Back to California Paid Family Leave

Amina Bah

PFL appeal claim disappeared from myEDD portal after I submitted the DE 1000A

I filed a PFL bonding claim back in August and got denied in October. EDD mailed me the denial notice, the DE 2514, and I filled out the appeal form that came with it and mailed it in about three weeks ago. When I first got the denial I could see the claim sitting there in myEDD with a status showing, but now when I log in the whole claim is just gone. Like the bonding claim and everything under it has vanished from the portal. I didn't do anything differently, I didn't delete anything, it was just there one day and gone the next. Has anyone else had this happen? Did I actually lose my appeal or does the claim disappear while the appeal is being processed? I'm kind of panicking because I have zero confirmation that EDD ever got my appeal paperwork and now there's nothing in my portal to even check on.

Appeals go to a different office than the EDD claims side. The claim dropping off your view in myEDD doesn't mean the appeal is gone, it means it moved. Keep the envelope you mailed the DE 1000A in and note the date you sent it. That's your record until you hear something.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Did yours disappear too or are you going by what someone told you? I want to make sure I'm not mixing up a glitch with how it actually works.

0 coins

Went through it myself last year. Claim vanished about two weeks after I mailed the form. Got a hearing notice six weeks later, so the appeal was fine.

0 coins

Oh I went through almost this exact thing with a care claim appeal. The claim kind of goes into a limbo state once the appeal is processing and you can't track it in SDI Online the same way. It's not deleted, it's just not surfacing in the regular claims view anymore. So stressful though, I completely get the panic.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

How long did it take before you got any paperwork from EDD acknowledging the appeal was received?

0 coins

Got a hearing date letter maybe five or six weeks after I mailed the DE 1000A. Nothing between mailing it and that letter, so the silence felt forever but it was fine.

0 coins

Same here. No acknowledgment, then suddenly a hearing date showed up.

0 coins

My denial notice showed up in October and I couldn't figure out if the appeal form I mailed had even made it to EDD, nothing changed in the portal. After a couple weeks of silence I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at EDD's PFL line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent looked up my claim and confirmed the DE 2514 was on file and that my appeal had been logged, then told me the appeal would go to the Office of Appeals and I'd get a hearing notice by mail, so at that point I just had to wait.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? The EDD line I call just dumps me after the hold music.

0 coins

You give it your number and it handles staying on hold with EDD until an agent picks up, then your phone rings and you're talking to a real EDD person. I'd use it if you have a question about where your own denial is sitting.

0 coins

My care claim has a DE 2514 out there too and I've been trying to figure out if the appeal window is still open. That's what I'd ask. Might be worth trying if the line keeps ending the call on me.

0 coins

Mailing the appeal is enough. EDD doesn't send a receipt when it gets the DE 1000A. The claim disappearing from myEDD while an appeal processes is something a few patients I work with have mentioned too. The hearing notice by mail is your first real confirmation.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Is the 30-day window from the date on the denial letter or from when I received it?

0 coins

From the date on the notice. Mail it well before the deadline so there's room if anything runs slow.

0 coins

Came here to say exactly this, 30 days from the notice date, don't cut it close, anyway.

0 coins

EDD's portal is basically decorative at this point. Had a bonding claim just stop updating and nothing I did in myEDD showed me anything useful. At least you mailed it in time, that's what actually matters not whatever the portal is showing you.

0 coins

The portal thing is infuriating. Mine showed pending for so long I thought the whole thing was stuck.

0 coins

Two and a half weeks trying that phone line every morning before it finally connected me. The portal and the phone are equally useless until they're not.

0 coins

I was under the impression you could file a PFL appeal online too, not just by mail. Is that right, or is the DE 1000A always a paper form?

0 coins

You can appeal online or by mail using the DE 1000A. The form comes with the denial notice, but you can also appeal through SDI Online. Either way the 30-day window from the notice date applies.

0 coins

Good to know the online option exists. For people who already mailed it, is there any risk in also submitting online just to have a record?

0 coins

Filing twice could create confusion on EDD's end. If you've already mailed it, don't file again. Hold on to proof of mailing and wait for the hearing notice.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

I wish I'd known about the online option before I mailed mine. Next time I'll know.

0 coins

my bonding claim got denied because EDD said my proof of relationship didn't come through, lol like I uploaded the birth certificate the same day I filed. had to appeal and yeah the claim just went dark in the portal after I sent the form in. hearing date came eventually tho

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Did EDD ever say why the birth certificate wasn't counted as received even though you uploaded it?

0 coins

agent said they couldn't see it matched to the claim, which made zero sense to me. the appeal hearing sorted it out though.

0 coins

For bonding claims, documents need to be matched to the claim ID. Upload confirmation in SDI Online doesn't always mean EDD has linked it.

0 coins

The portal going blank is honestly one of the most alarming things when you're already stressed about a denial! You did the right thing mailing the form. The hearing process takes a while but it does move forward.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Thank you, that actually helps. How long did your appeal take from mailing to a decision?

0 coins

About three months from sending the DE 1000A to getting the written decision after the hearing. It felt long but the hearing itself was straightforward!

0 coins

Proof of relationship not matching up was the whole reason my bonding claim got tangled. Uploaded the birth certificate, nothing changed in SDI Online, and the claim just sat there. I called EDD using Claimyr and the agent told me the document was received but hadn't been matched to my claim yet. Once it was matched the claim moved forward.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself for a receipt number issue and glad I did. The agent pulled up my claim right away and confirmed the receipt number was tied to the correct claim ID, which had me worried because the confirmation screen had shown something different. I hadn't realized the display could lag.

0 coins

What did you do after the agent confirmed the receipt number was correct on their end?

0 coins

Just waited. The agent said to give it a few business days for the status to update in SDI Online and it did.

0 coins

been trying that line most mornings this week, no luck yet. might try what you did.

0 coins

Don't file the appeal twice. Already said upthread but it's worth repeating. One DE 1000A mailed on time is enough.

0 coins

what happens if you do accidentally submit twice? asking for a friend lol

0 coins

Creates a mess. EDD has to figure out which one to process. Just don't.

0 coins

EDD having to sort out duplicate filings is not something you want to cause.

0 coins

Track the mailing if you can. Certified mail gives you a USPS tracking number and date of delivery, which is proof if EDD ever says they didn't get the DE 1000A. Worth doing for anything with a deadline attached.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

I didn't send it certified, just first class. Is there anything I can do at this point to confirm delivery besides waiting for the hearing notice?

0 coins

At this stage, waiting for the hearing notice is your most reliable signal. If you have your original envelope with a postmark date and you mailed it well within 30 days, your documentation is solid.

0 coins

USPS certified is the move for anything EDD-related going forward.

0 coins

my claim went missing from myedd after a denial too and i thought i had done something wrong. turns out it was just processing. got a letter with the hearing date and that was the first sign anything was happening

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

How many weeks was it before the letter came?

0 coins

like six weeks i think. felt like forever but it showed up.

0 coins

A payment that never posted after my care claim was approved is what sent me back to the phone. I used Claimyr to reach someone at PFL and the agent pulled up the payment and found it had been issued but to an old address on the account. The date it was issued was in October, so I knew exactly what to ask EDD to fix.

0 coins

A payment going to an old address sounds like something EDD would do. And the whole thing sounds a little too convenient, like a service that promises you an agent just happens to be real?

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I saw it mentioned. Used it anyway because the hold music had ended my call four mornings in a row. The person I spoke with was an actual EDD agent who had my claim on screen. Asked about the Notice of Computation and she read me the weekly amount off the DE 429DF and confirmed which quarter it came from.

0 coins

Fine. I've been at this long enough that I'll try anything once.

0 coins

The agent was straightforward and had everything right there. Worth trying when the line keeps ending before anyone answers.

0 coins

Denied bonding claims and appeals both drop off the standard myEDD view while they're processing. It's not a glitch, it's just how the system handles the handoff to the appeals office. Your appeal record lives with the Office of Appeals now, not on the claims side.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Is there any way to check status with the Office of Appeals directly, or do I just have to wait for mail?

0 coins

The Office of Appeals has its own contact information on the EDD site. You can reach out to them separately from the PFL line if you want confirmation the appeal was received.

0 coins

Didn't know the Office of Appeals was reachable separately. That's actually useful for people stuck in the waiting period.

0 coins

One thing I had wrong before my denial was thinking PFL had a waiting period where the first week doesn't pay. Someone had told me you don't get paid for the first week. That's disability insurance, not PFL. PFL starts paying from day one of your leave.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Wait, so there's no unpaid first week for PFL at all?

0 coins

No waiting period for PFL. The seven-day unpaid stretch is a DI thing. I mixed them up too before EDD straightened it out.

0 coins

So many people get those two confused. PFL and disability are both under SDI but they're completely different claims with different rules.

0 coins

Appeal in and portal blank, that's exactly where I was two months ago with my bonding claim. The silence is brutal but the hearing notice does show up, anyway. Hang in there.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Did your denial have anything to do with the proof of relationship or was it something else?

0 coins

EDD said my wages didn't qualify, turned out they had the wrong base period quarters. The hearing fixed it.

0 coins

Wage calculation errors on PFL claims are more common than people realize. Good that you pushed back on it!

0 coins

For anyone wondering about job protection while all this appeal stuff is going on: PFL itself doesn't protect your job. It's just the benefit payments. CFRA is the job protection piece and that's separate from PFL. I confused them for a while and was asking EDD questions they couldn't answer.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

So if my employer wants to fill my position while I'm waiting for the appeal, PFL doesn't stop them?

0 coins

PFL has no say over your job. CFRA is what protects your position and that's between you and your employer. EDD handles PFL only.

0 coins

For anything about job protection, talk to HR about CFRA. EDD won't have that answer.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window counted from the date printed on the DE 2514 is strict. I've seen people assume it's from when they receive the letter and they miss the window thinking they have more time. The notice date is the clock.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Mine was dated October 9th and I mailed the DE 1000A on October 27th. That's within 30 days right?

0 coins

October 9 to October 27 is 18 days. You were inside the window.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Okay. That's the most relieved I've been reading a reply in weeks.

0 coins

Waiting is the main job now. Appeal in, 30 days cleared, hearing notice will come. Nothing in myEDD will help you.

0 coins

Blunt but accurate.

0 coins

Genuinely the right advice even if it's hard to sit with.

0 coins

the portal disappearing thing happened to me too and i assumed it meant my appeal got rejected automatically. it didnt. hearing notice came in the mail and the whole appeal was intact

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

How did you stay calm waiting? I keep refreshing myEDD like something is going to change.

0 coins

i didn't stay calm. but nothing i did in the portal made any difference so eventually i stopped checking every hour.

0 coins

logging into myedd every day hoping it updates is a whole mood

0 coins

EDD not sending any acknowledgment when they get a DE 1000A is poor design. You shouldn't have to wonder if your appeal exists.

0 coins

The whole system is built like it was designed to make you give up. No receipt, no portal update, no way to confirm anything until weeks later.

0 coins

Exactly. And when the portal removes the claim too, there's genuinely nothing left to look at.

0 coins

For future reference, SDI Online has a Request Claim Update option where you can send EDD a message on the claim. If the claim is fully gone from your view you may not be able to use it for this appeal, but for anyone still seeing their claim in the portal it's worth knowing about.

0 coins

Does Request Claim Update work for appeal questions or only for active claims?

0 coins

It works while the claim is still visible and active in SDI Online. Once it moves to the appeals office and drops off the portal, you'd contact the Office of Appeals directly instead.

0 coins

Good distinction. Two different offices, two different contacts.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure