Back to California Paid Family Leave

Yuki Nakamura

PFL claim denied wrong birth certificate how to submit correct document

So my bonding claim got denied and I'm honestly panicking a little. What happened is I uploaded a hospital-issued keepsake birth certificate, the decorative one with the footprints, instead of the official certified copy from the county. EDD sent me a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination saying my proof of relationship wasn't accepted. I've since gotten the real certified copy from the county clerk but I have no idea what to do next. Do I appeal? Do I just upload the right one somewhere in SDI Online? Do I have to start the whole claim over? I'm so scared I'm going to miss some deadline and lose the benefits entirely. My son is six weeks old and I really need this money. Any help would be so appreciated.

The denial notice you got, the DE 2514, should have come with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to file an appeal, so check the date right now and count forward. Upload the certified birth certificate in SDI Online under your claim, and file the appeal too, because EDD needs to know you're contesting the denial. Don't do only one or the other.

0 coins

Pulling up the notice now. The date is from eleven days ago so I still have time. Going to do both today, the upload and the appeal form.

0 coins

The DE 1000A can be filed online or mailed. Online is faster.

0 coins

Exactly right. In SDI Online you can upload the document and file the appeal from the same claim screen. Keep a copy of everything you send.

0 coins

Keepsake certificate happens to a lot of guys. County issues the real one, that's what EDD wants. You got it now, upload it and appeal before those 30 days run out.

0 coins

Same mistake I almost made. The hospital hands you the pretty one first and nobody tells you it doesn't count.

0 coins

Yep. Different paper, different seal. Easy mix-up but you gotta catch it.

0 coins

Five weeks into my bonding leave I had a whole separate headache, EDD still showed three weeks available but I'd lost track of what was actually left in my 12-month window after some intermittent days earlier in the year. Tried the phone line a bunch of mornings and kept hitting the busy signal or getting cut off, so I ended up trying Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly how many of the eight weeks I had remaining in my current 12-month period. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Need to ask EDD how many weeks I have left too, used some for bonding and then some for a care claim for my dad and I genuinely have no idea what's remaining. Going to try this. What do I need to have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and roughly the dates you took leave. The agent can see everything on the claim but those help them pull it up faster.

0 coins

been trying that phone line since monday. three mornings in a row, nothing. might just try what you're describing.

0 coins

Tried it this afternoon. Got through and the agent confirmed I have two weeks left in the period. Way less stressful than the phone roulette I'd been doing.

0 coins

Worth pinning down which document EDD actually accepts so you send the right thing this time. For a birth parent, the certified copy from the county registrar is the one, not a hospital-issued record. If you weren't listed on the birth certificate you could use the Declaration of Paternity form CS-909 instead.

0 coins

Confirmed it's a certified county copy. Already have it in hand. Uploading it now alongside the appeal.

0 coins

Good to know about the CS-909. I didn't realize there was an alternative if the other parent isn't on the certificate.

0 coins

Right, it's one of a few options EDD accepts. Adoptive Placement Agreement or a foster care agency letter work for those situations too.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window is not a suggestion. EDD will not care that you were confused or busy. Count from the date printed on the DE 2514 and file before that date, full stop.

0 coins

Does filing the appeal stop the clock, or do I also need to get the new document to them before 30 days?

0 coins

File both as fast as you can. The appeal is what contests the denial. The document is what fixes the underlying problem. Neither one alone is enough.

0 coins

Filing the appeal also means EDD has to review the new evidence. Without it the denial just stands.

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days, upload the certified copy in SDI Online. Those two things together are what reverses a denial like this.

0 coins

Done on both. Submitted the appeal form online and the document is uploaded. Trying to breathe now.

0 coins

Good for you for acting fast! That's exactly the right move.

0 coins

Start date on my care claim kept showing a date I didn't recognize, and I needed to verify it because the 41-day filing window runs from that date and I was cutting it close. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr after two weeks of dead ends on the phone. Agent confirmed the claim start date and told me how many days I had left to get Part D submitted. Got the doctor's office moving the same afternoon.

0 coins

Start date question matched my situation exactly. Had used Claimyr for a different reason, the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, wasn't showing in my claim. Agent found it had been issued but to an old address. Went to the post office that day to reroute it. Took me eleven straight mornings on that line before I tried something different.

0 coins

eleven mornings thats rough. ive been at it for a week on a totally different claim issue, starting to wonder if anyone ever gets through the regular way

0 coins

Some do. Week two I genuinely considered just driving to the office.

0 coins

November 14th is when the denial notice was issued if I'm reading your post right. Thirty days puts the appeal deadline at December 14th. Mark that date somewhere obvious and don't cut it close, file today if you can.

0 coins

Already filed it this afternoon, so I'm ahead of the deadline. Thank you for doing that math.

0 coins

Good. Keep the confirmation number from the appeal submission, same as you'd keep a receipt.

0 coins

Just want to flag one thing, you mentioned being scared about losing the whole claim. The appeal is specifically so you don't have to refile from scratch. If EDD sees the correct document and the denial gets reversed on appeal you should be back on track, not starting over.

0 coins

That's actually really reassuring. I thought I might have to refile and lose my place in line.

0 coins

Nope, the appeal keeps the original claim alive. That's what it's for.

0 coins

Does the weekly benefit amount stay the same if the appeal is approved, or does EDD recalculate?

0 coins

The amount on your Notice of Computation stays the same. The appeal is about eligibility, not about the payment calculation.

0 coins

edd is brutal with this stuff. upload the right certificate today dont wait even one more day. 30 days sounds like a lot until its not

0 coins

Agreed. It goes fast when you're dealing with a newborn on no sleep.

0 coins

exactly, file it and forget it, let edd sort it out

0 coins

Payment method on my bonding claim was showing debit card but I'd set up direct deposit when I filed. Tried the phone line probably a dozen times over two weeks and never got a person. Ended up using Claimyr and the agent confirmed direct deposit was actually on file and that the first payment would go there. Had me double-check my banking info in SDI Online while I was on the call.

0 coins

That phone line has beaten me too. Called four mornings in a row last month for a document question and never got past the automated message. I'm not sure I'd trust something like that for a claim that's already been denied, seems like it might just be marketing for a service that doesn't deliver.

0 coins

Totally fair to wonder. I had the same thought. The agent I spoke with confirmed the direct deposit routing number on file matched my bank, and walked me through what to look for in SDI Online. Straightforward call, nothing fancy.

0 coins

Used Claimyr when my intermittent days weren't updating on my claim. The agent pulled up the DE 2580GF and confirmed EDD had received it and which weeks had been certified. Went back into SDI Online after and the status had already refreshed.

0 coins

Okay, that's more concrete than I expected. Going to give it a shot for my document question.

0 coins

For anyone wondering what 'certified copy' actually means, it's a copy issued directly by the county registrar with an official seal or stamp. The hospital gives you a memento, but only the county can issue the legal document EDD is looking for.

0 coins

Didn't know the difference until I read this thread. Glad I checked before filing.

0 coins

County clerk's office, vital records department. Some counties let you order online through their site.

0 coins

SDI Online lets you upload documents directly to the claim. Log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and go to your claim, there's an upload option there. That's separate from the appeal form, do both.

0 coins

Used that exact path. Upload went through and I got a confirmation. Appeal form submitted right after.

0 coins

Keep screenshots of both confirmations. If anything goes sideways you have proof of the submission dates.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period before payments start, right? I keep seeing people mention a seven-day wait and I'm not sure if that's something that applies here or if I'm confusing it with something else.

0 coins

You're mixing it up with Disability Insurance, which does have an unpaid waiting period of seven days. PFL has no waiting period at all. Once eligibility is confirmed the payments can begin right away.

0 coins

Thank goodness. I'd been dreading that.

0 coins

Really common confusion since both programs are under SDI. PFL is its own thing with its own rules.

0 coins

Different program, different rules. No waiting period for PFL.

0 coins

Appeals at EDD take time. File it today, then expect to wait. Keep checking SDI Online for status updates on the claim.

0 coins

Noted. Trying to manage my expectations and not refresh every hour.

0 coins

Refresh once a day. More than that just drives you crazy.

0 coins

The certified birth certificate was actually the first thing on EDD's proof of relationship list when I looked it up! Glad you have it now. The appeal process exists exactly for situations like this.

0 coins

Wish I'd read that list more carefully before filing. Lesson very much learned.

0 coins

Honestly it's an easy mistake. The hospital hands it to you and it looks official!

0 coins

EDD's phone line being impossible to reach is a whole separate problem from the denial, but it matters because sometimes you need a real person to tell you the appeal went through or that the document was matched to your claim. I tried calling at 8am on the dot three different Fridays and got cut off every single time.

0 coins

Same experience. 8am, 8:01, didn't matter.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update in SDI Online is the workaround I finally used. At least you get a written response.

0 coins

Bonding claim and the proof of relationship is something I stressed about too. Filed the appeal in SDI Online this week for a different document issue and the system walked me through it step by step. Less scary than it sounds.

0 coins

Good to know the appeal flow in SDI Online is actually usable. I was expecting something confusing.

0 coins

Pick the claim, find the appeal option, fill it out. Had mine submitted in maybe ten minutes, anyway.

0 coins

the keepsake certificate thing should honestly be on a warning label somewhere. so many people dont know.

0 coins

facts. hospital should hand you a note that says this one is decorative get the real one from the county

0 coins

county offices arent even open on weekends which makes it worse

0 coins

EDD can't use the decorative hospital certificate for a legal determination, that's always been the rule. County-issued with the official seal is the bar they set. You have that now so the path forward is clear: appeal on file, correct document uploaded, wait.

0 coins

That's the summary I needed. All three of those boxes are now checked.

0 coins

Then you've done what you can do. Status updates in SDI Online will tell you when it moves.

0 coins

For your peace of mind, bonding benefits can be used anytime in the 12 months after your son's birth. Even if the appeal takes a few weeks to process you haven't lost the opportunity to use those weeks.

0 coins

Didn't know that. I thought every day I wasn't getting paid was a week I'd lose forever.

0 coins

The 12-month window is from the birth date, not from when you filed. You have the full period to use all eight weeks, as long as the appeal goes through.

0 coins

That is genuinely helpful to know. I'd been assuming the same wrong thing.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure