Back to California Paid Family Leave

Zara Shah

PFL overpayment letter bonding instead of SDI postpartum depression — can it be waived?

I had my baby in July and my OB diagnosed me with postpartum depression a few weeks after. I filed for SDI for the postpartum depression, got approved, and then when that claim ended I transitioned to PFL for bonding. EDD paid out both. Now I got an overpayment letter saying I was paid PFL bonding benefits during the same weeks my SDI was active, and they want the money back. I genuinely don't understand how this happened because I thought the two claims were supposed to follow each other, not overlap. The letter mentions I can appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A form. My question is whether this can be waived, or if I even have a shot at appealing it. I didn't intentionally double-dip, I thought EDD had it all set up correctly on their end. Has anyone dealt with a PFL overpayment from overlapping with an SDI claim and gotten it resolved?

Three weeks left on my bonding claim and I had no idea how many of my eight weeks I'd actually used because the SDI Online portal wasn't making it obvious. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and asked them straight. The agent pulled up my claim and told me I had used five of the eight weeks and had three remaining within my 12-month window. That cleared it up faster than anything else I'd tried. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Reads like a paid placement to me. EDD's line is brutal but I'm not handing over my info to some third-party site I've never heard of.

0 coins

I had the exact same reaction, honestly. Then I spent four mornings in a row getting the busy signal and hanging up. Tried it, got an agent, and she told me the DE 2500E had been issued for my bonding claim. That was real EDD, real answer. You can stay skeptical, up to you.

0 coins

Fair enough. If the line keeps eating my calls I'll probably try it.

0 coins

The overlap situation you're describing is actually more common than people realize, especially when a new mother's postpartum disability claim and the PFL bonding claim don't get separated properly by EDD's system. PFL and SDI cannot be paid for the same days, so when they are, EDD issues an overpayment notice. That doesn't mean you did anything wrong intentionally.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

That's what I figured, that it wasn't my mistake. But will they actually waive it or do I have to pay it all back?

0 coins

Appealing within that 30-day window is your best move right now. The DE 1000A is the form, and you write out that the overlap wasn't something you caused or were even aware of. EDD reviews the facts of each case.

0 coins

Sending the appeal in writing with any paperwork you have helps.

0 coins

This happened to my partner after her second baby, the SDI and PFL dates got tangled somehow, overpayment letter showed up, she appealed and explained the timeline. Took a while but anyway, definitely appeal don't just pay it back without asking.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Did she end up getting it resolved? Or did they make her repay the full amount?

0 coins

Partial resolution I think, she had to pay back a smaller amount, the overlap was only like a week or two. I don't know the full details anyway.

0 coins

Not sure if this matters but, I think you have to appeal within 30 days of the letter date, not 30 days from when you got it, right? I'm not 100% sure.

0 coins

The DE 1000A lists the deadline on the notice itself. File as soon as you can either way, don't wait on the exact date question.

0 coins

Don't pay anything before you appeal. File the DE 1000A first, explain the postpartum SDI claim ran into the PFL dates, and let them sort it out. You didn't file both at once on purpose.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Filing the appeal tonight. I want to get it in before I second-guess myself into missing the window.

0 coins

Good move getting it in quickly. Keep a copy of the appeal form and the overpayment notice both.

0 coins

The rule is PFL and SDI don't pay at the same time, they're separate claims and the weeks can't overlap. What probably happened is your SDI end date and PFL start date weren't set right, or EDD processed them in a way that created a gap or overlap. That's worth spelling out in your appeal.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

My OB signed off on the SDI ending and I filed the PFL right after, so I thought the dates were clean. I'll attach all the paperwork showing the timeline.

0 coins

Exact dates on each claim, the SDI end date and the PFL start date, those are the key things to lay out clearly.

0 coins

The DE 1000A has space to explain the basis of the appeal. The instructions say to attach any supporting documents, so your claim dates from SDI Online would help.

0 coins

My client went through almost this exact thing after her baby, she kept getting confused about when one claim ended and the other started. She appealed and EDD adjusted it. Honestly just get that appeal in writing and explain everything clearly.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Knowing someone got through it helps. I keep worrying I'll owe the whole amount no matter what I do.

0 coins

You won't know until you appeal and EDD looks at your dates. Worth doing.

0 coins

Submit the appeal. Explain the SDI postpartum claim, the PFL bonding claim, the dates of each. Keep it simple and factual. That's all you can do from here.

0 coins

This. Don't overthink the wording, just state the facts of when each claim ran.

0 coins

Short and clear tends to work better than a long explanation.

0 coins

The start date on my care claim had me confused for weeks, I wasn't sure if EDD had processed the right date or the wrong one. I ended up having an EDD agent confirm the actual claim start date and how it lined up with the 41-day filing window, and I did that by calling through Claimyr. The agent checked my file and confirmed the start date was recorded correctly. That one call saved me a lot of back and forth with the portal.

0 coins

What did you need to have ready when you called? Like any specific numbers or info?

0 coins

Social security number, the receipt number from SDI Online, and the DE 2514 I'd gotten. Having those ready meant the agent could pull everything up fast.

0 coins

been trying that EDD line most mornings for two weeks, nothing but the busy signal. might just try what you did.

0 coins

edd does this overlapping thing way more than they should, same thing happened to my sister after her baby, she didnt even know she had an overlap until the letter came. appeal it dont just send them money

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Yeah I definitely wasn't aware of any overlap when it was happening, that's going to be a big part of my appeal.

0 coins

tell them exactly that in the de 1000a, that you didnt know and didnt cause it

0 coins

I'm kind of scared about this for my own situation. I'm about to transition from my pregnancy disability to PFL bonding and I really don't want to end up in this situation. Is there anything I should check to make sure the dates don't overlap?

0 coins

Before your SDI ends, verify the exact end date in SDI Online, then file your PFL bonding claim starting the day after. The DE 2501FP that new mothers get makes that transition easier.

0 coins

So I file the DE 2501FP, not the regular PFL form? I didn't even know that form existed.

0 coins

Right, the form for new mothers is the DE 2501FP and EDD mails it to you as your pregnancy disability claim winds down. It needs no extra documents.

0 coins

The 41-day window runs from the bonding start date, not the birth date. Just something to watch when you get that form.

0 coins

Appeal. You have 30 days. Use them.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Letter is dated eight days ago so I need to move.

0 coins

Then move.

0 coins

EDD overlapping two claims is 100% an EDD systems problem and they still send you the overpayment notice like it's your fault. The DE 1000A appeal is the only lever you actually have. File it.

0 coins

EDD sends the notice automatically when it flags an overlap, it doesn't mean they've decided you owe it yet. The appeal is exactly the right step.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

That framing helps, I've been treating the letter like a final verdict. It's not.

0 coins

Looking at the DE 1000A, there's a section for the reason you're disputing the amount. For an overlap between SDI and PFL, I'd list each claim's start and end dates in that section so the numbers are right there for whoever reviews it.

0 coins

That's a clean way to do it. Dates side by side so there's no ambiguity about which weeks are in question.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Pulling up my SDI Online history now to get the exact dates. I want those numbers accurate.

0 coins

Lots of people get this overlap letter and don't appeal because the letter sounds final. It isn't. EDD has to hear your side before anything is determined.

0 coins

yeah the letters from edd always sound like the decision is already made but it usually isnt

0 coins

The appeal form DE 1000A is straightforward, it's one page. Don't let the process feel bigger than it is.

0 coins

Payment method ended up being a whole thing on my bonding claim, the debit card was mailed to an old address and I couldn't figure out how to update it. I ended up speaking with an EDD agent through Claimyr about it, and she confirmed they had the wrong address on file and what I needed to do to get the card reissued. Everything in the portal looked fine so I never would have caught it otherwise.

0 coins

My question is about whether my direct deposit info transferred correctly from my old claim to the new one. Going to try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have your SDI Online receipt number and the last four digits of your bank account number ready. The agent can see the payment method on file right away.

0 coins

Posting because I had a small SDI and PFL overlap issue last year too, different reason but same type of letter. I appealed, wrote one page explaining what happened with my claim dates, and EDD adjusted the amount. The whole thing resolved in about six weeks.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Six weeks feels manageable. I was afraid it would drag on for months.

0 coins

Mine didn't, but every case is different of course. Just keep a copy of everything you send.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone reading this thread: PFL does not have a waiting period, but SDI does have unpaid days at the start. If your dates were off by even a day or two between the SDI ending and the PFL starting, that could explain how the overlap happened without you doing anything wrong.

0 coins

Wait, PFL has no waiting period at all? I thought both programs had the same seven-day unpaid thing at the start.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period, that's correct. Only SDI has unpaid days at the beginning of a claim. Easy thing to get mixed up.

0 coins

Okay that's actually a relief, I thought I was going to lose a week of PFL pay for nothing.

0 coins

For anyone else who lands here through a search: the overpayment appeal goes to the address on the DE 1000A or the overpayment notice itself, not to EDD's general address. The form also has an option to submit online through Ask EDD, but check the notice for which method they want.

0 coins

Good point on the address, that's the kind of detail that gets overlooked when you're stressed about the letter.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Checked my letter and it has a specific address. Sending the DE 1000A there certified mail tomorrow so I have proof it was received.

0 coins

You said in your post you didn't intentionally file both at the same time. Put that in the appeal exactly as you said it here. Plain language works fine on the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Wrote out a draft tonight. It's about half a page, lays out the SDI dates, the PFL dates, and says clearly I had no intention of drawing both at once.

0 coins

Half a page is plenty. Send it.

0 coins

the overlap thing on my claim was just one week but edd still sent the letter. i just appealed and that was months ago, still waiting

0 coins

EDD's timeline on appeal reviews is not exactly speedy. Hope yours moves faster.

0 coins

yeah me too

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days, state the facts clearly, attach documentation of both claim dates. That's the process.

0 coins

Zara Shah

Author

Sent the DE 1000A this morning, certified mail. Receipt number and both claim date ranges included. I'll update when I hear something.

0 coins

Good luck with the review.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure