Back to California Unemployment

Mei Wong

Can I refuse job offer to return to work unemployment - California EDD question

So my old employer sent me an email last week asking me to come back. I've been collecting UI since they let me go in March, everything has been going fine with certifications and I've been doing my work search like I'm supposed to. The thing is the job they're offering back is different from what I had before - lower pay, different shift that completely messes up my kid's school pickup schedule, and honestly the commute is worse too since they moved to a different location. I declined in writing and now I'm paranoid I just blew up my entire claim. Does anyone know if California EDD lets you turn down a job offer, even from your old employer? Like is there any protection if the job isn't the same as what you left? I don't want to lose my benefits over this but I couldn't take a job paying $180 less a week than what I was making.

Eight weeks into my own claim, UI Online showed my payment for week 6 flip back to Pending out of nowhere, right as I'd just gotten a 'return to work' offer myself from a former client. Needed to know fast whether declining it would tank my claim status. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the line with an EDD agent - there's a video they have on reaching a live person at EDD if you want to see what that looks like: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me week 6 was pending because my identity check hadn't cleared yet, nothing to do with the job offer. She also said the offer question depends on whether the work is 'suitable' - same kind of job, similar pay, reasonable distance - and that EDD makes that call after they hear from both me and whoever made the offer. Filed my identity docs that same day through ID.me.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

Wait, so EDD actually contacts the employer who made the offer? Like they reach out to my old company to get their side of it?

0 coins

From what the agent said, yes - when there's a question about a refused offer they talk to both sides, same way they do when someone gets fired. EDD makes the decision from whatever both of you tell them.

0 coins

The 'suitable work' thing is real. The job has to be a reasonable match for your skills, pay, and situation - EDD doesn't expect you to take anything and everything just because it's available.

0 coins

$180 a week less than your previous pay is a significant cut. From everything I've read and experienced, California EDD looks at whether a job offer is 'suitable' before deciding if refusing it disqualifies you. The pay difference, the location change, the shift problem - all of that factors in. It's not automatic that you lose benefits just because you said no.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

How does EDD even find out I turned it down though? Does my old employer report it to them?

0 coins

Employers can and do report refusals - EDD notifies your last employer when you file, and employers sometimes reach back out about offers. It's not guaranteed they report it but it happens, especially if the company is trying to manage its unemployment costs.

0 coins

My cousin's boss did exactly this, reported a refused offer almost immediately. So yeah they can and some definitely do.

0 coins

Had a nearly identical situation last year. Former employer wanted me back at a 20 percent pay cut, different location, and I turned it down. EDD sent me a questionnaire asking about the refused offer - what it paid, what my old pay was, the distance, why I said no. I filled it all out honestly and they found in my favor, kept getting paid. The key was documenting everything about why the offer wasn't comparable.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

They sent you an actual questionnaire in the mail, or was it through UI Online?

0 coins

Mine came by mail, but I've heard people get it through UI Online too depending on the situation. Either way you have to respond and be specific about the differences between the new offer and your old job.

0 coins

Did your payments pause while they were deciding, or did they keep coming through the whole time?

0 coins

Payments paused for about two and a half weeks while EDD looked into it. Then they backdated everything once it was resolved. Definitely nerve wracking but it worked out.

0 coins

WAIT. I thought if your EMPLOYER offers you your job back and you say no, that's automatic disqualification no matter what??? I've been telling everyone that for months, is that actually wrong??

0 coins

That's not how it works in California. EDD looks at whether the offer was for 'suitable work' - if the pay is significantly lower, the conditions are worse, or the location changed, it's not automatically disqualifying. EDD has to decide based on the specific circumstances.

0 coins

okay wow I definitely had that wrong, glad I saw this thread before I ended up in this situation myself

0 coins

A lot of people assume a former employer recall = must accept or lose benefits. The suitability question is really the whole thing.

0 coins

From the EDD rules I know: they expect you to be able and available for work, but 'available' doesn't mean you have to accept any job at any pay. The question is whether a reasonable person in your field would consider that offer suitable given your skills and what you were earning before. A pay cut that size, plus the location change, plus the shift issue - that's a pretty solid case that the offer wasn't suitable.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

Should I be documenting all of this somewhere, like writing down the details of their email offer and my response?

0 coins

Absolutely save everything. The email from your employer, your written reply, anything showing the pay difference between the new offer and your old role. If EDD reaches out to ask about it, you want specifics, not just 'it was less money.

0 coins

Screenshots too if the offer came through any kind of messaging platform, not just email. Paper trail matters.

0 coins

okay so genuine question - does the reason it's a different shift actually matter to EDD? like childcare conflict seems personal not job-related, worried they'd just say that's your problem to figure out

0 coins

EDD does consider whether a shift makes it genuinely difficult to accept the work - childcare obligations are recognized as a real constraint in eligibility determinations. It's not guaranteed to be decisive on its own but it's a legitimate factor, especially combined with the pay cut and location change.

0 coins

oh okay that's better than I thought, I figured they'd just brush that off

0 coins

The fact that you declined in writing is actually good for you. Some people turn down offers verbally and then there's a 'he said she said' situation. Having it in writing shows the offer existed, what it included, and that you gave a clear response.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

I did keep a copy of both the email they sent me and my reply, so at least that part I handled right

0 coins

That's exactly what you want. If EDD asks for documentation of the offer and your refusal, you have it ready.

0 coins

One thing worth knowing - the written record also shows the date of the offer, which matters if there's any question about which certification weeks are affected.

0 coins

Does anyone know if you have to proactively tell EDD you refused an offer, or do you just wait to see if they contact you? I'm in a somewhat similar boat and not sure if staying quiet looks worse than saying something.

0 coins

From my understanding you're not required to report a refused job offer on your certification - the certification questions ask about work you did and wages you earned, not offers you turned down. If EDD has a question about it, they'll reach out. But if your employer reports it, EDD will likely contact you anyway.

0 coins

Got it, that's helpful. I wasn't sure if staying quiet would look like I was hiding something

0 coins

EDD reaching out is different from you being in trouble - it's just their process to get both sides before deciding. Getting a questionnaire doesn't mean you're being disqualified.

0 coins

ugh this whole suitable work thing is SO vague though. like who decides what's 'suitable'? EDD gets to just decide and you have no say? what if they get it wrong?

0 coins

EDD makes the initial call, but if they decide the refusal was unjustified and disqualify you, you can appeal. You'd get a Notice of Determination with an Appeal Form and you'd have 30 days from the mailing date to file a written appeal. An administrative law judge would actually hear your side.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date, okay writing that down. did not know there was an actual appeal path

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

How serious is the appeal process, like do you need a lawyer or can you just show up and explain yourself?

0 coins

On the appeal question - you can represent yourself at an CUIAB hearing. You don't need a lawyer. You testify under oath, present your documents, explain the situation. The judge is an administrative law judge, not a regular court. Plenty of people do it on their own, especially when the facts are pretty clear like a documented pay difference.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

That's honestly reassuring. I was imagining a whole courtroom situation.

0 coins

It's pretty different from that. And again, you may never even get to that point - EDD might find the refusal was justified and you just keep getting paid.

0 coins

My neighbor went through an appeal hearing for a different issue and said it was way less intimidating than she expected. The judge actually asked good questions.

0 coins

Dealing with the return-to-work refusal question ended up being way more complicated for me than I expected. The job offer on my claim was flagged and my payments stopped cold with no explanation on UI Online beyond 'Pending' for three weeks. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent and she told me my case had been sent to an adjudicator, so it wasn't going to clear on its own. She also confirmed the specific weeks that were held and told me to watch for a DE 4800 notice about a phone interview to discuss the refusal. I had no idea I was about to get scheduled for an interview until she said that.

0 coins

Wait three weeks with nothing showing in UI Online at all? That sounds awful. Did the payment for all those weeks come through once the interview happened?

0 coins

It did, eventually - but only after the interview and EDD's decision. The pending weeks weren't paid until the whole thing was resolved.

0 coins

So the phone interview for a refused offer refusal is specifically about THAT issue, not just a general eligibility check?

0 coins

The DE 4800 notice I got listed the specific questions EDD was going to ask - it was definitely about the job offer and why I turned it down.

0 coins

Quick flag on the CalJOBS side of this: I got confused when I first filed about whether CalJOBS registration and the work search stuff was separate from a refused offer question. They are separate. CalJOBS is about registering and posting your resume - the work search and the refused offer are different issues EDD handles on their own.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

Okay yeah I'd kind of mixed those up in my head a little, thanks for clarifying that

0 coins

CalJOBS registration has to happen within 21 days of the date on the notice EDD sends you about it. Easy to miss that deadline if you're focused on other stuff going on with your claim.

0 coins

Does 'return to work' have to mean the same exact company? Like what if a completely different employer made an offer and I turned that down - same rules apply?

0 coins

Same suitability standard applies regardless of whether the offer is from your old employer or someone new. EDD doesn't treat your former employer's offer as automatically requiring acceptance.

0 coins

Huh okay, I figured there might be a different standard since it's your own company asking you back

0 coins

The 'old employer trying to recall you' situation is actually the more common version of this question. Both types go through the same suitability analysis.

0 coins

The pay difference part of this is worth spelling out more clearly. EDD looks at what you were earning before and whether the new offer is reasonably comparable. A job that pays $180 less a week than your previous position is a substantial gap. That alone is a real factor in whether the offer qualifies as suitable work. The location change piles on top of that. I had a similar situation, flagged offer on my claim, and ended up calling EDD through Claimyr to ask what documentation I should pull together before my interview. The agent walked me through what the adjudicator would likely be looking at - the wage comparison being a main one.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

Did the agent give you a sense of how EDD typically weighs the wage difference - like is there a percentage threshold or is it more of a judgment call?

0 coins

More of a judgment call from what she said. It's not a fixed percentage, it's about whether the pay is reasonably comparable given your skills and what you were making before. She didn't give me a number.

0 coins

Makes sense that it's judgment-based, otherwise employers could just offer you something 24.9% less and claim it's suitable

0 coins

My payments went to Pending for about 10 days when EDD got the flag about my situation. Freaked me out completely. Eventually I got a questionnaire asking about the offer, filled it out with every detail I had, and payments resumed once they made a decision. Never even had a phone interview for mine.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

No interview at all, just the questionnaire and then a decision? That's interesting, I wonder if it depends on how complex the situation is

0 coins

Probably, yeah. Mine was a pretty clear-cut case - written offer, big pay difference, different city. Maybe less back and forth needed.

0 coins

Honestly kind of relieved to hear some of these get resolved without the full interview process

0 coins

Heads up that your weekly benefit amount doesn't change based on what the offered job would have paid - your WBA is locked in from your base period wages. So declining a lower-paying offer doesn't somehow lower your benefit.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

Oh I hadn't even thought about that angle, was not worried about it but good to know

0 coins

People sometimes assume EDD adjusts things based on what you 'could have earned' and that's not how it works

0 coins

Worth mentioning that if EDD does decide against you on the refused offer question, the Notice of Determination they mail you will also have an Appeal Form right in it. The 30 days to appeal starts from the mailing date on that notice, not from when you receive it, so act fast.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

Mailing date not received date, got it. That's a distinction I could have easily gotten wrong.

0 coins

Yeah it's the kind of thing that trips people up. The postmark basically sets your clock running.

0 coins

30 days sounds like a lot until you're waiting around for the mail and panicking and suddenly two weeks are gone

0 coins

Returned from a layoff to what my company called the 'same role' but it was clearly not - different pay grade, different reporting structure. When I declined the recall, my claim went into some kind of review and I couldn't figure out from UI Online what was actually happening. Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask what stage my claim was at. She confirmed a suitability review was open and that I'd receive a DE 4800 scheduling my phone interview within two weeks. Then she told me the interview would specifically cover the differences between my old role and what I was being offered, so I should have anything in writing about both jobs ready.

0 coins

What happened at the actual interview - did they give you any indication of how it went?

0 coins

The interviewer asked me specific questions about both positions, went through the differences in pay and duties. No decision on the call itself, that came later in a separate notice.

0 coins

The fact that they put it in writing as the 'same role' when the pay grade was different seems like it would be pretty helpful documentation

0 coins

Coming back to the original question one more time: the core thing to know is that California EDD does not automatically disqualify you for refusing a job offer. The 'suitable work' standard exists specifically so claimants aren't forced to take anything and everything. Your situation - documented pay cut, location change, shift incompatibility - is exactly what that standard is designed to address. File your certifications on time, keep documenting everything, and respond promptly if EDD reaches out.

0 coins

Mei Wong

Author

This whole thread has been genuinely useful. I went from completely panicked to understanding what to actually expect. Still nervous but at least I know there's a real process here, not just automatic disqualification.

0 coins

That's the main thing to hold onto - there's a process and you get to participate in it. The documentation you already have puts you in a decent spot.

0 coins

Agreed, and OP keep certifying through all of this no matter what. If it ends up going to appeal down the road, EDD can only pay back certified weeks.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure