Backpay after benefit year ended reapplied lower weekly benefit amount - what happened to my missing weeks?
Okay so I need someone to help me make sense of what just happened with my claim. I got laid off from my warehouse job back in spring and filed immediately. My weekly benefit amount on the award notice was $387 and things were going okay until I had some adjudication issues that held up about 9 weeks of payments. I kept certifying the whole time like people told me to, which I did. Then my benefit year ended before EDD ever paid those 9 pending weeks. I went ahead and reopened a new claim like UI Online told me to, and my new weekly benefit amount came back at $294 because my wages during the base period for the new claim are lower - I was out of work most of that period obviously. So now I have two separate situations and I don't know if EDD is going to pay me the old rate for those 9 backed-up weeks from my first claim, or if everything just resets to the lower $294 going forward. Those 9 weeks were certified under the old claim. Does the backpay from the first claim still pay out at $387, or does reapplying somehow change that? And does anyone know what happens to the maximum benefit amount I hadn't used up on the first claim - does that just disappear when the year ends?
76 comments

Zoe Papanikolaou
Similar situation hit me earlier this year - my first claim had about five weeks stuck in pending when the benefit year rolled over and I ended up filing a new one with a lower amount too. Getting through to EDD to sort out what was happening with those old weeks felt impossible, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and actually got to speak with an EDD agent. The agent pulled up my first claim and confirmed those pending weeks were still tied to the original claim and would pay at the original weekly amount once the issue holding them cleared - the new claim's lower rate had nothing to do with them. There's a video on reaching a live person at EDD by phone at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what that looks like. What I had to ask about was whether my pending weeks would still be processed, and the agent said the weeks certified under the first claim pay out under the first claim's terms as long as the eligibility issue gets resolved.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorThis is exactly the answer I needed to hear, honestly. So the 9 weeks I certified during my first benefit year should still come through at $387 even though I've now got a new active claim running at $294? That's a huge difference in what I'm owed.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
EDD agent confirmed the same thing on my end when I had a similar overlap - the two claims run completely separately. The old weeks don't get recalculated just because you filed again.
0 coins
Mei Lin
What was the adjudication issue that held your weeks up if you don't mind me asking? Mine have been pending for six weeks and I still have no idea what's being decided.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Wait, I'm confused about something - when you say you 'reopened' a claim, did you file a brand new application or did you do something else in UI Online? I thought if your year ended you were just done and had to start completely over from scratch.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorUI Online prompted me to reopen and I went through what felt like a full application again - entered my work history, the reason I'm still unemployed, all of that. Got a new DE 429Z with the lower amount. So I think it was technically a new claim but the system called it reopening.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
You can file a completely new claim once the benefit year on the old one ends, yeah. The 52 weeks runs from when you first filed, not from when you last got paid. So the old one closes and you start fresh with whatever wages are in your new base period.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
The base period shifts when you file later, which is why the weekly amount changed - your wages during the time you were actually out of work are now part of what EDD looks at. That's not a mistake or a penalty, it's just how the calendar lines up.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
Those 9 weeks that are still pending - do you know why they were held up in the first place? Because if it was an eligibility question that never got resolved, the benefit year ending might not automatically fix it. EDD still has to make a decision on whatever was open.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorThere was a phone interview scheduled and I did it, but after that the weeks just sat in pending for months. I never got a Notice of Determination saying I was denied, they just stayed pending. So I assumed EDD was still processing.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
If you did the interview and never got a denial notice, that's actually a decent sign - it usually means EDD didn't disqualify you, just that the payment processing is backed up. Keep an eye on your Claim History in UI Online for those weeks to flip from Pending.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
Same thing happened to me - did the interview, nothing moved for three months, then one day all the pending weeks posted at once. No letter, no explanation, they just paid out.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
The maximum benefit amount question is a good one that I got burned by. My first claim had maybe $800 left in it when the benefit year closed and I figured EDD would just apply that to the new claim somehow. Nope. Whatever was left in the old claim's maximum when the year ends is gone. The new claim starts completely fresh with its own maximum based on the new wages.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorThat's what I was afraid of. So the unused balance from my first claim just disappears and the new claim's max is calculated totally separately?
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
Exactly. The 26-week maximum and the total dollar cap are specific to each claim and don't carry over. It's one of those things EDD really doesn't explain anywhere obvious.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
Is there any way to appeal that or get EDD to honor the old balance? Asking because I'm about six weeks from my benefit year ending and still have a lot of balance left.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
Appealing the balance cutoff isn't really a thing - the benefit year end date is set when you file and can't be extended just because you had unused funds. What you CAN appeal is a denial of specific weeks, if EDD issued a Notice of Determination saying you weren't eligible for certain weeks during the year.
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
Nine weeks of backpay at the old rate is real money. At $387 that's over $3,400 sitting in limbo. Have you been able to get anyone at EDD on the phone to ask directly what the status is on those weeks, or has it just been UI Online and waiting?
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorMostly just UI Online and refreshing Claim History obsessively. The phone line is brutal - I've called at 8am and been told the volume is too high and to try again. That's part of why I posted here, trying to figure out if I should just keep waiting or if I need to push harder.
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
Push harder. With that many weeks and that much money at stake, waiting passively is a risk. EDD can and does sometimes let things age out without paying if nobody follows up.
0 coins
Ava Garcia
The 8am thing is real, the line fills up fast. I've had better luck calling right before lunch sometimes but honestly it's unpredictable.
0 coins
StarSailor}
Something I went through that might be relevant - I had a pending week from an old claim that showed up in my Claim History even after I filed a new claim. I could actually see both claims in UI Online at the same time. Can you see your old claim and the pending weeks still in there, or did everything disappear when you filed the new one?
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorI can still see the old claim in Claim History and the 9 weeks are still showing as Pending there. The new claim shows up separately. So it doesn't look like anything got erased, which I guess is reassuring.
0 coins
StarSailor}
That's a good sign. As long as those weeks are visible and showing Pending rather than any kind of denial status, there's still a path to getting paid for them.
0 coins
Miguel Silva
Both claims showing separately is normal. EDD tracks them independently - the pending weeks on the old one don't get absorbed into the new claim, they stay where they were filed.
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
Okay can I jump in with a dumb question - when you certified for those 9 weeks during the first benefit year, were you certifying that you were able and available for work each week? Because if you weren't available one of those weeks for whatever reason, EDD might be holding them for that reason and not telling you exactly why.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorYes, every week I certified I was available and looking for work. I didn't work any of those weeks so there were no wages to report either. The weeks should be clean from my end.
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
Good. I ask because I had three weeks held up and when I finally talked to someone at EDD it turned out I had accidentally answered a certification question in a way that flagged something. Wasn't intentional but it still caused a delay.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
This happened to me too - one mis-tap on the phone app and suddenly a week is in pending hell for two months. EDD's certification questions are weirdly easy to accidentally misanswer.
0 coins
Yara Nassar
The adjudication on those old weeks being unresolved is what I'd focus on. When my claim had weeks stuck after a phone interview, the agent I reached through Claimyr looked up my file and found there was a secondary document request EDD had sent that I never received - it had gone to an old address. Once I resubmitted what they asked for through a UI Online message, the weeks cleared within a few weeks. Worth having someone check whether there's anything open on those old weeks beyond just 'pending.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorA document request I never received - that's a real possibility. My address is current in myEDD but I've had EDD mail go missing before. Can you send documents through the UI Online message system or does it have to be faxed?
0 coins
Yara Nassar
For general correspondence and responding to requests, the UI Online message system works. For anything formal like an appeal, the notice will tell you where to send it. The agent I spoke with told me to respond through UI Online for what I needed.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
I had no idea you could send documents through UI Online messages. I've been faxing everything which is a whole ordeal.
0 coins
Mei Lin
Nobody told me this when I first filed but the CalJOBS registration can hold things up too if EDD flagged that it wasn't done. Did EDD send you a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work? Because if that was part of your original claim and you registered late or not at all, that could be one of the pending week holds.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorI did register in CalJOBS - I remember doing it because I was worried about exactly that. But I might have done it late. The notice said 21 days and I think I did it around day 25.
0 coins
Mei Lin
Late CalJOBS registration can flag weeks for review, so that could genuinely be part of what's holding those 9 weeks. When you eventually get to talk to EDD, that's worth bringing up specifically.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
The 21 days on the DE 8405 is a real deadline and EDD does track it. Not saying it definitely caused the hold but it's a lead worth following up on with EDD directly.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
Does the new claim's lower weekly amount affect what work search activities you need to do or is that separate from the dollar amount? Asking because I'm about to refile and trying to understand what changes.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
Work search requirements don't change based on your weekly amount - you need to be able and available for work and looking every week regardless of what your payment is.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
Got it, makes sense. I was wondering if lower benefit meant less required somehow but that logic doesn't really hold up.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
The lower weekly amount on the new claim made me think about whether the alternate base period ever helps in a situation like this. My first claim had me at $312 a week and when I refiled the new one came back at $241 because I'd been out of work. I tried calling EDD about it forever and eventually got an agent using Claimyr - asked specifically whether my new claim was using the standard or alternate base period, and the agent confirmed it was already on the alternate base period because the standard one didn't produce a valid claim. So in your case if you're wondering whether switching base periods would raise the new $294, an agent can confirm which one EDD is already using.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorI hadn't even thought about asking which base period they used. If the new claim is already on the alternate, then $294 is probably just the ceiling given my work history during that window.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
That's essentially what the agent told me too - once EDD moves to the alternate base period automatically, there's no higher-earning period left to calculate from. The amount is what it is based on your actual wages in that window.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Wait, EDD switches the base period automatically? I thought you had to request it.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
The automatic alternate base period thing is worth clearing up because I got this wrong on my first claim. EDD switches to the alternate base period on its own, but only when the standard base period doesn't get you to a valid claim at all - not just to get a higher weekly amount. If you already have a valid claim under the standard period, EDD won't switch to alternate just because it might pay more. The alternate is a floor, not a calculator.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Okay so if the original poster already has a valid new claim at $294, EDD isn't going to swap to alternate to try to get the number up?
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
Right, the alternate only kicks in when the standard period would leave the claimant with nothing. If you're already getting $294 it means the standard period worked - there were enough wages to qualify. The alternate base period isn't used to try to increase a weekly amount that's already calculated.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
This is one of those things that trips people up constantly. EDD's site explains it but it's buried.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
Has anyone gotten backpay at the old rate after a benefit year ended and a new claim was already paying out at a lower rate? The original poster's situation is specific enough that I want to hear from people who actually went through both claims paying at the same time.
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
The five weeks from my old claim paid out at the old rate while my new claim was already running. They showed up as separate payments in UI Online under the old claim. It was a little confusing to see two different payment amounts but EDD processed them correctly.
0 coins
StarSailor}
Same experience here - the old weeks posted under the old claim at the old amount. It looked weird in Payments because the numbers were different from what I was expecting, but it was correct.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
That's actually really helpful. Good to know the system can handle both running at once without mixing up the rates.
0 coins
Ava Garcia
The thing that gets me about EDD is that 9 weeks of pending with no Notice of Determination and no explanation is apparently just normal. Like they can sit on your money indefinitely and you're supposed to just keep checking UI Online forever.
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
It's genuinely not okay and I get the frustration. The lack of communication about why something is pending is one of EDD's most consistent failures.
0 coins
Ava Garcia
And then they wonder why people get panicked and do things like certify incorrectly trying to 'fix' something they don't understand.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
I did exactly that - tried to 'uncertify' by re-answering questions differently and just made the whole thing worse. EDD does not make it easy to understand what's actually blocking your payment.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
If those 9 weeks end up getting denied after all this time, do you know if you can appeal them even though the benefit year has already closed? Or does the year closing end your appeal rights too?
0 coins
Miguel Silva
Appeal rights are based on when EDD mails you a Notice of Determination, not on when your benefit year closes. If EDD eventually sends you a denial notice for those weeks, the 30-day appeal window starts from the mailing date on that notice - even if the benefit year is long over. The benefit year end date doesn't take away your right to appeal a specific week's denial.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
That's a relief. I was worried that if EDD dragged it out past the benefit year they could use that as a way to just not pay without you being able to fight it.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorGood to know I can appeal individual weeks even now. If a denial notice shows up I'll have that in mind - 30 days from the mailing date on the DE 1080CZ.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
Went through almost this exact situation last year - two claims open with different weekly amounts, old pending weeks from before. The one thing I wish someone had told me is to keep certifying on the new claim while waiting for the old weeks to resolve. EDD can only pay certified weeks, so stopping certifications on the new claim while waiting for old money would just dig a deeper hole.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorI am still certifying on the new claim every two weeks, yes. I haven't stopped. Good reminder though because I honestly wondered if I should pause the new one somehow until the old situation clarified.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
Don't pause it - keep certifying and let EDD sort out the two claim balances on its end. Stopping certifications is the one thing you have direct control over and it's the one thing that will definitely delay money.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
Certifying while waiting for a resolution seems obvious in hindsight but I could see someone thinking they should wait until everything is sorted. Glad this came up.
0 coins
Amina Toure
My benefit year closed while I had four weeks pending at $341 a week - an employer dispute that had dragged on. EDD's phone line was not helping me and I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr about what the status was on those four weeks. The agent told me the employer had finally responded to EDD's inquiry and my weeks were cleared for payment. They actually posted two days later at the full $341 each. If you haven't been able to get anyone live at EDD to tell you what's specifically holding up your old weeks, that's the step I'd take next.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorThe employer dispute angle is something I hadn't thought about - my layoff was straightforward but I don't know for sure what my former employer told EDD. That could be part of what's dragging.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Employer response is one of the more common reasons weeks sit in pending without you knowing why. EDD waits for the employer's side before deciding, and sometimes employers drag their feet responding to EDD's inquiry.
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
And you have no way to see in UI Online whether EDD is waiting on the employer - it just shows Pending with no detail. That opacity is a real problem.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
Before I figured out what 'base period' meant I spent two weeks thinking EDD had made a math error on my new claim's weekly amount. Went back and forth with their online message system three times. Turned out EDD was calculating from a completely different set of quarters than I expected because I was looking at my most recent pay stubs, not the base period quarters. If $294 feels wrong compared to what you were earning, it might just be the timing of which quarters are included.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorThat tracks - my most recent quarters before the new claim are the ones where I was mostly unemployed, so EDD is working with lower wages in those quarters than what I was earning before the original layoff.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
Exactly. And the alternate base period wouldn't help in your case because those more recent quarters are the low-wage ones anyway. The timing just puts you in an unfortunate spot with both options.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
This is a really common source of confusion on refiling. People expect the new weekly amount to match the old one and don't realize the base period shifts by however many months have passed.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
Just to anchor on the original question since we've covered a lot - the backpay for the 9 weeks certified under the first claim absolutely pays at $387 if EDD clears them. The new claim's $294 rate is irrelevant to those weeks. And yes, whatever unused maximum was in the first claim when the year ended is gone. Those are two separate answers to the two separate parts of the original question.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
AuthorThank you for bringing it back to the actual question. So my path forward is: wait or push EDD to resolve the adjudication on those 9 weeks, expect $387 each if they clear, and separately keep certifying the new claim at $294 and treat them as totally unrelated. That's my understanding now.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
That's exactly it. And 'push EDD' means actually getting someone on the phone, not just waiting for UI Online to update - with 9 weeks at stake it's worth making that happen.
0 coins
Miguel Silva
Agreed on the phone call. EDD's online systems tell you what the status is but not why it is what it is. Only a live agent can actually look at your file and tell you what's open.
0 coins