Can EDD send overpayment notice if you quit for covid reasons?
So I'm dealing with something stressful and could really use some input from people who've been through similar situations. I quit my job back during the height of the pandemic because my employer refused to put any safety protocols in place and I had underlying health conditions that made the risk genuinely dangerous. I collected unemployment for several months after that and everything seemed fine — I got my weekly benefits, I certified every two weeks, no issues flagged at the time. Now, out of nowhere, I got a Notice of Overpayment in the mail saying I owe back a pretty significant chunk of benefits. The notice doesn't say much about why — just that I was paid benefits I supposedly wasn't entitled to. My question is whether EDD can actually come back and do this after so long, and whether the reason I quit (health and safety concerns related to covid) could have any bearing on whether I actually qualified in the first place. I never hid anything when I applied. I told them why I quit. Am I stuck repaying this or is there an appeal process?
75 comments

Hugh Intensity
Got the same kind of notice two months ago and my first instinct was to ignore it, which was a terrible idea. The appeal deadline is 30 calendar days from the mailing date printed on the notice — not from when you got it in the mail. I found that out the hard way when I almost let it slip by. Pull out that notice right now and look at the date at the top. If you're within 30 days you can still appeal it in writing using the DE 1000M form or just a letter, mailed to the address on the notice itself.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorChecked the notice just now and I'm at day 18, so I still have time. What do I actually write in the appeal? Do I need to explain why I quit all over again?
0 coins
Effie Alexander
Appeal letters don't need to be fancy — just say you disagree with the overpayment determination, state your reason (you reported everything accurately when you certified), and ask for a hearing. The administrative law judge at the CUIAB hears it, not EDD itself, which is actually good.
0 coins
Hugh Intensity
Also keep certifying while the appeal is active. EDD can only pay back weeks that were actually certified, so don't let that lapse thinking the appeal pauses everything.
0 coins
Melissa Lin
DE 429Z on my claim showed $390 a week and I had a question about whether a lump-sum severance from a previous employer was eating into that. Called a live agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it basically sits on hold with EDD so you end up with an agent on the line without spending hours redialing. There's a video about reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see it in action. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed which weeks were showing as pending and why a wage entry was flagged. Turned out it was a data entry mismatch, not actual fraud, so they noted my file and told me to watch for the corrected notice.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorMine isn't a severance situation but the idea of actually getting someone on the phone is appealing. Did the agent give any indication about how long a resolution takes once they note your file?
0 coins
Melissa Lin
Agent said to watch for mail within a few weeks but couldn't give a firm date — EDD decides on its own timeline. What helped was knowing exactly which issue was flagged so I wasn't just waiting blind.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
Lump-sum severance is worth knowing about actually — EDD's own guidance says severance paid under a company plan isn't counted as wages for UI purposes, so it usually doesn't reduce your weekly amount. But you still report it when you certify and EDD makes the final call.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
Whether EDD can send that notice depends on whether the overpayment is fraud or non-fraud. Here's what I'd look at first if I were you: does the notice say anything about false statements or intentional misrepresentation? If not, it's likely a non-fraud overpayment. Non-fraud still has to be repaid in most cases, but there's something called a waiver — Form DE 1446UI — that you can apply for if repaying it would be a real financial hardship and the overpayment wasn't your fault. No guarantees on the waiver, but it's worth asking about alongside your appeal.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorThe notice doesn't use the word fraud anywhere, which is at least slightly reassuring. It just says benefits were paid for weeks I wasn't eligible. My question is what 'wasn't eligible' even means — I thought I qualified because I quit for health and safety reasons.
0 coins
Romeo Quest
EDD's eligibility rules say that if you quit, you need to show a good reason. Health and safety concerns during covid could absolutely count, but EDD makes that call after a phone interview where both you and your employer give their account. If a phone interview happened and EDD ruled against you later, the overpayment notice would follow from that ruling.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
Exactly right. And if EDD ruled against you, you should have gotten a Notice of Determination before this overpayment notice. Did you get one of those at any point? That would explain what their finding was.
0 coins
Romeo Quest
Something specific to check: did EDD ever schedule a phone interview with you after you filed? The interview notice is a form called the DE 4800 and the time is on that form and also shows up on your UI Online homepage. If the interview happened and you weren't there, EDD decides based only on the information it has, which often goes against the claimant. That could be the source of this overpayment — not anything you did wrong in certifying.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorI honestly don't remember getting that form. Is there a way to check in UI Online whether an interview happened without me?
0 coins
Romeo Quest
UI Online's Claim History section shows what's been processed. You won't see the DE 4800 there but you can see if there are weeks flagged as Pending or if a determination was entered. If you see a gap where payments stopped or changed, that's roughly when the interview would have been scheduled.
0 coins
Val Rossi
If the interview was missed, you should phone EDD the same day you find out — well, in your case as soon as possible since it already happened. Explain that you didn't receive or weren't aware of the notice. That doesn't fix the overpayment automatically but it creates a record.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Quit reasons and covid — this came up a lot during that period. EDD's standard is whether you had a 'good reason' to quit, and the bar for that includes genuine health and safety concerns. The problem is proving it now, after the fact. What documentation do you have from back then? Anything showing your employer refused accommodations, or medical records showing your underlying conditions? That kind of evidence is what makes the difference at an appeal hearing in front of a CUIAB administrative law judge.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorI have emails from my employer declining my request to work remotely and a letter from my doctor at the time about my health conditions. Would those be enough?
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Those are genuinely useful — the employer email shows the refusal, the doctor's letter establishes the medical basis. Bring both to the hearing. The judge takes testimony under oath and you're allowed to present documents. You can represent yourself or have anyone help you, including a union rep or an attorney.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
Just want to add — the CUIAB hearing is separate from the initial EDD review. EDD reviews the appeal first, then sends it to the Office of Appeals. The hearing notice comes by mail at least 10 days before the actual date so you'll have time to prepare.
0 coins
Caden Turner
Wait, is the question about whether they CAN send the notice, like legally, or about whether the overpayment is valid? Because EDD can send a notice basically whenever they determine there's a discrepancy, there's no hard cutoff I know of. The question of whether you actually owe it is what the appeal is for.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorBoth honestly — I was surprised to get it at all after so long with no issues flagged. But yeah the main concern is whether I'll actually have to repay.
0 coins
Caden Turner
Appealing makes sense then. Worst case they uphold it and you still owe — but if you have documentation from the time you quit, you've got a real argument to make.
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
Had a non-fraud overpayment notice for $1,850 on my claim last year. Filed the appeal form DE 1000M within the window and also submitted the DE 1446UI waiver application at the same time. EDD reviewed it, then it went to a CUIAB hearing. The judge looked at my certifications and my employer response and found in my favor — the overpayment was wiped. It took a few months but it resolved. Document everything and don't skip the appeal.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorReally glad to hear it can actually resolve in the claimant's favor. Did you have an attorney or did you go in alone?
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
Went in alone but brought a folder with every document organized by week — pay records, the certification printouts, the employer's initial response to EDD. Organization mattered more than legal training, honestly.
0 coins
Harmony Love
The waiver and the appeal are two separate processes though right? I always thought you had to pick one or the other.
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
You can do both at the same time — appeal the finding and also request the waiver. If the appeal succeeds the waiver becomes moot. If the appeal fails but the waiver is approved, you still might not have to repay. Doing both keeps your options open.
0 coins
Rudy Cenizo
NOBODY explains this clearly but there's a difference between the notice saying you weren't eligible to begin with versus saying you were overpaid because of a calculation error. The first one is about the quit reason — EDD decided after reviewing everything that your quit didn't qualify. The second is usually an administrative mistake. Which does your notice say?
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorMine says something about 'not meeting eligibility requirements for the weeks claimed' — sounds like it's the first kind, about whether my quit was valid.
0 coins
Rudy Cenizo
Then the appeal is the right move and the documentation about why you quit is directly relevant. The administrative law judge looks at whether EDD's eligibility finding was correct, which puts your employer emails and medical records right at the center of the hearing.
0 coins
Natalie Khan
Weeks on my claim were showing Pending in Claim History with no explanation and I'd been trying to reach EDD for days with no luck getting through. Ended up using Claimyr — their site is claimyr.com — and got a live agent on the phone who told me one specific week was flagged because my part-time wages for that week hadn't posted correctly. I reported the fix through the Report Wages section in UI Online like the agent suggested and the pending cleared in a few days.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorHow did you find out that reporting through UI Online would fix it? Did the agent walk you through the steps?
0 coins
Natalie Khan
Agent explained that Report Wages in UI Online is for correcting wage info before you certify — if a week is already certified and something is wrong you have to contact EDD directly. My situation was a pre-certification fix so it worked. For a post-certification issue you'd have to message through your UI Online account or call.
0 coins
Daryl Bright
One correction — Report Wages in UI Online only works out a week's wages before certifying. It doesn't correct weeks that are already certified. If something was wrong after certification you'd need to contact EDD through a UI Online message or phone. Good that in your case it was pre-certification.
0 coins
Val Rossi
Fraud versus non-fraud matters a lot for what you owe beyond the principal amount. Non-fraud overpayment means repay what was paid, no extra penalty. Fraud means a 30 percent penalty on top, and can mean a false statement disqualification of anywhere from 2 to 23 weeks on future claims. If your notice doesn't mention false statements, you're almost certainly in the non-fraud bucket, which is still stressful but significantly less severe.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorThe notice only mentions 'overpayment' and 'ineligibility' — no mention of fraud or false statements. So that's the non-fraud type?
0 coins
Val Rossi
Sounds like it, yes. That means your exposure is limited to the principal amount. The waiver and appeal paths are both available to you and you haven't done anything that triggers the fraud penalties.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
Worth saving that notice too even after this resolves — EDD can collect non-fraud overpayments from future unemployment or disability benefits, or even from state tax refunds. Having the full paper trail of your appeal and any waiver approval protects you if something shows up later.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
Has anyone dealt with the situation where EDD sent a Notice of Determination and then an overpayment notice pretty close together? I got both within a few weeks of each other and wasn't sure if I needed to appeal both or just one.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
Appeal deadlines run separately for each notice from the mailing date on that notice. If EDD mailed both notices with different dates, you have 30 days from each of those dates. Appeal both if you disagree with both — especially the determination, since that's the underlying finding the overpayment follows from.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
Okay so if I win the appeal on the determination, does the overpayment automatically go away too?
0 coins
Effie Alexander
If the administrative law judge finds you were actually eligible for those weeks, the overpayment should fall away because the basis for it is gone. But it's cleaner to appeal both explicitly so there's no ambiguity in the record.
0 coins
Harmony Love
Something I keep seeing people mess up — the appeal hearing and the phone interview are completely different things. The phone interview with EDD is what happens before they make the eligibility determination. The hearing is what happens at the CUIAB after EDD makes a ruling and you disagree. I've seen people miss the phone interview thinking they'd just 'explain everything at the hearing' and then walk into the hearing without their explanation already on record.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorThat's actually useful context — in my case the initial determination has already been made since I have the overpayment notice. So I'm past the phone interview stage at this point?
0 coins
Harmony Love
Right, the determination is already in and you're in the appeal phase now. The hearing is where you make your case to the CUIAB judge. Any documentation you have about why you quit goes to the judge there, not back to EDD.
0 coins
Romeo Quest
Though if there's any chance EDD didn't actually conduct a phone interview at all before issuing the determination, that itself is a point to raise at the hearing — the finding may be based on incomplete information if only one side was heard.
0 coins
Sienna Gomez
CalFresh is worth looking into while you're sorting this out if money is tight. Someone on unemployment benefits can still qualify as long as income stays within the limits, and unemployment counts as proof of income. Applications go through BenefitsCal, by phone at 1-877-847-3663, or at a county office. The county handles that separately from EDD so a pending overpayment notice doesn't disqualify you automatically.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorHadn't even thought about CalFresh — that's actually helpful. Is Medi-Cal in the same situation, applied through the same place?
0 coins
Sienna Gomez
BenefitsCal handles Medi-Cal applications too. Covered California is another option for health coverage while unemployed. The overpayment situation with EDD is a separate lane from either of those.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
Penalty weeks and false statement disqualifications came up on my claim — EDD flagged an issue from a certification period where my income reporting was off. The claim went into a weird status and I couldn't tell from UI Online what specifically was wrong. Used Claimyr to get through to an agent at EDD and asked what the specific flag was. Agent confirmed it was a reporting mismatch on one week's wages, not a fraud finding, and told me the corrected amount I'd need to have on file. Knowing the exact issue meant I could address it directly instead of guessing.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorHow specific was the agent about what documentation they needed to correct it?
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
Pretty specific actually — they said a pay stub for that week showing gross wages, submitted through a UI Online message to match it to my account. Got a response in about a week confirming it was resolved.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
Reporting mismatches usually mean the amount you certified doesn't match what an employer reported to EDD. It's one of the more common triggers for a non-fraud overpayment, and usually fixable with documentation.
0 coins
Daryl Bright
What counts as a 'good reason' to quit is something EDD decides after the interview — there's no published checklist. I know health and safety is on the list of things they consider, but whether a specific situation clears the bar is a judgment call EDD makes case by case. At the hearing stage the administrative law judge does the same thing. Presenting the strongest possible picture of why you quit — medical documentation, employer communications — is the best path.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorThat's how I'm approaching it. I have the emails and the doctor's letter and I'm going to lay out the timeline as clearly as possible.
0 coins
Daryl Bright
Chronological timeline is a good idea — something like: date of diagnosis or doctor visit, date of request to employer, date of refusal, date of quit, date of application. The judge can follow the logic of your decision.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
EDD can collect non-fraud overpayments from future unemployment benefits, disability benefits, state tax refunds, state lottery winnings, and other state money. They can also record a lien or pursue a court judgment. That's the enforcement side if someone just ignores the notice. The appeal is the right move — but if the appeal doesn't go your way and there's no waiver either, those are the collection methods they can use.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorCan they garnish wages? That's what I'm most worried about.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
EDD's own pages don't say they garnish wages — their listed collection methods are future state benefit offsets, tax refunds, state lottery, liens, and court judgments. Wage garnishment isn't something they publish as a standard method.
0 coins
Caden Turner
A lien or court judgment could eventually lead somewhere in that direction depending on how collections proceed, but that's a downstream scenario if you've already lost an appeal and ignored the judgment. Appealing now is by far the smarter path.
0 coins
Ahooker-Equator
Paycheck from a part-time gig I took while certifying wasn't showing up correctly in Claim History and I kept seeing one week stuck as Pending. Got through to EDD using Claimyr — it held the phone queue for me and I got to talk to an agent. Asked specifically about that week and the agent confirmed the wages I reported matched what my employer filed, so the hold was actually from an identity verification step I had missed. Agent told me to complete verification through ID.me, which I did that day.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorID.me step — is that something that can hold up multiple weeks or just one?
0 coins
Ahooker-Equator
In my case it was flagging several weeks at once. Once I completed it through ID.me the account updated and the pending weeks moved along. The agent said identity holds affect the whole claim, not just individual weeks.
0 coins
Harmony Love
ID.me identity verification is something EDD flags early on, usually right after you apply. If it got missed it can hold up everything. Good that the agent caught it — that's a fixable problem unlike an eligibility determination.
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
Had a friend tell me EDD can't come after old claims because of some kind of time limit and I want to know if that's actually true before I tell anyone else that.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
EDD's published guidance doesn't name a fixed statute of limitations for overpayment recovery in everyday terms. The overpayment notice process and collection methods they describe don't mention a cutoff. It's not safe to assume there's a limit — if EDD sent the notice, treating it as a valid claim and responding with an appeal is the responsible move.
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
Okay yeah I'll stop saying that then. Good to know before I gave someone the wrong information.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
Benefits are taxable at the federal level but not for California state income tax. If this overpayment gets resolved in your favor after you've already filed a tax return that included those benefits, you'd want to track the documentation in case of an amendment. If EDD rules you weren't eligible, the question of whether income you received but have to repay affects your tax situation is one for a tax professional — EDD's pages don't give guidance on that.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorI hadn't thought about the tax angle at all. I did include the benefits on my federal return at the time. So depending on how this resolves there could be a tax implication?
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
Possibly, yes. EDD issues a Form 1099G each January and it's available in UI Online under Payments. But the specifics of what happens to past filings if the overpayment ruling changes are outside what I can say with certainty — worth asking a tax professional if the appeal resolves one way or the other.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Last thing worth noting for the appeal hearing: testimony is taken under oath. You can bring a union rep, an attorney, or any other representative. You don't have to pay for a lawyer — plenty of people represent themselves successfully. But if the amount in dispute is large enough that it's worth the cost, some employment attorneys take unemployment appeal cases. The CUIAB sends the hearing notice by mail at least 10 days ahead so you'll have time to decide how you want to handle representation.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
AuthorThe amount is several thousand dollars so I'm seriously considering at least a consultation with an attorney. Good to know I have the option.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
A consultation at minimum is worth it for that dollar amount. Some attorneys offer free initial consultations for unemployment appeals, especially if the case involves a documented quit reason with supporting evidence like you have.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
CUIAB hearings run differently from what most people picture as a courtroom. It's usually just you, potentially your representative, the judge, and a recording device. Witnesses can be called. It's formal in that testimony is under oath but it's not dramatic — judges are generally focused on the specific eligibility question.
0 coins