Back to California Paid Family Leave

Saleem Vaziri

Paid family leave claim denied typo last day worked — appeal or resubmit?

I filed a PFL bonding claim in SDI Online a couple weeks after my daughter was born and I was pretty nervous the whole time I was filling it out. Got the denial notice in the mail last week, the DE 2514, and I've been going in circles trying to figure out what happened. I'm pretty sure I put the wrong date for my last day worked — I think I typed a date in September when I actually stopped working in October. EDD shows the claim as denied and I honestly don't know if I should appeal using the DE 1000A that came with the notice, or just start a brand new claim. The notice says I have 30 days to appeal. My daughter is almost six weeks old now. Does anyone know which way to go here, typo-related denials specifically? I don't want to lose any of the bonding weeks because I messed up a date.

Direct deposit info on my own bonding claim was showing the wrong account number, so I had EDD's number saved and tried for three mornings before anyone picked up. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) instead and ended up talking to an agent who pulled up my claim and confirmed the payment method on file, then told me how to update it in SDI Online before the first payment went out. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent was clear that the payment method had to be corrected before the next scheduled pay date or it would go to the old account anyway.

0 coins

Honestly that video and site feel like an ad to me. EDD has a phone number, why would you pay someone else to dial it for you?

0 coins

I had the same reaction about six months ago. After my care claim for my mom got a DE 2514 I tried the EDD line myself for two weeks, then gave Claimyr a shot. The agent I reached confirmed the determination on the notice and walked me through what the appeal window was for my specific notice date. That was a real EDD agent, not a middleman.

0 coins

Ok that's actually useful context. I'll probably just try the line myself first but if I keep striking out I might look at it differently.

0 coins

Wait so the agent actually told you what the DE 2514 said and what the appeal deadline was? That's exactly what I need to know for my situation.

0 coins

The appeal route is almost certainly the right move here. The DE 1000A came with your denial notice for a reason, and a typo on the last day worked is a factual error EDD can verify against your employer's records. Filing a whole new claim wouldn't fix the underlying record and could complicate things. Appeal within that 30-day window, explain the correct last day worked, and attach any documentation you have showing when you actually stopped.

0 coins

So I shouldn't start over, just correct it on appeal. That makes more sense than I thought, I was worried a new claim would be cleaner but you're right that the date would be wrong there too.

0 coins

Yep, appeal is the move. New claim with the same wrong-ish history doesn't solve anything and you'd be eating into your 41-day window all over again.

0 coins

Don't file twice. Appeal the denial, state the correct date, done. EDD can look at your work records and see when you actually clocked out for the last time.

0 coins

yeah exactly, filing twice just makes a mess

0 coins

That's reassuring, I keep second-guessing myself on this.

0 coins

Worth knowing about the 30-day appeal window: it runs from the date on the notice, not the day you got it in the mail. So check the date printed on the DE 2514, not the envelope postmark, when you're counting your days.

0 coins

I did not know that. The notice is dated November 3rd and I got it November 7th. So I'm counting from November 3rd?

0 coins

That's how the window is calculated, yes. I'd file the DE 1000A as soon as you have your documentation together just to be safe.

0 coins

Correct on the date. I'd recommend writing the appeal date in the top margin of your copy of the DE 1000A so you have a record of when you submitted it.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke, tried eight mornings in a row when my bonding claim got held up and either got the busy signal or the system hung up on me after ten minutes of hold music. Eventually sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online and that at least got a response in a few days.

0 coins

Request Claim Update is underrated. More reliable than the phone most of the time.

0 coins

yeah i did that too, response was slow but it existed at least

0 coins

I'm in a somewhat similar spot and this thread is helping me think through it. My PFL bonding claim got flagged but not denied yet, still pending at day 11. If mine does come back as a denial, is the DE 1000A the only way to appeal or are there other options? Also does appealing automatically pause the 41-day deadline for the original leave start date?

0 coins

The DE 1000A, online through SDI Online, or by mail are all valid appeal paths. As for the 41-day window, that's tied to when your leave started, not to any appeal. If you're still within 41 days of your leave start date that clock is separate from the appeal clock.

0 coins

Ok so the two clocks run independently. That's actually a little scary, I need to make sure I'm still within 41 days no matter what.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline is in the PFL guide, DE 2530. Worth downloading and reading the section on when to file so you know exactly where you stand.

0 coins

A wrong date on the last day worked is a simple fix on appeal. Bring the correction clearly, state what you put versus what the real date was, keep it brief. EDD's reviewed plenty of these.

0 coins

That's how I'll approach it. Direct correction, real date, documentation attached.

0 coins

Exactly. Don't overthink it.

0 coins

My coworker filed a bonding claim for her second kid and ran into a denial too, though hers was because the proof of relationship document wasn't received in time, not a typo. She ended up appealing and it took a few weeks but she got it sorted. Point being, denials aren't always the end of the road.

0 coins

Proof of relationship timing trips so many people up, they think uploading it in SDI Online is good enough and it still might not reach the right queue in time.

0 coins

Wait, should I not upload my birth certificate through SDI Online? I did that already for my pending claim.

0 coins

Uploading a proof of relationship for a bonding claim in SDI Online is the right way to do it. You're thinking of Part C and Part D on a care claim, those two should never be uploaded, they go by mail or the doctor submits Part D online. Proof of relationship for bonding is uploaded normally.

0 coins

Oh thank goodness, I uploaded the birth certificate so I was worried for a second.

0 coins

Receipt number on my bonding claim wasn't showing in SDI Online for two days after I filed, started to panic that the claim never went through. Tried EDD's line a few times with no luck then gave Claimyr a shot and talked to an agent who confirmed the receipt number was in the system and the claim had been received — just hadn't populated on my screen yet. Anyway that cleared it up fast.

0 coins

Did you have to give the agent anything specific to look up the receipt number, like your SSN or the date you filed?

0 coins

Just my SSN and the date I filed, they found it right away. Have both ready before you get on the line.

0 coins

been trying that line most mornings this week, just rings and drops. good to hear someone actually got through.

0 coins

On the typo question: the appeal form DE 1000A has a section for your statement. Keep it factual. Write the date you entered, write the correct date, and state that the error was a data entry mistake. If you have a final pay stub dated in October or a termination letter, attach a copy.

0 coins

I do have my last pay stub from October. I'll attach that. That's exactly the kind of documentation I wasn't sure I'd need.

0 coins

Pay stub is perfect. Date on it speaks for itself.

0 coins

you got 30 days from that notice date so dont sleep on it. appeal is def the right call here, new claim would just restart everything and youre already on the clock with the 12 months for bonding

0 coins

Yeah I'm treating the 30-day window as urgent. Already printed the DE 1000A.

0 coins

good luck, the appeal form is not that bad once you just start filling it out

0 coins

EDD denies claims for small errors all the time. Appeal, state the right date, attach your pay stub. That's really all there is to it.

0 coins

That's the clearest version of this I've heard. Thank you.

0 coins

My bonding claim was denied initially and I had no idea PFL doesn't have a waiting period like disability does. I thought I had seven unpaid days first and had reported my start date wrong based on that. Appeal fixed it once I explained the actual leave start date.

0 coins

That waiting period mix-up catches so many new parents. Disability has the seven-day wait, PFL has nothing, you're eligible from day one of leave.

0 coins

I literally would have made that same mistake if I hadn't read this thread. I thought PFL had a waiting period too.

0 coins

Yeah EDD's own DE 2530 guide spells it out clearly but most people don't read it before filing. PFL, no waiting period. DI, seven days unpaid at the start.

0 coins

DE 429DF on my care claim came in and the weekly amount looked off to me, couldn't tell if EDD had used the right base period quarter. Spent three days trying the phone with nothing. Claimyr got me to a live agent who read me the weekly benefit amount off my claim and told me which base period quarter they used. Turned out EDD had it right, I'd just miscalculated on my end.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and I'm not sure the amount on mine is right either. I've been meaning to phone but can't get through. Going to try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have the DE 429DF in front of you and your pay stubs from your base period ready. The agent will read off what's on the claim and you can compare it right there.

0 coins

If you've been trying the EDD line and nothing's going through, that tracks with what everyone here says. At least having a plan beats another dropped call.

0 coins

The base period question is worth looking at carefully. EDD uses your highest quarter of wages in the 12-month base period that runs from 5 to 18 months before your claim start. You can estimate on EDD's site with the calculator before your Notice of Computation arrives.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a calculator on EDD's site. I've been guessing at what my weekly amount would be.

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov under the PFL section. Enter your quarterly wages and it gives you a range. The real number is on the DE 429DF when it arrives.

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days of the notice date. Correct date in writing. Pay stub attached. That covers it.

0 coins

Said more clearly than I managed to say it myself in the original post.

0 coins

One thing that helped me when my bonding claim got complicated was logging into SDI Online through myEDD (https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/) and using the Request Claim Update option. It let me put the question in writing and I got a response without having to get through on the phone.

0 coins

I haven't tried the Request Claim Update yet. After I file the appeal I'll use that to follow up if I don't hear anything within a couple weeks.

0 coins

Request Claim Update and the actual appeal are two separate things. Submit the DE 1000A first, then Request Claim Update can be used for any follow-up questions after.

0 coins

Payments were showing as issued in SDI Online but I couldn't tell which weeks were covered or when the next one was coming. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who read off exactly which weeks had been paid and confirmed the date the next payment was scheduled to go out. Made it a lot easier to plan around.

0 coins

The weeks covered piece was unclear on my care claim too. I used Claimyr for that after the proof of relationship document EDD was waiting for finally got matched to my claim. The agent confirmed the doc had been received and the weeks that had opened up after that. Then I went back into SDI Online and the payment history matched what she'd told me.

0 coins

I kept trying the EDD line Tuesday through Friday last week and got the busy signal or the system dropped me every single time. No idea how people actually get through on a regular morning.

0 coins

Honestly this whole thread has me realizing the phone situation is rough for everyone, not just me.

0 coins

Just to close the loop on the original question since we got into a lot of side topics: appeal with the DE 1000A, state the typo, attach the October pay stub. You're within the 30-day window still. Bonding benefits run for up to eight weeks and they have to be used within 12 months of the birth, so once your appeal goes through you'll still have the full eight weeks available.

0 coins

That's the clearest summary of my path forward. DE 1000A, correct the date, attach the stub, appeal within the window. I'll file it this week.

0 coins

Keep a copy of everything you send, with the date you submitted it. If you filed the appeal online through SDI Online, screenshot the confirmation.

0 coins

Already planning to screenshot and print. Thank you all, genuinely.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure