Back to California Paid Family Leave

Jessica Nolan

PFL overpayment appeal ignored while collections sends notices — what do I do?

I'm losing my mind a little here. I filed a PFL bonding claim after my daughter was born in August and took the full eight weeks. Everything seemed fine until November when I got an overpayment notice saying I owed back several weeks of benefits. I didn't understand why, so I filled out the Appeal Form (DE 1000A) and mailed it in within the 30-day window. That was six weeks ago. Since then I haven't heard a single word about the appeal, but I keep getting collections notices in the mail like the appeal doesn't exist. Can EDD actually send you to collections while an appeal is still pending? Is there something else I'm supposed to do to make the appeal stop the collections process? I called the PFL line a few times and couldn't get through. Really scared about this.

Filing the appeal within 30 days is exactly the right move, and you did that. The appeal and the collections process can run on separate tracks inside EDD, which is frustrating but does happen. The most important thing right now is to get confirmation that your appeal was actually received. If you filed on paper by mail, EDD doesn't always send an acknowledgment quickly. I'd send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online explaining that your appeal is pending and asking about the status.

0 coins

I didn't even think of sending a Request Claim Update. I assumed once I mailed the DE 1000A it was just a waiting game. So I can send that message through SDI Online even though it's about an appeal and not the original claim?

0 coins

You can. Open SDI Online in myEDD, choose your claim, and pick Request Claim Update from the options there. Write that you submitted your DE 1000A on whatever date you sent it and that you're receiving collections notices and want to confirm the appeal is on file.

0 coins

Thank you, doing this tonight.

0 coins

Appeals take time. Six weeks isn't that long unfortunately. Keep every piece of mail you're getting from collections dated and in order. If the appeal gets denied you'll need that paper trail.

0 coins

This. Don't throw anything away. Every envelope, every notice. Date everything when it arrives.

0 coins

I've been keeping them in a folder. Good to know that's the right call.

0 coins

Overpayment notice showed up on my care claim last spring and I had the same panic about whether anything was moving. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the phone line just kept cutting out on me after the first menu. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my leave start date was recorded two days later than I'd filed it, which is why they said I owed for those days. She also confirmed my 41-day window had been met, so the late recording wasn't going to wipe the claim. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about whether having the agent fix the start date also stops the collections side, or is that a separate process?

0 coins

She told me she could note the dispute on my claim but that the actual decision would come by mail in a notice I'd need to read and appeal within 30 days if I disagreed. So the collections notices kept coming until the written decision arrived. I appealed again off that one and it stopped after.

0 coins

I've been dialing that line before eight in the morning since October and it hangs up on me every single time before I even finish the menu. Nice to know there's a way through for some people.

0 coins

Worth pinning down what triggered the overpayment notice in the first place if you haven't already. The DE 2514 — that's the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination — should spell out EDD's reason. If you reported wages from going back to work and the math didn't line up with what EDD had, that's one common reason. If EDD thinks your base period wages were recalculated, that's another. Knowing the stated reason sharpens your appeal argument.

0 coins

The notice says I was paid for days after I returned to full-time work. I did go back two weeks early, but I reported it in SDI Online. I thought reporting it would handle everything automatically.

0 coins

Reporting wages doesn't automatically adjust the payment that's already been issued for those days. EDD issues the payment, then reconciles when they receive your wage report, and that gap is where overpayments get created. Your appeal should center on proving you reported the return-to-work date on time.

0 coins

That reconciliation lag is real. I had the same thing on a care claim and I had no idea it worked that way.

0 coins

EDD's collections arm and EDD's appeals arm genuinely don't talk to each other much. Getting the appeal on record fast and in writing is about all you can do from your side.

0 coins

Sounds like every other government department I've ever dealt with.

0 coins

Unfortunately accurate.

0 coins

You said you reported the return in SDI Online. Do you have a screenshot or a confirmation from that? The timestamp on that report is probably your strongest piece of evidence for the appeal.

0 coins

I don't have a screenshot but SDI Online might still show it in my claim history. I'm going to log in and look right now.

0 coins

Check the payment history section on your claim. If the report is in there with a date, write that date down and reference it specifically in your appeal or Request Claim Update.

0 coins

Absolutely hold onto that date. The appeal reviewer will look at when EDD received the wage report versus when the payment was issued.

0 coins

I went back to work early too during my bonding claim and stressed about this exact thing. What nobody tells you is that the Continued Claim Certification DE 2580GF is what EDD actually uses to adjust payments going forward after you report returning, so if yours wasn't returned that could be part of the issue.

0 coins

I never got a DE 2580GF in the mail. Would that explain part of this mess?

0 coins

If EDD sent one and you didn't return it, they may have issued payment for more days than they should have. Worth checking your SDI Online message history to see if anything about the DE 2580GF is listed there.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared to look at my own SDI Online now after reading this. I've been doing intermittent days and I'm not sure I handled it right.

0 coins

edd collections while appeal is pending is so stressful i went through it and the letters kept coming for weeks after i thought everything was settled. hang in there

0 coins

Thank you for saying that. It really does feel like being attacked from two directions at once.

0 coins

yeah it feels like that because it kind of is. the two sides dont seem to sync until a human reviews it

0 coins

Payment method question actually came up on my own bonding claim around the same time all this started. I'd switched banks and wasn't sure if EDD still had the right direct deposit info or if overpayment clawbacks would go to the old account. I used Claimyr to reach someone on the PFL line and the agent confirmed which account was on file for my claim. Turned out the payment method had flipped back to the debit card at some point and she told me how to update it in SDI Online. Mostly sharing because if you're dealing with overpayment notices and payments going to the wrong place it compounds everything.

0 coins

My direct deposit situation on my care claim is making me nervous reading this. I'd want to ask an agent whether the account I entered at filing is still active on the claim. I'm going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and your claim ID from SDI Online. The agent will want to pull up the specific claim rather than just your account.

0 coins

been trying that phone line since november. glad someone found a way through.

0 coins

Switching banks mid-claim sounds like a nightmare anyway.

0 coins

Something that sometimes helps when appeal and collections aren't talking to each other is also submitting through Ask EDD in writing. It creates a paper trail separate from the phone. Not a guarantee but it documents that you notified them of the pending appeal before any escalation happens.

0 coins

I didn't know Ask EDD worked for overpayment disputes. I thought it was only for general questions.

0 coins

You can write in about anything on your claim. Keep your message short and factual: appeal submitted on this date, DE 1000A, claim ID number, and that you're receiving collections notices and want confirmation the appeal is on file.

0 coins

Documenting through Ask EDD in addition to the Request Claim Update doubles your paper trail, which matters a lot if this ever goes to a formal hearing.

0 coins

EDD really does operate like two different agencies sometimes. Appeal sits in one queue, collections in another, and nobody coordinates until someone complains loudly enough.

0 coins

Or never. Sometimes never is the answer.

0 coins

Filing everything in writing and keeping copies is the only move that consistently works across both.

0 coins

Are you sure the collections notices are from EDD itself and not from a third-party collector? Because if EDD turned it over externally that changes what options you have.

0 coins

The notices all say EDD at the top. No third party mentioned so far.

0 coins

That's actually better for now. While it's still internal to EDD the appeal process should still be able to intercept it. Document the date on each notice just in case.

0 coins

Good. Keep watching the sender closely as this goes on.

0 coins

Receipt number question came up on my own bonding claim and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr because I'd filed on paper and wasn't sure my DE 2501F had even been received. The agent looked up my claim by name and Social Security number and found the receipt number for me. She told me the claim was in the system and my proof of relationship document was showing as received.

0 coins

Receipt number situation on my own claim is similar — I filed intermittently and lost track of which claim period I was on. I've used Claimyr too and after the agent confirmed which weeks were still open, I went straight to SDI Online and submitted my DE 2580GF for the days I hadn't reported yet. Getting that cleared up was a relief.

0 coins

Reporting intermittent days promptly matters a lot. Gaps in reporting are where overpayments start.

0 coins

Yeah the agent made that clear. She said any day I worked but didn't report would show as a paid day I wasn't entitled to.

0 coins

I've been redialing that line since early morning most days this week. Gets cut off every time around the same point in the menu.

0 coins

Honestly the scariest part of an overpayment notice is not knowing if EDD even got your appeal. No acknowledgment letter, nothing. I sent mine certified mail just so I'd have the delivery confirmation anyway.

0 coins

I didn't send it certified. That's such a good idea in hindsight.

0 coins

Next time anything goes to EDD by mail I'd do certified. At least you have the postal service confirming delivery even if EDD doesn't.

0 coins

Certified mail for anything that has a deadline attached. That's just the rule.

0 coins

Did your Notice of Computation show the right benefit amount to begin with? Sometimes overpayments trace back to the base period wages being wrong from day one, lol, and the appeal has to fix the root number not just the days.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation looked right to me at the time but I'll pull it out again and compare it to the overpayment notice to see if the numbers match up.

0 coins

Compare the weekly benefit amount on your Notice of Computation with what EDD says it paid you per week in the overpayment notice. If those numbers differ that's a separate issue from the return-to-work dates.

0 coins

An appeal on file doesn't automatically pause the collections notices. It goes to a separate review. Keep everything you've submitted documented and don't ignore the collections mail even while you wait.

0 coins

Is there any risk that the collections escalates to something outside EDD while the appeal is in progress, or does EDD hold that internally while the appeal is open?

0 coins

I honestly don't know the specifics of EDD's internal timeline for escalation. I'd ask that directly through Ask EDD or in your Request Claim Update so you have an answer in writing.

0 coins

Had an overpayment notice during a care claim. The appeal took about two months to get any written response. The collections letters kept coming through most of that.

0 coins

Two months. Okay. That is not fun to hear but it's helpful to know what the real timeline might look like.

0 coins

The written decision did eventually come. Read it carefully when it arrives, there's a 30-day window to appeal again if you disagree.

0 coins

To loop back to what you said about reporting the return-to-work in SDI Online: the Continued Claim Certification DE 2580GF is EDD's main tool for reconciling those days. If you reported wages but the DE 2580GF was never returned to EDD, the system may have issued payment based on the original schedule and then flagged it later. Your appeal should address both: that you reported the return and that you were never sent the DE 2580GF to complete.

0 coins

This is really helpful. I'm going to look for any mention of the DE 2580GF in my SDI Online message history and include whatever I find in a follow-up to my appeal.

0 coins

If you can show through SDI Online that the return-to-work was reported on time and that you never received or returned the DE 2580GF, that combination is a reasonable basis for the appeal.

0 coins

EDD collections sending notices while an appeal sits unacknowledged for weeks is the most EDD thing I've ever heard. Zero communication between departments, all pressure on the claimant to prove they exist.

0 coins

yeah its wild that the burden is entirely on the person who already filed all the right forms

0 coins

The burden being on the claimant is consistent across every part of this system.

0 coins

Update: I sent the Request Claim Update through SDI Online this morning and also submitted through Ask EDD. I referenced the DE 1000A, the date I mailed it, and that I'm receiving collections notices. I'll report back when I hear something. Thank you all for the specific steps.

0 coins

That's exactly the right approach. Two written records, two timestamps. Keep copies of both submissions.

0 coins

Documenting the appeal date in both places was the right call. When the written decision comes, read it line by line and don't miss that 30-day response window.

0 coins

DE 2580GF history in SDI Online is worth pulling up too while you're logged in. If there's a record of it being sent and not returned, that tells you something important about where the overpayment originated.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure