Back to California Unemployment

GalacticGladiator

Can I get unemployment if fired for unapproved overtime - California EDD question

So I got let go last Friday and I'm still kind of in shock about how it happened. I'd been working at a distribution warehouse for about two years and yeah, I stayed late a few times without getting supervisor sign-off first. My hours ran over on maybe four or five occasions over the last couple months. My manager kept saying I needed prior approval for anything beyond my scheduled shift, I'd acknowledge it, then end up staying late again because there was work that needed to get done and I didn't want to leave the team short. Last week they handed me a termination letter citing repeated unauthorized overtime as the reason. I've been reading about how California EDD handles firings and I'm seeing the word 'misconduct' everywhere and honestly I don't know if what I did counts as that or not. I'm not talking about theft or harassment or anything like that, I literally just kept working past my scheduled time. Does that rise to the level of misconduct EDD cares about? Has anyone been in a situation like this where they were fired for something that feels pretty minor and still got approved? I filed my claim online through myEDD already but I'm bracing for a phone interview and I want to understand what I'm actually dealing with here before that happens.

Unauthorized overtime at a warehouse job, and that termination letter, those are exactly the kind of details you need to have ready when EDD calls. My situation was different - got let go from a logistics company for a policy violation they said was 'repeated' and the whole misconduct question hung over my claim for weeks while it sat in adjudication. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent after I'd been getting nowhere calling on my own. The video on how to reach a live EDD person is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what that looks like. What I actually asked the agent was whether my case would be decided before or after the employer responded, and she told me EDD sends a DE 4800 notice with the interview date and time, and the decision can't go out until after both sides have been interviewed. She also confirmed the pending weeks in my Claim History would stay that way until EDD made its determination. I went ahead and kept certifying while it was all being sorted out.

0 coins

The part about certifying while it's pending - did you have any weeks that ended up not being payable once the decision came through, or did they all go back and get paid once EDD decided in your favor?

0 coins

All the weeks I'd certified during adjudication were processed once the determination came out in my favor. If I hadn't kept certifying through that whole waiting period those weeks would've just been gone.

0 coins

Waiting on that DE 4800 is genuinely stressful when you don't know exactly when the interview is scheduled. Good to know the UI Online homepage shows the time too.

0 coins

Firing someone for unauthorized overtime is the kind of thing where the word 'misconduct' gets used really loosely by employers, and EDD doesn't see it the same way they do. If I were in your position I'd be thinking hard about a few things before that interview: how many times did your manager specifically tell you in writing, did you sign anything acknowledging the policy, and was there any kind of progressive discipline before the termination? The way EDD looks at it, your employer has to show there was actual misconduct on your part - and that's more than just breaking a rule once or twice. Staying late to finish work because you didn't want to leave the team short reads differently than, say, falsifying time records. EDD is going to hear from both you and your employer, and what you say about why you kept staying late matters a lot.

0 coins

About the progressive discipline piece - they did give me two written warnings before the termination. Does having those warnings work against me or is it more neutral in how EDD sees it?

0 coins

Warnings show EDD you knew about the policy, which is part of what makes this tricky. But knowing a rule existed and willfully flouting it to hurt the company are pretty different things. Tell EDD exactly why you stayed late those times - finishing a task, covering for the team, whatever the real reason was.

0 coins

The employer having written documentation of the warnings will definitely come up. EDD interviews both sides, so whatever the employer says about those warnings, you'll have a chance to give your side of it in your own interview.

0 coins

I'd just want to make sure you're not mixing up the phone interview with an appeal - they're two separate things. The interview that gets scheduled when there's a question about why you were fired, that's EDD figuring out the facts before they decide anything. An appeal is what you do after EDD makes a decision and you disagree with it. Had a friend who skipped the interview thinking they'd just appeal if things went wrong and ended up with a denial because EDD decided on the information they had without hearing his side.

0 coins

That's a really important distinction, I hadn't fully separated those two in my head. So the interview is basically my chance to tell EDD what actually happened before any decision gets made?

0 coins

Exactly right - the interview on the DE 4800 is your one shot before the determination. Miss it and EDD moves forward without your input.

0 coins

What your friend went through - EDD moving forward without the claimant's side because they missed the interview - that happens more than people realize. The DE 4800 notice has the date and time, and you keep your phone free at that exact moment.

0 coins

Missed phone interviews are a really common reason for denials that feel unfair. EDD's pages say if you miss it, phone EDD that same day to explain.

0 coins

The misconduct bar in California isn't just 'did you break a rule.' What I'd look at first if this were my claim is whether staying late to actually do work looks anything like the kind of willful, deliberate harm they're usually talking about. Working extra hours without sign-off is a policy violation, sure, but EDD's standard is about misconduct connected to the work itself, not just any rule your employer has. Had a coworker years ago who was let go for a dress code violation - repeated, documented, all of it - and still got approved because the nature of what they did didn't rise to that level.

0 coins

The 'dress code violation' example is a useful way to think about it. What would you say is the clearest sign that EDD is leaning toward misconduct vs. just a policy issue?

0 coins

Honestly the clearest signal comes from the Notice of Determination after EDD decides. Before that, nobody can tell you which way it's going to land, not even the most experienced person on this forum.

0 coins

This is accurate - EDD's own language is that the employer has to prove misconduct, but how that plays out case by case isn't something anyone here can predict. Tell your side clearly in the interview.

0 coins

Two written warnings and then a termination is a standard progression and it makes the employer's case look organized on paper. That said, the reason you gave - wanting to get the work done, not leave your team in a bind - is exactly the kind of thing you need to say out loud in the interview. EDD isn't looking for a perfect employee, they're trying to figure out if what you did was deliberate harm or bad judgment. Those aren't the same thing.

0 coins

How much detail do I need to give in the interview about each individual overtime incident or is a general explanation enough?

0 coins

Give specific examples if you remember them - which shifts, what was going on, why you stayed. Vague explanations are easier for EDD to discount than concrete ones.

0 coins

Specifics matter a lot. If you kept a note anywhere about those shifts, even a text to a coworker saying 'staying late tonight to finish the inventory', that kind of thing is worth mentioning.

0 coins

The pending status after filing when there's a fired-for-cause question is pretty normal, and my claim sat that way for a while after I lost my retail job for a register policy thing. DE 429Z showed up in the mail showing my weekly benefit amount while I was still waiting. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr when I needed to find out whether my employer had responded to EDD's inquiry yet - the agent told me the employer had submitted their response and my interview was the next step before any decision. Kept certifying every two weeks and the pending weeks all resolved once the determination letter came.

0 coins

The DE 429Z showing up - does that mean EDD approved the claim, or is it just showing what the claim could pay if they determine you're eligible?

0 coins

The DE 429Z just shows what the weekly amount would be if they decide you qualify. It's not any kind of approval - EDD still has to decide the misconduct question first before any weeks actually pay out.

0 coins

A lot of people think getting the DE 429Z in the mail means they're approved and then get blindsided by a denial later. The document just shows the potential amount, the actual decision is in the determination that comes after.

0 coins

Glad someone clarified that because the DE 429Z coming in the mail does feel like good news when you first get it. The real signal is whether the pending weeks in Claim History actually show payment.

0 coins

Before anything else I'd track down the exact wording in that termination letter and think about whether 'unauthorized overtime' is how they phrased it or if they used language like 'insubordination' or 'policy violation.' The specific words matter because that's what EDD is going to see from the employer side. I needed to get a clear read on what my former employer had told EDD about my own separation and used Claimyr to get through to an agent who pulled up my file and read back what had been submitted. Helped me prepare for the interview knowing exactly what they'd said.

0 coins

I actually do have the letter and it says 'repeated unauthorized overtime in violation of company policy' pretty much verbatim. Is that more or less serious sounding than insubordination to EDD?

0 coins

Honestly, 'policy violation' framing tends to be a weaker word choice for employers trying to prove misconduct than 'insubordination' or 'deliberate disregard.' The interview is where you explain the why behind the overtime.

0 coins

The wording on that letter really can shape how EDD reads the employer's side. 'Policy violation' is different territory than something that sounds like willful defiance.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up when I filed after a termination was thinking I should wait until everything was sorted to start certifying. EDD can only pay certified weeks - if you don't certify during the adjudication period you lose those weeks entirely, there's no going back. File and certify every two weeks regardless of what the pending status says.

0 coins

Certifying through a pending adjudication period always feels a little weird because you're certifying for weeks that might not pay out, but you're absolutely right that it's the only way to preserve them.

0 coins

Overtime pay from my last job was something I wasn't sure how to handle on the certifications. Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr about it - the agent walked me through the Report Wages option in UI Online and explained that any wages get reported for the week they were earned, not when the check came. That cleared up a lot of confusion I had about how my final paycheck would affect my first few certification weeks.

0 coins

The earned vs. paid distinction on wages is one that really catches people off guard with final paychecks. Glad someone confirmed that piece.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is something a lot of people completely forget about when they're focused on the misconduct question. EDD sends a DE 8405 notice telling you if you need to register and post a resume in CalJOBS, and there's a 21-day window from the date on that notice. Missing it can hold up your payments even if everything else with the misconduct determination goes fine.

0 coins

I haven't gotten a DE 8405 yet - does that come after the determination or is it separate from the whole adjudication process?

0 coins

The DE 8405 and the adjudication process run separately. Watch the mail for it and don't assume you're exempt unless EDD's notice says so.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration tripping up an otherwise clean claim after a determination comes through is genuinely frustrating. The DE 8405 deadline doesn't pause while adjudication is happening.

0 coins

Reading everything in this thread and I'm in a pretty similar spot - got fired from a hotel front desk job for taking a shift extension without manager approval, twice. I always thought California EDD would automatically deny anyone fired for a policy violation and I never even filed. Turns out I probably should have, right?

0 coins

Filing is always worth doing when you're fired - EDD decides the misconduct question, your employer doesn't get to decide it for them. The worst that happens is a denial, and then you can appeal within 30 days of the notice date.

0 coins

EDD's own take is that the employer has to prove misconduct, so the outcome isn't predetermined by the fact of a firing. Apply through myEDD and let the process work.

0 coins

Honestly didn't realize EDD could rule in a claimant's favor even when the employer has documentation. Filing today.

0 coins

The appeal process is worth understanding even before you need it. If the determination comes back as a denial you have 30 days from the mailing date on the notice to appeal in writing - either the DE 1000M form that comes with the notice or a letter mailed to the address on it. Keep certifying through any appeal too.

0 coins

Does the appeal go straight to a judge or does EDD review it again internally first before it goes anywhere?

0 coins

EDD reviews it first after you submit the appeal, then it goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. An administrative law judge holds the actual hearing, and you get a Notice of Hearing in the mail at least 10 days before.

0 coins

The fact that there are two levels - EDD's internal review and then CUIAB - means a denial isn't necessarily the end of the road. Worth understanding before you're staring at a denial notice trying to figure out next steps.

0 coins

Unauthorized overtime being cited as the reason for termination is something I'd think about from the employer's side too. They're going to respond to EDD's DE 1101CZ notice and explain their side. If they frame it as insubordination, EDD weighs that against what you say about why you stayed late. The more specific and credible your account of your reasons, the better.

0 coins

I didn't know the employer gets notified and responds - is that response something I ever get to see or know the contents of before my own interview?

0 coins

EDD doesn't share the employer's response with you before the interview as far as the process goes. That's why having your own clear account ready matters, you're going in without knowing exactly what they said.

0 coins

Both sides give their account without seeing the other's first. The interview is EDD's way of getting the full picture before making a determination.

0 coins

Wages are a piece of this nobody's mentioned yet. If your overtime hours were actually worked and paid, those wages are on the books - which could affect what your base period looks like when EDD calculates your weekly benefit amount. The highest quarter of earnings in your base period is what drives your weekly amount, and overtime pay in that quarter bumps the number up.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about overtime wages actually helping the weekly benefit calculation. If the unauthorized overtime showed up in the highest quarter that could mean a noticeably different weekly amount compared to regular hours only.

0 coins

Exactly - EDD uses actual wages reported to them, so overtime pay is in there regardless of whether the overtime itself got your fired. The DE 429Z will show what they calculated.

0 coins

For the work search piece - once your claim is active and you're certifying, EDD expects you to be out there looking for work every week you certify. That part of the process runs the same whether the claim started from a layoff or a termination. Keep a personal record of where you're applying.

0 coins

Are there specific types of activities EDD wants to see for work search or is applying to jobs the main thing?

0 coins

EDD's pages don't give out a specific number of contacts or a list of what counts on their end, so I'd just document what you're actually doing each week - applications, interviews, networking, whatever you're doing to find work.

0 coins

Keeping your own log somewhere regardless of what EDD requires specifically is just a smart habit. If there's ever a question about a week you can point to something concrete.

0 coins

The first certification after filing usually covers the waiting week plus one payable week - EDD has a one-week unpaid waiting period that every claim has. So don't be alarmed when that first batch of certified weeks processes and one of them shows no payment. It's not a denial, it's just the standard waiting week.

0 coins

Does the waiting week count toward the total weeks of benefits or is it sort of outside the 26-week calculation?

0 coins

The waiting week doesn't reduce the total amount your claim can pay - it's the first eligible week you serve, but the max benefit amount stays based on 26 times your weekly rate or half your base period wages, whichever is less.

0 coins

A lot of people burn a worry cycle on that first week showing no payment thinking something went wrong. Good to have it spelled out that the waiting week is standard for every claim regardless of how it was filed.

0 coins

Something worth flagging for anyone reading this later - there's a myth floating around that if your employer paid for your overtime hours they can't claim misconduct. That's not how EDD sees it. The employer paying you for the time worked is separate from whether they had a policy you violated repeatedly. EDD is looking at the conduct question independent of whether you got the paycheck.

0 coins

The paycheck-misconduct distinction is a real point of confusion. Payment for time worked is about wage law, not about whether the conduct that led to termination qualifies as misconduct under EDD's standard.

0 coins

Heard this one come up before where someone thought being paid the overtime wage meant EDD had to find in their favor. The two things are separate processes entirely.

0 coins

If the determination comes back as a denial, the Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) comes with the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) right there in the same envelope. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice, not from when you receive it, to submit the appeal. Mail matters for that deadline - cut it close and you're asking for trouble.

0 coins

The mailing date vs. receipt date distinction is a real practical issue. Mail that takes a few days to arrive eats into that 30-day window, so the moment the envelope shows up, look at the date on the notice itself.

0 coins

Worth keeping the envelope too in case there's ever a question about when it was mailed. The postmark is evidence if the deadline becomes a dispute.

0 coins

If someone did miss the 30-day window is there anything they can do or is it completely over at that point?

0 coins

A late appeal needs a reason for missing the deadline - EDD and CUIAB can consider it but they don't have to. If you miss it, appeal anyway and explain why, it's worth trying.

0 coins

Direct deposit is worth setting up in myEDD if you haven't already - payments land in your account and UI Online updates the payment information daily. The automated line at 1-866-333-4606 also gives payment status 24 hours a day if you'd rather check by phone than log in.

0 coins

Can you switch to direct deposit mid-claim or does it have to be set up when you first apply?

0 coins

Payment method can be changed in myEDD at any point during the claim, it's not locked in from the application. Payments default to the Money Network prepaid card unless you change it.

0 coins

The Money Network card comes in the mail and takes a few days to arrive, so if you're right at the start of a claim and direct deposit isn't set up yet the card is what you'll get for the first payment.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure