Back to California Paid Family Leave

AaliyahAli

PFL claim denied proof of relationship not provided — time how to appeal before the 30 days runs out?

So I filed a PFL bonding claim for my daughter back in October and uploaded her birth certificate the same week. Everything looked fine in SDI Online and I figured I was good. Then last week I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) in the mail saying my claim was denied because proof of relationship was not provided. I am losing my mind because I definitely uploaded that document. I have the confirmation in SDI Online and everything. Now I have an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) sitting on my table and I don't even know where to start. Does the 30-day appeal window start from the date on the notice or the date I received it? And do I need to gather anything else before I file the appeal? I'm a single mom and these eight weeks of bonding pay are not something I can just let go.

Denial notice showed up for my bonding claim too, same reason, back in August. Spent three mornings on EDD's line before I ever reached anyone. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to a live EDD agent that same day. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's Paid Family Leave line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my DE 2514 and told me exactly which week the determination covered and that the appeal deadline was 30 days from the mailing date on the notice itself, not from when I got it. So get the postmark and the date on the letter and count from the letter's date.

0 coins

Appeal deadline on the notice itself, not delivery, that's the part that matters to me right now. My claim's still pending but if it goes sideways I want to be ready. What should I have in front of me if I try Claimyr for the appeal question?

0 coins

Receipt number from when you filed, the DE 2514 denial notice, and whatever document EDD says it didn't get. That's what the agent asked me for right away.

0 coins

The date on the letter, not when it arrived. Good to know because mine sat in my mailbox over a weekend. I'm counting from the letter date now.

0 coins

The Appeal Form (DE 1000A) can be filed online through SDI Online or mailed to the address printed on the form itself. Do not send it to EDD's general mailing address. Write on the form exactly why you believe the denial was wrong and attach a copy of anything you think shows EDD received the document, such as a screenshot of the SDI Online upload confirmation if you have one.

0 coins

I do have that SDI Online screen showing the upload went through. Would you attach that as the main evidence or do you think I need a fresh certified copy of the birth certificate too?

0 coins

Bring both. A certified copy of the birth certificate alongside that upload confirmation gives you two layers of proof that the document exists and that you submitted it.

0 coins

Mailing it straight to the general address is such an easy mistake to make. The form really does have its own address on it and it matters.

0 coins

The 30 days running from the mailing date caught me off guard when I read about it. So if the notice is dated November 10 you'd want your appeal in by December 10, not by however many days after you opened the envelope. Appeals filed even one day late can be dismissed, so I'd move fast.

0 coins

Does filing the appeal online through SDI Online count as filed on that day, or does EDD go by when they process it? I keep worrying they'll say it arrived late even if I submitted it on time.

0 coins

Filing it in SDI Online should timestamp it on the day you submit. I'd still take a screenshot of the confirmation page just in case.

0 coins

The timestamp thing honestly scares me too. I'd probably mail it certified and do the online one on the same day just to have both records, not sure if that's overkill.

0 coins

Had the same

0 coins

How did you get the reversal in writing? Did EDD send you an updated notice or did it just show up as approved in SDI Online?

0 coins

Got a letter in the mail. Then the payments started showing up after that. Nothing updated in SDI Online first, the letter came first.

0 coins

The Appeal Form DE 1000A is listed on EDD's site under Paid Family Leave forms. EDD's own language says you have 30 days from the mailing date of the determination to file. That 30-day clock is worth writing on your calendar the moment the notice arrives.

0 coins

Wrote the date in my calendar before I even finished reading the notice. Good habit.

0 coins

November 14 mailing date on mine, so December 14 is the hard deadline I'm tracking. Worth noting the date in two places.

0 coins

I uploaded documents for my bonding claim twice because the first upload showed confirmed in SDI Online but EDD acted like it never happened. The portal says one thing and their system does another sometimes. If you have the upload confirmation screenshot, lead with that in the appeal and attach the fresh copy of the birth certificate right behind it. Don't just describe what you uploaded, show them.

0 coins

wait so the upload confirming doesnt mean they actually got it matched to the claim?

0 coins

Apparently not always. The upload can show confirmed on your end while EDD's side hasn't connected it to your specific claim yet. That's exactly why the confirmation screenshot matters as evidence in an appeal.

0 coins

This is making me feel better about having the screenshot actually. I was second-guessing whether it would even count as proof.

0 coins

Pending over two weeks on my bonding claim and SDI Online just kept showing no movement. Tried the EDD line several times across different mornings, never got past the recording. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent who checked what document EDD was still waiting for. Turned out the proof of relationship I uploaded hadn't been matched to my claim ID yet, and the agent told me which form EDD actually had on file.

0 coins

The unmatched document part is exactly what happened to me. I used Claimyr for the receipt number question and once the agent confirmed EDD had my birth certificate under my receipt number, I knew the appeal would hold up. Spent probably six mornings trying to get through that line before I tried it.

0 coins

How many mornings did you try that line before you gave up and tried something different?

0 coins

Six, like I said. Some days the line just ended the call without putting me in any queue at all.

0 coins

that line ending the call with no queue is the worst. happened to me four mornings straight.

0 coins

For the appeal form, describe what you uploaded, when you uploaded it, and reference the SDI Online confirmation. Keep it factual, like you're writing a timeline. EDD appeals reviewers go through a lot of these, the clearer the better.

0 coins

Timeline format makes sense. I was going to write it as a paragraph but bullet points with dates might be sharper.

0 coins

Bullet points with dates, yes. Upload date, notice date, appeal filed date. Short and clear.

0 coins

Bring a certified copy of the birth certificate to the appeal regardless of what you already uploaded. Clean documents beat explanations every time.

0 coins

Can you get a certified copy fast enough if you're close to the 30-day deadline? My county clerk takes a couple weeks sometimes.

0 coins

File the appeal first to protect the deadline. Send the certified copy as soon as you have it. Don't wait for the copy before filing.

0 coins

Filing first to hold the deadline then sending the copy after, that's the order I'll follow.

0 coins

My bonding claim had a similar hiccup and I actually got through to EDD to sort it out. Tried the PFL line repeatedly before I found Claimyr and once I reached an agent she told me the payment that had been held was issued on a specific date and I should see it within a few business days. Filed my appeal on the other issue the same afternoon with that date confirmed!

0 coins

Several mornings on that line myself and it never got past the busy signal into an actual queue. How did your call actually go once you got through?

0 coins

The agent was straightforward, pulled up the claim right away and read me the payment date. Took maybe ten minutes once I was actually talking to someone. I did have my receipt number and the denial notice both right there.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself when my Notice of Computation amount looked wrong. The agent confirmed the weekly benefit amount on the notice was correct based on my base period wages. Cleared up the question I'd been sitting on for days.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared to file the appeal wrong and lose the chance entirely. Is there any way to mess up the form in a way that makes it invalid? Like if I write too much or don't describe it the right way?

0 coins

The form itself is fairly straightforward. State what the denial said, state why you disagree, and attach your evidence. EDD's appeals process is meant to be accessible without a lawyer.

0 coins

Don't overthink the wording. What mattered in the cases I've read about is that you file within 30 days and include your evidence. A clearly stated disagreement is enough.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps. I was picturing some legal brief but it sounds more like a written explanation.

0 coins

EDD denies bonding claims for

0 coins

Does that mean the appeals reviewers see this exact issue regularly and know what to look for?

0 coins

Probably. Doesn't mean automatic win, but you're not presenting something they haven't seen.

0 coins

my cousin got the same denial and just refiled instead of appealing and it worked for her but she still had time before the 12 months ran out so the bonding window wasnt closed yet

0 coins

Worth flagging here: refiling works only if you're still within 12 months of the child's birth and within 41 days of when your leave started. If the 41-day window for the original leave start has passed, an appeal of the denial is the right path, not a new filing.

0 coins

oh yeah she filed pretty quickly after the baby came so she had room. good point for people who waited longer.

0 coins

My daughter was born in September and I filed in October so I'm definitely past the original 41-day start window. Appeal is the only route for me.

0 coins

Appeal in writing, attach your proof, mail it certified so you have a postal record. That's the whole move.

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt is how I did mine. Had the green card back as my timestamp.

0 coins

If the appeal is approved, do the payments for all eight weeks go back to when I was supposed to start, or only from when the appeal is decided? I'm trying to figure out if I'll lose the weeks that passed during the appeal process.

0 coins

If the appeal succeeds the benefits should cover the eligible period from your original claim dates, not just from the appeal decision forward. That's the whole point of reversing a denial.

0 coins

Just make sure the weeks you're claiming fall within the 12-month bonding window from the child's birth. The appeal doesn't extend that window.

0 coins

So I could potentially get paid for the weeks I already missed while waiting? That's actually a relief to know.

0 coins

Appeal filed October 28 on my bonding denial, reversal letter arrived November 19. So roughly three weeks, though I know that's just my own experience and it could vary.

0 coins

Three weeks is faster than I expected honestly.

0 coins

Three weeks I could handle if it means getting the full eight weeks paid out.

0 coins

The SDI Online upload confirmation screenshot is genuinely your strongest piece of evidence here. Date-stamped, tied to your claim. Lead with that on the appeal form.

0 coins

I'm printing that screenshot out tonight and attaching it to the paper form as my first exhibit basically.

0 coins

Add your receipt number on every page you attach. Makes it easier for the reviewer to match everything to your file.

0 coins

eight weeks is real money. dont let the denial just sit there.

0 coins

Filing the appeal tomorrow morning. Not letting this one go.

0 coins

One thing I noticed in my own appeal packet: EDD's address for the appeal was different from the address I'd been mailing other forms to. Double-check the address printed on your DE 1000A before you send anything.

0 coins

Correct, the DE 1000A has its own designated address and that is where the appeal should go, not EDD's general office.

0 coins

Learned that one the hard way on a DI appeal years ago. Address on the form is the one that counts.

0 coins

Coming back to say I filed the appeal in SDI Online last night, attached the upload confirmation screenshot and a photo of the birth certificate. Receipt confirmation came up on screen and I took a screenshot of that too. Now the waiting begins but at least it's filed within the 30 days. Thanks everyone for talking me through this.

0 coins

Good move getting it in. Keep that confirmation screenshot safe.

0 coins

Filed and timestamped. That's the hard part done.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure