Back to California Paid Family Leave

Alejandro Castro

PFL claim denied because of full wages — appeal as a part-time caregiver?

I've been taking my dad to his treatments twice a week since August and filed a PFL care claim for those days. I'm still working my regular hours the other three days, so I thought this was pretty straightforward. EDD sent me a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination saying I was denied. The reason on the notice said something about wages — I think because my employer kept paying me my full salary on the days I do work, so my total weekly wages looked like my normal full-time pay? I honestly don't understand how they calculated it. I'm not taking full weeks off, just specific days, and I'm definitely losing those hours with my dad. Can I appeal this? Has anyone dealt with a denial like this when you're doing part-time or intermittent caregiving and still getting paid for the days you do work?

Filing an appeal is absolutely the right move here. The DE 1000A is the form you want, and the notice itself should have it attached or at least reference it. You have 30 days from the date on that determination letter, so check the date right now and don't let it slide. On the wages question: PFL pays for the days you're not working and not earning, not the days you do work. If your employer paid your full salary across all five days even when you only worked three, EDD would see wages that look like full-time pay and might conclude you had no wage loss on the care days. Your appeal is the place to explain the actual breakdown.

0 coins

Pulling up the notice now — it's dated twelve days ago so I still have time. Do I need to include anything besides the form itself, like a letter from my employer showing which days I actually worked?

0 coins

Attach whatever documents show the actual days and hours worked versus days off for caregiving. A pay stub that breaks down daily hours, a letter from HR, even your own written statement with specific dates can all help. The clearer the picture you give EDD, the better.

0 coins

The DE 1000A instructions say you can submit additional evidence with the appeal. Anything that documents the wage loss on the specific care days is fair game. Payroll records showing daily hours are probably the strongest thing you can include.

0 coins

Intermittent PFL denials tied to wages tripped up my own care claim last year. I filed for two days a week caring for my mother and EDD initially processed it as if my wages were uninterrupted. I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the phone line kept ending before I ever reached a person. The agent pulled up my claim and told me I had four of my eight PFL weeks still available in my benefit year, which I hadn't been sure about since I'd used some weeks bonding with my youngest two years before. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD's Paid Family Leave line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

How did the call actually go once you got through — did the agent ask you to send anything in or just explain the wage issue over the phone?

0 coins

The agent explained what the claim showed on their end and said to send payroll records that break down the specific days I worked versus the days I was off caring for her. After that I submitted them through SDI Online and the claim moved forward.

0 coins

I've been dialing that PFL number on my lunch breaks for going on three weeks and it either rings forever or dumps me before I even hear a menu. Nice to know there's a way that actually lands you with someone.

0 coins

Worth understanding how EDD counts wage loss for intermittent days. Each day you're on leave, EDD pays one-seventh of your weekly benefit amount for that day. If your employer's payroll system paid you your full weekly salary regardless of which days you were actually in, EDD's records would show no reduction in wages for the leave days. That's probably the disconnect. Your appeal should spell out exactly which days in each week you worked and which days you were with your dad, and what your pay actually was for each.

0 coins

That makes it clearer. My employer does pay me salary weekly, not by the day, so the paystubs won't break it down automatically. I'm going to get a letter from HR that lists the exact days.

0 coins

A signed letter from HR on company letterhead listing each date you were absent for caregiving is exactly what I'd attach. Pair it with the determination notice and the DE 1000A and you've got a solid appeal packet.

0 coins

I'm in a somewhat similar situation caring for my wife two days a week and I'm honestly not sure my employer's payroll is set up to show daily breakdowns either. Does EDD have a way to verify which days you were off if the paystub just shows a weekly total?

0 coins

EDD relies on what you report and what your employer confirms. If the paystub can't show it, the HR letter is the next best thing. Some people also include a written statement they sign themselves listing the specific dates, though employer documentation carries more weight.

0 coins

appeals for care claims are annoying but they do work out sometimes. the main thing is getting your paperwork together before you send anything in

0 coins

Did yours get overturned on appeal or did it just take forever?

0 coins

took about six weeks and they reversed it. had to send in a pay stub and a note from my job. not a fun wait but it worked

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window goes fast, especially when you're already running around taking your dad to appointments. If your employer can email you an HR letter quickly, file the appeal first with what you have, then send the supporting documents right after. You can submit documents through SDI Online.

0 coins

Filing it first to protect the deadline makes sense. I didn't realize I could send documents separately after.

0 coins

You can send additional evidence after the initial appeal is filed. Just note your claim ID on everything so it gets matched correctly.

0 coins

Same. File first, gather the rest after. Don't wait for everything to be perfect.

0 coins

EDD and intermittent claims are genuinely a headache. My sister tried to do two days a week for my dad and they kept paying her wrong amounts. every time she tried to call it was the same wall of hold music and then nothing

0 coins

ugh the phone situation is the worst part of all of this, you have an urgent question and there's no way to get a real person

0 coins

exactly. and by the time you do get someone you've forgotten half of what you wanted to ask

0 coins

I've started writing my questions down before I call. still doesn't get me through but at least I'd be ready if it happened

0 coins

Before my appeal I wanted to know if I even filed within the right window so I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr. The agent looked up my care claim and confirmed the start date and that I'd made it inside the 41 days. That alone settled a lot of the anxiety I had about whether the whole thing was going to be thrown out before anyone even looked at it.

0 coins

I want to ask EDD whether Part D from my mom's doctor ever got matched to my claim, it's been showing unconfirmed for two weeks. Going to give Claimyr a try for that.

0 coins

Have your receipt number and your claim ID ready when you get through. The agent pulled mine up right away once I gave them the claim ID.

0 coins

Part D matching is such a stressor, I hope yours gets sorted quickly! My claim sat unmatched for 11 days and I was convinced something had gotten lost.

0 coins

Good to know about the claim ID. I've got mine written on a sticky note next to my laptop already.

0 coins

A few things worth checking before you send the appeal in. EDD's rules for intermittent PFL say you report the specific days and hours you work on the leave period, not just your weekly total. If you answered question A13 on the original DE 2501F as a yes for working during leave, verify that you attached a schedule showing which days. If that attachment was missing or unclear, that could have contributed to the denial alongside the wages question.

0 coins

I filed through SDI Online, not on paper. Is A13 still a question in the online version?

0 coins

SDI Online covers the same information as the paper form, just in a different format. It would have asked whether you planned to work during your leave period. If you said yes, it should have prompted you to enter your work schedule. Worth reviewing what you submitted on that claim.

0 coins

I had no idea about the A13 question. I filed for intermittent leave for my wife and I might have just answered no without thinking about it because I wasn't sure how to describe a two-day-a-week schedule.

0 coins

appeal it. plain and simple. EDD gets things wrong on intermittent claims all the time. get your pay records, write down what days you worked and what days you were with your dad, and send it all in together

0 coins

That's the plan. HR said they can get me a letter by Friday so I should be able to file everything together.

0 coins

good. don't overthink it. the facts are on your side if you're actually taking those days off for care

0 coins

edd does this thing where they see your full weekly pay and just deny the whole thing without looking at which days you actually worked. happened to my coworker too. appeal and show them the actual days

0 coins

she won hers by the way. took like two months but they paid her back to the original dates

0 coins

Two months is about right for an appeal. Sometimes faster, sometimes not.

0 coins

From an accounting standpoint, the issue is that your weekly gross wages match your pre-leave baseline. EDD's system sees no reduction in weekly pay. For the appeal, if your HR can provide a breakdown showing regular salary attributable to three days worked and zero wages for the two care days per week, that's the clearest possible documentation. If your employer uses a time-and-attendance system, a printout from that system is even better.

0 coins

HR told me their system does track daily attendance separately from payroll. So there might actually be a report I can get from them.

0 coins

Get that attendance report. Dates, in and out, specific to each week. Combined with the DE 1000A and your Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, that's a strong package.

0 coins

If the attendance report shows each care day as an absence, that directly contradicts what EDD's payment records showed. That kind of concrete documentation is exactly what an appeal reviewer needs.

0 coins

just want to say you're doing a lot being there for your dad twice a week while still working the rest of the time. PFL should be supporting you, not adding more stress with a denial

0 coins

Thank you. It's been a lot to manage. I really thought the claim would go through without issues since I was clear about the intermittent schedule when I filed.

0 coins

Intermittent care claims are honestly more complicated than the full-leave ones, which shouldn't be the case. You filed correctly, the system just didn't process it right.

0 coins

kind of scared reading this because I'm about to file for my wife's care in a part-time setup too. should I be doing something differently when I file to avoid this happening?

0 coins

When you file through SDI Online, be very specific about which days of the week you will be working and which days you'll be off for caregiving. The more precisely you document the schedule in the initial claim, the clearer the wage-loss picture is.

0 coins

Also make sure Part D, the physician certification for your wife's condition, reaches EDD within 41 days of your first care day. That's separate from the wage reporting piece but equally important for the claim to go through.

0 coins

I did not know Part D had to get there within 41 days. Is that 41 days from when I start the leave or from when I file?

0 coins

41 days from the first day of your family leave, not from when you filed the claim itself. Make sure the doctor's office has your receipt number so they can submit it correctly.

0 coins

Paid the first week out of pocket waiting for my payment to go through on a care claim and EDD couldn't tell me over that impossible phone line whether the money was actually coming. I ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr to ask about the payment method on my claim. The agent confirmed they had direct deposit info on file and that the first payment had been issued — just hadn't hit my account yet. Anyway

0 coins

Direct deposit for my own intermittent claim is exactly the question I'd want answered. I used Claimyr too and once the agent confirmed the DE 2500E had been sent to me I knew things were actually moving. Before that I kept checking SDI Online and couldn't tell if anything was actually happening.

0 coins

I've tried that PFL number six mornings in a row and gotten through exactly zero times. Good to know there's a path that lands you with an actual person.

0 coins

yeah the line is brutal. once I had an agent though it took maybe five minutes to get everything cleared up. anyway.

0 coins

EDD sees a lot of these intermittent care denials reversed on appeal. Put the dates in front of them in a format they can't misread and you'll probably be fine.

0 coins

HR came through faster than expected. I have the attendance report and I'm putting the appeal packet together tonight.

0 coins

file it and don't wait. clock is what matters here

0 coins

tired from a long shift but reading this because my own care claim got hit with something similar. my employer pays weekly salary too. glad to see the appeal actually works

0 coins

file yours if you're still in the 30-day window. the same approach should apply — attendance records and an HR breakdown of the days you worked versus the care days

0 coins

still inside the window, barely. going to put something together this weekend

0 coins

The good news is that EDD does issue back pay if the appeal succeeds, all the way back to when the original claim should have started. So you don't lose those weeks just because the denial delayed everything!

0 coins

That's actually a relief to hear. I was worried that losing two months to an appeal process would mean I'd miss out on benefits for those weeks entirely.

0 coins

If the appeal reverses the denial, EDD goes back to the original claim dates. Keep records of every care day during the appeal period in case they ask for the full accounting.

0 coins

Definitely keep a running log. Dates, what appointments or care tasks happened that day, hours away from work. It makes the eventual payment calculation much cleaner.

0 coins

wait so pfl doesnt have a waiting period right? like you can get paid from day one of leave? i told my coworker she'd have to wait a week before getting anything and now im not sure i was right

0 coins

No waiting period for PFL. That's a disability insurance thing, not PFL. PFL starts paying from the first eligible day, so you'll want to correct that for your coworker.

0 coins

oh no i definitely told her the wrong thing. thanks for catching that, sending her a message now

0 coins

yeah pfl is different. the seven day wait is only for state disability not for bonding or care claims

0 coins

the system is set up to deny first and ask questions later. everyone I know who had an intermittent claim got hassled about it one way or another

0 coins

Not wrong. Anything that isn't a simple eight-week block seems to trigger extra scrutiny.

0 coins

appeals exist for a reason. file it and let the process run

0 coins

Update for anyone following this: I filed the DE 1000A this afternoon through SDI Online with the attendance report from HR and a signed letter from my manager listing each care day since August. 23 days left on the appeal window. Going to log every care day going forward too in case they need more detail.

0 coins

Keep logging those days no matter what. If the reviewer asks for anything further you'll have it ready.

0 coins

Submitting through SDI Online means there's a timestamp on record. Keep the confirmation page or reference number from the submission.

0 coins

Really glad you got the HR documents in time — sounds like a solid appeal packet!

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure