Back to California Paid Family Leave

Jason Brewer

Will I be denied PFL if SDI denied not enough wages? Filing bonding claim next

So I got hit with a denial on my SDI pregnancy disability claim, they said I didn't have enough qualifying wages. Baby is due in about six weeks and I was planning to file PFL bonding after the pregnancy claim wrapped up. Now I'm spiraling because if SDI kicked me out for wages, will I be denied PFL if SDI denied not enough wages too? Like are they even looking at the same thing or is PFL totally separate? My husband keeps saying they're different programs but I'm not sure he actually knows and I'm too stressed to just guess. Anyone been through this?

Fourteen days after my bonding claim went in, SDI Online still said pending and I had no idea if the 41-day window was ticking from the birth or from when I filed. Tried the EDD line four mornings straight and got the same recording every time. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on the PFL line. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my start date was recorded as the day after discharge from the hospital, so I had used nine of the 41 days already. That was the number I needed. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Every morning this week I've tried that line and hit the same wall. Something that promises a live EDD agent sounds like something I'd read on a billboard and ignore. What actually happened when you tried it?

0 coins

Dialed the EDD number myself, same as always, and got that recording. Claimyr handled the hold, my phone rang, and there was an actual EDD agent on the other end. She worked for EDD, not for Claimyr.

0 coins

My intermittent days situation had me completely confused about the DE 2580GF, so I tried Claimyr for my own claim. The agent confirmed EDD had received my Continued Claim Certification and that the two days I hadn't reported yet needed to go on the next one before the payment could process.

0 coins

PFL and State Disability Insurance draw from the same base period wages, so if EDD found your SDI wages too low, PFL will likely land the same way since the threshold is the same $300 in wages with SDI withheld. That said, it is worth confirming your base period quarters with EDD directly, because sometimes wages from a different job or a corrected W-2 can shift the picture.

0 coins

Wait so they're literally looking at the same paystubs? I had two part-time jobs last year. Would both count?

0 coins

Both jobs' wages count as long as SDI was withheld from each, yes. The paycheck stub will say CASDI if it was withheld. Worth adding up what both jobs show before assuming you're out.

0 coins

Mine said CASDI on one job but not the other. Does the one without it just not count at all?

0 coins

Correct, only wages where SDI was actually withheld go toward the PFL wage requirement. If a job didn't withhold it, those wages don't count for this purpose.

0 coins

Got my SDI denial last spring for the same reason and assumed PFL was dead too. Didn't file and lost that bonding window entirely. Wish someone had told me to at least try the PFL claim separately and let EDD decide, because they DO look at both independently even though the wage base is the same.

0 coins

So you should always just file and let them say no rather than assuming?

0 coins

Pretty much. The worst they can do is deny it. At least then you get the denial in writing and can appeal.

0 coins

Does the appeal actually work for a wage denial though? I'd be scared to go through all that and still get nowhere.

0 coins

An appeal is filed with the DE 1000A within 30 days of the denial notice. EDD's site says you can appeal online or by mail. Whether it succeeds depends on the specifics, but at minimum it gets a second look.

0 coins

I'm in almost the exact same situation and I'm panicking. My SDI got denied two weeks ago and I haven't filed PFL yet because I assumed it would be pointless. Is there still time? The baby is four weeks old now.

0 coins

You have 41 days from the first day you wanted PFL bonding to start. If you wanted it to start the day after birth, count from there. Four weeks is 28 days, so you're inside the window, but file soon.

0 coins

The day I wanted it to start would be right after I stopped getting paid by my job. Does that count as the first day of leave?

0 coins

The start date is the first day you stopped working and started leave, not a date you pick later. Whatever day you last worked and then were off, that's what EDD uses to count the 41 days.

0 coins

ok filing tonight then. thank you

0 coins

The SDI denial for wages doesn't automatically carry over to PFL as a denial. EDD processes them as separate claims. That said, the qualifying wage requirement is the same for both, so if SDI looked at your base period and found less than $300 with SDI withheld, PFL will see the same thing. The useful move is to check whether you have any wages in a quarter that maybe weren't included, or if there's a different base period that might work.

0 coins

Is there actually a different base period option? I didn't know that was a thing.

0 coins

There's an alternate base period available in some cases. EDD's site explains it and their calculator can give you a rough sense of which wages they'd count. Worth checking before you assume the PFL claim will go the same way as SDI.

0 coins

didn't know that either. good to know.

0 coins

File the PFL claim. Don't sit on it. If they deny it you'll at least know and can appeal within 30 days. Waiting and guessing doesn't get you anything.

0 coins

Yeah that's what my husband said too. I think I was just scared to get another denial.

0 coins

Understandable. But a denial in writing beats a maybe.

0 coins

Payment method thing tripped me up after my PFL was approved, I had no idea if I had set up direct deposit right because I filed on paper. Spent two full mornings trying the EDD line, got nowhere. Tried Claimyr on a Wednesday and ended up talking to an EDD agent who confirmed they had my bank info and that the first payment had been issued that same week.

0 coins

Wait I've never heard of Claimyr, what is it exactly?

0 coins

It waits out the EDD hold for you and your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's about all there is to it.

0 coins

Oh that's actually really useful. I'd want to ask about why my Notice of Computation amount looks lower than I expected based on my wages last year.

0 coins

I think I read somewhere that if you get denied for not enough wages you can't appeal it, like it's just a hard cutoff. Is that true? Because that's terrifying.

0 coins

That's not right. The denial notice comes with a DE 1000A appeal form and you have 30 days from the date on the notice to file it. The wage requirement is a threshold, but there are cases where wages were miscounted or a quarter was missed, and the appeal is how you flag that.

0 coins

Oh okay, that makes me feel slightly better. I thought once they said no it was just over.

0 coins

Definitely appeal if anything looks off in what wages they counted. Sometimes a reporting error from an employer changes the picture.

0 coins

My bonding claim went in but the receipt number screen timed out before I could write it down. Had no way to check whether Part anything was needed or how to track the claim. I tried the EDD line three days in a row, different times, never got through. Claimyr got me to an agent who looked up my claim by my Social and gave me the receipt number, and confirmed no additional documents were needed for a bonding claim.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself when I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) that I didn't understand. Agent confirmed the denial was for wages and read me the base period quarters they had on file, so I could see which one was short. I appealed within the 30 days.

0 coins

did the appeal actually do anything for you

0 coins

EDD sent a letter asking for wage records from a second employer I'd forgotten to list. I sent the pay stubs and the claim went back into review. Still waiting on that outcome.

0 coins

Same base period. Same wage floor. If one said no, the other probably will too. But probably isn't definitely, so file and let EDD do the math.

0 coins

This is basically where I landed. Filing tonight.

0 coins

Good. Clock's running.

0 coins

my sdi got denied same reason last year and i just assumed pfl was out too so i never filed. found out later i shouldve just tried. dont do what i did

0 coins

Ugh that's exactly what I was about to do. Thank you for saying something.

0 coins

yeah file it. worst case they say no and you appeal

0 coins

To answer the original question directly: PFL and SDI are separate claims and EDD makes a separate decision on each. The wage requirement is the same, so a wages denial on SDI is a strong signal for PFL, but it's not automatic. File the PFL claim, check every W-2 and pay stub for CASDI withholding, and if it gets denied, appeal within 30 days with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Is there a way to check what wages EDD actually has on file for you before they decide?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation they send shows the wages used to calculate your benefit amount. If you haven't gotten one yet, you'd need to contact EDD to find out what quarters they have.

0 coins

Mine never came. The SDI denial came but no Notice of Computation. Is that normal for a denial?

0 coins

If SDI was denied for insufficient wages, there's no benefit amount to compute, so the Notice of Computation may not issue. The denial notice itself should list the base period wages they found, or lack thereof. That's what you'd use to check and potentially appeal.

0 coins

Just file it. EDD decides, not you. Stop guessing.

0 coins

Filing tonight I promise.

0 coins

Something worth double-checking: if any employer deducted SDI from your pay but reported it late or under the wrong quarter, that could have thrown off what EDD sees. A call to EDD or an employer check might catch it.

0 coins

I had a gap between jobs earlier this year. Could that have affected which quarter they look at?

0 coins

The base period quarters are set by when your claim starts, not when the gap happened. But if wages landed in a quarter outside the base period because of timing, they wouldn't count. EDD's site has a calculator that maps your start date to the quarters they'd use.

0 coins

This is a real issue. I had wages that fell just outside my base period because of when I started the job. The alternate base period captured them. Worth looking at.

0 coins

filed pfl after sdi denied me same reason. it also got denied but at least now i know and i appealed both. still waiting

0 coins

Did they give you any timeline on the appeal?

0 coins

no just said theyd mail a decision. been about three weeks.

0 coins

The DE 1000A appeals go to an Administrative Law Judge. EDD doesn't publish a fixed timeline for how long decisions take. The denial notice says what to expect.

0 coins

PFL and SDI share the wage requirement. Denial on one doesn't block filing the other. File, get the decision in writing, appeal if anything's off in what wages they counted.

0 coins

Short and clear. That's the answer.

0 coins

Okay I feel like I actually understand this now. Filing the PFL claim tonight and I'll see what they say.

0 coins

Does the 41-day clock pause at all if you're waiting on a decision from the SDI appeal? Because if SDI takes months and you're waiting to see if that changes anything, you could blow past 41 days on PFL.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline on PFL runs on its own. It doesn't pause for a pending SDI appeal. PFL and SDI are separate clocks. File PFL before 41 days is up regardless of where SDI stands.

0 coins

That's what I figured but good to have it confirmed. The deadlines on these things overlap in confusing ways.

0 coins

EDD does not care that you were waiting on another claim. The 41 days is 41 days. File PFL now and sort out the SDI situation separately.

0 coins

If PFL also gets denied, does that use up any of the eight weeks? Like would I have zero weeks left for bonding even if I appeal and win later?

0 coins

A denial doesn't consume weeks. If you appeal and EDD reverses the decision, the weeks are available within the 12 months from your child's birth or placement. The clock on that window runs regardless, so a long appeal could eat into how many weeks are left, but the denial itself doesn't use them up.

0 coins

Okay so the 12-month window keeps running even during an appeal?

0 coins

Yes. The 12 months from the birth date keeps moving. If the appeal takes long enough that you're outside that window when it's decided, that's a problem. Worth filing and appealing as quickly as possible.

0 coins

This part is what stresses me out the most. Baby is 4 weeks old and I still haven't filed. Filing right now.

0 coins

To the original question about whether the SDI wage denial automatically means PFL denial: technically no, they adjudicate separately. Practically, if the same quarters show the same wages, the outcome is likely the same. But there are edge cases: a corrected employer record, wages that show up under an alternate base period, or a clerical error that undercounted a quarter. Those are worth chasing before accepting a PFL denial as final.

0 coins

The alternate base period point is underrated. A lot of people assume the first base period is the only one and walk away when they don't have to.

0 coins

Exactly. It doesn't apply to everyone but it's worth running your dates through the calculator on EDD's site to see.

0 coins

Nobody told me PFL had no waiting period when I filed. I'd been bracing for a week of nothing like with disability, and then the first payment came faster than I expected. If you do get approved, don't be surprised when it moves quicker than SDI did in that sense.

0 coins

Wait PFL doesn't have a waiting week? I thought all EDD claims had one.

0 coins

SDI has a seven-day waiting period before benefits begin, but PFL has no waiting period. EDD is clear on that. Someone confusing the two is very common.

0 coins

I had no idea they were different on that. I would have waited a week for nothing.

0 coins

Really common mix-up. PFL starts paying from day one of the leave once approved.

0 coins

If you filed SDI and it got denied, the denial notice tells you why. Read that notice carefully before you file PFL, because if there's a correctable error in what wages they counted, fixing it before PFL goes in is smarter than filing twice and appealing twice.

0 coins

The SDI denial notice just said 'insufficient wages in base period' and listed a dollar amount that looked lower than what I earned. Could they have missed a job?

0 coins

Possible. Get your W-2s and pay stubs together and compare what they listed to what you actually earned. If a job is missing, that's your appeal argument.

0 coins

Employer contribution mismatches show up sometimes too. Worth looking at every CASDI line on every pay stub from both jobs across the whole year before you assume the number EDD has is right.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure