now to check exactly this. This might actually be what happened with mine.

0 coins

This is a really common mistake. The ID.me account confirmation email and the EDD account confirmation are two separate things and EDD only cares about the second one.

0 coins

i thought the same thing when i first applied, did the id.me stuff and figured that was it. had no idea you had to actually link it to the edd account separately until someone in a thread like this pointed it out

0 coins

My disqualification came for a slightly different reason, fired from a restaurant job, but the appeal process was the same. The thing I didn't realize until my hearing was that I could bring documentation from my employer that actually helped my case. For an ID.me verification appeal you'd want to bring your ID.me completion confirmation, the original DE 1326C if you have it, and any screenshots showing the account link to myEDD. The administrative law judge at my hearing was straightforward and explained each step as we went. It's not as intimidating as it sounds if you go in with your documents organized.

0 coins

Knowing the judge walks through it step by step makes this less terrifying. I've been imagining a full courtroom situation.

0 coins

Appeals hearings are way more low key than people expect. Usually by phone these days, judge goes through the evidence, you explain your side.

0 coins

Testimony is under oath but it's conversational. Having your documents ready matters more than knowing legal procedure.

0 coins

Fourteen days into the 30-day appeal window is where I found myself before finally getting a straight answer from EDD. After days of trying the phone line myself and getting cut off, I used Claimyr to get through to an agent. She confirmed my identity verification was showing as incomplete on EDD's end despite my ID.me records showing it finished. The agent told me to mail in the DE 1326C with supporting documents as a backup to the electronic submission and to file my appeal in writing before the deadline. I'm now three weeks past that call and my pending weeks are still being reviewed, but at least I know what's actually in my file.

0 coins

Three weeks out and still pending review is a little anxiety-inducing but at least having the actual claim information from EDD is better than guessing from the outside. Hope yours resolves soon.

0 coins

Knowing what's in the file is half the battle honestly. At least you can track against what the agent told you instead of just watching Pending forever.

0 coins

For the appeal letter itself: you don't need to write anything elaborate. The DE 1000M just needs your name, claim number, the date on the Notice of Determination, and a brief statement saying you disagree with the disqualification decision. Something like 'I completed identity verification through ID.me on [date] and have confirmation of completion. I believe the disqualification was issued in error.' That's enough to get the appeal started. Mail it to the address printed on the Notice of Determination, not to a general EDD address.

0 coins

Using that exact framework for my appeal letter. The address on the notice is different from the general EDD address, good to know.

0 coins

Does the postmark date count or does it need to actually arrive by the deadline?

0 coins

The 30 days runs from the mailing date on the notice, and mailing it before that date is what matters. Send it certified mail so you have proof of the date you mailed it.

0 coins

EDD's CalJOBS requirement is something else to make sure is handled during all of this. After you got your Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405), you had 21 days to register on CalJOBS and post a resume there. If that slipped through the cracks while you were dealing with the verification issue, it could create a separate problem on top of the disqualification appeal.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration was done within the first week. Resume posted before the 21-day deadline on the DE 8405. At least that's one thing I handled right in all this.

0 coins

good that you did it early. i missed the calJOBS deadline once because nobody explained it clearly and it added a whole separate issue to my claim

0 coins

Missing CalJOBS is brutal because it creates a whole separate eligibility problem that runs alongside whatever else is pending. Good you got that cleared.

0 coins

My claim went through the same verification disqualification cycle earlier this year after a tech company layoff. What helped me keep my sanity was treating each step as its own task with its own deadline, not one giant overwhelming problem. Appeal first because of the 30-day hard deadline. ID.me verification correction second, through UI Online messages or by phone. Mailing the DE 1326C third as a physical backup. Each of those is separate from the others and can move at its own pace. The appeal doesn't fix the ID.me issue and the ID.me fix doesn't satisfy the appeal. They're parallel processes.

0 coins

Breaking it into three separate tracks with separate deadlines is genuinely how I need to be thinking about this. The appeal has the hardest deadline so it goes first.

0 coins

This framing is accurate. EDD processes these separately anyway so treating them as one problem creates confusion about what step you're waiting on.

0 coins

Something that helped me when I was appealing my own disqualification: keep certifying in UI Online every two weeks through the entire appeal period. I stopped certifying for about three weeks because I figured the claim was dead and lost those weeks entirely when the appeal went in my favor. EDD could only pay weeks that had been certified. Even when everything looks blocked and hopeless, keep certifying. Those weeks accumulate and EDD pays them retroactively if you win.

0 coins

Already certified last week. Will keep going every two weeks regardless of what happens with the appeal.

0 coins

i made the same mistake of stopping and lost weeks i should have gotten. it's not intuitive but you have to certify even when it seems pointless

0 coins

Watching every certified week show as Pending in Claim History is demoralizing but those weeks are protected. Stopping is the one thing that actually kills your back pay for certain.

0 coins

About the timeline: a lot of people expect EDD to review the appeal quickly after they submit the DE 1000M, but EDD does its own internal review first before sending it to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. That internal review sometimes resolves the issue without a formal hearing, especially for identity verification cases where EDD can see the ID.me records directly. Either way, file the written appeal on paper, don't rely on digital submissions alone for something with a hard deadline. Send it certified mail with return receipt so you have documented proof of delivery.

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt is going to be my method. Not leaving paper trail to chance on this.

0 coins

EDD's internal review resolving it before it goes to CUIAB is what happened for a friend of mine with a verification case. Faster than a full hearing but not guaranteed.

0 coins

DE 1080CZ is the form number on the disqualification notice, right? Just want to make sure I'm reading mine correctly and looking at the right document before I start drafting my appeal letter off it.

0 coins

DE 1080CZ is the Notice of Determination, yes. That's what gets mailed when EDD decides you don't qualify. The Appeal Form is DE 1000M, which is a separate form often included with or attached to the DE 1080CZ.

0 coins

Finding the DE 1000M in the envelope now. It was included with the notice, just hadn't connected that the two forms were related.

0 coins

Both forms coming together in one mailing is standard. Some people set aside the DE 1000M thinking it's a separate correspondence and don't realize it's the appeal form for that exact notice.

0 coins

My weekly benefit amount on the Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award (DE 429Z) came to $380 based on my earnings from earlier in the year, but then the disqualification froze everything before any of it paid. After four weeks of UI Online showing all my certifications as Pending, I got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr and found out my verification had a flag on it that the agent was able to document for review. The agent told me the Notice of Determination would reflect whatever EDD decided and that I should appeal within 30 days if I disagreed. I filed the DE 1000M the following morning.

0 coins

Knowing what the actual flag in your file was seems like it made the appeal easier to respond to specifically. That's what I'm hoping to find out when I get through to someone at EDD.

0 coins

DE 429Z coming in and then watching the whole claim freeze before a dollar shows up is the worst specific kind of frustrating. Glad you got some clarity at least.

0 coins

Legal aid might be worth looking into if the appeal gets to a formal CUIAB hearing and you feel unsure about representing yourself. Some California legal aid organizations take unemployment appeal cases at no cost. For a verification disqualification you can usually handle it yourself since the facts are pretty clear-cut, but having that option available is worth knowing about.

0 coins

Keeping legal aid in the back of my mind as a resource if the hearing feels beyond what I can handle alone. For now planning to represent myself since the ID.me documentation should be clear.

0 coins

Verification disqualification appeals are some of the more straightforward ones to self-represent on because the evidence is documentary rather than interpretive. Bring your ID.me records and the timeline and let those speak.

0 coins

Went through five months of my claim being a mess after I moved to a new address mid-claim and my verification documents got sent to the old address. EDD mailed things there, I never got them, things went into disqualification because I didn't respond to their verification request. The moral of that story: if you've moved at any point since filing, make sure your address in myEDD is current so EDD's mail is actually reaching you and not sitting at a previous residence.

0 coins

Address is current in myEDD, fortunately. But this is a really important detail for anyone reading this thread who might have moved recently.

0 coins

Address mismatches causing disqualifications is way more common than EDD's materials make clear. Updating it in myEDD as soon as a move happens should be the standard advice but it barely gets mentioned anywhere.

0 coins

EDD's live chat through the Help button in UI Online is another option to try while you're working on getting through by phone. It's available Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. and sometimes you can get a faster answer than leaving a message, which can take days to get a response. For documentation purposes, it also gives you a written record of what you were told.

0 coins

Trying the live chat tomorrow morning at 9 a.m. sharp to ask about the ID.me status while I also send the appeal form by certified mail today.

0 coins

live chat works if you get in early. if you try mid morning the queue fills up fast and it closes out

0 coins

Logging in right at 9 is the move. The window closes at 2 but if the queue fills before that you're out of luck.

0 coins

EDD phone line at 1-800-300-5616 is available Monday through Friday 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Early morning is generally when you have the best shot at getting through before call volume builds up. Afternoons on Mondays are the worst. If you get cut off or can't get through, trying the UI Online message system as a parallel track is a good backup so you have something in writing.

0 coins

Setting an alarm for 8 a.m. Monday to try the phone line before anything else. Good to know about avoiding Monday afternoons specifically.

0 coins

Tuesday and Wednesday mornings are even better than Monday in my experience. Monday mornings get flooded because everyone who had the whole weekend to stress about their claim is calling at the same time.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later who is confused about whether this is an adjudication issue or an appeal situation: they're related but different. Adjudication is the process EDD uses to decide eligibility when there's a question on the claim, like an identity issue. An appeal is what you do after EDD has already issued a decision in a Notice of Determination and you disagree with it. If your claim is still in adjudication you're waiting for EDD's decision. If you got the Notice of Determination, that's already the decision and now you're in appeal territory. I confused these two things early on and wasted time waiting for adjudication to finish when I should have been filing an appeal.

0 coins

Had this exact confusion in my head and you just untangled it completely. Got the Notice of Determination already, which means EDD already decided, which means I'm in appeal territory not adjudication waiting mode.

0 coins

i asked someone about this and they kept saying 'wait for adjudication' but i already had the determination notice. this explains why that advice wasnt making sense for my situation

0 coins

Once that DE 1080CZ is in your hands, EDD has already decided. Appeal is the path, not waiting.

0 coins

One more thing for anyone appealing a verification disqualification: when you write your appeal statement on the DE 1000M, being specific about dates matters a lot. 'I completed ID.me verification on [specific date], received confirmation of completion at [specific time], and my account showed as verified.' Specificity tells the administrative law judge that you have receipts for your side of the story, and vague statements like 'I did everything right' don't hold up as well under questioning.

0 coins

Going back through my email to pull the exact timestamps from the ID.me confirmation. Specific dates are going in the appeal letter.

0 coins

Exact dates and times are what differentiate a compelling appeal from a vague one. Administrative law judges are going through a lot of cases and the specific documentation stands out.

0 coins

I wrote 'I think I did it in October' on my appeal and it did not help my case at all. Exact dates matter as much as people are saying here.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure